<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<rss version="2.0" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:media="http://search.yahoo.com/mrss/">
  <channel>
    <xhtml:meta content="noindex" name="robots" xmlns:xhtml="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml"/>
    <title>State of the Arts</title>
    <link>https://steady.page/state-of-the-arts</link>
    <description>Cultural criticism and commentary on the performing arts. Primarily focusing on Europe, with occasional reports from the world beyond!</description>
    
    <atom:link type="application/rss+xml" rel="self" href="https://steady.page/state-of-the-arts/rss"/>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[He’s back!]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Hey there!  I want to apologize for neglecting this forum over the past weeks: In early April, I was hired as musical supervisor and orchestrator for a new musical…]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<hr aria-hidden="true"/><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/state-of-the-arts/about">Become a member</a></p><p>Hey there!  I want to apologize for neglecting this forum over the past weeks: In early April, I was hired as musical supervisor and orchestrator for a new musical theater piece, <em>Amanda: The night before me</em>, which had it’s premiere in Vienna on May 9th. I’m sure you can understand my quandry: roughly four weeks to arrange and orchestrate and entire score, with an already full schedule. This meant less trips to the opera and concert hall, and almost no time to sit down and write. Happily, the premiere was went very well and the production will move to London in the fall. I will share more about this project in the coming months.</p><p>A favor: some people have said they are not receiving these post updates. Could you please send me a response to the email that they are arriving?  Thanks!</p><p>I have a few large format topics which I am researching and I will soon share. In the meantime, a few of my spring 2026 highlight and lowlights. </p><p>                                                                       The last weekend in March…</p><hr aria-hidden="true"/><h5>27.March.2026, Vienna</h5><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/0d651c1b-b037-44de-9cab-a8340158038f/uploads/images/4h7npxd5gj/image.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt="Maria Theresia and family."/><h2><strong>Maria Theresia</strong> </h2><h4>Ronacher Theater</h4><p></p><p>Vereinigte Bühnen Wien, and their audience, have long loved Vienna-based historical musicals. From <em>Freudiana</em> to <em>Mozart</em> to <em>Rock me Amadeus: Das Falco Musical, </em>VBW has for better or worse primed their audience for <em>Maria Theresia, </em>the latest dead royal who, like <em>Elisabeth </em>and <em>Rudolf </em>before her, has been subjected to Musical-ization.</p><p>I dubbed the piece ‘Hamilbeth’ in the intermission, as <em>MT</em> owes an extraordinary dramaturgical and stylistic debt to those priors. Much in the way <em>Tanz der Vampir</em> (another VBW creation) appears to be a succession of familiar scenes lifted from other shows, <em>MT </em>generously repurposes (without upcylcing) bits of <em>Hamilton</em>, <em>Elisabeth</em>, <em>Six</em>, and any number of other recent musicals. </p><p>Still, I honestly can say I didn’t hate it. There were parts of the production I found well crafted (or astutely nicked?). Of course, these bits were almost always followed by something extremely distasteful or embarrassing. This contrast was present in every department and betrays director Alex Balga’s professional trademark; the liberal ‘borrowing’ of other people’s ideas. If only he had the discernment to sort the good ones from the bad, the night might have been more consistent and avoided inevitable cringe.</p><p>The book (Thomas Kahry) and lyrics (Jonathan Zelter) in the spirit of so many dramatizations of historical people, romanticize, sentimentalize and dumb down MT’s life and considerable accomplishments to cohere to modern morality and sensibilities. MT is part Elle Woods, part post-film Elphaba; her beau, Franz Stephan, a <em>more</em> vapid and wet Fiyero-clone; and, in a nod to Che<em>, </em>Tod AND Lucheni,<em> </em>our surly antagonist is none other than Prussia’s ‘Grosse Fritz’ who, like his dramaturgical antecedents, chews the scenery while tormenting the heroine’s unconscious, purportedly offended at being rejected, despite all historical references clearly implying that the last place Fritz wanted to find himself was in the embrace of MT, or any woman. </p><p>The music (Dieter and Paul Falk) runs the gamut from spirited poppy stuff to syrupy, banal lovey-dovey duets, smattered with some theater ‘rap’ in the <em>Hamilton </em>vein. Most of it is forgettable, although the girl power number “Wir alle sind MT” does stick in the ear. The score provides ample opportunity for choreographer Jonathan Huor to showcase his now customary street-infused moves. As clever as he is, the past few years have born out that he is either over-exposing himself, or that his physical vocabulary is rather limited. Or both.</p><p>As usual at the VBW, the cast is good - I saw covers in numerous roles who all performed more than adequately - and the core ensemble is, also à la <em>Hamilton, </em>significantly and effectively utilized, giving the ears a necessary break from the scream-y belting women headlining this show. This is not an indictment of individual performers, who all did their best, but of the current musical theater aesthetic which insists high, loud and shallow is superior to depth, beauty and dynamics.</p><p>The ethos of the show is “female-forward:” strong female protagonists; a proposed engaging look at a truly interesting woman; a ‘Run the World (Girls)’ aesthetic. However, the 12-person creative team listed includes only one female identifying member, costume designer Alessandra Kica, which implies an underlying cynicism in VBW’s choice to develop <em>MT </em>in the first place. Surely there are qualified female creatives who would have been happy to lent the project their talents. (I’m sure Shaina Taub would have done it for the right price.) Had women been engaged, the humanity and authenticity in these legitimately interesting personae might have been unearthed. As it is it remains, like most VBW originals, uneven hollow spectacle.</p><h5>Emoji mood: 🤨</h5><hr aria-hidden="true"/><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/state-of-the-arts/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to newsletter</a></p><h5>28.March.2026, Erfurt</h5><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/0d651c1b-b037-44de-9cab-a8340158038f/uploads/images/fpfogjomlm/IMG_0202.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt="Mountain vista"/><h2><strong>Brokeback Mountain</strong></h2><h4>Theater Erfurt</h4><p></p><p><em>Brokeback Mountain</em> the opera. Hmm. When I discovered an imminent German premiere, I decided I must see it because, let’s face it, chances were it was either going to be really good, or really bad. Spoiler alert: it’s bad.</p><p>The fault lies only partly with the creative team and cast, more significantly at the feet of composer Charles Wuorinen. Wuorinen (1938-2020) was an American composer who initially favored serial atonality. Best known for an electronically programmed work in this vein, <em>Time’s Encomium (1969),</em> which won the Pulitzer Prize, Wuorinen had abandoned serialism (but not atonality) by the time of <em>Brokeback Mountain</em>’s composition. Annie Proulx was enlisted to adapt her short story into a libretto, expanding scenarios and beefing up secondary characters for Wuorinen to set in his self-declared ‘unabashedly complex Modernist’ style (what exactly does that mean?). Though they took their inspiration from the original text, it is hard to believe that the popularity of the 2005 film didn’t spur them on, or bear responsibility for the New York City Opera’s commissioning. The resulting piece is turgid, overly intellectual and is, in the accurate if understated words of New York Times reviewer Anthony Tomassini, “a hard opera to love.”</p><p>It is, overall, a missed opportunity. The story itself offers an optimal chance to use music as subtext, deepening and informing the spoken (and sung) word, particularly in the instance of Ennis Del Mar (the Heath Ledger role), who’s external emotional paralysis could have been effectively expressed internally through sensitive composition. Instead Wuorinen’s score is devoid of passion or sexuality, mostly dense but brittle commentary on the action lacking any lyricism or emotional release. My precursory listen to <em>Time’s Encomium</em> should have prepared me for this, as that piece is entirely devoid of expression. It is, possibly, the sound that math makes.</p><p>I do not believe that the chosen musical language is the problem. It would not be far fetched to draw a line between Ennis and Woyzeck, and I can think of few operatic experience that are more emotionally satisfying (even overwhelming) than Berg’s atonal masterpiece. But Wuorinen seems bent on negating all emotional impulses or lyrical adder. In other hands, Berg’s for example, this ill-fated love story might have sung and soared. Here it flails.</p><p>Granting that director Jakob Peters-Messer starts with a highly challenging work, his direction, nonetheless, does little to elevate the story. He is not helped by two leading men, baritone Máté Sólyom-Nagy (as Ennis) and tenor Michael Smallwood (as Jack) who not only have little chemistry with one another, but consistently telegraph their embarrassment in playing these roles, then have the gall to give a ‘we really gave it our all’ bow at the end. The rest of the cast are adequate, but none of them get enough stage time to elevate their efforts beyond ‘che dice’ functionality.</p><p>The star of the night, for better or worse, set designer Pascal Seibicke‘s monolithic white tundra. Bleak and barren it fills the stage, only later revealing the everyday sets of the protagonists life away from Brokeback Mountain underneath. These set changes are the most evening’s most satisfying moments. The set moves mountains. The piece, and performance, do not.</p><h5>Emoji mood: 😞</h5><hr aria-hidden="true"/><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/state-of-the-arts/posts">View all posts</a></p><h5>29.March.2026, Nürnberg</h5><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/0d651c1b-b037-44de-9cab-a8340158038f/uploads/images/wofy2fhfpm/IMG_8540.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt="Theater Poster"/><h2><strong>Kleiner Mann, was nun?,</strong> </h2><h4>Theater Nürnberg</h4><p></p><p>After two less than satisfying nights in the theater, I was hopeful, but wary, stopping in Nürnberg to see the acting company’s adaptation of the iconic Hans Fallada novel. Although it is a pillar of the 20th century German literature canon, I had neither read the book, nor seen any adaptation, despite knowing the title. The subject matter being incredibly timely - a Jedermann and his true love navigate failed capitalism and encroaching fascism - various adaptations have been on the boards across German theaters this season. I was eager to get acquainted with the story.</p><p>Marcel Kohler’s (director) adaptation successfully manages to emotionally tell the story of Pinneberg and Lämmchen, while conceptually framing it in Fallada’s real life story. In act one, the couple navigate the ups and downs of love, life and late stage capitalism, while Fallada, their downstairs neighbor, fights his demons and drug addiction, eventually managing to get down to writing the novel in question. Act two finds them all in Berlin, Pinneberg gainfully employed, Lämmchen caring for their son, Murkel, and where, of course, the Nazis have come to power. Fallada is busily rewriting, revamping, reframing his novel to maintain his relevance and position in the political climate. In a clever juxtaposition of the story and conceptual framework, Fallada is the client whom Pinneberg pleads with to fulfill his sales quota. After he is fired for this, Pinneberg and Lämmchen entreat Fallada to correct their narrative. He demurs, leading them to ‘check out of the system’ heading to the land. Kohler’s adaptation manages to maintain the integrity of Fallada’s original version, while referencing and integrating some changes the author made to appease the 3rd Reich.</p><p>It is easy to see why <em>Kleiner Mann, was nun? </em>was such a success at it is printing. It plays as a kind of 20th century counterpart to Voltaire’s <em>Candide: </em>both feature a naïve central couple bound by true love, but plagued by a need to be happy; they are surrounded by a cast of characters, who, with one exception, exploit and denigrate them; and all struggle through the collapse of the dysfunctional social, economic and moral systems in which they live, adapting to survive. Adding Fallada as a character gives Kohler a direct descendant to Pangloss (or Voltaire.) The climatic scene set in a post-apocalyptic garden could have been launching pad for an effective rendition of Bernstein’s “Make our garden grow.”</p><p>The story is good, and invites further exploration for further adaptation. And this version works well, pointedly underscoring the analogues between Fallada and our world. We are quickly engaged and invested. In no small part the strong cast, with exceptional performances from Joshua Kliefert as Pinneberg, Sasha Weis as Lämmchen and Luca Rosendahl in a double role as Fallada’s act one demon (Wolf), and Pinneberg’s one true friend, and nudism enthusiast, Heilbutt, in act two. They anchor and propel this performance emotionally. Even at a distance of two months, their performances remain with me.</p><p>A highly satisfying evening of theater in the best tradition: entertaining, thought-provoking, relevant and even, dare I say, edifying.</p><h5>Emoji mood: 👌</h5>]]></content:encoded>
      <category><![CDATA[Performing Arts]]></category>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/0d651c1b-b037-44de-9cab-a8340158038f/uploads/images/4h7npxd5gj/image.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;fm=jpg&amp;crop=faces" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/ef266393-5bad-4038-8276-ff16bd911a1d/posts/0d651c1b-b037-44de-9cab-a8340158038f</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">0d651c1b-b037-44de-9cab-a8340158038f</guid>
      <pubDate>Tue, 09 Jun 2026 22:10:02 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Stop me if you’ve heard this one before….]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[I am working on an essay about the transfiguration of popular films into stage musicals, plays, or… operas. It is turning out to be more labour intensive than I…]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><a href="https://steady.page/en/state-of-the-arts/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to newsletter</a></p><p>I am working on an essay about the transfiguration of popular films into stage musicals, plays, or… operas. It is turning out to be more labour intensive than I originally thought, so I offer up these short observational rants in the interim. Enjoy.</p><hr aria-hidden="true"/><p><strong>What are you standing for?</strong></p><p>I have discussed this disturbing trend with colleagues and other performance visitors over the past few months, and we seem to be of the same mind: <em>The standing ovation in no longer a useful measuring stick for the true valuation of performance. </em>It has become so commonplace, so abused, that it neither carries value, nor discernible caché.</p><p>When I started out in my career, a StandingOvation was so rare, so special, such a badge of honor, that it impelled work hard, striving and one’s best efforts on stage. It was reserved for extraordinary achievement, or given as tribute to an exceptional and consistent body of work over a long career.</p><p>Those days are a distant memory. TV casting shows were one of the earliest blows to standard and practice, as they successfully sold the misguided impression that everyone has talent of equal measure, they just have to be ‘uncovered.’ Shortly thereafter, software program improvements provided a user friendly means to glow up marginal raw recorded data into good enough, if somewhat clinical, end product. And to create ‘music’ with little or no measurable musical talent. Of course, the modern ear is now so accustomed to autotune that young singers have found a way to imitate it physically. These trends furthered the devaluation of skill and talent development, but the heaviest blow, as in so many instances in our 21st century world, was dealt by social media. Tik-tok, Snapchat, instagram… all of these outlets for ‘self-expression’ have mistakenly been taken as performance outlets, leading to a further dilution of the differentiation between life and performance or between skill/talent and avocational interest.</p><p>I do believe that most people carry hidden talents within them, and that it possible to develop and hone those upon discovery; the critical differential remains that just having talent isn’t enough. So many modern social structures gladly malign skill, tradition or technique, yet, without these, the performer will not be able to actualize their potential, and the audience will not be able to recognize the unique, special, or exceptional.</p><p>When I moved to Germany, I was somewhat shocked to observe that, no matter the quality of the performance we mustered at <em>Les Miserables</em> (and more than a few shows were questionable), we <em>always</em> took 4 bows, and by the last bow at the latest, the audience was standing. As MD of <em>Mamma Mia, </em>I observed this phenomenon close up, realizing it was still possible to tell how the audience truly felt about the performance by noting <em>when </em>they rose to their feet: at a particularly good show (in my tenure, at least, we had a lot of these) the audience was up before the bows, and requisite megamix, had even started; at a not-so-great show, they stood with the last bow. All intervening levels of quality aligned with parallel segments in the closing format comprising staged bows, megamix, and bows sequence.</p><p>Now, it appears, the SO is expected. Non-negotiable. Worse, it is not very much concerned with the people <em>on stage! </em>Rather, it is a performative device for audience - who dutifully have restrained themselves for the length of the performance - to get a desperate dopamine dose. “I was here, so give me a like. Notice me.” A friend even told me of an occasion where a standing ovation stopped and interrupted a show, spurred on perhaps, by what had occurred on stage, but nonetheless obviously intended to garner attention for themselves.</p><p>Even in the temples of opera, ballet, theatre - high culcha, as it were - this regularly happens. The audience jumps up for anything, be it out of tune singing, non-sensical ‘Concepts’, or just having patiently endured the evening. It is a sorry state of affairs and I don’t see it improving as the boundary between life and performance grows ever thinner. The ‘Curated Life’ and ‘The Performance’ are so closely aligned that we may soon enter an age where the authentic is untraceable, and where exceptional performance will no longer be recognized.</p><p>And that leads me to…</p><hr aria-hidden="true"/><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/state-of-the-arts/about">Become a member</a></p><p><strong>That Chalamet shit…</strong></p><p>There has been so much written about this that it seems almost silly to chime in so late, but, there is an aspect I haven’t yet found discussed, so, I am adding my two cents to the pot.</p><p>Firstly, Timothée Chalamet is a very fine actor who, despite being brought up in the theater and fine arts, is very young…And impressionable…And a product of the larger American culture in which he grew up.</p><p>The event in question happened during a town hall discussion with Matthew McConaughey. The two have a history, as an early Chalamet’s film role (at 17) was portraying McConaughey’s son in <em>Interstellar</em>. When I watched the video that so offended so many, it was palpably obvious to me that young Timmy’s flippancy was as much an attempt to gain street cred and respect from Matthew as it was to actually ‘diss’ the fine arts. (While he only called out ballet and opera by name, the indictment was clearly on the whole lot.) Chalamet wanted to be perceived as ‘cool.’ You can see this in his eyes. It doesn’t excuse the insensitivity, arrogance, stupidity or inaccuracy of what he said, and neither should we let McConaughey off the hook for not helping Timothée out of a bad situation, or defending all those ballet dancers, dramatic sopranos, and oboists out there.</p><p>Still, it has always been, and remains, the preferred strategy in America to summarily reject anything different. Or anything to which the word ‘art’ can be applied. Does it require introspection, or more than rudimentary intellect? Practice for implementation, or experience for successful interaction? It can and should be definitively denounced. American culture is created for the lowest common denominator, and everything else is suspect. (The exception to this is high performance sports, which are prized - but just to be clear, football, boxing et al. are better than figure skating, gymnastics or dressage, each of which require an artistic bent for successful execution.) Art is for sissies and commies. And might be ungodly. And obviously, the pressure to denounce and belittle rises the more white, male and cis you consider yourself to be.</p><p>When push comes to shove, Chalamet and McConaughey need their ‘common man’ fans to stick with them, so it is easiest to make fun of the usual suspects. Frankly, I’m surprised one of them didn’t refer to the ‘lofty’ pursuits as ‘gay’, ‘elite’ or ‘effete’ - just a few of the many epithets available to make sure the other bruhs know you’re where your alliances lie. The irony is that Chalamet was forged and minted by those fine arts, as much as he may now hope to extricate himself from the association.</p><p>McConaughey grew up in middle-class Texas, and his upbringing and rise appear fairly Americana standard in Hollywood terms. But Chalamet was, from birth it seems, immersed in the high arts - his family lived in Manhattan Plaza, <em>social housing in midtown reserved for artists</em> - his mother, a retired dancer, his (French) father, a journalist. He went to LaGuardia High School (of <em>Fame</em> fame) where he was surrounded by dancers, singers, actors, musicians. It is safe to say that he was in the midst of people pursuing the forms of artistic expression he so quickly slagged off throughout the bulk of his formative years, and, himself, owes a debt to his own early efforts in them. And then there is dual citizenship with France, for god sake, where he regularly spent time throughout his childhood. He was immersed, conceived, and christened in the fine arts, and in cultures that value them. It is virtually impossible to conceive that he lacks so much self-reflection to not be aware that his statement was false and unwarranted. Which means he’s a bit of a faker. And sadly, a hypocrite.</p><p>Boys will be boys.</p><p>Just to be clear: as long as I have been involved with them I have been told that opera, musical theater, ‘serious’ music and spoken theater were dying, no longer relevant, on their way out. I’ve had a 40+ year career, and most often, more than enough to do. Maybe someone has been misinformed?</p><p>Berlin, where I live, has five opera/music theaters houses, 5+ symphony orchestras, 1 ballet company (plus numerous contemporary dance troupes), 5+ spoken theater houses, and countless smaller organizations providing 1000s of performances throughout the season. While Berlin is exceptionally gifted in this respect, it is hardly the exception. In fact, the fine arts are developing and flourishing all around the world. Generally in cultures that place value on heritage, learning and knowledge in addition to The Arts. In societies where the economic systems are not bent on eradicating everything that doesn’t immediately make a profit they are vibrant, pertinent and a part of every day life. I remember, on a very early engagement in France, meeting a French boy my age. He asked me what I did, and I replied “I’m a singer, but you probably don’t know the music I sing.” Pressed, I listed some French composers, to which he replied, with perfectly French disdain (and sexy accent): “of courz ai know zem. Zey are French, ai am French. It is my culturelle eritage.”</p><p>I wasn’t offended by Chalamet’s remarks, but I was highly disappointed. I’ve always regarded him as a sensitive and highly gifted actor. Some of his performances show true brilliance (like the one below from ‘Prodigal Son’ - John Patrick Shanley’s moving and beautiful play for which tacky Tim won a bunch of awards) and because of this, his performance with McConaughey is all that more disheartening. Has success gone to his head? I hope it is youthful cowardice, not hubris. And that someday he will look back with embarrassment at the disrespect he showed for the people and traditions that buoyed his talents, and anchored his success.</p><hr aria-hidden="true"/><p><a href="https://youtu.be/iMPWx1v7ioM?is=druJxQyC6InfC3t3">“The prodigal son” John Patrick Shanley</a></p><hr aria-hidden="true"/><p><strong>Pay for Play</strong></p><p>My first post-graduation job offer was for a regional Equity production of <em>Evita.</em> Ensemble and cover Che. Yes, it’s true. Back in the 20th Century, I was, in all my dirty blonde, blue-eyed, 22 year old Caucasian-ness, considered appropriate casting for Ernesto “Che” Guevara. I was duly excited until the financial offer came in. 300 bucks a week, 150 of which would be deducted to pay my theater lodging. The rest would have to pay my daily living expenses and my running expenses in New York. Oh, and 10% would go to my agent. Basically, I would end up paying if I signed. I didn’t.</p><p>The tradition of underpaying and cheating artists who need experience or exposure has a long, unseemly history. My story is relatively harmless in comparison to many where performers are abused and mistreated through scams or misrepresentations. Paying for internships, salaries well below living wage, or ‘favors’ exchanged for employment (has #metoo finally killed the casting couch? I suspect not) all still run rampant, but a particularly unattractive scheme is pay to play. Payment for access.</p><p>I have nothing against young artists gaining contact to people with whom they can network, learn from, or show their talents. In fact, through all facets of my career, I have benefitted a great deal from workshop, showcase or course formats. But, if the power dynamic is so obviously skewed that the payee is in a substantial position to affect the payor’s status, then it is only a short step to bribery or extortion.</p><p>Over the past ten years, the prevalence of these grifts in the German Musical industry has grown. First came the agent boom. Currently, we are in the thralls of the Masterclass paradox.</p><p>There are no true agent/managers in the European musical theater industry, because there isn’t really an honest need for them. In other markets, agents get daily listing of upcoming castings, act as go between for actor and casting agent, and are there to assure standards and practices are maintained while getting the best possible fee for their clients if an offer is made. In the european markets, these functions are mostly unnecessary: Casting is handled internally by theatres and producers; standards, practices and fees undergo blanket negotiations long before the actor enters the picture. The resulting firm fee structures for state theaters and their commercial counterparts leave clear and settled guidelines for contracts. And since commercial producers will only ever negotiate with performers cast in roles, only those in high profile positions truly need agents, as negotiations in these cases <em>can</em> harvest higher fees. Additionally, for the run of the contract, those performers will need an advocate to mediate with the company when the shit, inevitably, hits the fan.</p><p>Nonetheless, about 10-15 years ago, agents started popping up like mushrooms after a rainstorm. Everyone suddenly had an agency and everyone started thinking they needed one. Occasionally, this led to entertaining, if unethical, stories like - the actor-agent who negotiated his <em>and</em> a client’s contract for the same role with the same producer. Or, my personal favorite, the musical supervisor-agent who, in an attempt to improve his percentage of a client’s fee, negotiated his client out of a leading role in a production which he was also supervising. Can you say ‘conflict of interest?’</p><p>The masterclass boom might be the most questionable of all these trends. Masterclasses can be a wonderful way for practiced industry professionals to impart wisdom and knowledge to the less experienced. And sometimes, these professionals might discover talent they want to work with, support, or feature. All good.</p><p>However, I can currently name at least three ‘workshops’ where the implicit value in the course is not so much the content as the access those courses bring. And while the owners or vendors marketing these courses don’t explicitly declare their UPI, first and second hand accumulated evidence clearly indicate that the true appeal of these products is guaranteed access and exposure.</p><p>One is hosted by a state theater which proudly and prominently features musical theater as a regular pillar of its programming. The workshop might be seen as ‘giving back’ to the community, and there is even a performance at the end of the week. The performers get no fee for this, but reports are, having paid their fee to the organizers, almost all get regularly invites to auditions for the director and musical director leading the workshop, who, between them, cast at least 25 shows annually.</p><p>Two are led by casting personnel responsible for casting at the largest German language commercial producer. In both cases, the data shows that after the workshops, actors who participated received significantly more attention and consistent audition access for that producer’s productions. At last accounting, one of them costs nearly 2000 euro, a not unsubstantial sum for a beginner in the business.</p><p>Importantly, I am not calling into question the quality or ability of the staffing for these workshops. I am sure participants learn and benefit from the work, even if doling out substantial sums to attend. I do, however, question the ethics of the courses, and the individuals behind them. What about the performer who simply cannot afford to pay for access? What about the inherent conflict of interest a pay for play policy creates? What about the lack of objectivity in evaluating a performance under these situations? It is an insidious creep that adds to the developmental stagnancy and qualitative denigration of our industry.</p><hr aria-hidden="true"/><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/state-of-the-arts/posts">View all posts</a></p><p></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <category><![CDATA[Performing Arts]]></category>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/b30d2e6e-ca35-45f9-9672-add47a6f1061/teaser_image/1776101377?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;fm=jpg&amp;crop=faces" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/ef266393-5bad-4038-8276-ff16bd911a1d/posts/b30d2e6e-ca35-45f9-9672-add47a6f1061</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">b30d2e6e-ca35-45f9-9672-add47a6f1061</guid>
      <pubDate>Mon, 13 Apr 2026 17:29:37 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Vienna waits for you]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Happy Easter! The weather in Berlin has finally started to warm up, with spring cleaning is on the roster! I spent the last two weeks on the road, attending a number of…]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Happy Easter! The weather in Berlin has finally started to warm up, with spring cleaning is on the roster! I spent the last two weeks on the road, attending a number of interesting performances on which I will report shortly. I am also exploring the multi-media capabilities of the site, adding links and pics to this entry. Let me know if it heightens your reading experience!</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/state-of-the-arts/about">Become a member</a></p><hr aria-hidden="true"/><hr aria-hidden="true"/><p>When I met Bernstein the first time, I earnestly (yet honestly) told him that as long at there had been music in my life, he had also been there. Typical of Lenny, he over dramatically engulfed me in a bear hug, nearly suffocating me in his distinctive cigarette and gin infused aura. As I age, I become ever more conscious of the debt I owe those role models and mentors who informed and schooled my artistic sensibilities. This near perfect evening in the Musikverein reminded me (again) that the artists whom I have looked up to and have emulated in my own work are growing fewer and far between. One purpose of this newsletter is to document and honor their legacy.</p><p>If you are any kind of arts enthusiast - whether you dabble, actively support, or are obsessed - hearing the Wiener Philharmoniker on their home turf is a worthy life goal. In any list of the greatest symphony orchestras, they land, for good reason, in the top 5. Their string sound is legendary, the other departments are equally impressive and distinctive: Bruckner played by this brass section is an event, and the versatile woodwind blend adds so much character to anything the orchestra plays (especially German/Austrian music which rightfully form Wien’s musical backbone.) The Musikverein, which they call home, is not only one of the most beautiful rooms dedicated to music, but has a refined acoustic that synchronizes remarkably with this orchestra’s playing. It is a feast for the senses. Not surprisingly, the most comprehensive and qualitative sampling of orchestral instruments, the Vienna Symphonic Library, or VSL, were done in this hall, by this orchestra.</p><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/8913de0f-b20d-436b-a8e7-191ae61f4a7a/uploads/images/kimieolr5j/IMG_0163.webp?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><p>Vienna is a city that actively participates and revels in it’s cultural institutions, and the Wiener Philharmoniker have a massive subscription base. Remaining tickets for their concerts are released very late, so you take what you can get. My seat, three rows deep in a balcony side loge, afforded me a good view of the impressive gilded ceiling and much of the audience, but a highly obstructed one of the last desks of the first violins and cellos to the left of the conductor, and little else of the podium.</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/state-of-the-arts/posts">View all posts</a></p><p>When I teach, I often avert my eyes from the student, allowing my ears and throat to do the listening, and my perch in the balcony allowed me to savor the aural sensations of this wonderful ensemble giving a special, and emotionally charged performance. In fact, it was one of those rare evenings that transcend ‘mere’ performance, to become a ‘happening.’ The program was as Deutsch as can be - von Weber, Bruch, Beethoven - but the man at the helm was anything but ordinary: the venerable Zubin Mehta.</p><p>Maestro has a long history with Vienna, having ditched his medical studies in Mumbai in the mid-1950s to study conducting here with Hans Swarowsky, unparalleled teacher of not only Mehta, but Abbado and Barenboim, among others.  Swarowsky felt Mehta ‘had it all’; his fearlessness and consummate musical viewpoint led to a quick rise, winning competitions and jumping in for ailing big names at major international orchestras. Over the following seven decades, Mehta has amassed a massive résumé. Rooted in 19th century technique while essential in 20th century innovation, he is rightly a titan of his generation.</p><hr aria-hidden="true"/><p>“I knew at university that medicine was just not for me. I saved many lives by not being a doctor!”</p><p>— Zubin Mehta</p><hr aria-hidden="true"/><p>First on the bill, Carl Maria von Weber’s<em> Overture to</em> <em>Oberon</em>. A standard program opener full of bravura and excitement, which the performance duly underscored. It reminding me of von Weber’s highly underestimated role in laying the groundwork for the next generation of young romantics. <em>Der Freischütz</em> rightfully is considered the foundation of German opera. But there is more to von Weber. His orchestrations foreshadows Berlioz, and boundary pushing string and wind writing presage Brahms (they shared a special love for the clarinet.) And we all know how Carl’s use of melodic motive to define characters excited Dicky Wagner. <em>Leitmotiv</em> ahoi! His music is dramatic and dramaturgical; at turns intelligently virtuosic or achingly lyrical, and most often, just plain fun. von Weber is a wonderful example of an artist taking big risks within the confines of expected mores and structure, and I think he is rife for a comeback.</p><a href="https://youtube.com/shorts/ve-XJCi43r8?is=xRCnftvPU1pc_HL3">https://youtube.com/shorts/ve-XJCi43r8?is=xRCnftvPU1pc_HL3</a><p></p><p>Following <em>Oberon</em>, Pinchas Zukerman took the stage for Max Bruch’s <em>Violin Concerto No. 1. </em>In his day, Bruch was a worthy rival to Brahms. His music was regularly performed and celebrated, but like Spohr before him, interest waned after his death. While nothing of Spohr remains standard repertoire, we can be thankful that Bruch’s <em>Concerto </em>is still a favorite of audience and performers. Joseph Joachim, the most important violin virtuoso of the late romantic famously believed “the Germans have four violin concertos. The greatest, most uncompromising is Beethoven&#39;s. The one by Brahms vies with it in seriousness. The richest, the most seductive, was written by Max Bruch. But the most inward, the heart&#39;s jewel, is Mendelssohn’s.”</p><p>Bruch’s brooding lyricism emerges from the first solo cadenza and engages through the famous third movement’s fireworks. These two elements frame the work’s heart, a stunning cantilena adagio. It is harder to think of a player better suited than Zukerman to spin Bruch’s long lines. Taught in the Central European tradition by Ivan Galamian (who incidentally also taught Mehli Mehta, Zubin’s father) his amazingly large sound is always warm and emotive, and his sovereignty over the music is both fascinating and moving. He and Mehta have frequently performed this concerto together in their long professional and personal collaboration, and this is evident in the nuance that Mehta gets from the orchestra in support of Zukerman. There was a long, well deserved ovation after the first half of the concert, and anyone in the room would have gone home happy at this point.</p><a href="https://youtube.com/shorts/kHbJ-xPz39Y?is=y71EzSFjuifxJA2z">https://youtube.com/shorts/kHbJ-xPz39Y?is=y71EzSFjuifxJA2z</a><p>But the best was yet to come. Herr Beethoven’s <em>Symphony No.7</em>. The 3rd, I admire, the 5th, I respect. I enjoy the 6th, and revel in the 9th. I think the quirky 8th should be played more, and I don’t know the 1st, 2nd or 4th well enough. I <em>love</em> Beethoven’s 7th.</p><p>I know it very well, and yet, Mehta and the Wiener managed to surprise and delight me, revealing lines I had forgotten, connections I had not yet discovered, and textures that in the Musikverein’s extraordinary acoustic took my breath away. Beethoven wrote the symphony while on a Kur, and it is inherently positive and forward looking. This performance bubbled with an immense joy and life that kept me on the edge of my seat.</p><p>Mehta’s attention to the structure within each movement and over the complete symphony revealed contours and colors that felt both inevitable and unexpected. After a sustained and luminous sostenuto in the first movement, Mehta manages somehow to both suspend and propel the transition to vivace (a personal favorite moment) highlighting the rhythmic motive, a kind of ‘invitation to the dance’, underscoring related motives Beethoven cleverly employs throughout the entire symphony. Each movement - the genial vivace, the famous and somber allegretto (it’s premiere audience was so affected that they demanded an encore), effervescent presto scherzo, and unconstrained allegro con brio, are underlaid with dance rhythms which in Mehta’s hands burst off the page. It makes you want to get out of your seat and join in. (And the Italian lady next to me did...)</p><p>(Not Vienna, but nonetheless well played)</p><p>1.movement - 3:50 for that great transition</p><a href="https://youtu.be/q5YhuIP_l9Y?is=rXwRdgyOOuPapPkC">https://youtu.be/q5YhuIP_l9Y?is=rXwRdgyOOuPapPkC</a><p>2.movement </p><a href="https://youtu.be/KbNGklNz8Yk?is=hiorAjluDN8MXF8Z">https://youtu.be/KbNGklNz8Yk?is=hiorAjluDN8MXF8Z</a><p>3.movement</p><a href="https://youtu.be/0lYWoVCfi5M?is=V75H_7_EMOCBQ2dR">https://youtu.be/0lYWoVCfi5M?is=V75H_7_EMOCBQ2dR</a><p>4.movement (especially from 5:00 to the end!!!)</p><a href="https://youtu.be/lOcV2CL6O0I?is=fYu-3jZ6pGVQMJ8H">https://youtu.be/lOcV2CL6O0I?is=fYu-3jZ6pGVQMJ8H</a><p>The last time I attended a performance under his baton, Mehta conducted from a high stool, but had walked (very) slowly to the podium. Now, just shy of his 90th birthday, he is brought to the podium in a wheelchair and helped to his stool. Everyone in the room was highly aware this might be one of the last opportunities to bask in Mehta’s great gifts, and this added gratitude and gravitas to the performance. His age and fragility may have limited his physical ferocity, but in no way the spirit, precision and focus that Swarowsky helped him develop all those years ago. In fact, it may well have enhanced his efficiency and effectiveness. And, clearly wanting to give their very best to the man leading, the orchestra exuded a vibrancy and emotionality in their playing that is often lacking from professional ensembles. I don’t think I have ever heard them better.</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/state-of-the-arts/about">Become a member</a></p><p>As if this wasn’t glorious enough, not one handy went off in the auditorium, no one coughed, or opened candy or talked in the quiet bits, and when the audience gave their extended standing ovation at the end of the night, it was not the performative kind so often delivered these days, but earnest, heartfelt and deserved. Great playing led by a master AND an appropriately behaved audience? What more could you want?</p><a href="https://youtu.be/Q2JnsI8MuDQ?is=rAdCX6l0CsTtmpW1">https://youtu.be/Q2JnsI8MuDQ?is=rAdCX6l0CsTtmpW1</a><p></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <category><![CDATA[Concert]]></category>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/8913de0f-b20d-436b-a8e7-191ae61f4a7a/uploads/images/kimieolr5j/IMG_0163.webp?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;fm=jpg&amp;crop=faces" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/ef266393-5bad-4038-8276-ff16bd911a1d/posts/8913de0f-b20d-436b-a8e7-191ae61f4a7a</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">8913de0f-b20d-436b-a8e7-191ae61f4a7a</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 05 Apr 2026 15:02:54 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Is life a cabaret, old chum?]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Cabaret Music & Lyrics: Kander & Ebb; Book: Joe Masterhof, based on I am a camera by John Van Druten, and Christopher Isherwood’s The Berlin Stories Residenztheater,…]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<hr/><p>Cabaret</p><h2>Cabaret</h2><h4>Music &amp; Lyrics: Kander &amp; Ebb; Book: Joe Masterhof, based on <em>I am a camera </em>by John Van Druten, and Christopher Isherwood’s <em>The Berlin Stories</em></h4><h5>Residenztheater, Munich. 27.February.2026</h5><p><strong>Direction</strong>: Claus Guth; <strong>Musical Direction</strong>: Stephan Delaney (co-direction Philip Tillotson; <strong>Set Design</strong>: Étienne Pluss; <strong>Costume Design</strong>: Bianca Deigner; <strong>Lighting Design</strong>: Gerrit Jordan; <strong>Choreography</strong>: Sommer Ulrickson; <strong>Dramaturgy</strong>: Yvonne Gebauer, Almut Wagner</p><hr aria-hidden="true"/><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/state-of-the-arts/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to newsletter</a></p><p>“Even though our lives wander, our memories remain in one place.” - Marcel Proust</p><p></p><p>Claus Guth is my new hero. After absorbing his stunning <em>Don Giovanni</em> at the  Staatsoper Unter der Linden (<em>see</em> ‘Conceptually speaking…’), I was excited to find him helming this production of <em>Cabaret</em>. In short, get yourself one of the few remaining tickets.</p><p>Rebecca Frecknell’s 2021 London production had, in my opinion, best addressed the difficulties encountered when mounting <em>Cabaret</em>. Well, Guth has outdone her. At the outset it is important to admit that the liberties Guth has taken with the script place it at the edge of needing an “inspired by” byline. And take note that this production is performed by an acting ensemble, not a cast of musical performers, so some potential audience members will be turned off at the outset. These caveats aside, Guth’s re-conception of the flawed masterpiece not only breathes new relevance into the story (so often hackneyed and kitschig) but also solves inherent challenges and problems book and dramaturgy present.</p><p>And I know, <em>Cabaret</em> was a hit from the beginning. The Broadway original ran 1,165 performances - a highly respectable run for the mid-60s. A ‘Concept Musical’ was born, Joel Grey was catapulted to stardom, and the show had knock-out performances from Lotte Lenya (lending ‘I vas dere’ legitimacy) and Jack Gilford né Gellmann (providing elevated schtick comedy.) It spawned a beloved and celebrated movie. Still, <em>Cabaret</em> is probably the work in the standard repertoire that, despite its initial success, has been most overhauled in subsequent productions. Unlike other oft revived musicals - <em>the Music Man </em>or <em>Oklahoma </em>for example - where a revival might update the script or change around some songs to <em>refurbish</em> the original’s good bones, <em>Cabaret </em>productions entail <em>renovations</em>.</p><p>The problems lie in the writing, and I believe Kander &amp; Ebb, Prince and Masterhof, the original architects of the show, were acutely aware they hadn’t quite ‘got it right.’ Even with all the boundary pushing the show managed, some choices made to get the show on also resulted in its weakening. Their willingness to let new creative teams have a crack at solving <em>Cabaret</em> is no doubt one reason it has so often been re-attempted.</p><p>Dependent upon how the major issues are handled, subsidiary kinks might reveal themselves, but the gist of the big things that need to be dealt with is: 1) The Matter of Sally Bowles; 2) The Function of the M.C.; and, most importantly, 3) The Cliff Compromise.</p><p><strong>The matter of Sally Bowles. </strong>On the page, Sally is quirky and common, delightful and obnoxious, clueless and all-knowing, but most important - as per Isherwood - a middle-class, second-rate performer who sings ‘badly, without any expression’ yet, possesses a mesmerizing charm. If you know the show (and who doesn’t?) you are one step ahead of me: Kander &amp; Ebb’s songs (for Sally) demand far more than serviceable warbling, they cry out for show stopping. Dependent upon the version of the show, she has 3-6 of these numbers to deliver as leading lady. Clearly, squaring these curves requires a performer of immense ability.</p><p>Having seen my share of <em>Cabaret </em>over the years, I can attest to the difficulty of finding this illusive Sally. There are wonderful singers who suffer in the scenes, and ladies who can act the shit out of the part yet disappoint in song. Jesse Buckley (2021 London), great in both respects, is probably the best we have yet had. Jill Haworth was famously, and cruelly, panned by Walter Kerr in the 1966 production, and - despite being John Kander’s all-time favorite - a reviewer of Dame Judi Dench in the 1968 London premiere began their article exclaiming: ‘What have they done to our Judi?!’ I have witnessed numerous German Sallys and most fall into category one: big in voice, not so big on character detail. To be fair, this is largely Miss Minelli’s doing, as that extraordinary Oscar winning performance is etched into the collective memory and largely considered <em>the</em> Sally prototype. It would be impossible to say Liza’s Sally sang ‘badly, without any expression,’ and her shadow weighs heavily on those that followed, but also has distorted Masterhof’s - and Isherwood’s - original intention.       </p><p>I did see Jane Horrocks in the Sam Mendes directed 1993 Donmar Warehouse revival (which later successfully transferred to Studio 54 in New York with Natasha Richardson in the role). Horrocks seemed to have the prerequisites. She had risen to prominence with two breakout gigs - one, playing a sad vulnerable girl with an uncanny ability to imitate big-voiced girl singers in <em>The Rise and Fall of Little Voice, </em>the other, her recurring role as quirky and lovable Bubbles in the ubiquitous <em>Absolutely Fabulous.</em> Despite her promise, the performance in the theater was unsatisfying. To be completely fair, she and Mendes did attempt to swing the pendulum back from the film’s distortions but, Horrocks never found Sally’s voice, tonally or vocally, and was wholly eclipsed by Alan Cummings, who, like Joel Grey before him, spotted a career making Golden Snitch in the M.C. and snatched it.      </p><p><strong>The Function of the M.C. </strong>Though the seeds were planted back in the late 40s (<em>Allegro, Love </em>Life), it wasn’t until the 60s that the ‘Concept Musical’ produced some exotic fruit. Three formative works, <em>Man of La Mancha </em>(1965), <em>Hair</em> (1967/1968) and <em>Cabaret </em>refined the format and led to 1970’s <em>Company. </em>Hal Prince, who interestingly first met Stephen Sondheim at the <em>Allegro</em> premiere, had been tinkering and toying with the technique since the 40s, and <em>Cabaret </em>is the first show where he implemented an over-arching Concept. His original structural conceit was a strict separation between the central ‘love’ stories with their story songs and the external commentary at the Kit Kat Club, which were to be presented in performance ‘numbers.’ However, character overlaps, the encroachment of fascism into both spaces, and Joel Grey’s overpowering performance effectively collapsed this scaffolding. In the book we now have, the two ‘worlds’ collide by the end of Act One, erasing the line between narrative and commentary. The commentary songs in Act Two also provide plot movement, and so forth. My theory is that this decision came during the original rehearsal period.</p><p>John Van Druten’s play <em>I am a camera</em> served as Masterhof’s blueprint, and Van Druten frames the story as a flashback after Cliff and Sally run into one another at a London cocktail party. Could it be that Masterhof’s original book used a similar device, but the addition of the Kit Kat Club (which was not a feature in Van Druten) and the sheer bravura of Grey resulted in it’s loss? You may know the stories about the rehearsal period rewritings of <em>Funny Girl, </em>which was increasingly tailored to the immense demands of Streisand’s talents. I am suggesting (without evidence) that something similar happened here. Though originally intended to exist in the periphery of the Kit Kat Club, it is not hard to imagine how Grey’s singularity and brilliance captivated and captured the original 1966 rehearsal process, moving his role from the sidelines to the center. And the hyper-centrality of the M.C. has only grown over the decades. In fact, I suspect that both Mendes and Rebecca Frecknell (and others) would argue that the M.C. is <em>central</em> to the story, either as protagonist (Mendes) or puppet master (Frecknell.) As the current script plays, it requires a clear tonal differentiation in narrative scenes/songs and commentary songs, so that its perversion and later destruction will be successful dramaturgically. The role of the M.C. is instrumental in establishing <em>and</em> destroying this tone, and requires a particularly enigmatic performer. But it <em>isn’t</em> his/her/their story. It is Cliff’s story.</p><p><strong>The Cliff Compromise<em>. </em></strong>He must be the hub anchoring the spokes of all plot lines. Cliff is not a difficult sing, but the vestiges left of various incarnations from years of script rewrites have made the role increasingly more difficult and layered for the actor. And while Sally and the M.C. get more than enough bravura ‘turns’ to cover up the deficits in their writing, Cliff cannot rely on star allure or histrionics to motor the show.</p><p>Much of this is the result of a successive compromising of Isherwood’s original depiction of Christopher from <em>The Berlin Stories </em>to Cliff in Masterhof’s <em>Cabaret </em>book, via John Van Druten’s  <em>I am a camera</em>. It is further complicated by the fact that Cliff is the only character wholly based on one historical person, who also happened to have authored the source material. Isherwood originally presented himself as an asexual observer - “I am a camera with its shutter open, quite passive, recording, not thinking.” His relationship with Sally is close, but platonic. They share a flat, but not sex. There is never any question that he might be father to her child, and in fact, he helps her procure an abortion.</p><p>In <em>I am a camera, </em>Van Druten half-sexualizes Christopher, and places him at the center of the story. When Sally moves in, he comes on to her, and she rebuffs him. In an attempt to legitimize the pregnancy, he offers to marry her, then, after she again rejects him, sells a story to raise money for her abortion. Van Druten’s desire to construct a linear narrative arc from Isherwood’s vignettes no doubt led to this adjustment to Christopher, using him as sympathetic Everyman protagonist to center and narrate the story.</p><p>The 1966 Masterhof book, despite stretching formal, subject and style limits, becomes, at least as concerns Cliff and Sally, garden variety musical comedy - ‘boy meets girl, girl gets pregnant, girl gets an abortion, boy leaves girl.’ There is no intimation that 1966 Cliff might <em>not</em> be heterosexual; he enters into a relationship with Sally, is prepared to become father to a child that may or may not be is, and the love story is the prime instigator of his character arc. But…</p><p>By the time <em>Cabaret</em> was being written, Isherwood’s homosexuality was common knowledge, in fact, the diaries upon which he based his original were filled with detailed accounts of participation in 1930’s Berlin gay life, and from the late 40s he had been dropping clues to this fact.</p><p>Masterhof’s and Co’s ambivalence to broach Cliff’s sexuality is notable. It is peculiarly quaint and revealing that 1966 Broadway balked more about mentions of homosexuality than abortion. Oh, how things have changed. Since Isherwood’s 1976 autobiographical full disclosure of his Berlin escapades, Cliff has undergone a slow <em>bisexual</em> coming out, from toe-dipping ambiguity in Fosse’s 1972 film script, to implication in 1987’s revival, to ‘full disclosure’ in Mendes’ 1993 and 1998 productions, the current licensed script. I’m not saying that Cliff needs to be gay, but I am arguing that the initial writing of the character, however inauthentic, built the dramaturgical flooring, and subsequent <em>renovations</em> are not sufficient to truly put Cliff to rights, it requires a <em>facadectomy.</em> And this would substantially change the entire show, which no modern team has had yet had the stomach to undertake, though Guth shows he has the balls to do it.</p><p>The various re-writes have diffused and complicated the original writing, leaving the onus of making sense of Cliff inordinately upon the actor and director. And since it is his story, he quickly becomes an unreliable narrator if inconsistent decisions are made about who Cliff is, and how he sees the world. Many directors neglect Cliff’s central function, focusing on Sally or the M.C. (or both.) While good performance in either of these roles <em>can</em> carry the show, the result is generally empty, relying on style over substance. And while a well cast Frau Schneider and Herr Schulz can provide depth, without a well considered Cliff, the show has no backbone. We encounter this world through him and he must be the person with whom we, the audience/observer, sympathize.</p><p>Happily, Guth gets it, and has come up with novel solutions that not only equalize the book’s contradictions, but manage to improve the piece as a whole.</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/state-of-the-arts/about">Become a member</a></p><p>Nearly all modern productions (as in 1966) are set in the infamous Kit Kat Club - life is a cabaret, after all, ya da ya da ya da - and the first clue Guth gives us that his will be no ordinary <em>Cabaret</em> is the neon sign hanging in front of the show curtain. When the M.C. appears through that curtain, it is without fanfare. Instead of singing  ‘Willkommen’, as Concierge, we are welcomed to the hotel to which the neon sign refers.</p><p>Then the curtain rises, and we find ourselves in a nondescript, mid-class Manhattan hotel room, circa 1970-something. The Concierge ushers an elderly man into the room, leaving him to settle in. He is pensive. In an attempt to relax, he lays down on the bed, turns on the radio. After some (very accurate) 1970s ads, the radio starts playing the inimitable ‘Willkommen’<em> </em>vamp, and our friend recognizes it. He tries to sing along, but the vamp evades him. It does, however, involuntarily jog his memory, triggering a painful soul searching and sorting that is the core of this production. For, the old man is Cliff.   </p><p>Various characters begin appearing in Old Cliff’s increasingly Proustian world: A bellboy’s face and attitude in the real world trip a flashback to Young Cliff and Ernst Ludwig’s first meeting on the train; the real chambermaid reminds Old Cliff of Frau Schneider; the Kit Kat Club emerges out of the mini-bar and any other available orifice in the room; and finally, when present and past have sufficiently blurred, in walks Sally, gin and cigarette in hand, ostensibly to place a phone call.</p><p>The act progresses, Old Cliff’s foothold in reality loosens, and he wanders from Étienne Pluss’s beautifully drab hotel room to it’s equally provocative hallway, whose row of anonymous red doors become the Kit Kat Club. Each time Old Cliff wanders from room to hallway, the walls grow thinner, finally being obliterated when the Nazi threat, in Act One’s climax, becomes spoken. Act Two, finds Old Cliff and his ghosts wandering through the wreckage, seeking anchor, meaning or salvation. Young Cliff, at the end, physically escapes the carnage, but Old Cliff is left stranded. No one is left unscarred, and as the curtain falls, we are left face to face with our discomfort. I do wonder what might have been gained if we had returned to the hotel room and Old Cliff’s reality in a symmetrical epilogue, witnessing him putting back the pieces of his shattered life, or not, to let all his trauma ‘hang out.’ What is certain is that it would have spared us the interminable and tasteless bows and song reprises which undermined every great thing Guth and his cast managed to do through the evening. This decision was a misstep in an otherwise entirely well-modulated production.</p><p>Guth’s prologue ingeniously transforms <em>Cabaret</em> into a memory play. Centering the story in Old Cliff’s evocations, allows Young Cliff to experience them, heightening their emotional core in both present and past. Splitting the role also underscores examination of past mistakes, a perspective that is particularly au courant for this piece. I don’t think it is possible to sit through this production without being confronted by the precarious state of the world in which we are living. In 2021, Frecknell, inflected by the isolation of the covid years signaled trouble on the horizon. In 2026, trouble has most decidedly come to call, and Guth’s direction adeptly presents a worst case scenario, if we don’t act. In a beautifully Brechtian touch in Act Two, Frau Schneider leaves Cliff and Sally mid-scene, ambles to the apron as the house lights rise, to look directly in our eyes as she accusingly sings ‘What would you do?’</p><p>The physical aspects of this production do their jobs extremely well; and like a good soundtrack, they enhance the narrative without calling attention to themselves. In addition to Pluss’s effective sets, Gerrit Jurda’s lighting is on point, especially in the second act, when play of light and shadow becomes all the more important. And Bianca Deigner’s costume plot is period true and outwardly reflective of each characters inner life. Stephan Delaney and Philip Tillotson have cast an exceptional band and the score is musically well served.</p><p>The cast is good across the board. Musical fans expecting brassy voices with stroppy vibratos, might be disappointed, and granted, I would have relished more vocal payoff from Miss Sally. But, the other roles are more than adequately sung, and what we win in story-telling clarity and depth in <em>all</em> roles tips the scales in favor of these performers.</p><p>The young and diverse Kit Kat kids are strong and each shine in their crucial featured moments. Myriam Schröder looks like she walked off an UFA set, circa 1931, and backs up this first impression with a sly and razor-sharp Fräulein Kost. Once exposed as Nazi sympathizer, Guth employs her in the background, spying on everything and everyone, a foreshadowing of the ‘Inoffizieller Mitarbeiter’ yet to come. It was particularly refreshing to see Ernst Ludwig cast as youthful contemporary of Young Cliff, and Vincent zur Linden embodies the role with a cocktail of seductiveness and danger that attracts and repels simultaneously…‘I know I shouldn’t want him, and yet, I do.’ His reveal as party member is so very disheartening (and I already knew the story!) because we really like Ernst Ludwig enough to hope it might not be true. Herr zur Linden elevates the role well beyond its generally accepted serviceability to leading role status.</p><p>Cathrin Störmer is a lovely Fr. Schneider. She sings and acts with a spry sweetness, humor and likability in Act One that heightens her disillusionment in Act Two beautifully. This Frau Schneider deserves and should get the love she is denied. And, I have never been so aware of the Yiddish cadence in her dialogue. I can’t be sure if Masterhof, Guth, Störmer, or a combination there of, are responsible for this so logical and fitting effect. As an Uhr-Berlinerin, Frau Schneider is surrounded by the Jewish culture that infused and imbued the fabric of the city at this time. It is part of her vernacular, linguistically and culturally, so her amazement that Herr Schulz’s jewishness could be of issue, is entirely believable and understandable.</p><p>Störmer is balanced extremely well by Robert Dölle, whose Herr Schulz is odd and winsome, geekily ‘Prestiging’ fruit until, of course, the trick doesn’t work anymore, spelling his doom. This magician Schulz perplexed, if fascinated me, looking as if he’d wandered in from a Fritz Lang set; part Wizard of Oz salesman, part benign Dr. Caligari. I think, ultimately, he is a benevolent Svengali, beguiling Frau Schneider with his strange fruit.</p><p>This couple are the true love story in the book and Frecknell managed to revitalize them by casting them in early middle age, hardly the last chapter of their lives. Guth counters with two joyously vital misfits who become the greatest victims of the coming storm, simply because of their capacity to love.</p><p>As in the original script, Guth introduces us to the M.C. before his newly minted prologue, implying laws of time do not apply and even, perhaps, denoting that more than person, the M.C. is a shape-shifting Diabolus ex Machina, catalyst of each inevitable plot twist. This is not dissimilar to Frecknell’s solution, in which the M.C., a thing rather than being, transforms as needed however the story deems necessary. But Guth, and Vincent Glander infuse their M.C. with dimension and ultimately, humanity. Grey was cold and implacable, Cummings unapologetic and vulnerable, Redmayne mercurial and existential. Glander is a ghost in purgatory, the gallows humour only thinly veiling a tortured desperation to get out. Entirely variable, but insistently human underneath, this M.C. inveigles a way into our hearts, as it runs the gamut of incarnate possibility. It is a tour de force performance that defies conventions of the role, commenting upon and supporting, without usurping the story from Cliff.</p><p>Not to be outdone, Vassilissa Reznikoff delivers a damn good Sally Bowles. From her ‘mistaken’ entrance into Old Cliff’s room - a verbal-physical comic turn worthy of Mabel Normand - to her heart-breaking final goodbye to Cliff, she dominates the stage. Yes, her voice is weak, but she calls up a loveably tragic girl, constantly under the influence of something, which rivals any Sally on record. And let’s remember, the problem of the part is Kander &amp; Ebb’s doing, not hers. Frecknell’s solution to the problem was to take Isherwood as his word; in the story songs 2021 London Sally is sexy and flirty and womanly, in the Kit Kat Songs devoid of emotion. Lifeless. Since Reznikoff doesn’t have the requisite voice for the music as written, Guth has rightly cut a few songs, and invested in the fine-tuning of character, which it pays off remarkably well. Reznikoff puts every trick she knows at Sally’s disposal, yet each of them is rooted in the character’s emotional need, never relying on cliché. I think Isherwood would find her mesmerizing. I did. I do hope that future directors and Sallys will look for alternatives to the nervous breakdown take on the title song, which has been the overused since Jane Horrocks started yelling at the audience in 1993. Maybe a manic, evangelical approach could have some mileage in it, or a committed reveling in the decision to go down with the ship?</p><p>Which brings us to Cliff. As I sit writing, thinking about the collective and individual qualities these two actors bring to the role, my eyes (again) begin to tear up. Michael Goldberg’s Old Cliff undergoes the Proustian disintegration, descending ever deeper into the darkest corners of memory, mind and soul. Goldberg does this without ever resorting to melodrama, rooted in a palpable emotional core that guides us and his Cliff to the edge. Helpless to change the past, but evermore destined to relive it, he helps Young Cliff’s escape, and entraps himself. And Young Cliff, in the hands of Thomas Hauser, is so guileless, so innocent, so eager to taste life that it hurts. One feels Cliff’s great, untethered love for all the inhabitants of his Berlin, and even more the pain from each wound and disappointment they inflict upon him. Despite his inexperience, his moral compass is strong, and his awakening is both his deliverance and his downfall; it shows him the writing on the wall, but leaves him with a guilt and repression that even 40 years on, Old Cliff can’t manage to entirely heal. These wonderful actors work so well together, aptly re-claiming Cliff, and Isherwood’s story, that it is hard to think that the script wasn’t written this way.</p><p>The last 20 minutes are harrowing (not including the bows, which are harrowing in an entirely different way), and appropriately, at the final curtain, the audience doesn’t know how to respond. The only other time I have experienced an audience so collectively engaged and moved was at a screening of Robert Benigni’s <em>Life is beautiful</em>. As the credits rolled, we sat in silence, no one moving for about 5 minutes. This <em>Cabaret</em> has a similar profundity, and I believe it is a worthy enough effort to leave us with our self-reflections. It has been a long time since I have I had such an emotionally and artistically satisfying a night in the theater.</p><p>Go if you can!</p><p></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/state-of-the-arts/posts">View all posts</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <category><![CDATA[Musical Theater]]></category>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/eb6b3149-e326-4bab-937f-d2a6c69e613d/teaser_image/1772763324?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;fm=jpg&amp;crop=faces" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/ef266393-5bad-4038-8276-ff16bd911a1d/posts/eb6b3149-e326-4bab-937f-d2a6c69e613d</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">eb6b3149-e326-4bab-937f-d2a6c69e613d</guid>
      <pubDate>Fri, 06 Mar 2026 18:54:08 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Conceptually speaking…]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Lohengrin, 1.February.2026 Music and Libretto, Richard Wagner Don Giovanni, 6.February.2026 Music: Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Libretto: Lorenzo da Ponte Staatsoper Unter…]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h2>Lohengrin, 1.February.2026</h2><h4>Music and Libretto, Richard Wagner</h4><h2>Don Giovanni, 6.February.2026</h2><h4>Music: Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Libretto: Lorenzo da Ponte</h4><h3>Staatsoper Unter den Linden, Berlin</h3><p>Nowadays, it is virtually impossible to attend any type of theatrical production without encountering…‘The Concept.’  It is de rigeur that a director work within an overarching, cohesive idea (often supplemental to the piece itself) that will encompass, organize and illuminate the work being staged. Possibly initiated with Herr Wagner’s <em>Gesamtkunstwerk</em> ethos, it took final hold of opera in the mid-60s German state theater system, thereafter quickly asserting itself into musical theater and straight theater worldwide. There are earlier examples (<em>Lady in the Dark</em>, <em>Love Life, Allegro</em>) from the 40s, but the first hit ‘Concept Musical’ is generally considered to be Hal Prince’s 1966 original production of <em>Cabaret. </em>Or Albert Marre’s 1965 staging of <em>Man of La Mancha. </em>At any rate, no self-respecting director will arrive at rehearsals these days without ‘The Concept’ in hand.</p><p>In a best case scenario, we might just call it considered, intelligent direction: If homework has been done and a director is capable of communicating their vision to team, cast and collaborators, there will be an inherent continuity and consistency of tone to the production. Without it - and regardless of the intrinsic quality of the work being subjected to ‘The Concept’ - the production is at the mercy of the weakness of ‘It.’</p><p>To be functional, ‘The Concept’ needs thorough vetting, particularly as it relates to the existing dramaturgy and - painfully obvious, but remarkably oft neglected - story. A useful example: when placing an older story in modern context, parallel’s between past and present need to be determined and quantified. My memory of Peter Sellar’s late 80’s updating of <em>Le Nozze di Figaro </em>(from late 18th century Seville to late 20th century New York) is that every detail had been meticulously considered and assigned an appropriate modern equivalency. Relationships, behaviors and plot devices were justified and believable, bringing revelation to the piece without, in any way, sacrificing the original’s integrity.</p><p>Often, however, this doesn’t happen.</p><p>Without background preparation ‘The Concept’ will implode, at best spawning incoherence, at worst unraveling the piece entirely. A favorite cautionary tale of this ilk: ‘The director who wanted to <em>do something new </em>with<em> Anything Goes’</em>. (Hint: This motivation almost always leads to disaster.) Cole Porter’s show, a star vehicle for Ethel Merman, takes place during Atlantic crossing on a luxury cruise ship. It has a lot of great, famous songs, and, <em>comme il faut</em> in 1934, a screwball plot with plenty of ‘gags, girls, mirth and merriment.’  It does not presume to be ‘serious,’ yet possesses enough craft and intelligence, spark and dramaturgical soundness to have kept it in the standard repertoire for nearly a century. The director in question, taking the title of show too literally, determined his new take would be… … … sinking the ship. Yes.   Let that <em>sink</em> in. On the sunken ship, the cast were instructed to add burbles and gurgles to their dialogue while blowing bubbles to back up his faulty premise. This idiotic masterstroke breaks any dramaturgical backbone the story may have. For, a sunken ship, I believe, cannot in Southampton dock, for happy ending and rousing reprisal of the title tune. This is not apocryphal, it really happened somewhere in provincial Germany. I pray the cohort of willfully incompetent directors currently at work is too small to ever make this kind of near criminal negligence commonplace. </p><p>Also, not infrequently, ‘The Concept’ interests the director more than the actual show, sucking all the oxygen out of the rehearsal process. I produced a show with a director/choreographer pair who were so enamored of their faux-immersive conceptual framework that they neglected to tell the <em>actual</em> story. Despite my repeated entreaties, they pottered away on motivation and coherency in their framing device, and never got around to the plot. When the authors saw the premiere they were, understandably, perplexed, if forgiving. Thankfully, their script could withstand this dereliction and the cast found their own answers. More often performers feel lost and unseen, stranded and in desperate need of guidance.</p><p>Of course, it helps to know what you want to say with a production concept. It might aspire to new perspective or relevance of the original (i.e. Sellar’s <em>Figaro</em>), or add a structural device that will inflect and inform, and conceivably, better the story. Michael Mayer’s concept for <em>Spring Awakening </em>- a modern musical reworking of Franz Wedekind’s proto-expressionistic <em>Frühlingserwachen (1891)</em> - included a clever device, namely, utilizing Duncan Sheik’s songs as performer commentary on the action, rather than as plot development. With this one stroke, Mayer strengthened the universality of his subject (adolescent angst), justified the stylistic juxtaposition of 21st century music idiom and proto-19th century dialogue, used the fourth wall to communicate directly with the audience, and, transmuted the somewhat static nature of the songs from liability into intention. In fact, I would contend that Mayer’s contribution is equally responsible to the authors for the dark horse success of <em>Spring Awakening</em> enjoyed in the 2006-2007 Broadway season. After all, it did win them all Tony awards. </p><p>You may be asking, ‘what’s it all about, Alfie?’  Well, you see, I will happy extol ‘The Concept’ when successful, and I will rail shoddy efforts just as vociferously. And these two Staatsoper shows are a matched set: a rave and a rant. An exultation and a reprobation. </p><p></p><p>Calixto Bieito, seemingly discontent with just ‘<em>The</em> Concept’ for <em>Lohengrin</em>, drums up a bunch to vie for our attention. Those identifiable (there may be ones I missed) appear to be:</p><p>a) <strong>Update</strong>: set it in a modern lecture hall at University of Brabant. Or is it a court? Or a chorus rehearsal space? I decided on U of B, since the seating platforms from Act One become stadium bleachers in Act Two;</p><p>b) <strong>Frame</strong>: there are lots of videos played during the instrumental bits of Wagner’s score. Act one’s centers on the pre-story of Gottfried’s demise, however by drowning not transfiguration. (Spoiler alert: Gottfried <em>is the swan</em> in the opera proper: Mean Girl Ortrud transformed him, then framed his sister, Elsa, for his death. O. is also married to Friedrich who is Elsa’s protector. It’s a long story…) The Gottfried footage is coupled with a very pregnant, very naked black woman, who, in Act Two’s film gives birth to…a swan. Huh? This footage is interspersed with clips of a sports car (Porsche?) cruising about town… … OK… … The Act Three video adds a potpourri of other images - I vaguely remember close range chewing of spaghetti - but to be honest, by then I was not invested enough to care; </p><p>c) <strong>Delve</strong> the unconscious psychology: for some reason, there was a white cage on stage through most of the opera, in-to and out-of which various characters went. And, the chorus frequently began slo-mo writhing and physical distortioning, to physicalize their inner turmoil. I think.</p><p>Towards due diligence, I spent much of the first act trying to glean connections between framing video, updated university challenge and psychological staging -  Elsa’s cage wanderings, the spastic scene stealing of the Herald (Arttu Kataja), and the odd psycho quasi-choreo of the chorus. I got little help from Ingo Krügler’s costume plot, nor further clues from the set (those bleachers? Or, the clichéd ‘grassy island living room’ at Elsa’s place in Act Three? Huh?) - and came to the conclusion that Bieito was of the <em>do something new </em>school (see warning above.) I decided to divert my attention to the glorious music, played extraordinarily under the steady and dramatic baton of Simone Young. And the chorus under Dani Juris sang uniformly strong and heroic, adding excitement to a satisfying musical experience.</p><p>The trouble with all of Bieito’s performative nonsense, of course, is that the performers suffer. Given a modicum of guidance their strengths could be exploited, their weaknesses addressed. Under the given circumstances, each must invoke some strategy to get through the night. To his credit, the aforementioned Kataja (whom I imagine was told ‘be physically awkward and never stop moving) takes the note and keeps grabbing our attention. You might argue that the story dictates our attention be directed elsewhere. But this doesn’t phase René Pape, as Heinrich, who seems to have decided ignoring ‘The Concept’ as much as possible, to stand and sing, is his best bet. He was, despite indisposition, vocally strong and secure. Benjamin Bruns (Lohengrin) seems to have employed Pape’s tactic, though probably for different reasons. Last month I heard him sing Mahler 8, and I could copy and paste my comments from that performance here. In brief: good voice; clarion, attractive big bits; everything else annoyingly sharp and feckless. What the Mahler could not have exposed was Brun’s incredible woodenness on stage. He did jump in for an ailing Eric Cutler, so his ill ease may be a result of under rehearsal, or Bieito’s neglect of character direction. Or Caroline Staunton’s (resident direction) interpretation of Bieito’s original intention. We will never know, but Bruns, despite an optimal voice for the role, lacks the presence and stature needed of a dramatis personae. It has been a while since I witnessed someone so uncomfortably moving across a stage. </p><p>I also fear Elza van den Heever, as Elsa von Brabant, was instructed ‘to behave like a bratty teenager.’ She valiantly tries, but her rather (to be expected) adult voice and the gravitas of her story force her into a dichotomy that is impossible to navigate. She sings the role well, and I hope she gets a production where she can explore her good instincts to deepen her portrayal. In this production, we can’t put a finger on who, or why, Elsa <em>is</em>. Anja Kampe really dives in to Ortrud. I bet it is a fun role to play. She revels in the blackness of the character and gives it dramatic dimension. Vocally, it is, for my taste, not successful. To quote Phyllis Curtin: “We don’t always need to sing like a Mack Truck.” Kampe received high praise at the bows, but this is not how Wagner is meant to be sung. She has ample voice, and I wish she would match the differentiation and color she displays in her acting to her singing. Wolfgang Koch (Friedrich) fares the best in every way. His singing is beautifully registered, textually expressive, musically engaged, with an honest and believable character arc. He is the only named role to successfully traverse ‘The Concept’ while doing justice to Wagner.</p><p>There are considerably worse implementations on record, still this production is a prototype of ‘The Concept’ out of control. I admit, on my first encounter with <em>Lohengrin</em> many years ago, I found the story a bit ludicrous. Still, ignoring it in favor of adding ‘stuff’ around the periphery is not a responsible tactic for reclaiming whatever relevance the story may have hidden at its foundation.</p><p>The maturity and viability of musical theater (pan-stylistic) has undoubtedly benefitted from good use of ‘The Concept.’ Sondheim/Furth/Prince’s <em>Company</em> (1970), which codified and solidified the technique in modern theatre, is a masterpiece in many ways. I include Hal Prince in this <em>creative</em> trio, because his input and development of ‘The Concept’ parallel to the writing process was integral to the end product. It would take far too much space here to discuss Prince’s impact on the development of modern theater vernacular, and by corollary, opera, but integrating the director into the creative process, especially with new works, can assure ‘The Concept’ is well anchored into the production.</p><p>It is more difficult, but certainly not impossible, to do this kind of work with an existing piece. Claus Guth’s <em>Don Giovanni</em> is proof of the pudding. This production is joy; A fine tuned collaborative effort, which plays more like spoken theatre than opera. Guth’s concept supports, illuminates and reveals aspects of Da Ponte and Mozart’s already solid blueprint that entirely revitalize the piece.</p><p>First and foremost, a 21st Century <em>Don Giovanni</em> must decide how to approach the <em>dramma giocoso</em> (roughly, dramedy) in the staging. In case you don’t know the opera, it is the story of Spanish lothario Don Juan, who ultimately gets his comeuppance. Over the 200 plus years since its writing, it has been mostly played for laughs, a kind of distant relative to British sex comedies. Thankfully, Guth and his team have rebalanced <em>dramma </em>to <em>giocoso, </em>and gone even further. Treating the text as black comedy, they set it in a thick, night forest which recalls Gregory Crewdson photos (astutely designed set and costumes by Christian Schmidt), with a tonal direction that owes a nod to David Lynch. This is an appropriately dark <em>Giovanni - </em>in both the stage and lighting plot (the gorgeously moody lighting is Olaf Winter’s contribution) - and any laughs that bubble up are bitter and realistic. Gallows humour. (Sideline: I found it intriguing how much of the audience were desperate for any hint of tonedeaf burlesque they could get. Have they been asleep the past decade?)</p><p>Musically equally well served, the use of the recitativi is particularly striking. Heading toward a 15 year run, I don’t know how much of these efforts were present in the original incarnation of this production (Salzburg 2012 with Barenboim conducting), but Finnegan Downie Dear’s hand is self-evident in this iteration. We are treated to a rare occurrence in opera: recitative scenes which truly play as dialogue, equally weighted to the musical numbers. Downie Dear very adeptly transitions seamlessly in and out of recit and number, embuing the entire score with a refreshing inevitability and cohesiveness. If, occasionally, his tempos in numbers are fast, putting the singers on edge, it is never without dramaturgical justification.</p><p>Caroline Staunton is again responsible for the resident direction, and her fine, focused work in this piece suggests that the deficiencies in <em>Lohengrin</em> are less hers than Bieito’s. Here, the delineation in character portrayals is consistent and authentic. Guth’s clever stroke at the start - Donna Anna’s father (read: Commendatore) shoots Giovanni in the stomach - hurls us towards the Don’s ultimate demise. Rather than seeking help to dress his wounds, the ensuing scenes send Giovanni careening through the dark, untamed forest, introducing us in turn to the people and forces that will bring about his deserved end. The extra-story psychology this set up invites are probably obvious, and they inform the story without overpowering it. Sex addict Giovanni can neither help nor stop himself. He does his schtick for the next victim, even while boring and hurting himself, in pursuit of a ‘fix.’ Leporello, put upon and angry, facilitates Giovanni’s nonsense, cleans up his messes, but is too burnt out to muster more than sarcasm as defense. Their co-dependency anchors the narrative as they trample over the obstacles in their wake. Ambiguous Donna Anna, ineffectual Don Ottavio, crazy-ex Donna Elvira and the young, guileless Zerlina and Masetto each offer challenge, in their own way, to the duo, until ultimately the boys fall victim of their own hubris, and the Commendatore finishes the job he started at the outset. The symmetry of the staging suggest the entire story might simply be Giovanni’s life flashing before his eyes between the shot that wounds him and the one that kills him. </p><p>It is a wonderfully theatrical evening, and the close knit work of this ensemble carry it. All of them either belong to the Staatsoper ensemble, were (or are) members of the house studio, giving them a shared history. They perform like a well-oiled theatre troupe, such a rarity at this level of the industry. </p><p>Gyula Orendt is a dream Don Giovanni, sexy and dangerous, in possession of one of the most lusciously beautiful baritone voices I have ever heard, which he uses extremely well. Throughout the story he dares and prods and eggs on his foes, and when one finally succeeds in doing him in, he seems relieved. It is a star performance, but he never panders, upstages or forces focus. Every choice is made in service of story and score. He is paired with Friedrich Hamel as Leporello, who not only looks like a meth dealer, but is a master enabler. A true pusher. Maybe he secretly enjoys his predicament after all? He complements Orendt well, using his bass-baritone in total commitment to story. Evelin Novak’s Donna Anna exudes ennui and dissatisfaction. She’s less invested in avenging dad’s death than in sneaking a cigarette to tolerate another dullish day. Her voice has the necessary gravitas for Anna while remaining lithe and youthful. Sandra Laagus has difficulties with the first act, but comes into her own in “mi tradi quell’alma ingrata.” If Giovanni is addicted to sex, this Donna Elvira is addicted to love…And it’s no matter the kind. Jingjing Xu is a lovely Zerlina, clean and clear sung, passive-aggressively negotiating her conflict between the edgy desire bad boy Giovanni represents and the security and goodness of Irakli Pkhaladze’s Masetto. With his presence and warm baritone, he embodies Masetto with the frustration of a outwitted man just trying to grasp the ever changing rules of the game. Lastly, Siyabonga Maqungo possesses a singular voice, incredibly light in tone and huge in size. It is certainly understandable why the audience was so enamored with him. But. His voice sits so high that much of Don Ottavio doesn’t speak, and his breathing issues led to peculiar and unmusical phrasing in “Il mio tesoro.” In the first act, he fared better, but even then tended to be very much on the top side of the pitch. He is an intriguing talent, no doubt, but there are issues which need to be addressed.</p><p>Originally staged in 2012, this production preceded #metoo and the Epstein files by some years. Watching the performance, it was impossible to not be conscious of how recent history, and our ever escalating class, cultural and societal divisions, diminish our lives. And if these themes were always to be found in the undercurrent of Da Ponte and Mozart’s libretto, in this case, ‘The Concept’ has illuminated them, pulling them to the surface, to provide us with a relevant and pertinent parable of our times.</p><p>But even more…Just as Hal Prince’s integral production of <em>Sweeney Todd </em>represents a standard by which all subsequent productions must be measured, Claus Guth’s impressive work will remain my point of reference for any <em>Don Giovanni </em>in my future. Go see it if you can. </p>]]></content:encoded>
      <category><![CDATA[Performing Arts]]></category>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/62e5997d-7707-4d9d-a783-a487ec9eafa7/teaser_image/1771462388?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;fm=jpg&amp;crop=faces" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/ef266393-5bad-4038-8276-ff16bd911a1d/posts/62e5997d-7707-4d9d-a783-a487ec9eafa7</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">62e5997d-7707-4d9d-a783-a487ec9eafa7</guid>
      <pubDate>Thu, 19 Feb 2026 00:53:09 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Nihilism on the Nile?]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[GIULIO CESARE in EGITTO George Friedrich Händel Libretto by Nicola Francesco Haym Conductor, Jörg Halubek; Director, Michaela Dicu; Set Design, Rival…]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h2><strong>GIULIO CESARE in EGITTO</strong></h2><h3>George Friedrich Händel Libretto by Nicola Francesco Haym</h3><h5>Conductor, Jörg Halubek; Director, Michaela Dicu; Set Design, Rival Ajdarpasic; Costume Design, Ariane Isabell Unfried; Light Design, Michael Kantrowitsch; Choregraphie, Paolo Fossa; Dramaturgie, Juliane Schenke</h5><h4>Deutsch Oper am Rhein, Theater Duisburg, 18.January.2026</h4><p></p><p>A few times during pandemic lockdowns, the YouTube algorithm blessed me. We all know this is the exception to the rule, as most recommendations are repeats of something we watched yesterday, nudges towards right wing slop, manosphere nonsense (I would hope women and gender fluid folk are spared this) or other unwanted content. And yet, occasionally, I was offered up extraordinary talents whom I have continued following. Big surprise to anyone who knows me, the first algorithmic bull’s-eye was Alexander Malofeev, about whom I will soon write an extended post. Another was Dennis Orellana.</p><p>Researching vocalists for an online workshop, he popped up from under the camera, a teen in his bedroom, to sing ‘Sempre<em> </em>libera’ from <em>La</em> <em>Traviata</em> in original key and octave. The coloratura was a bit sloppy, but the voice was good, and, most importantly, his joy and delight in the music exuded from the screen. I followed his progress, from Honduras to Spain and on to Stuttgart where he finished his studies, thereafter quickly making professional inroads with one high-profile debut after another. Last year, he won the Farinelli prize which only sped up the tempo. When I discovered he was singing in <em>Guilio Cesare in Egitto, </em>and even more wonderfully, singing Cleopatra(!) not Cesare, I naturally made plans to attend.</p><p>On paper, this is a very interesting concept: Gender flip the two main protagonists, giving Cesare to a female singer, and Cleopatra to a male soprano. (Even if you don’t know this opera, you can guess from the title what it is about: Caesar travels to recently acquired Egypt, encounters Cleo and her dastardly brother, Ptolemy. Caesar falls for Cleo, all manner of political and social intrigues follow, Caesar wins the day and Cleo. The opera ends there, although we know from history there is heartbreak and an asp in Cleo’s future.) Exciting right? The gender switch invites investigations of so many themes - gender dynamics, women in power, sexuality as weaponry, and on and on. It could be fruitful, rebalancing of the opera to explore pertinent subject matters. Thus, I had high hopes.</p><p>Throughout the performance, I kept asking myself why there was so little propulsion in the action, why many characterizations seemed unfocused and 2D, why, despite a clearly committed, willing and able cast, the story telling was so…inarticulate. Fortuitously, the director and dramaturg held an audience discussion after the performance and I wanted to see what they had to say. There was some praise for the concept from audience members, or for the costumes, or (deservedly) musicians, conductor, and individual singers, but also a number of detractors who, like me, felt that the potential such a ‘big switch’ was not fulfilled, and ultimately made for an unsatisfactory night. When one participant understandably queried what the intention behind the swap was, the dramaturg answered that she and the directress had no intention. The idea had offered itself, but any meaning to be gleaned from it was the responsibility of the audience. We should decide for ourselves. Director Michaela Dicu dryly chimed in that she merely gave the performers the context and then, well, left the cast to their own devices. You can well imagine the steam coming out of my ears upon hearing this.</p><p>Basically, the leading team made a significant change to a well-known, well-traversed work in order to ‘explore’ new dynamics, but abdicated any responsibility to make decisions or determinations about WHAT they were exploring, HOW they wanted to present it to an audience, or WHY this shift was valuable or necessary<em>. </em>So f’ing lazy.</p><p>The greatest pity, is that it is a REALLY GOOD idea. <em>One I wish I had come upon.</em> There is so much to expose by throwing opening this closet door, but it is not enough to look at the mess inside, you need to organize it so you can see what’s in there.</p><p>Dicu sets her ‘experiment’ in a überglitzy post-Modern golf and country club in the tropics. Set and costumes reek of the green and gold tastelessness of the rich (did somebody say Mar-a-Lago?) and the space feels intrinsically public; there is no place to hide, nowhere private. So far, so good. The design aspects of this production are all completely competent and successfully support the story, which makes Dicu’s neglect of character direction even more disappointing.</p><p>Anna Harvey is earthy and her lady Cesare has clearly worked hard to achieve position, still, she does not display the charisma and gravitas expected of a world leader. Orellana’s young and charmingly naive Cleopatra is completely without intrigue, becoming a victim of circumstances, with few weapons with which to combat brother Tolomeo (Tobias Heckler) let alone the other awful stuff that comes his way. It is a big question as to what exactly this Cesare sees in this Cleopatra, or vice versa. They have little chemistry, and the central significance of this relationship to the opera’s story is lost. Although both Harvey and Orellana are clearly willing, they seem to be operating from a different understandings of style and story-telling, and this hinders their ability to ‘rescue’ themselves. I would maintain that if Dicu had acknowledged the dynamic between these two performers (and thus, characters) it could have been harnessed to strengthen the story and the initial conceit in the gender swap. However, left to themselves, opportunities are squandered. Just one example: Orellana <em>sang</em> an exquisite “Piangerò…” but the impact was marred by his puppy-like physicality. Given guidance and focus (from a director, maybe?), this could have been a heartbreaking, beautiful defining moment for the character.</p><p>Harvey is vocally capable, but not entirely satisfying. When she manages to open into her voice, it is appealing, but she is generally late in the fioratura and resorts to singing quite thinly, I assume hoping it will keep her on time. She was (with Orellana and Danta) announced as ‘under the weather’ and maybe that is to account for the deficits.</p><p>I predict Orellana will have a long and illustrious career. To sing this notoriously high, difficult role with such ease, beauty and expressivity (at the age of 24!) is impressive. As he gains stage experience and his acting chops catch up to his singing chops, the possibilities become thrilling. I find myself thinking about all other things he could ‘rediscover.’ He’s already played Cherubino and probably Orlofsky. Oscar? Tebaldo? Or(!) he what about “Knoxville: Summer of 1915?” That would be stunning. Someone program that immediately!</p><p>Having neglected helping the main couple, Dicu can be thankful that her secondary leads are mostly capable of picking up some slack. The ‘che dice’ roles of Curio and Nirena were adequately filled by Torben Jürgens and Annabel Kennedy respectively. However, the heart of this <em>Cesare</em> are Cornelia (Katarzyna Kuncio) and Sesto (Maximilano Danta.) Both give strong, emotionally connected performances. Kuncio is a seasoned performer, and while her voice isn’t optimally suited to Händel, she makes it work, embodying Cornelia with dignity and pathos. Danta is a discovery for me. Another counter, of rich mezzo character, he sings and acts Sesto with real skill and dimension, and is one of the characters (with Cornelia and Achilla) who has built a character arc that spans the story, from hapless rich boy to actualized hero-in-waiting. It is a role he has played before (perhaps there, the director was not an ‘absent parent’?) and his understanding of character, coupled with musical and vocal adroitness rival Orellana. (Light bulb!: in the early 2000s, Hamburg Schauspielhaus produced a gender f’ed version of <em>Cosi fan tutte</em> with male ‘singing’ actors. Imagine a relaunch with Orellana as Fiordiligi and Danta as Dorabella…I’m in!)    </p><p>Achilla has the trickiest dramaturical arc in the libretto and Roman Hoza manages this adeptly. He also possess a suave voice and after starting as a ‘baddie’ completely wins our sympathies by story’s end. Lastly, the final ‘counter’ of the night, Tobias Hechler as Tolomeo resorts (<em>sans aide</em>) to all manner of villain tropes mixed with the ever popular German predilection for sexually deviant behavior. When he unnecessarily putted a golf ball up Cornelia’s hoo-hah it made me uncomfortable. If this was his choice, it saddens me. If it was Dicu’s choice I am embarrassed for Hechler. Vocally, he is of the traditional countertenor mold, coming with the factory standard registration issues. He got laughs (intended or unintended?) when evoking his full baritonal chest voice to pique a phrase. I think that he could offer us a more nuanced, threatening and relevant antagonist. If only he had been asked.</p><p>Dicu and Schenke’s neglect of the central relationship of this story leaves us with a wheel that doesn’t spin. Thankfully, the musical side of things fare immensely better. The Duisburger Philharmoniker under Jörg Halubek sounded splendid. Although I couldn’t find confirmation, I believe this production adhered closely to the original 1725 version with only two interpolations from other Händel works. The chosen cuts enhanced the musical proportion of the arias beautifully, the recites were organic and successfully moved the plot. The musical efforts of the Halubek, the orchestra and the singers truly salvaged a troubled evening.</p><p>I lived in Duisburg my first two years in Germany, and on the few occasions I wasn’t myself onstage, I managed to cache some memories in this theater: A not so great <em>Anatevka (</em>the German title of <em>Fiddler. </em>It long puzzled, how that show - or the sit-com ‘Hogan’s Hero’s’ - had became beloved by the Germans. Humility and self-reflection. That’s how.) It was my first experience of this show in Germany. Golde was played by a well-beyond expiration date Martha Mödl, paired with a Tevye at least three decades younger her junior. (How did Yentl get away with that?); there was also a trés Brechtian <em>Mahagonny </em>with a stellar performance by Trudeliese Schmidt as Widow Begbick; and, a solo evening in which Gwyneth Jones smashingly sang her way through the entire back catalog of Malvina Schnorr von Carolsfeld (<em>i.e</em>. first Isolde, <em>et al.) </em>On those evenings, the women won my heart. Upon my return, the boys have one-upped them. And even though the production didn’t live up to its theatrical potential, it surpassed expectations musically. I look forward to hearing more from Halubek, Hoza, Danta, Orellana, while I await another algorithmic home run from YouTube.</p>]]></content:encoded>
      <category><![CDATA[Opera]]></category>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/aa0623c6-33b5-4ac4-8998-453ce0cebe40/teaser_image/1770474073?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;fm=jpg&amp;crop=faces" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/ef266393-5bad-4038-8276-ff16bd911a1d/posts/aa0623c6-33b5-4ac4-8998-453ce0cebe40</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">aa0623c6-33b5-4ac4-8998-453ce0cebe40</guid>
      <pubDate>Fri, 13 Feb 2026 11:39:39 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[State of the Arts, Sunday Update!]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Hi guys! It’s my first Sunday update! Thanks for subscribing! I hope you have had some time to check out the posts that are already online: Hello There! a general…]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/9afc6b8a-9788-434d-9766-c76672c83146/uploads/images/3o4k7i7l2q/fulllogo.jpg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><p>Hi guys!</p><p>It’s my first Sunday update! Thanks for subscribing! I hope you have had some time to check out the posts that are already online: </p><h5>Hello There! </h5><p>a general welcome post with some thoughts about my goals and intentions with the newsletter;</p><h5>Warmer Climes….</h5><p>Konzerthaus Orchestra Berlin and Programmatic Music</p><h5>“Is there no telephone?”</h5><p>Aufstieg und Fall der Stadt Mahagonny, Komische Oper Berlin </p><h5>“Free your doubtful mind and melt your cold, cold heart”</h5><p>Das Kalte Herz, Staatsoper Unter den Linden</p><h5>“Singing the songs of angry men” </h5><p>Andrea Chenier, Deutsche Oper Berlin</p><h5>“The eternal feminine”</h5><p>Berliner Philharmoniker, Kirill Petrenko, Mahler 8!!!</p><h5>“Hey Alexa, you got a head on that plate?”</h5><p>Salome, Komische Oper </p><h5>Don Carlo and the Romantics</h5><p>Don Carlo, Deutsche Oper Berlin</p><p></p><p>Coming up next week are reports from a trip to Duisburg 😱 for <em>Giulio Cesare in Egitto</em>, a look at ‘Concept’ productions, and some thoughts about the ‘lost’ composers being rediscovered at the Deutsche Oper Berlin. </p><p>On this week’s plan are a few concerts and Rosa von Praunheim’s <em>Insel der Perversen </em>at the Deutsches Theater. I am very much looking forward to that! </p><p>You may have noticed that I haven’t written about any musicals yet… I promise some are coming up, so keep an eye peeled out to the page.  </p><p>I would love to hear from you! Anything particular you want me to cover? And a special thanks to my first members! I hope you are enjoying the content! </p><p>OK! I’m off to Bruckner now! More later, </p><p></p><p>Perrin </p><p> </p><p></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <category><![CDATA[Performing Arts]]></category>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/9afc6b8a-9788-434d-9766-c76672c83146/uploads/images/3o4k7i7l2q/fulllogo.jpg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;fm=jpg&amp;crop=faces" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/ef266393-5bad-4038-8276-ff16bd911a1d/posts/9afc6b8a-9788-434d-9766-c76672c83146</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">9afc6b8a-9788-434d-9766-c76672c83146</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 08 Feb 2026 14:18:03 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Warmer Climes…]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[KONZERTHAUS ORCHESTER BERLIN Constantinos Carydis, Conductor Haochen Zhang, Piano Eduardo Belmar, Flute Periklis Koukos Ode to Oedipus; Franz Liszt Concerto for Piano…]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h2>KONZERTHAUS ORCHESTER BERLIN</h2><h3>Constantinos Carydis, Conductor</h3><h4>Haochen Zhang, Piano Eduardo Belmar, Flute</h4><h5><strong>Periklis Koukos </strong><em>Ode to Oedipus</em>; <strong>Franz Liszt </strong><em>Concerto for Piano and Orchestra No. 2 in A </em><strong>Ottorino Respighi </strong><em>Fontane di Roma - Poema sinfonico</em>; <strong>Claude Debussy </strong><em>„Syrinx“ for solo flute</em>; <strong>Ottorino Respighi </strong><em>Pini di Roma - Poema sinfonico</em></h5><hr aria-hidden="true"/><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/state-of-the-arts/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to newsletter</a></p><h5>Konzerthaus, Berlin, 23.January.2026</h5><p>“Music inspired by warmer climes” inspired conductor Constantinos Carydis’s diverse program, and though Liszt’s 2nd Piano Concerto doesn’t directly fit that description, his crediting with the coining of the term ‘programmatic music’ does justify it’s inclusion. All of the other works are good examples of this musical genus, evoking place, feeling or story more and less successfully.</p><p>When Liszt coined the term, there were already plenty of examples of programmatic music - Beethoven’s <em>Pastoral Symphony</em> or Vivaldi’s <em>Four Seasons </em>spring to mind - and the use of the term is now common in our music vernacular. In fact, even film music is a reversed version of technique; traditional programmatic music attempts to call up an image, wherein a film composer is interpreting an existing image to imbue it with deeper meaning.</p><p>At any rate, the idea of using music to illustrate, paint or depict something (or someone) is not foreign to our modern ears, in fact one can probably assume that all music, to some extent, is in some way programmatic, though there are any number of composers who would rail against this generalization. Still, many of the most beloved pieces in the orchestral repertoire belong to this category, and Respighi is a master of the technique. Debussy, as well, is at home sketching objects or narrative musically, but may be the most adept at emotionally inspired programmatic music.</p><p>I would guess Perikles Koukos was influenced by both 20th century masters with whom he shares this programm, but for a living composer with a significant output, surprisingly little information pops up in a google search. I could elicit he is best known for his operas, and after hearing this piece, I would believe he writes graciously for the voice; his compositional language is entirely rooted in tonality and rhythmic impulses, with a generous melodic signature. From the titles, most of his orchestra work are inspired by existing Greek subjects or myths, and <em>Ode to Oedipus (2025) </em>(dedicated to Carydis) is the latest in this line. He employs a comparable orchestra to Respighi and scores it well. Nevertheless, as pleasant and proficient as it is, the suite never got under my skin. In fact, it felt more like a successful soundtrack to a documentary about Oedipus than a work that stands by itself.</p><p>I liked the piece, and yet, I found myself asking why it was that Koukos’ entirely proficient piece didn’t have the impact of any of the works on the second half of this concert? Of course, how we experience a piece of art, or anything for that matter, is subjective and personal, but is there some way of measuring quality <em>objectively</em>? When I am coaching students, I often differentiate between bad, good and brilliant composers. But is this just my taste? My partiality? There are artists that we collectively have decided are ‘greater’ than others, but how did we arrive at this identification? And if we reject this determination, what is responsible? An example:</p><p>I realize this borders on blasphemy, and despite being a very capable pianist, I have never responded to either Liszt or Chopin’s Piano Concertos. I adore other works of both composers, but the concertos I am drawn to are those of Beethoven, Mendelssohn, the 20th century masters, some Mozart, etc. Since tastes change and develop with age and experience, I was looking forward to hearing the Liszt 2 to see if the cranky old(er) man I now am would feel differently.</p><p>I do understand why musicologists and pianists taut the virtues of this piece. It’s compact one movement, more episodic than sonata form, filled with Franz’s compulsion for dissecting, transforming and transfiguring melodic motives, is all very attractive. Not quite ‘theme and variations’, more ‘theme and alterations’, Liszt often makes the soloist the accompaniment to the action rather than the star, actually most thematic material is debuted by other instruments before being picked up, mutated and passed on by the piano. Nonetheless, the focus is on virtuosity, and for me, it lacks the emotional depth of other works by him I admire. Whereas the solo piano music successfully often uses devilish technicality to express emotionality, this concerto seems feels as if it were written as an assignment. Yes, it took him twenty years to get to a version with which he was (apparently) content, but it was started in the height of his megastar touring years, and certainly would have been a means toward pleasing an audience. Ironically, after all that time and effort, he never performed the solo in public.</p><hr aria-hidden="true"/><p><a href="https://youtu.be/ha4iQjz_tN0?is=sf8Ue23LCwIj3uR0">Haochen Zhang; Debussy, Images, book 2</a></p><hr aria-hidden="true"/><p>Haochen Zhang is <em>not</em> the reason the piece didn’t ’land’ with me. He is a fine player, adeptly powerful when necessary, but equally able to color and shape his sound in the intimate bits. (He exploited this ability to best effect in his encore, Debussy’s <em>Images, ‘Et la lune descend sur le temple qui fut’ </em>which not only served as a great contrast to his playing of the Liszt, but cleverly augmented Carydis’s programmatic program.) Zhang highlighted the Concerto’s idiosyncrasies, while minimizing the disjointed nature of the non-traditional form. And even in the climaxes, he remained refined and gentlemanly. He is one of many fine pianists in his generation. Only time will tell which one’s manage the long haul, but Zhang is certainly one who on whom to keep tabs.</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/state-of-the-arts/posts">View all posts</a></p><p>I went into the intermission mulling over my question of the quantifiable worth of art (as you do), but in the second half, I was reassured that I could still be emotionally swept away. Both of the Respighi <em>Poema sinfonici </em>are stunning pieces, walking that very fine line between popularist appeal and ‘high’ art. They are fun but not campy, wondrous but not maudlin, and truly, truly evocative. The grandeur and force of the last movement of <em>Pini di Roma</em> can hardly be beat in the standard repertoire (Hindemith’s <em>Marsch</em> from <em>Symphonische Metamorphosen </em>comes to mind) and the Konzerthaus Orchester rose to the occasion. Throughout the night, their playing was on point, but in the second half they raised their game. Carydis, who’s inherent theatricality fit this program so well, led them vigourously through the Respighi, while highlighting textures and nuances in the scores I have never heard before. A special shout out to the beautiful playing of the offstage trumpet solo (I think this was Peter Dörpinghaus?)</p><p>Placing the Debussy between the Respighi tone poems was surprisingly fitting: On paper, I wondered how this would play, but in performance, the <em>Syrinx </em>(beautiful scaled and colored by Eduardo Belmar) became commentary and palette cleanser between the Rome portraits. The dramaturgical curve of Carydis’s program was impressive. By identifying through-lines, and connecting devices between these pieces he plotted a satisfying emotional journey through the night culminating in the intense and massive finale of <em>Pini di Roma,</em> which literally took my breath away.</p><p>So… Why is it I am more viscerally invested in the Respighi and Debussy? Are they ‘better’ than the composers on the first half? Koukos’s score is good, the Liszt concerto has stood the test of time. But the second half of this program was inherently more gratifying. I don’t believe this is purely <em>my </em>personal taste, as it was palpable in the hall that I was not the only attendant to feel the difference. Is it a result of the program order? Is it inherent compositional skill? Or emotional intelligence? Or the choice of subject depicted? I don’t yet know the answer, and perhaps it is impossible to know, but the great advantage of living in a city with numerous world class cultural institutions is that I get to keep working on figuring it out. I happily take on this burden, and will get back to you shortly with new findings.</p><p></p><p><a href="https://youtu.be/pMeXzqTfNcY?is=H-9d1hbNl7VAF9PS">Respighi; Pini Di Roma, via Appia</a></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/state-of-the-arts/about">Become a member</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <category><![CDATA[Concert]]></category>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/b86bd72f-72c6-4345-b1a9-6f2908083a0b/teaser_image/1770395869?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;fm=jpg&amp;crop=faces" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/ef266393-5bad-4038-8276-ff16bd911a1d/posts/b86bd72f-72c6-4345-b1a9-6f2908083a0b</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">b86bd72f-72c6-4345-b1a9-6f2908083a0b</guid>
      <pubDate>Fri, 06 Feb 2026 16:37:49 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[“Is there no telephone?”]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[AUFSTIEG UND FALL DER STADT MAHAGONNY Kurt Weill Libretto Bertolt Brecht Komische Oper, Berlin, 13.December.2025 Conductor: Alexander Joel							…]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h2>AUFSTIEG UND FALL DER STADT MAHAGONNY </h2><h3>Kurt Weill                       Libretto Bertolt Brecht</h3><h4>Komische Oper, Berlin, 13.December.2025</h4><h5>Conductor: Alexander Joel								Stage Direction: Barrie Kosky</h5><p></p><p>I have a love/hate relationship with Barrie Kosky’s stage direction. It is rare that his slant on a work leaves me indifferent (Wiener Staatsoper “Figaro”.) He has mounted some of the most paltry productions I have ever seen (“Kiss me, Kate” “West Side Story”) and has also been responsible for incredibly engaging and well-thought out nights of music theatre (“Anatevka” “Candide”.) This ability to trigger me has earned my respect and admiration. So, I keenly trotted off to the Schiller Theater wondering if I this encounter with his work would leave me gagged or aghast.</p><p>Up to the intermission, I wasn’t sure, but feared it might be the latter. I couldn’t discern how I felt about Kosky’s approach to the divine Brecht/Weill monstrosity that is <em>Mahagonny</em>. Slow dramatic propulsion, unclear relationships, motives or narrative decisions - the dense first act’s unsettling music sent me and my companion into the pause thinking we had missed something, or just weren’t clever enough to get it. One exception: the build up to Jim’s verboten song “Denn wie man sich bettet” (Act I, No.11) which ends the <em>written</em> first act was thrilling and suspenseful, and when the song came, I gasped.</p><p>This production, as many do, moves the first act curtain into the middle of Brecht/Weill’s intended second act and may account, in part, for my discomfort: The new first act becomes primarily expositional, setting up dominos that will inevitably fall during act two. But there are a lot of dominos, not a lot of plot action and little payoff, which endangers the first act of getting turgid. In the three act version, Jim’s “crime” (see above), is committed under the assumption that the hurricane is about to land and raze the city, and it gratifyingly releases all the built up tension. By extending the act and circumventing the hurricane, this effect is emotionally dissipated, even if it does create a logical dramaturgical ‘rise and fall’ that appeals to the intellect.</p><p>[Side thought: would it be conceivable to restructure the end of a new act one by inserting the hurricane’s charting off course (from the old act two) <em>between</em> ‘du darfst’ and ‘denn wie man sich bettet’, thereby maintaining the admittedly pleasing dramaturgical symmetry without lessening an emotionally satisfying payoff at the close of the act? Since both Brecht and Weill estates are notoriously prickly, we will likely never know. Still, a boy can dream…]</p><p>At any rate, Act Two definitely does take us on a ride. The turgidity of Act One gives way to a rollercoaster through the absurd demise of character after character, and arguably to the unavoidable demise of civilization itself. Jack O’Brien aka Jakob Schmitt succumbs to his venal gluttony, Joe is murdered via boxing, and, of course, Jim is railroaded through a rigged trial then crucified by the town (only Jenny and Bill refuse to participate). Bill has managed to survive, maybe because of his inherent caution, or because he could best manipulate the powers that be without getting his hands dirty? As the inevitable encroaches, the dramatic and musical pacing builds through an especially horrifying and gut-wrenching final 20 minutes.</p><p>Musically, the score was in good hands. Alexander Joel navigates adeptly the  angularity and quirks, lyricism and beauty in the music. (Weill’s orchestrations have that singular ability to sound as if the world has already ended.) Happily, the orchestra played significantly more confidently and astutely than when I last heard them, coloring and informing the drama throughout the night. The chorus as major character in this epic is crucial, and as expected at this house, they were willing and able - for most intents and purposes - to actively contribute (there is always that one member who does far too much, far too ineptly, just as there is another member who doesn’t do, well, anything much.) If the intonation was sometimes iffy, the blend was consistent, and their expressiveness generally pitch perfect.</p><p>The principal cast was refreshingly good. Hubert Zapíôr’s Bill is beguiling; we want to know his secrets. He also looks great and has a stunningly beautiful voice. As the stand out of the evening, he is rivaled by Seth Carico as Moses. He literally sings and acts his shirt off in this part. Whether his instinct, or Kosky’s intention, Moses becomes the motor of this <em>Stadt</em>, propelling the story while overpowering Ariana Lucas’s miscast Witwe Begbick. She is, however, game, interestingly having her best moments in the Benares Sextet. Generally, she struggles vocally, and thus, the character suffers. They are supported and abetted by Fatty, played by Ivan Tursič, whose fearless singing and engaging personality serve him well throughout the night. Caspar Krieger offers up a Jack O’Brien who makes you wish he wasn’t the first to die, and Philipp Meierhöfer, as Joe, fills out the lumberjack quartet competently. Only Nadja Mchantaf as Jenny relies on cliché and doesn’t get to the core of this potentially fascinating woman. Admittedly, as long as the memory of Stratas or Migenes in this part holds, the bar remains quite high. However, her wooly, thick and dark sound limits her linguistically, and obscures both the directness and litheness the role demands. Sadly, this significantly reduces the character’s status from Jim’s equal to one more of the doomed surrounding him. And yet, this doubles the focus on Jim Mahoney. This is a beast of a sing, and Gerard Schneider does well. Although the voice loses power and size in the top, the color is always engaging and appropriate, and he is emotionally connected to music and text. Moreover, his inherently likable humanity anchors the evening. This is his story, and we feel with him as his search becomes ours, making his inevitable destruction all that more devastating. Jim’s final aria, death and the following moral sermon pack a punch.</p><p>My curious ambivalence towards Kosky’s work extends generally to the Komische Oper, and if last night’s <em>Salome</em> was an unsuccessful attempt at relevance and provocation, newness and ‘Art’, tonight’s <em>Mahagonny</em> proves that striving for these things is not only valid but important. At the end of the night, there was still much I felt i had not understood: What did the Hebrew on the monkey cart mean? Was Kosky’s intent an allegory on late stage capitalism? Or a commentary on the Israel/Palestine conflict? Or both? Or none of this? Is it simply a series of impulses meant to lead me to my own reflections on meaning? Maybe. I don’t know, but in the end, it is irrelevant: the night moved me, made me think and feel. It is a great score and was respectfully presented. And when I go to the theater, this is what I want. </p>]]></content:encoded>
      <category><![CDATA[Musical Theater]]></category>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/581b7f4f-2f18-47f2-a7bb-5327443d4bf1/teaser_image/1770315975?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;fm=jpg&amp;crop=faces" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/ef266393-5bad-4038-8276-ff16bd911a1d/posts/581b7f4f-2f18-47f2-a7bb-5327443d4bf1</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">581b7f4f-2f18-47f2-a7bb-5327443d4bf1</guid>
      <pubDate>Thu, 05 Feb 2026 18:26:15 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[“Free your doubtful mind and melt your cold, cold heart”]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[DAS KALTE HERZ Matthias Pintscher Text by Daniel Arkadij Gerzenberg Staatsoper Unter den Linden, Berlin, 20.January.2026 Conductor, Matthias…]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h2><strong>DAS KALTE HERZ</strong></h2><h3>Matthias Pintscher Text by Daniel Arkadij Gerzenberg</h3><h4>Staatsoper Unter den Linden, Berlin, 20.January.2026</h4><h5>Conductor, Matthias Pintscher; Director, James Darrah Black; Set Design, Adam Rigg; Costume Design, Molly Irelan; Light Design, Yi Zhao; Video, Hana S. Kim; Dramaturgie, Olaf A. Schmidt</h5><p></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/state-of-the-arts/about">Become a member</a></p><p>One of Daniel Barenboim’s last acts before departing from the leading team of the Staatsoper was to commission this new work from Matthias Pintscher, esteemed German (in exile) composer and conductor. According to press and interviews, the idea of re-visiting Wilhelm Hauff’s 19th Century fairy-tale take down of the capitalistic system (itself a reworking of Washington Irving’s “The Devil and Tom Walker”) came to him on a walk in the Schwarzwald.</p><p>Despite some beloved adaptations, Hauff’s tale is not in the league of Aesop or the Grimm Bros, so a short synopsis of the original story is useful for our purposes:</p><p><em>Discontented Peter, a poor charcoal burner, hears about a Black Forest sprite which grants wishes to those who, like Peter, are Sunday’s children. On the way to the (good) imp in the woods, Peter meets Dutch-Mike, a different (evil) woodland spirit who nightly haunts the forest. When the wishes granted by the good woody imp go to pot, Peter cuts a deal with Dutch-Mike to trade his heart for a cold, stone heart (hence, the title.) Through this exchange he gains all the wealth and status he desires, but loses empathy, emotionality and his capacity to be a ‘mensch’. After various misadventures, culminating in him murdering his wife and promptly giving up the ghost, he is redeemed when his first (good wood) forest friend helps him trick (bad) Dutch-Mike: He gets his heart, wife and life back, and lives happily ever after.</em></p><p>Texter Daniel Arkadij Gerzenberg’s late-stage-capitalistic rewrite, presents us a Peter who no longer needs status and riches (tbh, he seems pretty well off), but just really wants to get rid of his heart and all the <em>maleur </em>it is causing. He is goaded by Azaël (Gerzenberg’s re-assignment of the wood imp) and yearns for Anubis (G’s version of Dutch-Mike) to do the deed. Encouraged and abetted by his mother, who seems to be in cahoots with the spirits, he is consistently enjoined by wife Clara, who just wishes he would come to his senses and be happy. His child-self lurks in the corners, sometimes trying to lead him out of this nightmare, some times participating. When Anubis finally arrives, Peter’s Mother is tasked with removing the heart, which she does despite her torment at doing so. Peter’s happy ending, once the heart is gone, and the spirits are quelled, is that he is separated from everyone and everything; finally, at peace.</p><p>Since this was a World Premiere (11.Jan.2026), I was intrigued to read how the press had reacted. Most of what I found was ambivalent to negative, either complaining that Hauff’s perfectly good (and still valid parable) wasn’t dramatized, or bemoaning the extreme symbolism mash-up culled from diverse world traditions and used through all aspects of the production. They also criticized Pintscher’s use of filmic sound-palettes or ‘fx’ in his scoring. And I will be honest, during the performance, many of these same questions occurred to me. I had done my due diligence and familiarized myself with Hauff, but Gerzenberg’s story was so far removed, I wondered why… … Why had the responsible parties made the choices they made?</p><p>An advantage to these musings of mine is that I am not on a deadline, and my commentary can (perhaps) benefit from my living a few days with my experience. In this case, it also provoked my consideration of what the creators intentions were and how successful they were in implementing them. The piece stuck with me, and I know that if it were rubbish, I wouldn’t have kept thinking about it. The time ruminating enriched my take away and brought me to an understanding of the piece. Without discussing it with the creators, I can’t know if I am on the right track, but there is high value in art that needs a few days of introspection to bring some kind of internal resolution.</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/state-of-the-arts/posts">View all posts</a></p><p>When comparing the old and new stories, it is impossible not to notice the packed symbolism in Gerzenberg’s text. In fact, so many symbols run amok through it, with yet more added in the design and directorial elements, that it might disorient the viewer. This affronted some critics, but I believe this was exactly the goal in order to differentiate between Peter’s 19th century <em>discontented</em> and his 21st century <em>debilitated</em> heart. Hauff was writing in reaction to early, industrial capitalism; Adam Smith’s exploration of the still youthful economic system was barely 50 years old. If Hauff is sounding warning where it <em>would</em> <em>likely lead us</em>, Gerzenberg is responding demonstratively to where capitalism and the associated aspects of Byung-Chul Han’s ‘achievement society’ <em>have</em> <em>led us</em>, reflecting not just the emotional malcontent, but the mental malaise which are so prevalent in our ‘brave new world.’ This new <em>Cold Heart</em> is concerned with heart <em>and</em> mind.</p><p>And so, in Peter’s confused and troubled mind, where he is both victim and perpetrator of his plight, his signals get continually crossed. Egyptian Anubis and Christian Azäel become cohorts in his brain. What he assumes is a transformational wood fuses with the destructive unrestrained appetite of his dreamed wolf, whose pelts in turn become a status symbol: There is a clever ‘reveal’ in the scenography when the forest of orderly saplings ‘transforms’ into a pack of dead wolves on meat hooks…As the story progresses, one after another are removed, most becoming the coats of the townswomen who frame the story. His sick mind is trying to cope, but mostly just gets lost, further terrifying himself. Rather than wealth and status, Gerzenberg’s Peter desperately needs a quieting of his senses, a peace in isolation.</p><p>As a viewer, we too are inundated with constant impressions, and all of the elements of the production add to the information overload. Every production department admirably contributes to this effect, and the immense contributions of the cast can’t be understated.</p><p>Samuel Hasselhorn is a fine actor singer. His baritone is lush and silvery, never stressed when singing over the thickest of Pintscher’s orchestrations, his diction is very good, and his Peter - sad, yearning, misunderstood and entirely relatable - anchors the narrative. The opera’s high point is his stunning final monologue, after his clamoring heart and mind (i.e., the orchestra) have been silenced. This scena is arguably Pintscher’s best writing of the evening, the seamless welding of text to melodic line plaintively beautiful and highly effective.</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/state-of-the-arts/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to newsletter</a></p><p>This high point follows the tour de force that is Rosie Aldridge’s Anubis. From her highly effective entrance to her final de-mythification, she owns the stage in a one woman show of vocal bravura and impressive acting. No gesture wasted, no phrase unexploited, Aldridge propels this story to it’s climax. Equally compelling is Sunnyi Melles as Azaël. In a role Weigel or Lenya would have killed for, actress Melles sets the fever dream in motion, part trickster, part devil, part Gollum, part Joan Dark. Katarina Bradić as Peter’s Mother successfully transits the curve from willing advocate to aghast malefactor with her warm mezzo. Clara, Peter’s wife, (sung by Sophia Burgos) perplexed as to just what could be wrong with him or how she might help him is, possibly, exhausted by it all. As Clara’s tessitura rises through the evening, so does the impact of Burgos’s voice. Adriane Queiroz as the Old Lady beautifully sets the tone of the evening. Her interesting and adept bevy of vocal qualities (which I assume are in Pintscher’s score?) are impressive and effective. I wished she had had another scene. It is rare to go home happy with all the performances in any cast, but this cast, committed and capable, give everything they have to make this production succeed.</p><p>Pintscher’s music is evocative, the underlying pulse of the entire piece (the heartbeat, if you will) is constant, consistent and borders on incessant. During the performance, I found myself getting annoyed by it, but without this almost static over-stimulation the great emotional release (ironically) of the closing a capella monologue would likely have been significantly diminished. In a callback to Balstrode’s spoken utterance at the end of <em>Peter Grimes, </em>the stark contrast between the dense textures of the preceding scenes and this aria underscores Peter’s triumph, not by killing himself, but by removing his disquiet, and himself, from the world. Pintscher’s orchestral writing is most successful in the orchestral interludes depicting all things sylvan, invoking Lohengrin, or expressing the emotional intensity of Peter’s dilemma. He seems more hesitant to use this ability to color or differentiate orchestral textures in the scenes. That is not to say he is not clever. He manages, beyond Wagner, to pay homage to Henze, Berg and Britten, Bernhard Hermann and Jerry Goldsmith while still sounding like Pintscher.</p><p>As I said, the stage craft aspects of this staging are highly effective in underscoring Pintscher/Ginzenberg’s parable. The production is visually captivating. Adam Rigg’s rustically minimal set, is lit beautifully by Yi Zhao and coupled with an ever changing, disturbing video by Hana S. Kim and Molly Irelan’s costumes are both suited the individual characters while heightening the dysphoria of Peter’s world. The peak of the interconnection between production departments comes with Anubis’ red on red on red on red lair.</p><p>James Darrah Black’s spearheading of the entire production is astute. I suspect he had an influence honing and focusing the writing process, and the performances of the cast clearly benefit from his clear and decisive hand. This is not an easy piece, but it is a worthy piece, and he has successfully negotiated many of it’s perils. Of course, is not perfect, but deserves a life beyond the Berlin and Paris (Opéra Comique) productions. One can always quibble, but in this case I think the critical response was overly hasty.</p><p><em>Das kalte Herz </em>offers a valid commentary on the ever-darkening dystopian world we find ourselves. Will it, like Berg’s <em>Wozzeck</em> (to which it owes a great deal in narrative structure, dramaturical tone and musical form) transcend zeitgeist to become standard repertoire? I can’t know that. I do know that it moved me, made me think, and most importantly, appears to have been mounted by competent people who believed in the story they chose to tell. And for a first production of a new work, that is a worthwhile success.</p>]]></content:encoded>
      <category><![CDATA[Opera]]></category>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/90b53699-60e7-4975-a809-8eea6759657f/teaser_image/1770243355?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;fm=jpg&amp;crop=faces" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/ef266393-5bad-4038-8276-ff16bd911a1d/posts/90b53699-60e7-4975-a809-8eea6759657f</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">90b53699-60e7-4975-a809-8eea6759657f</guid>
      <pubDate>Thu, 05 Feb 2026 15:27:17 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Hello there!]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Welcome to State of the Arts! Thank you for subscribing to this experiment! You may already have seen a few articles available online. More are on their way, and I will…]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h2>Welcome to State of the Arts!</h2><p>Thank you for subscribing to this experiment! You may already have seen a few articles available online. More are on their way, and I will send out a weekly overview on Sunday nights.</p><p>For many years, I have ‘practiced’ doing this reporting: If I was really gobsmacked by a performance, I would head home to excitedly catalog my thoughts and impressions. Far more often, returning from a venue frustrated and unsatisfied, I found it cathartic and educational to dissect and analyze what I felt went wrong - primarily for my own edification and development. I think this made me a better theater-maker and musician, as well as a more participatory audience member. The logical next step was to share my private musings publicly with colleagues, friends, arts enthusiasts and the general public.</p><p>People who know me have witnessed my excitement and enthusiasm for quality effort and my equal infuriation at shoddy work. I have strong opinions, and happily offer them. The following guidelines are intended to help clarify my intentions in sharing.</p><p>After numerous decades in the performing arts (I started so young! Ha ha!), I firmly believe that those undertaking artistic pursuit — in any form or venue — have the best intentions. As fun as <em>The Producers </em>may be<em> (</em>the original 1967 film. The musical is - in <em>my</em> opinion - sadly inferior in most ways) I would assert that few people <em>intend</em> to do bad work. More often than not, they are highly invested in the projects to which they choose to commit, and very close to the creative process. Yet sometimes, despite their (our) best intentions, the work is not good. No one gets it right all the time. Arguably, this is what makes us grow the most as artists.</p><h5>“Failure is the foundation of success” - Lao Tseu.</h5><p>Misguided attempts are generally more interesting to analyze than successes, but it is important to note that when I am criticizing a work or performance, it is purely my experience of the work, and not the person(s) behind it. That said, I would generally suggest refraining discussion with creators or performers <em>directly after </em>the event: I read somewhere that Sondheim said he didn’t want critique directly after a premiere, just to be told he did a good job. Very relatable. Artists are sensitive and raw and especially after the high-stress lead up to premiere.</p><p>Another thought. One of my mentors, Judy Nataluci, used to say “80% of your career you will not be at 100%” and that is wisdom worth bearing in mind. There are so many internal and external factors that play a role in our ability to give our best performance. It is our responsibility to give the best we have, and understand where our limits lie. And so, it is entirely possible that an audience may ‘see’ a qualitively different show, simply by attending on a different night. This is one of the many beauties of live performance; each night is unique, and can’t be repeated. My observations, obviously, can only apply to the particular performance I watched.</p><p>A third related idea. I learned as a performer, and further underscored during my time as Artistic Director of the Joop van den Ende Academy, that it is impossible to evaluate, or predict, results any further than the moment at hand. Especially in regards to young artists. It is far too easy (and popular) to write off or minimize people’s talent in the creative industries: “You’ll never sing that. You’ll never play that part. You’re not that type” And so it goes. When I was 20, a teacher listed of five parts and said “those are the roles you will sing in your career.” I rightly responded: “How can you know that today? I am twenty.” The roles I have, in fact, performed over my career have been significantly more in number and varied in character than her dismissively short list. It is impossible to know where a performer’s career will go. We can only reflect to them what we see today, now, and in this context.</p><p>My goal is not to be a theater or music critic. There are too many of them as it is, and very often their work is short-sighted and seemingly deliberately destructive towards creativity and artistic expression. Instead, I hope that these posts can incite curiosity, begin an ongoing discussion about our performance work, and become a useful tool in elevating them.</p><p>Of course, I have no qualms in calling out lazy or negligent work. The determinate factor here is identifying efforts that do not strive to be the best they possibly can. As an artist and educator, this is really the only thing for which I have no patience. The only way our artistic industries grow and improve, or individual artists can fully actualize their potential, is by presenting relevant, pertinent and viable work - critically, financially, and morally - taken up with good intent.</p><p>So, enough of my ranting! I will continue to develop this platform, and hope soon to expand to other formats (ooh la la!). If you would like to send me (friendly, constructive) feedback, please respond to this email!</p><p>For the time being, these posts are available free of charge to subscribers, but if you would like to become a member (at a very reasonable price), I would very much appreciate your patronage! Click on the link below.</p><p></p><p></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <category><![CDATA[Performing Arts]]></category>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/ead382d3-ec0c-4e8a-8a39-9b105f94cdae/teaser_image/1770305175?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;fm=jpg&amp;crop=faces" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/ef266393-5bad-4038-8276-ff16bd911a1d/posts/ead382d3-ec0c-4e8a-8a39-9b105f94cdae</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">ead382d3-ec0c-4e8a-8a39-9b105f94cdae</guid>
      <pubDate>Thu, 05 Feb 2026 15:24:19 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[“Singing the songs of angry men” ]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[ANDREA CHENIER Umberto Giordano Libretto Luigi Illica Deutsche Oper Berlin, Berlin, 18.December.2025 Conductor: Michele Gamba Stage Direction: John Dew I was looking…]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>ANDREA CHENIER</strong></h3><h5>Umberto Giordano</h5><h5>Libretto Luigi Illica</h5><h5>Deutsche Oper Berlin, Berlin, 18.December.2025</h5><h5>Conductor: Michele Gamba Stage Direction: John Dew</h5><p></p><p>I was looking forward to seeing this production of <em>Andrea Chenier</em>, as I had never experienced the opera in its entirety. The best laid plans, however, do often go awry. Thanks to a technician strike, the production was performed without scenic devices. I believe that furniture, props and costumes were featured in their entirety, offering atmosphere to this semi-staged, semi-concert evening and some likely clues to the production’s original intentions.</p><p>The upending of such a well-routined show is possibly the most elemental factor for its deficits. Without scenery or normal staging, many of the performers seemed ill at ease, lost and struggling (especially in Act 1.) No doubt the performance conditions and the general discomfort coming from the stage influenced me. It may also account for the difficulty conductor Michael Gamba had in restraining the orchestra. Despite playing well (as they nearly always do), and Gamba’s good sense of proportion and drama, too often they overpowered the stage. It is impossible to know if this was exacerbated by the special conditions of this performance.</p><p>Additionally, as one of the older production at the house (it is now officially retired), it is highly possible that John Dew’s original direction has been significantly diluted over generations of restaging and may account for the tonal dichotomies - certain scenes seem directed as farce, others as political thriller - and general lack of clarity in the story telling.</p><p>Very loosely based on the titular poet’s life and subsequent execution during la Révolution française, the story leans significantly more into the love triangle between Chenier, Carlo Gérard (an amalgam of historical figures most inspired by Jean Lambert-Tallien) and the wholly fictional Maddelena de Coigny, using the political story to motor plot, add scenic color, and provide motivation for the romantic denouement. It is not a particularly venturous libretto and the two dimensional dramaturgy leads to obvious comparisons with Les Mis, though the music here is certainly so much more aspirational.</p><p>The ‘raison d’être’ for remaining standard operatic repertoire despite these issues is the centring of the story around a young dramatic tenor in the role of Andrea Chenier. From it’s premiere it served as a star making vehicle, elevating Giuseppe Borgatti from also ran to major star, and has solidified the reputation of many a tenor since, from Gigli, to Corelli to Domingo, etc. Interesting side note: following his Chenier success, Borgatti focused on Wagnerian roles for the large part of his career, becoming the first Italian Tenor invited to Bayreuth (although there is no record of an actual performance occurring.)</p><p>This production has featured Gregory Kunde, Jonas Kaufmann and such as the poet over the years, and it is for good reason that Chenier is a marker for the aspiring <em>spinto </em>or <em>drammatico</em>. It is a truly BIG sing, including 4 arias (arguably the most famous being “Come un bel dì di maggio”), a few duets, a duel, significant stage time, and all sung over a rather large orchestra. This production at the Deutsche Oper Berlin premiered in 1994 and has featured any number of Chenier’s. The man of the hour this season is again Martin Muehle. Back in 2017, jumping into the part put him on the map, and he is back for the productions finale run of performances.</p><p>Muehle definitely has the voice, and the looks, for the part. His timbre is reminiscent of an old school <em>spinto</em>, and this wins him big points with audiences. They happily shouted their bravos after each aria and in the curtain calls. While he has the vocal size and physical stamina to successfully negotiate the role, plus thrilling climax notes - pretty much everything under the passaggio was irritatingly sharp, most likely due to the extreme sub-glottal pressure he employs to attain and maintain his Corelli-like color. (I hoped this might be an anomaly at this performance, but happened upon numerous reviews of his 2020 performances which call him out for the same. Take the note, Marty…) And the extreme force he employs to sing naturally affects the character: Muehle’s poet is broodingly intense, but borders on aggressive, lacking grace and contour. The high notes are impressive, to be sure, but I would have like more passion, more charm, better intonation and more status in the portrayal.</p><p>The other two vertices of the love triangle are Roman Burdenko (also reprising the role) as Gérard and Maria Motolygina as Maddalena. Burdenko started slow. In the first two acts, his voice and character were occasionally lost under the bulky orchestration, but by the time he reached the third act aria (‘Nemico della Patria’) both timbre and dramatic propulsion were on point. This portrayal grew throughout the night and he won me over, especially in the scenes <em>after</em> the famous aria.</p><p>Maddalena, much like Giordano’s other notable soprano heroine, Fedora, lives in the middle voice, and it requires a meaty and colorful voice in this register. The usual suspects (Milanov, Callas, Tebaldi) come to mind. (If someone out there has a recording of Gencer singing “La Mamma Morta,” get in touch! I want to hear that.) Over the years, Radvanovky, Harteros, etc. have graced this production. While Motolygina does have the size of her colleagues, she lacks the palette of colors in the middle tessitura to elicit depth in Maddalena. Not helped by a libretto which tends to paint her as hapless and helpless aristocrat, there is little more for Motolygina to play than victimhood. She gave her all in Maddelena’s big number “La Mamma Morta” (of <em>Philadelphia </em>fame), but her limits relegate Maddalena to secondary character status, an appendage to Chenier.</p><p>The size and scope of the story surrounding our tragic lovers make room for numerous persons of varied stature which alternately assist or stop story development. Stefanie Wake-Edwards is a delightfully decadent Contessa, both in timbre and characterization, commanding the first act and justifying the coming revolution. She is helped by José Manuel Vázquez’s lavish costumes and the Chor’s complete enjoyment of the proceedings. Lucy Baker’s Bersi is equally good fun, but vocally weak, often having difficulty with Giordano’s (and Gampa’s) big ol’ orchestra. Despite a comic vein, she doesn’t quite yet know how to land her bits to optimal effect. Padraic Rowan (yet another returnee) possesses a beautiful, warm and large sound which infuses his Roucher with real pathos. He is a worthy compatriot to Chenier. And Burkhard Ulrich (returnee) revels in the machinations of the Incroyable and equally complements Gérard, while Dean Murphy (who is always good) is as engaging as a first rate Enjolras, allowing us to forget the lovers for a bit, in hopes that Mathieu and his compatriots will triumph in their cause. Last, but definitively not least, the iconic Doris Soffel is in complete vocal and dramatic command as Madelon turning a feature role into a highlight of the evening. (Here the bravos were deserved and gladly given.)</p><p>As the piece unveils itself, the similarities to the massive contours of Berlioz’s Les Troyens or the sprawling narrative of Hugo’s (or even Schoenberg/Boulbil’s) Les Miserables kept asserting themselves. I don’t know that Giordano and Illica were directly inspired by either of these works, but their likely popularity and caché at the time certainly justifies approaching <em>Andrea Chenier </em>from this perspective. Having not seen the fully staged production, I can only guess that Dew’s intention was to imbed the love story into a fleshed out historical context, which could help deepen and expand a relatively banal and predictable love story.</p><p><em>Andrea Chenier</em> is not an opera I would necessarily feel compelled to see, unless, of course, some hot young <em>drammatico</em> comes on the scene to pique my interest. I just hope he can sing in tune. <em>Vive la Révolution!</em></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <category><![CDATA[Opera]]></category>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/9ca0361e-b875-415e-b181-73f98621f451/teaser_image/1770069616?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;fm=jpg&amp;crop=faces" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/ef266393-5bad-4038-8276-ff16bd911a1d/posts/9ca0361e-b875-415e-b181-73f98621f451</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">9ca0361e-b875-415e-b181-73f98621f451</guid>
      <pubDate>Mon, 02 Feb 2026 22:04:58 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[“The Eternal Feminine”]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[10 minute read SYMPHONY 8, Berliner Philharmoniker, Philharmonie Berlin, 16.January.2026 Gustav Mahler Part I:“Veni creator spiritus”, 9th century liturgical text; Part…]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>10 minute read</p><h3>SYMPHONY 8, Berliner Philharmoniker, Philharmonie Berlin, 16.January.2026</h3><h5>Gustav Mahler</h5><h5>Part I:“Veni creator spiritus”, 9th century liturgical text;</h5><h5>Part 2: “Faust, Part II, Act V, Scene VII”, Johann Wolfgang v. Goethe</h5><h5>Conductor: Kirill Petrenko</h5><h5>Magna peccatrix: Jacquelyn Wagner; Una poenitentium: Golda Schultz; Mater gloriosa: Jasmin Delfs; Mulier Samaritana: Beth Taylor; Maria Aeyptiaca: Fleur Barron; Doctor Marianus: Benjamin Bruns; Pater ecstaticus: Gihoon Kim; Pater profundus: Le Bu; Rundfunkchor Berlin; Bachchor Salzburg; Knaben des Staats-und Domchors Berlin</h5><hr aria-hidden="true"/><p>“The symphony is the world; it must contain everything.”</p><p>Maybe this is why Mahler never wrote an opera, despite being a fine operatic conductor and, obviously, an accomplished composer for the voice. The 8th Symphony (I refrain from the famous moniker, since Gustav didn’t like it very much) is as close as he got to one, and in physical, musical, emotional and thematic respects it contains everything <em>but</em> the kitchen sink (as they say.) It is a remarkable, overwhelming experience, a <em>gesamtkunstwerk, </em>and one of those pieces I will move mountains to hear live, whenever possible.</p><p>When listening to Mahler, the recycling or revamping of thematic material - not just within a piece of music, but across his entire output - always strikes me: It is almost as if he was working on one, endless Symphony for the totality of his life (or eternity), as if his reaction to the post-Beethoven “curse of the ninth” was to keep throwing stuff against the wall to see what sticks. Or, to reference his mantra above, to keep returning to that ‘everything world’ until he had charted every corner. There has been plenty of work done analysing and cataloging the motivic and thematic connections between opuses, and we don’t need to repeat that here, except to note the particular relationship between the 2nd and 8th symphonies, the progression from ‘resurrection’ to ‘transfiguration’, an elevation of all of Mahler’s obsessions. To quote Dika Newlin: “…what else is the final page of the Eighth Symphony but a heightened, accentuated version of the corresponding passage in the Second Symphony?”</p><p>I don’t have a favorite performance of this work. It is notoriously difficult to get all the pieces ‘right’ and yet, like any true masterpiece, inferior parts can’t dilute the whole’s impact. Well, maybe an incompetent conductor or technically inadequate musicians could, but I hope in both of those cases, they are self-respecting enough to keep away from the score.</p><p>With really fine playing from all departments, expressive choral singing, Knabenchor exuberance, and soloists who were nearly all up to the demands of this score, this performance got a helluva lot right.</p><p>It was the second time I have seen Petrenko on the podium for the 8th; last time, conducting the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra, at the Royal Albert Hall. The Hall does in some ways lend itself to this piece, for example, the split choir banks delineate the double choir writing and the acoustic of the space make the loud bits feel louder, and the quite bits quieter, palpable and transparent. But I remember feeling that the scale of the room and those acoustics had Petrenko working very hard to keep it all together, and I couldn’t ascertain if his musical decisions were choice or necessity. At the Philharmonie, he is in complete command, and his take on the piece can be better experienced.</p><p>His 8th is trim and sporty. Sometimes I wished he would give into the operatic a little more - he seems afraid, or embarrassed(?) by the theatricality of the thing - and the tempos in Part I are sometimes on the fast side for the voices. I didn’t time him, but I suspect his running time is more on par with Dudamel than Bernstein or Rattle. On the flip side, however, is an impressive clarity of form. His resistance to sentimentality does not sacrifice emotionality, and creates an inevitable forward motion, coupled with a very successful scaled dynamic scheme: The piece starts really big - in some performances it is hard for the climax of part II to surpass, or transcend, these opening bars. Petrenko manages to span a high voltage curve through both movements to illuminate thematic and emotional connections between them. It is often very exciting (especially the end of Part I!), and these tempos do help maintain Part I’s momentum into the introspective and atmospheric Part II. And that is the greatest strength of his take on the work as a whole. He manages to make elements which often feel unmotivated or unrelated part of a much larger entity. That ‘everything world’ Mahler was mapping out?</p><p>The performances are almost all top notch. Jacquelyn Wagner (a tie over from the Royal Albert Hall performances) is an optimal Magna Peccatrix. She is equally comfortable with the big bits of Part I, the vulnerable bits of Part II, and her ease and control in the upper reaches of her voice is coupled with a size that anchors and commands the group in the large ensemble sections. Golda Schultz seems to sing Una poenitentium effortlessly, especially effective in Part II. These two complement each other well (which is not always the case) and both possess beautiful timbre throughout their ranges. Beth Taylor as Mulier Samaritana is, for me, a happy discovery. Her timbre recalls Maureen Forrester, rich and warm and chocolaty. It is an optimal voice for Mahler, and I hope I will have the luck to hear her in the 2nd symphony somewhere soon. Fleur Barron (great name!) is a disappointment as Maria Aeyptiaca. Her pretty voice, probably better suited to lighter music, is mostly lost under the orchestra, even in her Part II solo bits. Doctor Marianus is sung by Benjamin Bruns, who seems to be a regular with the 8th. His <em>jugendliche dramatische</em> tenor is solid and pleasing in the big utterances, but he gets pitchy and slack if he is not singing full-out. Gihoon Kim and Le Bu round out the male roles, both coming with impressive pedigree. Kim was Cardiff Singer of the World 2021 and possesses a big, warm, virile Baritone that suits Pater ecstaticus optimally. And Bass Le Bu’s matches him with a large and velvety voice which transits the ranginess of Pater profundus profoundly. Jasmin Delfs takes the pivotal role of Mater gloriosa. Certainly proficient, yet in this performance her sound lacked the ethereal luster one wants to hear at this critical moment. Maybe she just needs more experience or trust? Or maybe it was a daily condition, or getting used to the hall. It is, after a bitch: you sit backstage for a hour or so, then appear somewhere surprising and dramatic (usually high up, but never anywhere near the conductor) and are expected to spin out glorious high b-flats fearlessly.</p><p>The Rundfunkchor Berlin (Gijs Leenaars, Direction) has sung, and recorded, this piece numerous times, and it is clear they are at home. Joined by the equally fine Bachchor Salzburg (Michael Schneider, Direction) both the clarity of diction and the expressive coloring of the text were admirable. The Knaben des Staats- und Domchors Berlin (Kai-Uwe Jirka, Kelley Sundin-Doing, Direction) were a vibrant and able contrast to the adults. The transparency of piano singing, as well as the girth of loud singing from all the choral forces were integral in culling and enhancing Petrenko’s ascent into Mahler’s everything world.</p><p>The 8th Symphony is an act of force and will. Another one of his pieces inspired by, and dedicated to his wife, Alma, it was reportedly intended to save their marriage (imagine living in a time, and/or relationship where a work of art could save your relationship…) but probably was lots of effort, far too late, as Mrs. Mahler was already in the midst of an affair with Walter Gropius (whom she would marry after Mahler’s death and remain with until her death.) Mahler’s idealization and devotion of Alma, took on various different forms throughout his writing. While the sensitive poignant side of this love might be found in the Adagietto of the 5th, Part I of the 8th can be in danger of screaming out that love in a desperate plea. In Petrenko’s hands, this is circumvented. Often maligned for it’s bombast, here Part I actually logically leads us to Part II, where the Mahler digs deep into the complicated, land mine ridden fields of that devotion.</p><p>To be honest, I don’t know how you listen to this piece and remain indifferent. There are, no doubt, individuals who are not willing to give in to it’s magnificence, it’s overreaching and overarching emotional catharsis. But for (hopefully) most of us, it sweeps us up and away, offering up an artistic encounter like no other. It needs to be heard, experienced live, because recordings can’t catch all of it’s magnificence. The woman next to me, (for whom, I surmise it was the first live hearing,) was frequently reduced to sudden giggles of joy (and I hope also to tender tears.) I can’t think of a piece that more handily illicits this kind of feeling and connection. I urge you to seek it out and go on the adventure yourself. I will be the giggling, weeping guy in the next seat.</p>]]></content:encoded>
      <category><![CDATA[Music]]></category>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/184dd788-d3ce-4a5a-9f2f-5e63404fd821/teaser_image/1768840079?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;fm=jpg&amp;crop=faces" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/ef266393-5bad-4038-8276-ff16bd911a1d/posts/184dd788-d3ce-4a5a-9f2f-5e63404fd821</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">184dd788-d3ce-4a5a-9f2f-5e63404fd821</guid>
      <pubDate>Mon, 19 Jan 2026 16:27:59 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Hey Alexa, you got a head on that plate?]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[10 minute read SALOME, Komische Oper Berlin, 12.December.2025 Music: Richard Strauss. Libretto: Oscar Wilde, Hedwig Lachmann Conductor: James Gaﬃgan Stage Direction:…]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>10 minute read</p><h5>SALOME, Komische Oper Berlin, 12.December.2025</h5><h5>Music: Richard Strauss.</h5><h5>Libretto: Oscar Wilde, Hedwig Lachmann</h5><h5>Conductor: James Gaﬃgan</h5><h5>Stage Direction: Evgeny Titov</h5><hr aria-hidden="true"/><p>Being completely upfront, <em>Salome</em> is one of my favorite works of music theater and possibly the piece I have seen most often. I am partial to it and therefore, ruthless in my expectation. There are many reasons it lands in my top ten list: the singularly evocative music, foretelling the breakdown of standard harmonic usage and heralding the start of Strauss’s operatic legacy; a thrilling challenge to theatrical boundaries; madness; pathos; relentlessness; a quintessentially dysfunctional family; superhuman vocalism; the intensity of it all. I love this opera, and, par for the course, I am more often than not disappointed in large or small part by productions. Music Theater, and especially Opera, are fickle paramours. Yet, I keep coming back, hoping for that once in a lifetime performance that gets it all right. Spoiler alert: I’m still waiting.</p><p>It would be safe to say that Oscar Wilde’s original 1893 play caused a stir. It was banned in England, supposedly citing a law against the depiction of biblical characters on stage, despite Bernhardt’s backing. The sexual deviance, extreme decadence, frank implications of child abuse, and severed head on a platter might have added to an expected late Victorian reticence. It was premiered in permissive Paris three years later, sadly without Bernhardt. Wilde did not see this performance, as he was in prison for his own sexual proclivities, and in his lifetime never saw the work performed. The first German language production, translated by Lachmann and mounted by Max Reinhardt in Berlin, upped the play’s notoriety, and was highly successful. A friend piqued Strauss’s interest in the play as a suitable property for his first opera and after briefly working with a librettist, Richard attempted (à la Dicky Wagner) to write his own, but finally returned Lachmann’s translation, which he set almost unaltered. All of this background to assert that, although the music is transcendent and revolutionary, <em>Salome</em> lives just as importantly in the text.</p><p>It is truly a ‘musical play’. Any responsible production of this masterpiece must attempt to do equal service to both text and music.</p><p>This production had me wondering if the director (and many of the performers) had taken the time to <em>read</em> the text. An evening full of lazy directorial and conceptual choices which not only did not enhance or interpret the text, but willfully ignored it. This smacks of the arrogant German ‘concept’ stuﬀ that Komische Oper so often excels in and so many of the usual suspects appear: a mute chorus, fetish clad including dildos and vulvas, masturbating along to Herod’s aria, I assume as illustration of his depravity and deviance, although poor Herod was directed so one dimensionally that all he himself plays are those obvious character traits; big stroke behaviorism in favor of reading and directing the text - i.e., when the Nazarenes come they play generic stage drunk rather than making any acting or narrative choices relevant to the situation; a cheap and unrealistic Jochanaan-dummy in place of the ‘head on a platter’ in Wilde’s text for the climactic scene. And there’s more…</p><p>Can we at expect some narrative continuity? When the executioner (bare chested of course, because it’s sexy and Salome is a <em>sexy</em> opera) finishes his job, hauling up the cheap plastic Jochanaan from the cistern for Salome to play with, he is covered in blood. She, in the next scene, puts her hands in the dummy’s innards, way deep into the cavity and emerges - clean. No blood, no entrails, no nothing. How about logical staging? If a character says “do not touch me” while manhandling his scene partner or declares “I will not look at you” while looking directly at the person he/she is speaking to, it is nothing short of bad, lazy story telling. Yes, of course, one can work against the text, and there are cases where this functions, but in a play which lives from the characters dialogue, and in a scene which pivots on the needs and desires and points of view <em>of</em> those characters, it is just sloppy.</p><p>The intention of this production does not seem to be the telling of the story (or any story for that matter), but to use the narrative as a very, very slight springboard for the director to make empty visual eﬀects - example 1, the long shadows on the wall during the Salome/Jochanaan scene, example 2, the ‘moon’ lamp descending into the cistern so that Salome can clumsily yank the Jochanaan dummy onto it for a nice visual at the close of the opera, or my personal favorite, example 3, the Guanajuato inspired raised wall reveal of a display case filled with severed heads during one of Strauss’s dramaturical musical interludes? Presumably a gIimpse into Salome’s psychosis? Or is it because it looks cool, or because Titov doesn’t have a clue how to visualize what Strauss was musically dramatizing (although is clearly indicated in the score)? Or even worse, because he could care less what Richard’s or Oscar’s intentions were?)</p><p>Eﬀect without substance in service of pointless titillation. The whistles and bravos at the curtain call from confirm the hornswoggling worked. “We saw us some ‘Art.’” There is so much more in this story if you would just read it, ingest it and tell it. Oh, and I completely forgot to mention that the title character is literally relegated to wearing a faceless, white gynoid helmet throughout the entire night. “Featuring Alexa in the role of Salome.” Well, they let her take it oﬀ for the bow. How kind.</p><p>A dream production of <em>Salome</em> would be balance successful stage direction, with exceptional singing and playing of the score. And while a badly played or sung <em>Salome </em>is hard to rescue, it is conceivable that if the directorial work is lacking, the musical end of things can help salvage the night (read: Deutsche Oper Menswear production a few years back.) This performance almost managed. Conductor James Gaffigan, keeps the pace, mostly supports the stage action (occasionally overpowering the scene from the pit), and yet, much of the playing felt disjointed, uncoordinated, as if the diﬀerent departments were were working against each other. While one could argue against homogeny in this music (the shock and awe of some of the orchestration invites it), it does require a coherence it lacked. There were few moments of breathtaking beauty or of overwhelming horror, either from the pit or the stage (and we know they are in the score.)</p><p>Adequate, but not more.</p><p>Nicole Chevalier (Salome) is brave and makes some interesting dramatic/vocal choices (I did love the belted reiterations of “ich will den Kopf des Jochanaan), but too often she is pushed to the edge of her instrument, losing shine and shimmer. She powers through admirably, but there is little grace or sensuality in her princess. Of course, saddled that robot helmet, she gets extra credit for oﬀering as much expression as she did without a face. Günter Papendell is an impresssive Jochanaan, with a beautiful full voice and willing stage presence. He aptly fulfills whatever nonsense the director gave him without losing his, or Jochanaan’s dignity. He and Chevalier have drama and real chemistry together. Sadly, it seems no one actually absorbed the text, which reduces the philosophical core of their scene (and arguably, the opera) to a superficial ‘will they won’t they’ lover’s spat. Matthias Wohlbrecht and Karolina Gumos are well cast as Herodes and Herodias, both give scene-chewing performances, also duly doing what director Evgeny Titov, presumably, asked of them. But a more realistic and psychologically nuanced examination of this pair, and their respective relationships to Salome, would greatly inform both portrayals and the production as a whole. One suspects they both have the skill to do it, but weren’t given the opportunity. Agustin Gómez has sadly neither the heft of voice nor dramatic skill to craft an eﬀective Narraboth. This character is the audience’s entrance into this sick world and must center and focus the action for the first third. Although the length of a secondary role, it requires the gravitas and sympathy of a leading player. The minor roles are adequately filled. Nothing particularly oﬀensive or illustrative here: The Jews, looking in Esther Bialas costumes like they stopped by on their way home from the the <em>Anatevka </em>wedding<em>,</em> are pure parody, often lost under the orchestra, and not understandable; I already bitched about the Nazarenes; Susan Zarrabi’s Page is fine (is there a more thankless role in the repertoire?); and, Andrew Harris is a stand out as the 2.Soldat. He has stunning bass and engaging presence and was one of the people to seemed to consistently transmit what they were singing about. I hope to hear/see more of him soon.</p><p>The beauty of this masterpiece, as with any true masterpiece, is that weak or irresponsible productions may injure, but cannot destroy it. Last night I was again moved by the sheer, thrilling audacity of Strauss’s music, and the ballsy, edginess of Wilde’s text. Moreover, the relevance of <em>Salome</em>, in a post analysis, post #metoo society, with so many parallels bridging our 21st and it’s fin de siecle 19th century viewpoints, cannot be underestimated. So, I will keep me coming back with my ruthless expectation, hoping for that production that does, indeed, get it right. If I am lucky, it might never happen.</p>]]></content:encoded>
      <category><![CDATA[Opera]]></category>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/25c4c858-510a-4dd1-acfb-6264aacd2464/teaser_image/1768837079?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;fm=jpg&amp;crop=faces" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/ef266393-5bad-4038-8276-ff16bd911a1d/posts/25c4c858-510a-4dd1-acfb-6264aacd2464</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">25c4c858-510a-4dd1-acfb-6264aacd2464</guid>
      <pubDate>Mon, 19 Jan 2026 15:37:59 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Don Carlo & the Romantics]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[DON CARLO, Deutsche Oper Berlin, Berlin, 11.January.2026 Music: Guiseppe Verdi Libretto: Joseph Méry & Camille du Locle based on Don Karlos, Infant von Spanien by…]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>10 minute read</p><h5><strong>DON CARLO, </strong>Deutsche Oper Berlin, Berlin, 11.January.2026</h5><h5>Music: Guiseppe Verdi</h5><h5>Libretto: Joseph Méry &amp; Camille du Locle based on <strong><em>Don Karlos, Infant von Spanien</em> by </strong>Friedrich Schiller</h5><h5>Stage Direction, Set and Light Design: Marco Arturo Martello</h5><h5>Conductor: Jura Valčuha</h5><h5>Costume: Dagmar Niefind</h5><hr aria-hidden="true"/><p>There is really nothing like a good night at the opera. If the stars align, with singers, conductor and orchestra in form, a direction and production concept that works, the experience can be remarkable. This performance of <em>Don Carlo</em> came closest to this ideal than anything I’ve seen this season.</p><p>It helps that I like Verdi a lot, and <em>Don Carlo</em> is my favorite Verdi opera; I have happily sat through the full five act French original more than once. Deutsche Oper’s production (premiered in 2011, yet performed only 34 times since) takes advantage of the trimmer Italian four act version (Verdi’s seventh go at it), which gets right down to business. After that stunning horn opening (played beautifully), the curtain rises on the dark and troubled world view from which our Don suffers.</p><p>The real Don Carlo (of the incestuous Habsburger gang) was sickly, disabled, had a speech defect, underwent trepanation at 17 (after a debilitating fall), was <em>not </em>in love with his step mother, but <em>was</em> imprisoned by this father for planned (but unexecuted) insurgency. The circumstances of his death in prison have never been convincingly verified. Authors inspired by this source material dispense with most of the historical record in favor of tropes common during the height of romanticism. Schiller’s <em>dramatische Gedicht, </em>presents Carlo as a very cognizant and physically able gen-z-er suffering prolonged adolescence: he can’t have the girl he loves, and his dad just doesn’t understand him, and his bestie might be screwing him over, and, and the world, well, basically, sucks. Everyone in this drama is consistently undercutting each other, trust the greatest commodity, and after a Cyclone’s worth of happenings, it ends badly: Rodrigo dead, Carlo handed over to the Inquisition, Eboli in a convent and Elisabeth and Philipp stuck with each other. Only the Grand Inquisitor pegs a win.</p><p>In the original grand French opera libretto, an added early meeting for Elisabeth and Carlo at Fountainbleu ups the romance, rebalancing the whole opera in this direction. Although more weight on the romantic quadrangle does weakens the Schiller political finagling, it does remain, and Verdi’s music definitely ups the emotional stakes in all plot lines. Every principal get great music, and in spite of the title, it is conceivable for any of them, in the hands of the right performer, to ‘steal’ the show, even if the tenor gets the last bow. The deftly developed musical and character arcs, are arguably stronger than in the play, which favors allegorical over realistic characters. Verdi’s use of leitmotif writing is especially effective. The opening male chorus is echoed in Elisabeth’s fifth act <em>scena, </em>and, of course, the ‘friendship’ tune keeps showing up whenever Rodrigo and Carlo get a moment alone. If cast with singing-actors of comparable ability, <em>Don Carlo</em> becomes epic ensemble opera, delineations between protagonist and antagonist fade, allowing us to feel and sympathize equally with each of these doomed anti-heros. Whether the result of casting, direction, concept, or luck, we got quite close to an optimal constellation in this performance.</p><p>This well-balanced cast still manage to find moments to elevate their individual role in the drama. Each have their particular strengths and weaknesses, but all are committed and engaged. It greatly helps that the younger characters are cast younger, and the parallel of vocal magnitude (and literal depth) to age and status is especially pleasing in the male roles. Verdi wrote them this way, but in this cast, it is particularly effective. Tenor Valentin Dytiuk fearless dives into the Don. His youthful presence and <em>leiden </em>invites appropriate comparison to Werther, and the finesse his acting lacks, is more than compensated by his attractive tone and expressive musicality. Another young singer, Geom Kim, takes on Rodrigo. Presently, he lacks breadth and gets lost in his middle range, but it is clear that he will quickly grow into the Verdi baritone his beautiful timbre presages. What he is already better to do than many, is connect to text and emotion to move his audience. More than once his interpretive choices trounced me, and I have never heard a more stunningly poignant return of the friendship duet tune at Rodrigo’s death. This is a talent to watch. Liang Li’s Philipp II has a slow burn. Cold and calculated at the start, he slowly unravels through the night, ending up desperate and tragic by his pivotal dialogue with the Grand Inquisitor. And what an extraordinary Grand Inquisitor Patrick Guetti gives us. I have heard him often recently at the house, but this role really allows him to showcase the massive voice, overwhelming presence and detailed character building of which he is capable. A monster feeding on decay and evil, Guetti nearly succeeds in elevating the Grand Inquisitor to a principal character.</p><p>The ladies balance out the chaps nicely. Karis Tucker is a formidable Eboli with a big, impressive voice. Fast vibrato obscured the fioratura in the garden aria, and in “O don fatale” the high notes can best be described as edgy, still, she wins lots of points for her believability and likability in the role, managing to be villainous in deed without ever resorting to mean girl clichés. So many sopranos come to task with Verdi, as these roles generally require immense vocal range, flexibility and especially a good, rich voix mixte. Christina Nilsson has a lovely voice, and has the luck that as the night progresses, Elisabeth’s writing plays more and more to her strengths. The middle voice needed in the earlier acts often evades her, but by Act Five she is in her element. Her “Tu Che la vanita” is not fueled by the dramatic hunger of a Callas, Gencer or even Caballé; it is nevertheless achingly painful, well scaled and beautifully sung. Nilsson has a lucious pianissimo, and uses it to best effect. Like Tucker and the boys, she is still developing, and it would be particularly enjoyable to revisit this cast in a few years to see how each has grown.</p><p>There is no stand out in this cast, not because there is no star quality on the stage, but because they complement each other so well. One of my early mentors warned me that this kind of true collaboration comes only one out of ten productions, and I was lucky enough to have experienced it a number of times myself. How lucky for this cast and the audience that we get to experience it together. It makes for a very satisfying musical <em>and </em>theatrical evening, which is not to be assumed.</p><p>The success lies in equal part with the integrated work of director/designer Martello. Responsible for sets, lighting and direction, he has placed his cast in an ever-moving set, which alternately evokes claustrophobic palace, impenetrable labyrinth, damp monastery or city streets. There is a ‘game of thrones’ feel in the design, and the monumental scale of it dwarfs and oppresses the characters. The desperation is heightening by Martello’s shadowy lighting and Niefind’s costumes - historically accurate, fittingly lavish, yet all in a restrained (or deliberately repressed?) color palette. For example, the Grand Inquisitor makes his first appearance draped in an oversized boxy beige burlap monk robe, underscoring his pale and pasty complexion. Even fire on stage doesn’t warm or lighten the proceedings: The stakes in this story are high and the environs remain sober and gloomy. Martello uses the instrumental passages in Verdi’s score adeptly as underscoring for supplementary filmic scenes, importing information excised from Schiller, and abetting the narrative flow: A scene between Eboli and Tebaldo (sung and played fetchingly by Maria Vasilevskaya) or the extended procession and preparation for the auto de fa incorporating extras and chorus (also in great form), give our eyes a parallel to our ears, anchoring us in the humanity of these flawed and fascinating people, investing us in their trials and tribulations.</p><p>Spanish history, dramatized by a German, revised by Frenchmen, musicalized by an Italian, <em>Don Carlo </em>is a kind of pan-European, pre-EU collab, and this may be one of the reasons the opera manages to transcend the ordinary. Part love story, part political thriller, a pinnacle of romantic Sturm und Drang. Everyone struggles. Nobody wins. Everybody suffers. But what glorious suffering it can be.</p><p></p><p></p><p></p><p></p><p></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <category><![CDATA[Opera]]></category>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/61af7697-36ae-4f83-9a23-f50d9611391b/teaser_image/1768835585?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;fm=jpg&amp;crop=faces" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/ef266393-5bad-4038-8276-ff16bd911a1d/posts/61af7697-36ae-4f83-9a23-f50d9611391b</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">61af7697-36ae-4f83-9a23-f50d9611391b</guid>
      <pubDate>Mon, 19 Jan 2026 15:13:32 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
  </channel>
</rss>