<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<rss version="2.0" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:media="http://search.yahoo.com/mrss/">
  <channel>
    <xhtml:meta content="noindex" name="robots" xmlns:xhtml="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml"/>
    <title>Democracy Americana</title>
    <link>https://steady.page/democracyamericana</link>
    <description>Reflections on U.S. politics and history - and the ongoing struggle over how much democracy, and for whom, there should be in America</description>
    
    <atom:link type="application/rss+xml" rel="self" href="https://steady.page/democracyamericana/rss"/>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Introducing: The Democracy Americana Podcast]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[A place for in-depth conversations about the past, present, and future of democracy in the United States and beyond. Relentlessly big picture.]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>A place for in-depth conversations about the past, present, and future of democracy in the United States and beyond. Relentlessly big picture.</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, November 11, 2026</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/9105e0cf-f1a3-4dee-9d8d-662139888aea">Listen on Steady</a></p><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/9105e0cf-f1a3-4dee-9d8d-662139888aea/uploads/images/46vqyrsx74/DA_Logo_Main.png?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><p>Dear all,</p><p>I am really excited to introduce you to The Democracy Americana Podcast.</p><p>The first episode dropped this morning: Historian Seth Cotlar joins me to discuss our main takeaways from the midterms. We try to unpack what happened last week and grasp the broader political as well as historical significance that goes far beyond the question of who is going to be in charge in Congress.</p><p>Here is a link to the episode on Apple podcasts – but it should also be available everywhere else, wherever you commonly get your podcasts:</p><a href="https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-democracy-americana-podcast/id6833386899">https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-democracy-americana-podcast/id6833386899</a><p></p><p>I am also including the RSS Feed, which should enable you to find the podcast in whatever podcast player you are using:</p><a href="https://api.riverside.com/hosting/Fa0zMxEu.rss">https://api.riverside.com/hosting/Fa0zMxEu.rss</a><p></p><p>This episode is a good introduction to what this podcast will be: It’s a wide-ranging discussion, no hot takes, just a sincere attempt to take two steps back from the endless noise of the news cycle and provide some perspective. </p><p>The podcast is, in other words, very much an extension of the essays I write and publish via the newsletter. And that is exactly what I want Democracy Americana to be. I never thought of it as a newsletter only. The newsletter is a delivery system: It allows me to send out my analysis to thousands of people – and it allows all of you to get my analysis delivered straight to your inbox.</p><p>In fact, I have never been super comfortable describing Democracy Americana as a newsletter. Understood as a genre of publication / published text, the term “newsletter” suggests something that is shorter, focused on takes and opinions, or perhaps a news roundup of sorts. That is, as you all know, very much not what I do here. The main genre of text that I offer is the long-form essay, something you might prototypically associate with a piece in a political magazine.</p><p>I understand Democracy Americana as an independent publication that offers a newsletter. And here is the great news: That publication now also offers a proper podcast.</p><p>The plan is for the regular podcast episodes to come out biweekly. For now, they are audio only. Eventually, there might be video podcasting and livestreaming… But you will have to be patient with me. Democracy Americana is a solo operation. It is just me. I am only now learning how to edit a podcast recording…</p><p>For the podcast, I will be bringing on people whose work I admire, whose analysis and observations help me make sense of the world. That is what I am most excited about: The chance to introduce those people to you and share our conversations with all of you.</p><p>At this point, you might be asking: Ok, but do we really need yet another politics podcasts? I hear you. But I truly believe that the type of conversation you will get here is tremendously valuable.</p><p>The overarching goal of everything I do here at Democracy Americana is to provide perspective. And to make that perspective accessible to as many people as possible. Podcast conversations allow me to think through and talk through the important questions we are facing with people worth listening to and worth learning from. I will speak for myself: I love podcasts. And I believe the conversational format is also accessible in a way that long-form essays may not always be for everyone.</p><p><strong>To be clear: Nothing else changes.</strong></p><p>The podcast is not replacing anything else. It is an addition to everything else you have been getting from Democracy Americana so far.</p><p>Regular free episodes of the podcast will be available everywhere, across all the common podcast players. However, there will also be bonus episodes reserved for paid members of Democracy Americana - just as there already are essays / newsletters accessible only for members almost every week. If you have been on the fence about whether or not a paid membership is worth it, perhaps the podcast might finally get you there?</p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p>But there are other ways to help me get this show off the ground. Letting people know that the podcast exists will be crucial. Any help spreading the word is much, much appreciated!</p><p>I’m really proud to be offering the podcast in addition to the newsletter and all my writing. And I am exciting to continue this journey with you!</p><p>Take care, Thomas</p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/9105e0cf-f1a3-4dee-9d8d-662139888aea/uploads/images/46vqyrsx74/DA_Logo_Main.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/9105e0cf-f1a3-4dee-9d8d-662139888aea</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">9105e0cf-f1a3-4dee-9d8d-662139888aea</guid>
      <pubDate>Wed, 11 Nov 2026 18:49:24 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[A Remarkable Moment in U.S. History]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[A diminished MAGA government remains acutely dangerous. But the path to consolidated authoritarian rule is shut. America must use this fleeting window for transformation.]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>A diminished MAGA government remains acutely dangerous. But the path to consolidated authoritarian rule is shut. America must use this fleeting window for transformation.</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, November 8, 2026</em></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/014f72cf-2e67-4859-adcb-9ffc7916f155/uploads/images/qy6b46wjga/3EBA5E22-3106-4AA6-8F8A-77FEF2CD5169_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>credit: iStock / paseven</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></strong></p><p><em>The extended intro to this piece is free to read for everyone. If you want to </em><strong><em>read more</em></strong><em> than the preview, please consider becoming </em><strong><em>a paid member</em></strong><em> of Democracy Americana, which is </em><strong><em>solely funded by readers</em></strong><em> and constitutes my main source of income. </em></p><p><em>Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. </em><strong><em>If you can become a paid member, please do.</em></strong><em> As a member, you receive many additional essays, and you </em><strong><em>gain access to the audio versions</em></strong><em> of everything I publish (members can find the audio at the end of the piece or available for download in the podcast player of your choice).</em></p><p><em>As always, the </em><strong><em>German version</em></strong><em> of this essay will be available over at </em><a href="https://steady.page/de/demokratie-americana/posts"><strong><em>Demokratie Americana</em></strong></a><em> soon.</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><strong><em>NEW</em></strong><em> If you’re not ready for a paid membership yet, you can </em><strong><em>unlock this article for free</em></strong><em> by subscribing to the free version of this newsletter (via the registration wall below).</em></p><p></p><p>Tuesday, November 3 was a good day for democracy in America. A historic day.</p><p>Democrats won strong <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/11/03/us/elections/results-senate.html#mapType=shiftMap">majorities in both chambers</a> of Congress. When it’s all said and done, they will have won the House popular vote <a href="https://projects.gelliottmorris.com/election-night-2026/#/estimate">by around 14 percentage points</a>. By that measure, this is the most devastating defeat for a governing party since 1974.</p><p>As the dust is beginning to settle, it is really worth reflecting on the larger implications of this remarkable result. I want to offer six observations and arguments about the historical significance of this election – and where America might go from here:</p><p>1) Not that more evidence should have been necessary, but the result of the midterms proves once and for all that there was no lasting rightward “realignment” in 2024, no “vibe shift” in American society and culture. In fact, we should all remember that an election is rarely an ideological referendum – and it certainly doesn’t manifest some durable “will of the people.”</p><p>2) The idea that this election was entirely about affordability is diagnostically misleading and politically harmful. Yes, cost of living and the economy played a big role. But so did corruption and the authoritarian assault on democratic self-government. This was about all of those things. And it was very much a plea for accountability from the majority of the electorate.</p><p>3) Multiracial democracy returned – or, in many ways: conquered for the first time – the American South where reactionary one-party regimes have been the historical norm. It is impossible to overstate how much of a political earthquake that is. It has the potential to drastically reshape the political landscape across the Republic.</p><p>4) One election is not enough to restore functioning democracy in the United States. But as much as the authoritarian threat has been acutely real: The MAGA government has now lost so much legitimacy that there is no more realistic pathway for them to get from here to consolidated authoritarian rule.</p><p>5) Unfortunately, until they can finally be removed from power, the MAGA government remains dangerous and will continue to cause tremendous harm. In fact, as delusion, authoritarian desires, ideological zealotry, ineptitude, and mounting desperation all combine, we must expect them to seek escalation whenever and wherever they still possess agency.</p><p>6) There now exists, potentially, a window for the kind of transformational change this country so desperately needs. But it won’t stay open for long. Such moments are rare in U.S. history, and they are always fleeting. We better remind Democratic elected officials that they now have an enormous responsibility not to waste this opportunity.</p><p>Let’s go through each of these points one by one and make sure we truly grasp the significance of what happened here. Because moments like these are rare in history.</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/014f72cf-2e67-4859-adcb-9ffc7916f155">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/014f72cf-2e67-4859-adcb-9ffc7916f155/uploads/images/qy6b46wjga/3EBA5E22-3106-4AA6-8F8A-77FEF2CD5169_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/014f72cf-2e67-4859-adcb-9ffc7916f155</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">014f72cf-2e67-4859-adcb-9ffc7916f155</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 08 Nov 2026 12:19:04 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Closing Arguments]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Democracy itself is on the ballot. I know that sounds dramatic - but the stakes really are existential (Plus: Recommendations for how to get through election night)]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Democracy itself is on the ballot. I know that sounds dramatic - but the stakes really are existential (Plus: Recommendations for how to get through election night)</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, November 2, 2026</em></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/ebc6d386-a607-46bb-8970-3dada4c3d119/uploads/images/dgfgtn4who/iStock-2241499218-modified-514fafb1-3658-4ec4-a719-49546be9181c.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>credit: iStock / Blulz60</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></strong></p><p><em>The extended intro to this piece is free to read for everyone. If you want to </em><strong><em>read more</em></strong><em> than the preview, please consider becoming </em><strong><em>a paid member</em></strong><em> of Democracy Americana, which is </em><strong><em>solely funded by readers</em></strong><em> and constitutes my main source of income.</em></p><p><em>Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. </em><strong><em>If you can become a paid member, please do.</em></strong><em> As a member, you receive many additional essays, and you </em><strong><em>gain access to the audio versions</em></strong><em> of everything I publish (members can find the audio at the end of the piece or available for download in the podcast player of your choice).</em></p><p><em>As always, the </em><strong><em>German version</em></strong><em> of this essay will be available over at </em><a href="https://steady.page/de/demokratie-americana/posts"><strong><em>Demokratie Americana</em></strong></a><em> soon.</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><strong><em>NEW</em></strong><em> If you’re not ready for a paid membership yet, you can </em><strong><em>unlock this one article for free</em></strong><em> by subscribing to the free version of this newsletter (via the registration wall below).</em></p><p></p><p>There is a famous quote, attributed to poet, writer, and civil rights activist Maya Angelou: “When someone shows you who they are, believe them the first time.”</p><p>America is obviously way past the first time with Trump and the radicalized Republican Party. But after witnessing the most bigoted, racist, Islamophobic, morally depraved campaign by a major party in modern history, it has never been more urgent than now to believe them when they are telling us who they are and what they want to do to the country.</p><p>None of this is entirely new, of course. Trump won the presidency for a second time while openly professing his desire to erect a vindictive autocracy. He even finished his 2024 election campaign with an <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2024/10/27/us/trump-msg-rally.html?smtyp=cur&amp;smid=bsky-nytimes">aggressively fascistic rally at Madison Square Garden</a>. There was really no plausible deniability for anyone two years ago. And yet more people voted to return Trump to the power of the presidency than for his Democratic opponent. A significant percentage of the population supports ethno-nationalist ideas and is staunchly opposed to the vision of a pluralistic, gender-egalitarian democratic society. There are those who believe a dose of Trumpian extremism is exactly what this country needs right now. There are also a lot of people who, at the very least, did not consider Trump’s promise of instituting a white nationalist purge a dealbreaker.</p><p>But there was also a third group that voted for Trump based on a generalized frustration with “the system.” In 2024, an overwhelming anti-incumbent sentiment and a desire to overcome the vaguely defined “status quo” led many people in this group to either withhold their support for Kamala Harris by refusing to vote at all or to actively support Donald Trump in order to throw out whoever was in charge. And as hard as that is to accept for people who follow politics closely, a lot of these people were either unaware of what the Trumpists were really planning or convinced they wouldn’t be able to implement it anyway. Unfortunately, this  <a href="https://www.weekendreading.net/p/sleepwalking-our-way-to-fascism">“deadly disbelief,”</a> as Michael Podhorzer has aptly called it, significantly affected turnout and helped decide the election.</p><p>I wish we could finally discard the deep-seated myths and pervasive misunderstandings that contribute to this kind of deadly disbelief far beyond just the group of people who tend to be classified as “low-information voters.” There is, for instance, this hard-to-kill idea that campaign promises don’t mean much since they’re being ditched after the election anyway. But the empirical record demonstrates the opposite: Once elected, politicians actually attempt to enact their stated agenda. There is, moreover, a widespread reluctance among mainstream observers to accept that ideology is real and the people who are in charge of the Republican Party truly are extremists sincerely pursuing an extremist project. The fact that they have united behind Donald Trump has exacerbated this problem: Among a certain segment of the voting public, Trump is still primarily perceived as a symbol of wealth and celebrity, which is how he has been able to help sell the ideological agenda of far-right extremism and make it electorally more palatable.</p><p>And so, here we are. Yet again hoping that enough people will look at the deranged campaign of the president and his party and decide to believe them. The Trumpists couldn’t possibly be any clearer that this election is not about policy disagreements. They are at war with the very idea of pluralistic democracy. They seek to redraw the boundaries of the body politic itself. And while they are at it, they are devastating the country’s public infrastructure and ravaging whatever norms of morality and ethical conduct may yet exist, accelerating the desolation of America’s political culture.</p><p>Let us grapple seriously and earnestly with the fundamental reality of American politics: For the foreseeable future, democracy itself is on the ballot in every single election.</p><p>(And at the end, I’d also like to recommend some resources for how to best get through election night and the week ahead if we want to stay well informed without losing our mind…)</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/ebc6d386-a607-46bb-8970-3dada4c3d119">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/ebc6d386-a607-46bb-8970-3dada4c3d119/uploads/images/dgfgtn4who/iStock-2241499218-modified-514fafb1-3658-4ec4-a719-49546be9181c.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/ebc6d386-a607-46bb-8970-3dada4c3d119</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">ebc6d386-a607-46bb-8970-3dada4c3d119</guid>
      <pubDate>Mon, 02 Nov 2026 12:27:52 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Right’s Fascistic Fever Dreams Are a Sign of Weakness]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[MAGA wants us to believe that Trump can simply declare “martial law” and wipe away the system - but it’s just not true. A threat assessment before the midterms.]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>MAGA wants us to believe that Trump can simply declare “martial law” and wipe away the system - but it’s just not true. A threat assessment before the midterms.</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, October 25, 2026 (slightly updated October 29)</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/ce368414-634e-4401-a48e-07af9585c025">Listen on Steady</a></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/ce368414-634e-4401-a48e-07af9585c025/uploads/images/ri4i4k4ad5/iStock-1480868760.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>credit: iStock / John Webb</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></strong></p><p><em>This is the </em><strong><em>third and final part</em></strong><em> of my deep dive into the political situation in the United States before the midterm elections – an attempt to answer the most urgent questions, think through the dangers that lie ahead, and reflect on where we stand in the struggle between authoritarian escalation and democratic resilience. </em><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/d9a4df24-9b8d-4dd8-bb13-73fc07e56c5f"><em>In Part I</em></a><em>, I reflected on whether we can trust the polls and discussed the attempts by the Trump regime to manipulate their way to victory by taking control and subverting the process before we even get to election day. </em><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/1ebfca62-2ac4-4cd7-be24-1e888437c208"><em>Part II</em></a><em> focused on the attempts to overturn the election results and the dangers from election day through January 3, when the new Congress will be seated. This Part III deals with those in and around the government who harbor fantasies of Trump declaring a “national security emergency” or “martial law” and asks: What are we to make of such fascistic fever dreams?</em></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is a publication </em><strong><em>solely funded by readers</em></strong><em>. If you are reading the free version of this newsletter, I sincerely appreciate your time and effort engaging with my work. Please share it widely to help me reach new readers.</em></p><p><em>Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. </em><strong><em>If you can become a paid member, please do. </em></strong><em>As a paid member, you gain access to special benefits – including many additional essays and the chance to download the audio versions of all my pieces in podcast form.</em></p><p><em>As always, the </em><strong><em>German version</em></strong><em> of this essay will be available over at </em><a href="https://steady.page/de/demokratie-americana/posts"><strong><em>Demokratie Americana</em></strong></a><em> soon.</em></p><p><em>A quick announcement before we start: On Monday night</em><strong><em>, </em></strong><a href="https://www.republik.ch/2026/10/17/midterms-in-den-usa-wendepunkt-in-der-us-politik"><strong><em>I’ll be in Zurich</em></strong></a><em>, Switzerland to discuss (in German!) the political situation in the United States right before the midterms - and the lessons the rest of the world can/should learn from the situation in the U.S. If you are around, come join us and say hello!</em></p><p><em>Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work. Please know that I am immensely grateful for your generosity!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to newsletter</a></p><p> </p><p>MAGA extremists are fantasizing about Trump ending the American Republic. Faced with an election they know they are almost guaranteed to lose, they want us to believe Trump can wipe away the system if he finally dares to the pull the lever that has “Dictatorship” written on it.</p><p>Let us not help them perpetuate such authoritarian propaganda. It is not true. There is no such lever. These fascistic fantasies of mass violence are acutely dangerous. But they also reek of desperation rather than strength. </p><p>For many months, the Trumpists have tried, in ways blatantly illegal and unconstitutional, to take control of the election, to manipulate their way to victory by imposing new rules that would have disenfranchised millions and thrown the entire process into chaos. But their major schemes to subvert the midterms have so far failed.</p><p>Now their focus has turned to intimidation efforts on election day – and especially on overturning the results of the election afterwards, in the two months between November 3 and January 3, when the new Congress will come together.</p><p>We must brace ourselves for ever more outlandish claims, ever more ridiculous initiatives. On Friday, for instance, news broke that the Department of Justice <a href="https://www.reuters.com/world/trump-administration-sues-block-senate-race-certification-alaska-if-republican-2026-10-23/">is preemptively suing</a> to block Alaska from certifying the result of the senate election – in case the Democratic candidate wins. Get ready for more such shenanigans. The attempt itself, regardless of the outcome, constitutes a direct assault on the constitutional order. I do not believe, however, that the Trumpists will succeed. There is no evidence they have managed to organize a comprehensive effort of the scale that would be necessary to steal an election that, at least in the House of Representatives, won’t be particularly close. And there are many among the MAGA extremists who understand this precisely.</p><p>That is exactly why they are indulging in fascistic fever dreams of Trump doing away with all this election nonsense by declaring “a national security emergency,” of putting an end to the threat of liberal democracy by imposing “martial law.” But their theory of power boils down to making big, scary proclamations that are not actually connected to plans they can implement. They can, and likely will, cause tremendous damage. But that is not the same as consolidating authoritarian rule. They hope that if they threaten large-scale, state-sponsored violence, everyone will cave. But that is not what has been happening in America, as resistance has been hardening since last summer.</p><p>Let’s assess the danger and discuss what is actually behind these threats of declaring a “national emergency” or “martial law” and ask where exactly, how, and to what effect the Trumpists could apply force and coercion? Let us find the balance: Alarmed and vigilant but not panicked; determined, not despairing; insisting on analyzing the situation as it actually is instead of bowing to the assertion that reality does not apply to these dangerous clowns.</p><p><strong>They are throwing stuff against the wall</strong></p><p>It’s worth dwelling on the MAGA regime’s bizarre Alaska stunt, as it is indicative of where things stand. <a href="https://www.reuters.com/world/trump-administration-sues-block-senate-race-certification-alaska-if-republican-2026-10-23/">Here is what’s up:</a> The Department of Justice, under direct orders from Trump (at least that is <a href="https://apnews.com/article/alaska-senate-race-sullivan-name-lawsuit-certification-d8f4a3c7b5247cc427a05f796d7c0d82">what the president himself has claimed</a>), is preemptively filing a lawsuit in an attempt to block the state from certifying the result of the senate race… should the Democratic candidate win. In Alaska, the incumbent senator is Republican Dan S. Sullivan. According to the polls, Democrat Mary Peltola is ahead and favored to take his seat. There are two more candidates on the ballot – both identifying as Republican. And one of them is named… Daniel J. Sullivan. No relation to the incumbent senator.</p><p>The Department of Justice is alleging that the other Daniel Sullivan was planted by Democrats in a ploy to confuse GOP voters and channel votes away from the current senator. <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/28/us/politics/alaska-dan-sullivan-conspiracy-peltola.html?smid=bsky-nytimes&amp;smtyp=cur">It appears</a> that Democrats did indeed search for and encouraged people who could function as a spoiler candidate. This whole thing is still ridiculous. No laws have been broken, courts in Alaska have looked at the matter months ago, the federal government has no role in the process of adjudicating this. There is no actual legal argument here, nothing that would give judges any plausible deniability to go along with this nonsense. This lawsuit, if that is even the right term, is obviously frivolous.</p><p>More importantly, these are not the actions of a confident regime fully in control of the nation’s destiny. This certainly does not indicate there is a comprehensive secret scheme - some devious, unstoppable master plan. The MAGA government is in Hail Mary territory.</p><p>It is precisely this sense of having their backs against the wall that is fueling these fascistic dreams of using the military to install Trump as a dictator. Envisioning such direct violent oppression is a sign of weakness. Modern authoritarian regimes are always hoping to avoid such escalation. If they have managed to consolidate power, they rely on fully rigged elections in order to make some gesture towards democratic legitimacy to support their claims. They don’t want to resort to mass violence. Because they understand that in a complex modern society, the government – no matter the regime type – inevitably depends on millions of people following along to some degree. They depend on some measure of consent from institutions and individuals alike. In the face of widespread popular discontent, it can become very difficult very quickly to ensure the compliance of millions in order to keep the machine going. The federal government in the United States certainly does not have the apparatus or the manpower to do that by force across the entire country. You start shooting people in the streets, things can get away from the regime fast.</p><p><strong>Fascistic fever dreams</strong></p><p>And yet, that is exactly what the extremists on the Right desire. Not only do they want the federal government to <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2026/02/26/trump-elections-executive-order-activists/">interfere in the electoral process directly</a> by stopping the count in supposedly “suspect” districts and seizing ballots by claiming “fraud” – the type of intervention attorney general <a href="https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/justice-department/blanche-wont-rule-doj-post-election-action-doomsday-scenario-rcna605035">Todd Blanche</a> was installed to perform. Some corners of the MAGA sphere believe Trump shouldn’t bother with what they consider half-measures, especially since they are unlikely to keep Republicans in control of Congress. Prominent MAGA activists, some of them in direct contact with the White House and long-standing personal ties to Trump, <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/2026/09/trump-midterms-2026/688716/?gift=nHf7iWmpOKBdlkwz68mfUHQUCVACMATgQZWlif21uqk&amp;utm_source=copy-link&amp;utm_medium=social&amp;utm_campaign=share">have been calling for the president to declare</a> a “national security emergency” and impose “martial law” if the election “is rigged” – by which they mean: if Democrats win.</p><p>What does a realistic threat assessment look like in this situation? Well, it would certainly be a lot easier to dismiss such extremist fever dreams if we didn’t have ample evidence that there are influential people in and around the government who lust for a chance to violently oppress any opposition. Trump’s white nationalist homeland security advisor Stephen Miller, for instance, has been urging for such measures for a long time. He has been restlessly searching for ways to further militarize the conflict and get Trump to deploy the troops against the “enemy within.”</p><p><strong>What does “martial law” even mean in the U.S. context?</strong></p><p>Let’s start by clarifying terms to get an idea what we are even talking about here. What people are most often referring to when they say “declare an emergency” or “martial law” is not actually the replacement of civilian government by the military. They tend to think of deploying the military in order to complement and assist law enforcement <em>while leaving civilian authority in place</em>.</p><p>There are indeed ways for the president to deploy the military domestically. For that, Congress has set strict guidelines – that is, for instance, what the Insurrection Act does (and more on that later). But “martial law,” as in: removing civilian government and replacing it with military rule, is not really a thing. As this <a href="https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/research-reports/martial-law-united-states-its-meaning-its-history-and-why-president-cant">excellent explainer published by the Brennan Center</a> makes clear: Nothing in the Constitution and no existing statute authorizes the president to do that.</p><p>There is, in tension with this legal and constitutional baseline, the historical reality that something akin to martial law was often instituted, especially from the middle of the nineteenth through the middle of the twentieth century – especially by the states, but in some cases also by the federal government. There is also the fact that the Supreme Court’s decisions on the matter have been vague and inconsistent. And yet, the larger point stands: There is no basis in the Constitution or in the law for Trump to declare martial law. Most importantly, the president has no authority whatsoever to suspend or violate the Constitution.</p><p>This is the point where I am anticipating criticism that misunderstands the point I am trying to make: How can I possibly believe that the law will constrain the most lawless president in history? I don’t. My argument is not that Trump wouldn’t do anything illegal or unconstitutional (come on now…), nor does it rely on Trump following norms or the idea that he would show restraint. It matters that there is no constitutional or legal pathway to martial law because it means there is no avenue for Trump to exploit, no realistic mechanism for him to abuse, no lever to pull. That simply makes it far more difficult to apply the kind of pressure he would need to apply, to generate the kind of force necessary, to get enough people to comply and enough institutions to acquiesce.</p><p>So far, the MAGA regime has not shown the ability to get around this fundamental problem. I have not seen any indication that the Trumpist government is seriously preparing anything that would amount to the type of comprehensive action the extremists are envisioning. Could they have found a pathway to instituting something akin to martial law and made plans in secret? Theoretically, that is possible. But Trump has not exactly been running a tight ship. Journalistic investigations are constantly penetrating the inner circles of the regime. The more likely interpretation is that all this talk of “martial law” is deliberately designed to intimidate and project strength as part of a propagandistic effort to assert dominance – mixed with a whole lot of wishful thinking from a bunch of wannabe-totalitarians who are increasingly desperate.</p><p><em>This piece is free to read for everyone.</em></p><p><em>But recently, only paywalled pieces have generated new memberships and thereby revenue. I am hoping we can buck the trend so that I can keep publishing free essays like this one regularly. That is crucial for the long-term viability of this publication, as it is the only way to achieve visibility and thereby reach new readers.</em></p><p><em>Please help me by supporting Democracy Americana with a membership:</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><strong>What about the Insurrection Act?</strong></p><p>That doesn’t mean the Trumpists haven’t been actively discussing deploying the military in the streets. In fact, Trump himself has been talking about invoking the Insurrection Act for years; he <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2024/02/trumps-immigration-plan-is-even-more-aggressive-now/677385/">brought it up repeatedly</a> during the 2024 campaign. Since returning to the White House, he has often claimed that he has the power <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m4dkndrkwk2j">“to enact a certain act”</a> whenever he wants to. The president mentioned it again recently in an <a href="https://time.com/article/2026/10/01/donald-trump-2026-interview-transcript/">interview with Time Magazine</a>, where he mused, in typical Trump fashion: “I’ve never used it. I could use it. A lot of people think I should use it sometimes.”</p><p>The Insurrection Act basically creates an exception from the <a href="https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/research-reports/posse-comitatus-act-explained">Posse Comitatus Act of 1878</a>, which bars federal troops from being deployed domestically for law enforcement purposes. It allows the president to, as the Brennan Center puts it in <a href="https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/research-reports/insurrection-act-explained">a very helpful explainer</a>, “suppress rebellion or domestic violence or to enforce the law in certain situations.” What situations? Well, this is where it gets tricky. Unfortunately, the president has quite a bit of leeway over when and why to invoke the Insurrection Act. According to the Brennan Center: “In theory, the Insurrection Act should be used only in a crisis that is truly beyond the capacity of civilian authorities to manage. However, the Insurrection Act fails to adequately define or limit when it may be used and instead gives the president significant power to decide when and where to deploy U.S. military forces domestically.” Throughout U.S. history, it has been invoked about 30 times – most recently when President George H.W. Bush sent federal troops to Los Angeles during the Rodney King riots in the spring of 1992, at the request of both the governor of California and the mayor of Los Angeles.</p><p>It is obvious why the Insurrection Act appeals to Trump: He undoubtedly imagines it as a kind of cheat code that would give him <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m3kjyarncn2b">“unquestioned power”</a> – including to suppress protests, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kQYW_ITznX4">to “just shoot them,”</a> as he believes he should have been able to order the military to do during the George Floyd protests in the summer of 2020.</p><p>But here it is imperative we push back against such notions that present the Insurrection Act as the ultimate weapon in the hands of the authoritarian regime. Leave aside, for a moment, the question of how the courts would react (and how the regime would react to a court intervening, which would almost definitely happen): While this step would undoubtedly constitute a major escalation – one Trump has so far been reluctant to force, despite all the bluster and unhinged rhetoric –, invoking the Insurrection Act is not akin to waving a magic wand that vanquishes all opposition.</p><p>The Insurrection Act does not suspend the constitution and civil liberties, it does not establish martial law or a military dictatorship. It would allow Trump to put regular troops in the streets to serve as law enforcement. Federal troops patrolling the streets would still be constrained by the law, restricted to regular law enforcement powers.</p><p>The question we must insist on asking is: What would a realistic path be from there to a consolidated autocracy?</p><p>We can also turn the perspective around: Why hasn’t Trump invoked the Insurrection Act yet? If it makes him omnipotent and lets him install a dictatorship in an instant, why hasn’t he done it yet? The people who control the government are certainly not the most patient or a particularly prudent bunch. As a matter of practical reality, the idea that the minute Trump invokes the Insurrection Act all resistance is futile, Trump has won, Game Over is nonsense. That’s just regime propaganda. Perhaps the Trumpists, underneath all the bluster, know this too? Could it be that some in the administration are concerned that once they actually invoke the Insurrection Act, they can no longer use it as a constant threat? And if that doesn’t get their enemies to surrender, what do they have left?</p><p><strong>Different factions inside the MAGA regime</strong></p><p>Sources from within the administration have been adamantly claiming that these MAGA extremists who are urging Trump to declare martial law do not influence the decisions inside the White House.</p><p>As a default position, we should not trust anything any of these habitual liars say. In this case, however, the reporting points to crucial dynamics within the regime and the broader MAGA movement. They don’t exist as a monolith. There are different factions and there is real friction between them. And they are not entirely in agreement about how to handle the obstacles they have so far failed to overcome.</p><p>Not for the first time, the country is facing an inflection point in the struggle between authoritarian escalation and democratic resistance. <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/06/15/us/politics/trump-scharf-habeas-corpus-insurrection-act.html">We know</a> that the MAGA government internally contemplated radical steps that would have potentially ended the American Republic in previous such moments. In late April 2025, for instance, Stephen Miller pushed for the president to suspend habeas corpus for unauthorized immigrants in order to speed up the regime’s mass deportation efforts. Habeas corpus is the most foundational principle on which the rule of law is built: Anyone who has been detained by the government has the right to challenge their detention in court. They must have the chance to petition a court to order their release. If the government can arbitrarily detain you, all other rights you may possess on paper are null and void. Suspending habeas, without authorization from Congress, would have been a radically unconstitutional step; it would have taken the conflict between the Trump administration and the courts to a whole different level. And the Trumpists, one must suspect, would have inevitably extended the suspension beyond just unauthorized immigrants sooner or later. This regime, after all, is centered around the promise of purging not only the “illegal aliens” and “alien enemies” but also the “enemy within” who is supposedly in cahoots with those nefarious outside forces.</p><p>The Trumpists deliberated despotism – and those who demanded it are still very much part of the inner core of this regime. However, they ultimately decided against taking that step. They didn’t dare to suspend habeas corpus. And despite all their aggressive posturing about representing the “will of the people” and therefore standing above the law and the Constitution: They didn’t start entirely ignoring the courts either.</p><p>We encounter a similar dynamic in late January, when Miller and Vice-President JD Vance were urging for Trump to invoke the Insurrection Act and deploy federal troops to suppress the protests against the ongoing paramilitary occupation of Minneapolis carried out by ICE and Border Patrol. Yet once again, that is not what ultimately happened. The regime instead suffered a massive defeat at the hands of the good people of Minnesota who decided they were not going to acquiesce as their neighbors were being terrorized in the streets by masked agents of the state. </p><p>Recalling these previous inflection points reminds us that there are not only different ideological camps within the MAGA government, pursuing overlapping, but distinct visions of what America should look like. There are also fault lines defined by temperament. The different factions aren’t entirely in agreement about how far they should escalate – they differ in terms of appetite for radicalism. Those two dimensions, ideological extremism and temperamental radicalism, are certainly correlated. It is not a coincidence that Stephen Miller, a full-on white nationalist ideologue, has consistently been pushing for escalation. But there are evidently other factors playing a part.</p><p>The overriding concern among those who argued against the kind of escalation Miller and Vance demanded was to avoid self-inflicted damage. That doesn’t mean they might not also have substantively disagreed. But what they feared, first and foremost, was a high-stakes battle with the courts they believed the administration would lose – as well as an ongoing public relations disaster and the further loss of public support.</p><p>What did Donald Trump do in these moments – and what does that suggest about how he might act now? Well, in recent months, the president’s attention seems to have been increasingly focused on matters of monumental self-aggrandizement: The White House ballroom, the Triumphal Arch he wants to build, the Reflecting Pool… Meanwhile, the day-to-day operation of governing – or: consolidating authoritarian rule – has clearly not been his priority. It is a weird form of personalism we are confronted with. Personalism is the type of authoritarian regime where control is centralized in the hands of a leader figure, the center of gravity is one person at the top (rather than a party apparatus, or perhaps the military), power and influence are entirely dependent on the relationship with the regime’s leader. What we have here is personalism with a lazy, mentally and physically exhausted, increasingly delusional leader at the top who doesn’t want to be bothered with the actual work of governing and cares about the pageantry of power more than about consolidating it properly first.</p><p>In the spring of 2025, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/06/15/us/politics/trump-scharf-habeas-corpus-insurrection-act.html">the available<em> </em>reporting suggests</a>, Trump was at least somewhat involved in the deliberations over whether or not to suspend habeas corpus. But even then, he was not willing to fully side with one camp or the other. In January 2026, as his vice-president and chief white nationalist were pushing for him to invoke the Insurrection Act, Trump seems to have been largely absent. In key moments, when different factions within his government were engaged in a struggle for supremacy that would define the trajectory of his regime, Trump either hesitated – or simply couldn’t be bothered to pay attention, participate, and make a decision either way.</p><p>The most likely scenario for the midterms, I believe, is that Trump will once again hamper the efforts of the most extreme voices in and around the White House by displaying a similar lack of discipline and decisiveness. Unfortunately, the situation might be very different in 2028. I find it very hard to believe Trump will leave the White House willingly. At the risk of psychologizing too much, his ego and narcissism will be a much bigger factor two years from now, when Trump himself is about to lose power; he also understands he needs to be president in order to avoid accountability for his unprecedented crimes and corruption. But that is 2028. For the midterms, I struggle to see him becoming the energetic, ruthless, cunning fascistic leader his most extreme followers wish he were. </p><p><em>Want to support my work? Consider becoming a paid member:</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><strong>Where does America stand?</strong></p><p>I want to end with a threat assessment in three thoughts and observations.</p><p>One: MAGA will continue to escalate</p><p>If my analysis is correct, the Trumpists will fail to subvert the election, their attempts to overturn the results will be thwarted. But by no means is that a reason to relax.</p><p>We are faced with a somewhat paradoxical situation. The Trumpists are in a relatively weak position. As societal resistance has been hardening, they do not really possess a plausible strategy for how to impose and consolidate authoritarian rule across the country. But that weakness is also a source of radicalization. It is precisely the mounting frustration over the gulf between the authoritarian unreality and the real world that is fueling the frantic search for ways to assert the kind of dominance they so desperately desire.</p><p>MAGA is ideologically and psycho-politically incapable of moderating. It is a hysterical movement that exists in a constant state of imagined emergency. There is no room for compromise or restraint. Every crisis, every defeat only heightens their sense of being under siege, legitimizing and amplifying calls to hit harder, more aggressively.</p><p>This is where the gravest danger lies: When delusion, authoritarian desires, ideological zealotry, ineptitude, and mounting desperation all combine, things are bound to escalate further.</p><p>I believe MAGA will ultimately fail to consolidate authoritarian rule across all spheres of American life. But for the time being, the powers of the U.S. government are in the hands of a regime that is hellbent on imposing its unreality on the country and the rest of the world. And that is a truly frightening position to be in for all of us.</p><p>Two: No irresistible march towards authoritarianism</p><p>They will keep trying. But that doesn’t mean they must succeed. How we interpret the past 20 months of Trumpism in power shapes our expectations regarding the midterm elections. Has the country been irresistibly marching towards a Trump dictatorship? Will this be just another step in that direction? I don’t think so. </p><p>I see a different dynamic: Several times over the past twenty months the Trumpists seemed poised to vanquish the democratic opposition and break through whatever obstacles the constitutional order was still placing in their path – but then were unable to force that next step. About three months into Trump’s second presidency, as outlined above, the government announced it would henceforth ignore the courts entirely – but then didn’t. In the early summer of 2025, the deployment of National Guard troops to Los Angeles seemed to suggest the regime was ready to use emergency powers to quash the resistance in urban centers – but then pulled back from several major cities at the end of the year. After the murder of Charlie Kirk, the Trumpists laid the pseudo-legal groundwork for a sweeping criminalization of all political and societal opposition – but then didn’t actually implement the type of comprehensive oppression the Right has been clamoring for. In January, the Trumpists wanted to break the will of the people in Minneapolis, hoping it would serve as a warning to the rest of the nation. But the failed paramilitary occupation of the city turned into something else: A reminder of democratic freedom and solidarity.</p><p>This pattern stands in contrast to the idea of Trumpism’s irresistible march towards consolidated authoritarian rule. A past pattern is not a guarantee that the regime won’t ultimately break through somehow. But it should be a reminder: Being lawless, immoral, and violent does not make the Trumpists omnipotent.</p><p>Three: Panicked defeatism is neither savvy nor helpful</p><p>I said this in Part II of my deep dive and I will repeat it here because it is so fundamentally important: In order to successfully subvert the election or overturn the results, the Trumpists are not only dependent on the complicity of MAGA supporters, but also on the widespread acquiescence of those who oppose the regime.</p><p>I have no doubt about the MAGA movement’s intentions. But let us refuse to help them propagate the notion that reality does not apply to them. All those who value democratic self-government have agency and can act to block the path towards authoritarian consolidation.</p><p>And here, I will allow myself to write grumpy: I have very little patience for doomsaying and catastrophizing. If it is caused by sincere concerns and justifiable fears, I sympathize. But too often, it’s become a mindless reflex (or, worse yet, a calculated attitude intended to attract an audience). Some people – even among my own readers – react with consternation, even anger to anything that doesn’t reflect their own level of alarm back at them. I understand. But please consider this: If what you are saying boils down to “Trump could end the Republic whenever he wants to,” you are not contributing plausible analysis.</p><p>I don’t think it’s particularly helpful or enlightening to approach the political situation as if the task was to pour all our creativity into coming up with doomsday scenarios - without weighing their likelihood, regardless of the empirical evidence, and without considering the actual track record and trajectory of this regime. </p><p>The assertion of irresistible power is itself a key element of the authoritarian assault. We must not help them perpetuate it by giving in to pseudo-savvy cynicism and defeatism.</p><p>Let us always remember: The Trumpist lust for authoritarian control is limitless. But the gulf between those desires on the one hand and the realities of a pluralistic modern society and complex political system on the other remains vast. And in that space, politics continues, resistance can thrive, there is ample opportunity and agency to push back.</p><p><strong><em>Thank you for reading!</em></strong></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is my main source of income as an independent writer. Want to support my work? Consider becoming a paid member:</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/ce368414-634e-4401-a48e-07af9585c025/uploads/images/ri4i4k4ad5/iStock-1480868760.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/ce368414-634e-4401-a48e-07af9585c025</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">ce368414-634e-4401-a48e-07af9585c025</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 25 Oct 2026 11:57:03 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Trump Is Not Some All-Powerful God-King]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[To subvert the election and get from here to consolidated authoritarian rule, the Trumpists depend on cynicism, acquiescence, and defeatism in the democratic camp]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>To subvert the election and get from here to consolidated authoritarian rule, the Trumpists depend on cynicism, acquiescence, and defeatism in the democratic camp</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, October 19, 2026</em></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/1ebfca62-2ac4-4cd7-be24-1e888437c208/uploads/images/evpozwl6qe/iStock-660870098.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>credit: iStock / zimmytws</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></strong></p><p><em>This is </em><strong><em>the second part</em></strong><em> of a three-part deep dive into the political situation in the United States before the midterm elections – an attempt to answer the most urgent questions about the upcoming election and Trump’s attempts to interfere, think through the dangers that lie ahead, and reflect on where we stand in the struggle between authoritarian escalation and democratic resilience. </em><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/d9a4df24-9b8d-4dd8-bb13-73fc07e56c5f"><em>In Part I</em></a><em>, I focused on the state of public opinion and whether we could trust the polls as well as the attempts by the Trump regime to manipulate their way to victory by taking control and subverting the process before we even get to election day. This Part II outlines the dangers from election day on November 3 through January 3, when the new Congress will be seated.</em></p><p><em>The extended intro to this piece is free to read for everyone. If you want to </em><strong><em>read more</em></strong><em> than the preview, please consider becoming </em><strong><em>a paid member</em></strong><em> of Democracy Americana, which is </em><strong><em>solely funded by readers</em></strong><em> and constitutes my main source of income.</em></p><p><em>Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. </em><strong><em>If you can become a paid member, please do.</em></strong><em> As a member, you receive many additional essays, and you </em><strong><em>gain access to the audio versions</em></strong><em> of everything I publish (members can find the audio at the end of the piece or available for download in the podcast player of your choice).</em></p><p><em>As always, the </em><strong><em>German version</em></strong><em> of this essay will be available over at </em><a href="https://steady.page/de/demokratie-americana/posts"><strong><em>Demokratie Americana</em></strong></a><em> soon.</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><strong><em>NEW</em></strong><em> If you’re not ready for a paid membership yet, you can </em><strong><em>unlock this one article for free</em></strong><em> by subscribing to the free version of this newsletter (via the registration wall below).</em></p><p></p><p>We are getting close now. Merely two weeks remain until election day on November 3. But unfortunately, the threat to the American Republic won’t end there. The key danger now lies in what happens on and especially after election day, from early November through at least January 3, the day the new Congress will come together.</p><p>It’s been two weeks since I published <a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/d9a4df24-9b8d-4dd8-bb13-73fc07e56c5f">Part I</a> of this deep dive into the political situation in the United States before the midterm elections. And the structural conditions have not changed much. The party of a historically unpopular president holds both chambers of Congress and is pursuing a drastically unpopular agenda; most voters describe their top priority as economy / prices, areas where Trump’s approval rating is unprecedentedly disastrous. Under such structural conditions – what political scientists call “the fundamentals” – our default assumption should be a massive defeat for the party in charge.</p><p>A massive defeat for the Republican Party is also what all the data, all the indicators we have suggest. Everything points in the same direction. The polls, <a href="https://fiftyplusone.news/forecast/house">the prediction models</a>, the very high Democratic turnout during the primaries, the early voting that indicates an extremely energized Democratic base, all the historical comparisons to previous times the party that controlled the White House and Congress lost the midterms.</p><p>At this point, <a href="https://www.gelliottmorris.com/p/2026-10-15-podcast-normal-polling-error">it would take a historically unprecedented</a> polling error and a complete break from everything history suggests should happen with such “fundamentals” for Republicans to hold the House. In the Senate, the situation is far more uncertain. Realistic outcomes range from Democrats being stuck in the minority to the opposition getting to 55 seats. The most likely outcome is a Democratic majority here as well.</p><p>How does the staunchly authoritarian movement that controls the U.S. government and is firmly in charge of the Republican Party react to this situation?</p><p>Because the Trumpists are emphatically opposed to liberal democracy and fully convinced they are the sole proponents of “real America” and therefore the only legitimate rulers of the nation, they are committed to subverting, manipulating, and intimidating their way to victory. Over the past few months, as I have outlined in detail in Part I, they have tried to impose new rules that would either allow Republicans to steal enough seats outright by massively disenfranchising Democratic voters or, at the very least, cause chaos in order to guarantee there would be lots of ammunition for Trump to claim fraud and irregularity and create a pseudo-plausible basis for the federal government to intervene.</p><p>However, the MAGA government’s major schemes to subvert the election have so far failed.</p><p>Unfortunately, that is not the end of the story. They will keep trying. On election day and in the months thereafter. At least until the new Congress is constituted in early January, and perhaps even beyond.</p><p>At this point, this is no longer an exercise in analyzing and interpreting what is already happening. We are entering the territory of weighing different scenarios of varying likelihood for the near future. That is why it is all the more important to establish a framework for how to think about and conceptualize the dangers that lie ahead. The key challenge is to find the balance between, on the one hand, being vigilant and justifiably, inevitably alarmed – and, on the other, drowning in doomsaying and defeatism, which is exactly what the Trumpists rely on to bring the system down.</p><p><strong>What happens on election day?</strong></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/1ebfca62-2ac4-4cd7-be24-1e888437c208">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/1ebfca62-2ac4-4cd7-be24-1e888437c208/uploads/images/evpozwl6qe/iStock-660870098.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/1ebfca62-2ac4-4cd7-be24-1e888437c208</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">1ebfca62-2ac4-4cd7-be24-1e888437c208</guid>
      <pubDate>Mon, 19 Oct 2026 07:25:54 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Demonizing Democracy]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The Right has long derided any attempt at leveling racial and social hierarchies as anti-American “socialism” or “communism.” What they are actually fighting is equality.]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The Right has long derided any attempt at leveling racial and social hierarchies as anti-American “socialism” or “communism.” What they are actually fighting is equality.</strong></p><figure><a href="https://www.loc.gov/item/2009632339/"><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/51dc92fb-fbbe-4fbb-a7f3-1023da99da40/uploads/images/42z2wgmtly/1959-Little-Rock-Rally1.jpg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/></a><figcaption>Little Rock, 1959. A Rally of segregationists at the state capitol – credit: Bledsoe, John T. / Library of Congress</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></strong></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is a publication </em><strong><em>solely funded by readers</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p><em>Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. </em><strong><em>If you can become a paid member, please do.</em></strong><em> As a member, you receive many additional essays, and you </em><strong><em>gain access to the audio versions</em></strong><em> of everything I publish (members can find the audio at the end of the piece or available for download in the podcast player of your choice).</em></p><p><em>Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work. Please know that I am immensely grateful for your generosity!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can </em><strong><em>unlock this article for free</em></strong><em> by subscribing to the free version of this newsletter (via the registration wall below).</em></p><p></p><p>During a press conference on Thursday, Vice-President JD Vance was asked: “How do you define socialism, personally, and why do you think socialist candidates are popping up everywhere across the country?”</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qgd8TAXnchM">His response</a> offered the blend of ridiculous, unintentionally funny, outrageous, breathtakingly stupid, and acutely dangerous that is the true hallmark of rightwing politics in the Trump era:</p><p>“I think in reality what it actually means in the American context is that you wanna replace American workers with foreign workers and you want boys to play in girls’ sports. That’s what unites the socialists that I see running across the United States of America today.”</p><p>I know I owe you Part II of the deep dive into the most urgent questions about the upcoming midterm elections and Trump’s attempts to interfere – and that will be coming very soon. But I believe it is worth dwelling on what Vance said for a moment. Because as is often the case with the obviously bizarre nonsense the leaders of today’s Right are blurting out constantly, it reveals something of importance about the people and the movement that currently controls the U.S. government: About how they see the world and the political conflict, about the long-standing traditions of anti-democratic thinking on the Right that have gotten us here, about the radicalizing sentiment that is fueling the assault on liberal democracy.</p><p>The key point here is this: The political Right has always derided anything that threatens the social and racial hierarchy as a form of anti-American “socialism” or “communism” and used those terms to demonize anyone who dares to question the righteousness of past, present, or future white reactionary elite rule. What has united the different factions on the Right – those who came together in the middle decades of the twentieth century under the banner of “Modern Conservatism” as well as the different camps of the MAGA coalition today – is a commitment to fighting against any attempt at leveling hierarchies of race, gender, religion, and wealth. Rightwing political identity has always been centered around this commitment to a specific societal order – and by its hostility towards the “left”-coded forces working to change, undermine, or subvert it. It always defined the stakes of the conflict as existential because it set out to defend a “natural order” that was not up for political deliberation or subject to democratic control.</p><p>With so much of the Right’s identity wrapped up in rejecting “the Left,” and no equally strong commitment to limiting principles that could have moderated political action, where was the restraint against a continuous escalation and radicalization supposed to come from? If “traditional” conservatism was no longer commensurate with the challenge of upholding a societal order defined by strict hierarchies, more radical measures would have to be taken. That is how those who dominate the Right today have given themselves permission to embrace extremism and state authoritarianism.</p><p>But let’s take a step back: Let me offer a brief, incomplete history of the Right raging against “socialism” or “communism” when they really mean equality.</p><p><strong>“Race Mixing is Communism”</strong></p><p>In late August 1959, a group of angry white protesters assembled in front of the state capitol in Little Rock, Arkansas. To express their “concern,” if that is what we want to call it, they brought signs that read: “Race Mixing is Communism.”</p><p>The “race mixing” in question was the integration of public high schools.</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/51dc92fb-fbbe-4fbb-a7f3-1023da99da40">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/51dc92fb-fbbe-4fbb-a7f3-1023da99da40/uploads/images/42z2wgmtly/1959-Little-Rock-Rally1.jpg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/51dc92fb-fbbe-4fbb-a7f3-1023da99da40</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">51dc92fb-fbbe-4fbb-a7f3-1023da99da40</guid>
      <pubDate>Mon, 12 Oct 2026 10:05:28 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[What Do Authoritarians Do When They Are About to Lose an Election?]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Trump’s schemes to subvert the midterms have so far failed. What happens next? A reflection on the threat as well as the limits of authoritarian escalation]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Trump’s schemes to subvert the midterms have so far failed. What happens next? A reflection on the threat as well as the limits of authoritarian escalation</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, October 4, 2026</em></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/d9a4df24-9b8d-4dd8-bb13-73fc07e56c5f/uploads/images/vc5drdf7it/iStock-1278157634.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>credit: iStock / zimmytws</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></strong></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is a publication </em><strong><em>solely funded by readers</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p><em>Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. </em><strong><em>If you can become a paid member, please do.</em></strong><em> As a member, you receive many additional essays, and you </em><strong><em>gain access to the audio versions</em></strong><em> of everything I publish (members can find the audio at the end of the piece or available for download in the podcast player of your choice).</em></p><p><em>This is </em><strong><em>Part I</em></strong><em> of a two-part deep dive into the political situation in the United States one month out from the midterm elections – an attempt to answer the most urgent questions about the upcoming elections and Trump’s attempts to interfere, think through the dangers that lie ahead, and reflect on where we stand in the struggle between authoritarian escalation and democratic resilience. Part II will follow later this week.</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? </em></p><p><em>You can </em><strong><em>unlock this article for free</em></strong><em> by subscribing to the free version of this newsletter (via the registration wall below).</em></p><p></p><p>Around 2 pm Eastern Standard Time on January 6, 2021, a violent mob of militant MAGA supporters and riled-up Trump fans broke through the barriers and <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-56004916">entered the Capitol</a> in Washington, DC. The insurrection was the culmination of a multi-month, multi-level scheme to nullify the results of a democratic election. It was engineered and orchestrated by the president of the United States. And in the moment, it failed.</p><p>But four years later, the insurrectionist-in-chief returned to power without ever facing any real consequences and while explicitly declaring his intent to establish a vindictive autocracy. Those who are nominally tasked with defending democracy and the rule of law had proved unable and/or unwilling to hold the line. A pervasive, system-wide failure.</p><p>On his first day back in the White House, the most blatantly lawless and comically corrupt major politician in U.S. history <a href="https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/justice-department/trump-set-pardon-defendants-stormed-capitol-jan-6-2021-rcna187735">immediately pardoned</a> the January 6 mob of insurrectionists and violent vigilantes. It was the perverse apotheosis of Trumpism as a political project. Donald Trump signaled to the nation that those who commit political violence in his name would be protected and revered.</p><p>Now, that same man and his party are about to lose another major election. A defeat in the November midterms won’t end the Trump presidency. Trump himself is not on the ballot. But the stakes for the Trumpists are nevertheless high. If Democrats win at least one of the chambers, they should seek to reassert and defend the powers of Congress against the authoritarian regime, especially the power of the purse. They could also make life a lot more difficult for Trump and the people he has elevated to positions of power. Democrats may seek to impeach the president or members of his cabinet; at the very least, a series of Congressional investigations into the countless crimes and outrageous corruption of this administration should define the second half of Trump’s presidency (and hopefully create a record for future prosecution). Moreover, a clear victory for the opposition would be of great symbolic significance: The Trumpists have built their claim to authoritarian power on the myth that they represent the “will of the people,” that “real America” stands with them, that Donald Trump is the “tribune” of the “authentic” American Volk. A massive defeat in a national election would further undermine those claims.</p><p>And if the midterms are anything but a complete scam, that is what we should be expecting at this point: A massive defeat for the party of the president. According to all serious prediction models, Republicans have no realistic chance of keeping the House. They are also more likely than not to lose the majority in the Senate. The most likely scenarios we are looking at range from a brutal loss for the GOP to a nearly unprecedented wipeout. </p><p>Some part of Donald Trump must understand this too. And that means the country is in an acutely dangerous situation. Because this president and this Republican Party are obviously not willing to accept the result of a democratic election unless they emerge victorious. Trump has often and <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/05/05/opinion/trump-midterm-elections-2026.html">openly admitted</a> that he considers <em>any</em> democratic control of his power illegitimate. He and his rightwing allies have been trying to demonize the opposition, raging against Democrats <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/12/us/politics/trump-democrats-communism-midterms.html">as communist traitors</a> who must never be allowed to win an election, let alone govern. </p><p>What happens next? Can we even trust the polls? How certain can we be that what the prediction models are telling us is accurate? What schemes and strategies have the Trumpists already tried to subvert the election - and why have they, so far, failed? What else are they planning? What is going to happen on election day? What about the schemes to prevent Democratic representatives-elect from being seated in the House on January 3? And what are we to make of the fascist fever dreams emanating from the most extreme corners of the Right that envision Trump declaring “a national security emergency” or “martial law”?</p><p>I will try to answer, as best I can, the key questions we are facing now. The challenge is not a lack of information – rather the opposite, as we are constantly being bombarded with more polls, more reports, more revelations. The key challenge is to evaluate, contextualize, and interpret all this disparate information, to bring order into the chaos. My goal is, therefore, to combine my answers to specific questions with a broader reflection on the state of the regime and the political system one month out from the election: What does an authoritarian regime – this authoritarian government – do when it is about to lose an election? What are the forces and dynamics, both internal and external, that determine the MAGA regime’s trajectory? Where are we in the struggle between authoritarian escalation and democratic resilience? Let’s establish a framework for how to think about and conceptualize the dangers that lie ahead, something that can help us absorb and process the information and the noise as we are nearing this inflection point in the struggle against rightwing authoritarianism.</p><p><strong>Can we trust the polls and the predictions?</strong></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/d9a4df24-9b8d-4dd8-bb13-73fc07e56c5f">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/d9a4df24-9b8d-4dd8-bb13-73fc07e56c5f/uploads/images/vc5drdf7it/iStock-1278157634.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/d9a4df24-9b8d-4dd8-bb13-73fc07e56c5f</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">d9a4df24-9b8d-4dd8-bb13-73fc07e56c5f</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 04 Oct 2026 22:09:40 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Onward. Forward. With your help.]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Happy birthday to Democracy Americana! One year ago, I started this experiment. To keep it going, I need your support.]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Happy birthday to Democracy Americana! One year ago, I started this experiment. To keep it going, I need your support.</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, September 24, 2026</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/b3f0dfac-3f40-40a2-be05-d9510c10c451">Listen on Steady</a></p><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/b3f0dfac-3f40-40a2-be05-d9510c10c451/uploads/images/th3l3azezk/SocMediaBanner.png?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><p><em>A quick reminder: This newsletter is also available in German. If that is of interest to you, head over to </em><a href="https://steady.page/de/demokratie-americana/posts"><strong><em>Demokratie Americana</em></strong></a></p><p></p><p>Dear readers,</p><p>Exactly one year ago, I started a new life as a full-time independent writer. Democracy Americana became the focus of my professional work and my main source of income. Today, I want to say thank you! And I ask for your support to keep this publication – and me – going. </p><p>Being able to write for a living is an enormous privilege. And more than that: It honors me greatly to know that so many people are allowing me a place at the table, to be part of their conversations. That my writing is met with interest, energy, and engagement makes this work immensely meaningful</p><p>Twelve months ago, I took this step amidst a series of life-changing transitions. When I re-launched Democracy Americana last September, <a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/ab02af47-9e87-4143-ba51-afa2d1804c1c">I wrote extensively</a> about my decision to leave academia, about the reasons why my family and I decided to leave the United States. It was a nervous, anxious moment. I had to hope and trust that there would be enough people out there who not only value my work but are also willing and able to support it financially. I can honestly say that this is the most gratifying work I have ever done, the best job I have ever had.</p><p>Alas, in order to keep going and keep writing Democracy Americana, I rely on the generosity and the support of my readers.<strong> Allow me to ask you directly to support me with a paid membership.</strong></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to newsletter</a></p><p>I hope you will indulge me. I know this isn’t why you are reading this newsletter. And I promise that I will return to grappling with the madness that surrounds us as soon as I am done writing this. But I really do need your help. I figure this one-year anniversary is as good an occasion as any to tell you why, and what you get in return. <strong>Consider this my once-annual plea</strong>.</p><p>In what follows, I want to explain why Democracy Americana remains in a precarious situation one year after launch and outline what I believe my work can offer you, what I am – what we are, together – building here. I am not trying to guilt and coerce anyone into giving me money they don’t think I deserve or aren’t in a position to give. My goal is to make sure my readers have an adequate understanding of the realities that determine the future of this publication.</p><p>If you are a regular reader but you are not sure yet if Democracy Americana deserves your support, I hope I will be able to convince you. If you do find my work valuable, but you are currently not in a position to support it financially, you should know that I very much appreciate your time and effort engaging. Please help me spread the word and find new readers by recommending Democracy Americana to anyone in your circles who might be interested.</p><p><strong>Most importantly, if you value my work and you are in a position to offer financial support, please consider becoming a paid member.</strong></p><p>Look, I get it. The media landscape – and with it, the information environment in which we all exist – keeps fracturing. The number of independent outlets vying for attention has grown exponentially in recent years; every day our email inboxes are filled with more newsletters than anyone could possibly read.</p><p>I understand, therefore, that the onus is on me to make a convincing case. So, let me make my pitch and tell you what Democracy Americana can offer, why it matters, and what I believe distinguishes my work. I also want to share with you where I would like to be going in Year Two. </p><p>As I see it, there are two separate dimensions: There are, first of all, the <strong>exclusive benefits</strong> that come with a paid membership. While I publish free pieces regularly, at least half of my writing on Democracy Americana is reserved for paid members. In other words, as a paid member, you get about double the “content.” You also have access to the audio versions of all my writing in podcast form – either via an RSS feed that enables you to get the audio version in the podcast player of your choice or via a premium Spotify feed.</p><p>A second dimension is, I believe, even more important: <strong>You are not merely paying for a newsletter. With a paid membership, you are supporting me, my work</strong> – everything I do professionally is built on your generosity. You are allowing me to remain truly independent, to offer not just quick punditry, but an academically grounded perspective that combines historical context and political analysis – with a focus on the United States but situated within the transnational struggle over the fate of democracy. Every piece I publish in a newspaper, every talk I’m able to deliver to a live audience, every interview I do, every podcast appearance, every roundtable discussion: None of it would be feasible without your backing, your encouragement, and your generosity.</p><p><strong>The state of Democracy Americana</strong></p><p>Before I give you the more elaborate version of my pitch below and tell you what, exactly, I am hoping to accomplish, I owe you a little bit of transparency about the state of Democracy Americana – the business side of things, if you will. Since I am asking you for financial support, that seems only fair.</p><p>When I launched into this new life as a full-time writer, I said I would give myself one year to make it work. In the most immediate sense, that meant turning my independent work into a financially viable career, with Democracy Americana as the centerpiece of my “business strategy.” The goal I set for myself was to get to 1,000 paying subscribers – or: “members” – within twelve months. The newsletter goes out to about 20,000 total subscribers, and achieving a conversion rate of free-to-paid subscribers of about five percent seemed reasonable, if perhaps somewhat ambitious.</p><p>The goal of 1,000 subscribers was not chosen randomly: It’s the point where the revenue generated by Democracy Americana would translate into enough income to make a living without relying on lots of additional paid work like writing for newspapers and magazines, giving talks, or doing other public events. I like doing these kinds of gigs. But as any freelance journalist or writer will tell you, depending on such commissioned work creates a lot of stress and uncertainty. You are always pitching, negotiating, hoping the next thing will materialize… while much of the process is out of your hands, depending mostly on the ebbs and flows of the attention economy and on relatively opaque decisions in editorial meetings of media institutions. My biggest goal was to gain as much independence as possible from such dynamics in order to have more certainty and be able to put most of my energy into the actual work rather than into hustling to secure the next paid gig.</p><p>Alas, after twelve months, I am only about eighty percent there, with a little over 800 paying members. I’m sure there is more than one reason why I’ve fallen short. But it certainly has a lot to do with my departure from Substack, where the newsletter was hosted initially, and my decision to re-launch Democracy Americana at a different platform here at Steady. I have <a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/ab02af47-9e87-4143-ba51-afa2d1804c1c">written extensively</a> about the political and ethical reasons for moving away from Substack, a decision I stand by, even if it has cost me. I won’t elaborate on that story here. But I will admit that I vastly underestimated how high the price would be, how much leaving Substack would hurt the reach and visibility of Democracy Americana. It has turned out to be brutally hard to find new subscribers, let alone paying members, away from Substack. That is less a story about Steady, specifically, as <a href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/the-future-now-and-then-then-and-now">other writers</a> have described similar dynamics after moving to different platforms. The fact is that many millions of people are already on Substack, and the biggest accounts and media institutions with hundreds of thousands of subscribers keep drawing more people in. Away from Substack, there are no comparable network effects to benefit from, no comparable existing reservoir of potential readers. Growing an independent publication beyond a certain size as an individual writer away from Substack seems… very, very difficult.</p><p>That’s the not-so-good news. On the other hand, and that is the better news, I have gotten close enough to my initial goal where I can say that, as of right now, being an independent writer is a financially viable career for me - as long as I manage to supplement the income generated via Democracy Americana with enough paid work for newspapers, talks, etc.</p><p>That doesn’t mean I’m in a comfortable position. I have certainly been working more than ever before in my life, and I am not expecting that to change anytime soon. And the situation remains quite precarious. Especially now, as I am about to find out whether I have done enough to earn the long-term trust of enough readers, beyond the newborn and toddler phases of this publication.</p><p><em>Want to support my work? Consider becoming a paid member:</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><strong>My offer and my promise</strong></p><p>Whatever contribution I am able to make through my work: As a paid member, you are making that possible. But what, exactly, is it that I am contributing?</p><p>1) Democracy Americana has allowed me to <strong>remain independent</strong>, which is an enormous privilege. I have no sponsors, no income from advertisement. I am not constrained or restricted by any institutional commitment. It is literally just me. That makes things much more difficult financially (and it may well be stupid as a business model). But it also means that I am free of any obligation except the one to my readers – and to the analysis itself. I get to decide what to think and write about, when and how to think and write about it. I have to believe there is real value in that.</p><p>2) I offer a perspective at the <strong>intersection of academic research and the broader public discourse</strong>. Having spent almost two decades teaching and doing research within the academic system, I certainly don’t think academia has all the answers to all the questions. But there is tremendously helpful, valuable academic research being produced every day – research that is all too often ignored (sometimes willfully) by political leaders as well as media elites. Conversely, I think it is fair to say that academics often struggle to interject their expertise into the discourse in a way that is accessible and has a chance to actually break through (which is also simply not the job they are tasked to do). Democracy Americana can help translate the state of the academic discussion, can critique and evaluate public narratives from the perspective of academic research. My essays are intended for a broader audience – but I take pride in researching and writing them in a way that stands up to academic scrutiny. Others will always be faster or cover the news more broadly. But I don’t think anyone will be more thorough. </p><p>3) Both my academic as well as my biographical background enable me to situate current American politics not just in U.S. history, but also from an <strong>international perspective</strong>; to look beyond deep-seated notions of exceptionalism and identify what really is specifically American about the current situation and what is part of a much broader transnational struggle over the future of liberal democracy; to place Trumpism in the context of a global far-right mobilization against the idea of egalitarian pluralism. Conversely, I am also approaching the struggle against rightwing authoritarianism in Europe from a transnational and transatlantic perspective. I spent the past decade focusing on U.S. history and politics. But before that, I studied, researched, and taught modern German and European history. I spent most of the past ten years in the United States, but I moved back to Germany with my family just as the far-right AfD inches ever closer to power. The escalating struggle between the vision of democratic pluralism and the idea of an authoritarian ethnostate transcends national borders. If we want to understand this conflict, our perspective must not be confined to national boundaries either.</p><p>4) I am quite confident that Democracy Americana has so far managed to <strong>avoid the punditry trap</strong>. There are two things that I detest about a particular type of pundit who is far too prominently represented in our political discourse: They eagerly offer takes on everything, and they treat everything as if it were just a game. I get the temptation: Once you have a public platform, the pressure to constantly produce “content” is very real. I feel it every day. Once you have an audience, it is so easy to become seduced by the idea that every one of your opinions should be shared with the world. To counter these temptations, I promised myself I would be more rigorous, stick to my areas of expertise, never write anything that I wouldn’t want to defend at an academic conference or in a discussion with people who really knew their stuff. I believe I have been faithful to that philosophy. Moreover, I promise you I will never approach “the discourse” as just a game where we all throw takes at each other and the “quality” of our contributions is measured solely by whether or not they get enough attention, flatter the right group of people, and annoy those they were designed to annoy. I am not going to pretend I’m a “neutral” spectator writing from a place of detached irony. I take my contributions seriously, as an academically trained observer and as a citizen. The stuff I write about weighs on me. If it didn’t, it wouldn’t be worth writing about.</p><p><strong>The proof is in the pudding</strong></p><p>I can make promises all day long. But the best way for you to decide whether or not you want to support me is to actually look at my work. I invite all of you to take a stroll through the <a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts">Democracy Americana archive / catalog</a>, where you find all the pieces I have published in here. And I have also selected a few pieces from the past year I consider representative of what I do – and specifically pieces I wrote exclusively for paid members of Democracy Americana. For this occasion, I have taken down the paywall, making them accessible for free subscribers and anyone who might be on the fence. This, I hope, will give you a sense of the additional value that comes with a paid membership.</p><p>The five pieces, all written exclusively for paid members but now freely available to you, I want to highlight:</p><p></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/7edb91f9-c681-4769-b3cb-6eaebcc8ad4b">The Myth of a Rightward Realignment</a></p><p>Last November, I wrote about three stubborn myths regarding Trump’s support and what happened in the 2024 election – and why America is experiencing a de-alignment rather than a rightward realignment. In the piece, I tackle three building blocks of the misleading “realignment” narrative: 1) The idea that U.S. society moved right in accordance with the broader outlines of Trumpism’s vision; 2) that Trump is the tribune of the working class; 3) that he is building a stable multiracial coalition. All of these myths continue to shape the political discourse – in the United States and abroad – even though they have been thoroughly disproven empirically. This was my attempt to synthesize the empirical information we have and build on the best available analysis. Because we simply can’t afford to cling to fallacies and (willful) misunderstandings.</p><p> </p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/7b369a88-108e-4535-be65-b0faebebe324">Why the Tech Billionaires Are Aligned with Trump</a></p><p>In late April, I wrote about one of the defining - and most dangerous - stories of our time: Fueled by profit motives, ideological radicalization, and elite self-victimization, America’s tech barons are aggressively taking the side of authoritarianism. But why now? This was my attempt to portray the ideological and intellectual landscape of the tech billionaire world, trace their political trajectory since the height of the neoliberal consensus in the 1990s, and explain the more recent activation of long-standing anti-democratic tendencies.</p><p> </p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/8f16b18f-41d5-41f9-884b-f76a13852986">Putting the End of the Civil Rights Era in Historical Perspective</a></p><p>In May, I wrote about the Rise and Fall of the Second Reconstruction, 1964/65 – 2025/26: An attempt to really grasp what a profoundly important - and disturbing - moment in U.S. history we are currently experiencing. This was my reaction to the Supreme Court’s decision in <em>Louisiana v Callais, </em>which made the Voting Rights Act useless as an instrument to protect minority representation. In the piece, I explore the civil rights revolution of the 1960s, reflect on why it had such a transformative impact on politics and society – and examine why what we are witnessing now really is best understood as the end of a distinct era in U.S. history: The end of the civil rights order. This was also Part II of a series on the history of multiracial democracy in America. Not a total history, of course, but something that can serve as a framework for how to think about the dynamics of democratic extension vs reactionary retrenchment throughout U.S. history.</p><p></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/59b197fa-1a03-44e5-b155-2c221e2a3c0e">Understanding Our Disruptive Moment in History – and What It Requires</a></p><p>In late June, I wrote about how the political, economic, technological, and environmental crises intersect, why they are escalating now – and about the political implications of recognizing the profound disruption we are witnessing. The dynamic unleashed by these crises makes any attempt at “politics as usual” largely obsolete. One big advantage the Right possesses is that they are pursuing a transformative vision. They have a revolutionary theory of the moment and are committed to a (counter-) revolutionary political project. The Right doesn’t have answers, but it has a promise that fits our moment of unprecedented disruption temperamentally. The challenge is to counter this with a progressive vision that is adapted, both in substance and temperament, to the disruptive challenges we are facing.</p><p> </p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/da2ea08b-e35c-427b-b190-66a2fc097abb">Power, Opportunism, and Ideology in Republican Politics</a></p><p>In late July, I wrote about Lindsay Graham – and about so many more like him. The reason why it was worth dwelling on the last decade of Graham’s life is that it captured the core dynamics that have defined the behavior of the Republican establishment more broadly. This piece is about Graham and, more importantly, about the broader questions his case rases: About the trajectory of the Republican Party and the conditions that made Trump’s rise possible; about what made Trump attractive to conservative elites and why they are sticking with him. It’s a piece about the relationship between opportunism and ideology; about the logic of escalation that is fueled by a sense of having burned all bridges; and, ultimately, about the permission structure that has governed rightwing politics for decades. Unless we understand this permission structure, we understand nothing. Not how the GOP got to this point - nor where it is likely going next and why, as a default, we must assume Republican elites will continue to find ways to allow themselves to fuel and enable extremism.</p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><strong>What impact could my work possibly have?</strong></p><p>Does any of this really matter? I have to believe it does. Why anyone would go through the trouble of <em>writing</em> - a process I find endlessly demanding, challenging, often draining – is utterly beyond me. If none of this matters, why bother?</p><p>I’m under no illusions about the limits of what I can possibly achieve. I think it is rather rare – and in many cases downright impossible – to “persuade” people who have already settled on a political position and identity. The very idea that the political conflict is ultimately about better arguments is misleading. It’s one of the fallacies of which many educated liberals and lefties – like me! – apparently can’t fully let go. But a fallacy it remains: People like me would love it to be a contest of ideas, a competition of who has the better arguments. Because that’s the kind of struggle with which we feel comfortable, that we – naively, arrogantly – believe we would definitely win. But it’s not the kind of conflict we find ourselves in. Better to accept and grapple with that.</p><p>But that doesn’t mean it’s all pointless. There is value in providing perspective, in carefully crafting arguments that actually hold up empirically, in evaluating and critiquing the narratives that are shaping our world. A question I ask myself with every piece I write is: Does a person not fully aligned with my opinion and sensibilities still get something worthwhile out of this? Am I providing valuable information and context, am I offering an explanation that is worth grappling with? I believe Democracy Americana meets that challenge.</p><p>I also believe that making sense of the world is an interactive process, something that happens when we grapple with the thoughts and arguments we encounter. What I am hoping to do with my work is provide a vocabulary people can use to develop their own interpretations, express their own opinions. </p><p>And finally, I am convinced there is long-term value in injecting my arguments into the discussion. As a writer, you can’t possibly hope to revolutionize “the discourse” overnight. But perhaps I can contribute to shifting it over time, essay by essay, by offering my perspective as something people can draw on and work with whenever and wherever they encounter it.</p><p><strong>What’s next?</strong></p><p>When I look back at the past twelve months, I do have regrets and I certainly see lots of room for improvement. For starters, I wish I had been able to write more often, increase the frequency. I sit on a graveyard of essay drafts that never turned into published posts – because by the time I had something close to ready, the discourse had moved on, the next big thing happened… To some extent, that just comes with the territory when you’re setting out to write deep dives like the ones I produce here. That takes time and care. But I do think I should diversify my portfolio a little bit and find room for a slightly different genre of writing. You still won’t get any hot takes from me, no worries; but I do want to complement the deep dives with the occasional shorter form, a true “essay” in the sense of an attempt, an observation more than a comprehensive exploration. </p><p>I also regret that I have not been able to make Democracy Americana more interactive, be more responsive to your comments and questions. That is something I definitely want to work on, find formats that will allow me to interact with you more.</p><p>Finally, I miss having – and sharing – conversations with people whose work inspires me. Some of you will remember that I used to co-host a podcast called “Is This Democracy” where we regularly recorded and published such conversations. I am hoping I can add such a format to Democracy Americana soon: A chance to talk and think through the issues of the day with the help of people I admire.</p><p>Don’t get me wrong: I do not plan on making any drastic changes. The long-form essay remains the core of what I do here, and I am devoted to that central mission. But Democracy Americana is very much not a finished product. It is ever a work in progress.</p><p><strong>Onward. Forward.</strong></p><p>These are nervous times. As I write this, we are just six weeks away from the midterm elections. A far-right international is rising. The darkest forces of modern history are stirring. We are facing major disruptions – politically, socially, technologically, economically, environmentally. Tackling even just one of these challenges would be hard: The destructions wrought by the escalating rightwing “counterrevolution”; the profound disillusionment with the system brought about by decades of elite impunity and neoliberal “reform”; the technological revolution spear-headed by people who, in a fundamental sense, seem to be convinced that humanity itself is the problem; and the climate crisis rapidly accelerating to the point where the structures we built for a world that is quickly vanishing are starting to fail.</p><p>This is a scary moment. Status quo politics won’t cut it. What we need is transformational aspiration that meets the moment. I am convinced of two things: The only way is through. And the only way through is together. For me, that means together with you, my readers.</p><p>With your help and your trust: Onward. Forward.</p><p>With my sincerest thanks and deep gratitude,</p><p>Thomas</p><p><em>Democracy Americana is my main source of income as an independent writer. Want to support my work? Consider becoming a paid member:</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/b3f0dfac-3f40-40a2-be05-d9510c10c451/uploads/images/th3l3azezk/SocMediaBanner.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/b3f0dfac-3f40-40a2-be05-d9510c10c451</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">b3f0dfac-3f40-40a2-be05-d9510c10c451</guid>
      <pubDate>Thu, 24 Sep 2026 10:04:45 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[A Far-Right International Is Assaulting Democracy]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[MAGA and the AfD are united in a struggle against democratic pluralism that transcends national borders. It is an alliance of extremists defined by aggrieved revanchism]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>MAGA and the AfD are united in a struggle against democratic pluralism that transcends national borders. It is an alliance of extremists defined by aggrieved revanchism</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, September 13, 2026</em></p><figure><a href="https://www.loc.gov/pictures/item/96520973/"><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/3a16237c-484a-4d5e-8f15-2ea94fd8f4d2/uploads/images/7xazfkcw3r/service-pnp-ds-15200-15209v.jpg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/></a><figcaption>German American Bund parade in New York City on East 86th St. Oct. 30, 1937 – credit: Library of Congress</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></strong></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is a publication </em><strong><em>solely funded by readers</em></strong><em>. If you are reading the free version of this newsletter, I sincerely appreciate your time and effort engaging with my work. Please share it widely to help me reach new readers.</em></p><p><em>Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. </em><strong><em>If you can become a paid member, please do.</em></strong><em> As a member, you receive many additional essays, and you </em><strong><em>gain access to the audio versions</em></strong><em> of everything I publish (members can find the audio at the end of the piece or available for download in the podcast player of your choice).</em></p><p><em>Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work.</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can </em><strong><em>unlock this article for free</em></strong><em> by subscribing to the free version of this newsletter (via the registration wall below).</em></p><p></p><p>The party of Neo-Nazis and ethnonationalist extremists is on the rise in Germany - and the President of the United States is delighted. “Wow! The Populist Party in Germany just had a really big night,” Trump <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3mv273a7vxs2f">posted on social media</a> after the AfD got almost 44 percent of the vote in a state election in Saxony-Anhalt last week. “THEY ARE ON THE RISE, and not going to take it anymore!”</p><p>For once, these were not merely the delusional ramblings of the man in the White House. Trump’s post was entirely in line with the U.S. government’s official position and the core principle that guides American foreign policy. I know this doesn’t come as a surprise to anyone at this point, but it remains remarkable and shocking nonetheless: The government of the United States is in the hands of people who openly align with rightwing extremists in Germany. I hope we have not become too cynical or numb to acknowledge how outrageous this is. In fact, U.S. foreign and security policy is now officially built around the idea that America must lead the global struggle against the forces of “globalism,” pluralism, and egalitarianism by intervening on behalf of anti-democratic movements everywhere. All in the name of defending “Western civilization,” of course.</p><p>To oppose this emerging white nationalist international, we need to restore an anti-fascist consensus, as clumsy as that may sound, and we need to recommit to a vision of democratic pluralism. The darkest forces of modern history are stirring, and we all know where this ends if we allow them to succeed.</p><p><strong>MAGA is all in on the AfD</strong></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/3a16237c-484a-4d5e-8f15-2ea94fd8f4d2">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/3a16237c-484a-4d5e-8f15-2ea94fd8f4d2/uploads/images/7xazfkcw3r/service-pnp-ds-15200-15209v.jpg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/3a16237c-484a-4d5e-8f15-2ea94fd8f4d2</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">3a16237c-484a-4d5e-8f15-2ea94fd8f4d2</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 13 Sep 2026 07:52:15 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Warnings and Lessons from the Struggle Against Trumpism]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Germany is facing the prospect of rightwing extremism in power. Time to push back hard against the narratives that have undermined the democratic response in the U.S.]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Germany is facing the prospect of rightwing extremism in power. Time to push back hard against the narratives that have undermined the democratic response in the U.S.</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, September 5, 2026</em></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/01654b70-1319-4395-8191-0c6da2ae195b/uploads/images/qid4dexwjd/iStock-2198417559.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>A brick wall with the words “Nie wieder” – meaning: Never again – painted on it. Credit: iStock / mekke</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></strong></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is a publication </em><strong><em>solely funded by readers</em></strong><em>. </em></p><p><em>Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. </em><strong><em>If you can become a paid member, please do.</em></strong><em> As a member, you receive many additional essays, and you </em><strong><em>gain access to the audio versions</em></strong><em> of everything I publish (members can find the audio at the end of the piece or available for download in the podcast player of your choice).</em></p><p><em>Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work. Please know that I am immensely grateful for your generosity!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? </em></p><p><em>You can </em><strong><em>unlock this article for free</em></strong><em> by subscribing to the free version of this newsletter (via the registration wall below).</em></p><p> </p><p>Germany is staring into the abyss. In Sunday’s election in Saxony-Anhalt, one of the country’s 16 states, the far-right AfD, the parliamentary arm of German rightwing extremism, is polling at over 40 percent. For the first time since the Nazi dictatorship was defeated in 1945, a rightwing extremist party might control a state government. This is a real caesura in German post-war history.  </p><p>Founded in 2013, the AfD quickly evolved from what was initially mainstream-rightwing-to-reactionary territory into a far-right party that fully rejects liberal democracy and is undoubtedly the political home of Germany’s rightwing extremists. In the American public discourse, the AfD is often referred to as Germany’s Neo-Nazi party. The best “defense” one could plausibly come up with on behalf of the AfD is that, technically, many of the AfD politicians aren’t Neo-Nazis themselves, although some leading party figures certainly have strong ties into the Neo-Nazi scene and the AfD is all too happy to tolerate those connections as well as the fact that the country’s Neo-Nazis certainly see the AfD as their party. So, technically, the AfD is best described as a coalition between national-conservative reactionaries and seething extremists (very much including Neo-Nazis) that is defined by anti-Muslim sentiment, an escalating anti-immigration stance, and an aggressive ethno-nationalism; it is also increasingly focused on raging against any social and cultural progress of recent decades. The feminists, the environmentalists, the lefty students, queer people – they are all on the AfD’s enemy list.</p><p>(With those “qualifications” in mind, go ahead and call it Germany’s Neo-Nazi party.)</p><p>What is about to happen in Saxony-Anhalt – and to a slightly lesser degree in another election in the state of Mecklenburg-Vorpommern two weeks later – does not come as a surprise to anybody. Across east Germany, the AfD has long had the support of one third or more of the voting public. Exactly two years ago, it emerged as the strongest party in a state election for the first time when it received almost 33 percent of the vote in Thuringia. While the party is still significantly stronger in the east, the problem is not at all confined to the territory of the former GDR. In the general election in late February 2025, it received 20.8 percent of the vote, coming in second behind the conservatives. In state elections in two states in the southwest of the country earlier this year, the AfD got close to 20 percent in both Baden-Wuerttemberg as well as Rhineland-Palatinate. It is currently polling at around 27 to 30 percent nationwide – as clearly the strongest party, trailed by the conservative CDU/CSU at around 20 percent and everyone else at or below 15 percent.</p><p>And yet, the situation in Saxony-Anhalt is still qualitatively different. If the polls are to be believed, the AfD has about twice the support of the next strongest party, the conservative CDU – there are about 20 percentage points between them. Most importantly, there is even a chance the AfD might win an outright majority of seats in the state parliament, which would allow it to run the state alone, without a coalition partner. Germany is facing the prospect of rightwing extremism in power. It is watershed moment in the country’s postwar history.</p><p>For the past decade, I have observed, studied, and commented on rightwing extremism in the United States. Everything I do professionally revolves around the question of how to situate Trumpism in the broader context of U.S. history and how to explain its rise within the Republican Party; since January 2025, I have focused on covering the Trumpist assault on the political system, the civil rights order, and the very idea of democratic self-government – on what happens when rightwing extremists get to wield power.</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/01654b70-1319-4395-8191-0c6da2ae195b">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/01654b70-1319-4395-8191-0c6da2ae195b/uploads/images/qid4dexwjd/iStock-2198417559.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/01654b70-1319-4395-8191-0c6da2ae195b</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">01654b70-1319-4395-8191-0c6da2ae195b</guid>
      <pubDate>Sat, 05 Sep 2026 11:52:18 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Does Donald Trump Have an Ideology?]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[No, not exactly. But he has a consistent, grievance-fueled idea of how power and status should be distributed, and that aligns him with the Right’s ideologues just fine]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>No, not exactly. But he has a consistent, grievance-fueled idea of how power and status should be distributed, and that aligns him with the Right’s ideologues just fine</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, August 26, 2026</em></p><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/955a3f59-06c5-4dfe-a0e4-c66405bc56e3/uploads/images/prfyxqzhbv/Official_Presidential_Portrait_of_President_Donald_J._Trump_%282025%29_%283x4_close_cropped%29.png?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><p><strong><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></strong></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is a publication </em><strong><em>solely funded by readers</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p><em>Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. </em><strong><em>If you can become a paid member, please do.</em></strong><em> As a member, you receive many additional essays, and you </em><strong><em>gain access to the audio versions</em></strong><em> of everything I publish (members can find the audio at the end of the piece or available for download in the podcast player of your choice).</em></p><p><em>Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work. Please know that I am immensely grateful for your generosity!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? </em></p><p><em>You can </em><strong><em>unlock this article for free</em></strong><em> by subscribing to the free version of this newsletter (via the registration wall below).</em></p><p> </p><p>What’s up with Donald Trump?</p><p>No, seriously: What the hell is going on with the man who is President of the United States?</p><p>Considering that Trump has dominated U.S. politics for over a decade, I don’t talk or write about him all that much. As my work often focuses on the American Right, he is always there, of course. But I tend to emphasize how he is himself the manifestation rather than the cause of long-standing anti-democratic tendencies and pathologies of the political culture; and I generally focus on the different factions on the Right, on Trump’s role in mobilizing and integrating them as opposed to the Donald himself.</p><p>That’s partially because writing about Trump seems to be such an over-saturated market. I have certainly encountered a general exasperation with all things Trump even among my own readers (more than once, people have informed me that they have canceled their subscription because I kept using photos of Trump as illustrations for my essays and they simply didn’t want to see his face anymore…).</p><p>I do find myself wondering: Do we need more analysis of Trump? What else is there to say?</p><p>Then again, I do think it might be a misperception that we all understand what’s up with Trump, that there is a consensus about what animates him. In conversations with both audiences and readers as well as with journalists and politicians, I still encounter a wide range of assumptions and interpretations – many of which I find rather misleading or even dangerously off the mark. Even among those on the (small-d) democratic political spectrum – meaning: excluding everyone who supports Trump or has devoted themselves to anti-anti-Trump obstructionism – you still get a wide range of opinions: Is Trump a bumbling fool or a master manipulator? Is he a puppet controlled by sinister interests in the background or a quasi-totalitarian leader of a devoted cult? Is he a fully committed ideologue or purely animated by greed – a dealmaker, perhaps, with no convictions or sincere commitments, really no discernable politics whatsoever?</p><p>I am not interested in writing a biography of Trump nor am I qualified to provide a comprehensive psychological profile. But the man is President and has shaped the Republican Party in his image. We need a plausible operating theory of what drives him, what motivates his actions, if we want to predict where things are going and where the greatest danger lies. That remains true even if we acknowledge – as we must! – that Trump has retreated deep into his own unreality. It is entirely unclear what information about the world Trump still receives; much of it seems to be channeled through a very narrow system of loyalists (or perhaps <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/08/18/us/politics/natalie-harp-trump-devotion-white-house.html">just one loyalist</a> in particular). He is a disturbed authoritarian who is surrounded by people who either share his delusions, are too sycophantic to confront him, or believe the president’s warped perception of the world serves just fine as a vehicle for their own zealotry and ideological extremism. </p><p>Trump’s behavior is, euphemistically put, erratic. But I contend it is not random – in the sense that his actions, his raging, his unhinged ranting… all of it has a consistent direction, targeting his personal enemies and the many enemies of the Right.</p><p>Trump is not an ideologue in a strict sense. But he has a very clear view of how society should be ordered, how power and status should be distributed, and who should be at the top. He has, we might say, a consistent worldview that aligns him quite well with the extreme ideologues on the Right and helps explain why they have united behind him in the first place. It defines his perspective, structures how he perceives the world around him, shapes his relationships to other people and what actions he gravitates towards. We better take it seriously, because it animates the man who, even in his feeble state of mind, holds the most powerful political office in the world. Grappling in earnest with Trump’s worldview can also, at the very least, inoculate us against the many misleading, disingenuous, and frankly irresponsibly ignorant notions about him that have been floating around since the moment he entered politics, pushed by people who don’t know better themselves or hope we don’t. “Trump the dove”; Trump is secretly a “moderate”; Trump the businessman who only wants a good deal; Trump the inscrutable leader… Forget all this bollocks.</p><p>What follows may not explain every single thing about Trump or predict his every future action. But let us at least make sure we don’t get him catastrophically wrong.</p><p><strong>The pitfalls of studying “Trumpism”</strong></p><p>Let me try to make sure we are all on the same page here: When I say underneath the madness lies a fairly consistent worldview, I am not suggesting we should contribute to the rather bizarre attempts to intellectualize Trump and whatever comes out of his mouth.</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/955a3f59-06c5-4dfe-a0e4-c66405bc56e3">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/955a3f59-06c5-4dfe-a0e4-c66405bc56e3/uploads/images/prfyxqzhbv/Official_Presidential_Portrait_of_President_Donald_J._Trump_%282025%29_%283x4_close_cropped%29.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/955a3f59-06c5-4dfe-a0e4-c66405bc56e3</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">955a3f59-06c5-4dfe-a0e4-c66405bc56e3</guid>
      <pubDate>Wed, 26 Aug 2026 09:13:52 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Assault on Public Health and the Self-Sabotage of a Nation]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[MAHA channels vague grievances into a radical project. It’s a form of extremism that stands in a long tradition of paranoid conspiracism on the Far Right. We must stop it]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>MAHA channels vague grievances into a radical project. It’s a form of extremism that stands in a long tradition of paranoid conspiracism on the Far Right. We must stop it</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, August 16, 2026</em></p><figure><a href="https://edition.cnn.com/2026/08/02/us/video/22859716-sotu-rfk-measles-digvid"><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/06961553-0881-46b0-b0fa-5672ca718eae/uploads/images/h4fjj43ree/4D51FD02-34DC-4BD5-9FD3-B79724888CCC_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/></a><figcaption>RFK lying his way through an interview on CNN’s State of the Union, August 2, 2026</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></strong></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is a publication </em><strong><em>solely funded by readers</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p><em>Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. </em><strong><em>If you can become a paid member, please do.</em></strong><em> As a member, you receive many additional essays, and you </em><strong><em>gain access to the audio versions</em></strong><em> of everything I publish (members can find the audio at the end of the piece or available for download in the podcast player of your choice).</em></p><p><em>Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work. Please know that I am immensely grateful for your generosity!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership?</em></p><p><em>You can </em><strong><em>unlock this article for free</em></strong><em> by subscribing to the free version of this newsletter (via the registration wall below).</em></p><p> </p><p>The global superpower is in the midst of an unparalleled campaign of self-sabotage, utterly without precedent historically, via the deliberate destruction of state capacity and the elimination of professional expertise. The reckless assault on the nation’s public health infrastructure is only one example – but a particularly egregious one. It will potentially harm the lives of millions. All because the government of the United States is in the hands of shameless grifters, paranoid conspiracists, and ideological extremists.</p><p>On Monday, August 10, Donald Trump issued <a href="https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2026/08/delivering-gold-standard-childhood-vaccine-recommendations-for-americans/">an executive order</a> calling for significant changes to childhood vaccine recommendations. It aims to reduce the number of vaccines children receive – down to vaccinations against 11 diseases (compared to 18 at the end of 2024). It also recommends the MMR vaccine (a combo vaccine against measles, mumps, and rubella) be split up into three different jabs, spread out over separate doctor’s visits. And it instructs the states to revise their immunization laws and schedules accordingly. </p><p>Trump and his secretary of health and human services Robert F. Kennedy Jr. have been pushing in this direction for a while. <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/01/05/health/children-vaccines-cdc-kennedy.html?campaign_id=60&amp;emc=edit_na_20260105&amp;instance_id=168830&amp;nl=breaking-news&amp;regi_id=144191142&amp;segment_id=213153&amp;user_id=cd5549365965f167137df766d42c372b">HHS released similar recommendations in January</a>, but those were quickly <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/mar/16/judge-blocks-rfk-jr-vaccine-policy-changes">blocked by a federal court</a>. Now they are trying again – with an executive order that is likely illegal. Yet even if it is never implemented as written, only bad things can come from this: It will further fuel vaccine skepticism, animate Republican-led states to loosen or abolish vaccine mandates for schoolchildren, and make it more complicated for everyone to receive necessary protections. As a result, fewer children will get vaccinated.</p><p>In a saner, less stupid parallel universe, there could be good reason for a thorough revision of the vaccine recommendations. The scientific consensus on some of the vaccines might have changed – or the public health situation itself might have improved to the point where certain vaccinations are no longer necessary? And could it not make sense to bring the recommendations in line with what comparable countries are doing? That is, after all, what the Trumpists have been claiming: That Denmark, which indeed recommends fewer childhood vaccinations, is their role model.</p><p>In our universe, however, none of this applies. Which is why the serious part of the scientific community strongly opposes the MAGA/MAHA assault. And while it is funny for the Trumpists to claim they want to make America a little more like Denmark, a country they usually deride as a socialist hellhole, this makes zero sense either. Denmark is more of an outlier among comparable nations with a very low number of recommended vaccinations; <a href="https://www.dw.com/en/making-sense-of-trumps-executive-order-on-us-vaccinations/a-78321723">Germany, for instance,</a> currently recommends immunization against 14 diseases (including hepatitis B, rotavirus, and RSV that Trump’s EO cuts from the baseline recommendations). Most importantly, America is not Denmark, a country with universal healthcare that achieves extremely high vaccination rates anyway and also allows anyone who is sick to seek out medical care whenever needed.</p><p>In America, on the other hand, infectious diseases are soaring. The country is currently in the midst of <a href="https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/number-of-measles-cases">the worst measles outbreak in decades</a>. Even though the disease was officially eradicated in the United States in the year 2000, there were almost 2,300 cases last year, and America has already shot past that number in 2026. There are no mysteries as to why this is happening, and why now: Almost all of the people who contract measles <a href="https://www.cdc.gov/measles/data-research/index.html">are unvaccinated</a>. Because the disease is so highly contagious, stopping the transmission requires an extremely high vaccination rate north of 95 percent. America has now fallen significantly below that threshold, as more and more people are refusing to let their kids be immunized with the MMR vaccine.</p><p>Vaccine skepticism – a euphemism for a pervasive tendency on the Right to choose conspiracy theories over science – has been on the rise. <a href="https://news.gallup.com/poll/648308/far-fewer-regard-childhood-vaccinations-important.aspx">According to Gallup</a>, fewer than 70 percent of Americans now believe it is “extremely or very important that parents get their children vaccinated,” down from 94 percent in 2001. The decline is concentrated almost entirely among Republicans: In 2001, a little over 60 percent of them declared it was “extremely important” for kids to be vaccinated – by 2024, that number was down to 26 percent. Meanwhile, over the same time period, the percentage of Republicans who believe vaccines are more dangerous than the diseases they are supposed to prevent has gone up dramatically: From only 6 percent (and very much in line with the rest of the population) to almost one third.</p><p>This is a public health disaster. And in any remotely functioning political system, it would be treated as a national emergency. For the people who are in charge of public health in the United States and the leaders of the Republican Party, however, this is not an emergency. It is the result of what they have been preaching. </p><p>Let us refuse to play dumb. Trump’s executive order has nothing to do with a sincere effort to improve public health, it is not the result of a serious process of evaluation. The people behind this push are not good-faith actors, but extremists driven by paranoid conspiracies.</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/06961553-0881-46b0-b0fa-5672ca718eae">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/06961553-0881-46b0-b0fa-5672ca718eae/uploads/images/h4fjj43ree/4D51FD02-34DC-4BD5-9FD3-B79724888CCC_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/06961553-0881-46b0-b0fa-5672ca718eae</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">06961553-0881-46b0-b0fa-5672ca718eae</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 16 Aug 2026 07:11:22 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Power, Opportunism, and Ideology in Republican Politics]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[About cowardice and conviction, the complicity of conservative elites, and the permission structure that governs the Right]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>About cowardice and conviction, the complicity of conservative elites, and the permission structure that governs the Right</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, July 26, 2026</em></p><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/da2ea08b-e35c-427b-b190-66a2fc097abb/uploads/images/2aaajbk7dm/A329E50B-E73D-41EB-AF1A-88E48575E2E8_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><p><strong><em>A note before we get started:</em></strong><em> My apologies for the lighter publication schedule in July as I am (supposed to be) on vacation with my family. I promise I will be back to a more regular and more frequent schedule soon.</em></p><p><strong><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></strong></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is a publication </em><strong><em>solely funded by readers</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p><em>Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. </em><strong><em>If you can become a paid member, please do.</em></strong><em> As a member, you receive many additional essays, and you </em><strong><em>gain access to the audio versions</em></strong><em> of everything I publish (members can find the audio at the end of the piece or available for download in the podcast player of your choice).</em></p><p><em>Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work. Please know that I am immensely grateful for your generosity!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership?</em></p><p><em>You can </em><strong><em>unlock this article for free</em></strong><em> by subscribing to the free version of this newsletter (via the registration wall below).</em></p><p></p><p>Donald Trump is outlasting the Republican establishment: The people who thought they could control him, harness the “populist” energies he was mobilizing for their own purposes; those who initially vowed to resist his temptation, but then quickly acquiesced; the people who constantly debased himself in his service and their quest for domination.</p><p>It has occurred to me that my life choices may not have been ideal if I am thinking about Lindsay Graham and Mitch McConnell while sitting on a beach during a family vacation at the Atlantic Ocean. Alas, here we are, and I will admit that Graham’s story, in particular, continues to have an effect on me. Not that I am mourning the man who should be remembered as one of Trump’s most willing enablers. Not that his case was so exceptional, in the grand scheme of things - even though few people disgraced and humiliated themselves quite as much as quite as often as Graham did in his struggle to be Donald Trump’s friend. The reason why it is worth dwelling on the last decade of Graham’s life is that it captured the core dynamics that have defined the behavior of the Republican establishment more broadly. His trajectory was precisely that of conservative elites in general: Faced with an insurgency from far-right extremists, they may have initially signaled distance and skepticism. But once it became clear that the base was enthralled with Trump, they quickly fell in line – and in the process made a mockery of every stated principle they ever claimed to follow. </p><p>Senator Lindsay Graham from South Carolina passed away on July 11, aged 71. In December 2015, when Donald Trump first rose within the GOP, Graham vowed to stand against the man he called “a race-baiting, xenophobic, religious bigot” in a <a href="https://edition.cnn.com/videos/politics/2015/12/08/lindsey-graham-donald-trump-xenophobic-bigot-interview-newday.cnn">CNN interview</a>. In May 2016, when Trump was already certain to emerge from the GOP primaries as the Republican presidential nominee, he infamously <a href="https://x.com/LindseyGrahamSC/status/727604522156228608">posted on Ex-Twitter</a>: “If we nominate Trump, we will get destroyed … and we will deserve it.” That tweet, remarkably, is still up. But even though his public comments suggested Graham understood who Trump was and what he represented, he quickly became a staunch defender of the MAGA president during his first term – constantly praising him and fighting for his agenda. Then January 6 happened and Graham once again seemed to change course. The night of the Insurrection, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GfQfcURNM0E">he declared on the Senate floor</a>: “Trump and I, we had a hell of a journey. I hate it being this way. Oh my God I hate it … All I can say is count me out. Enough is enough.”</p><p>Alas, it wasn’t enough for Lindsay Graham. Just as the rest of his party quickly closed ranks behind Trump once the initial shock of the assault on the Capitol faded, Graham returned to doing whatever he could to be in Trump’s good graces.</p><p>What is there left to say about the rather pathetic case of Lindsay Graham? About his trajectory and that of his fellow Republican elites?</p><p>It has been a little over two weeks since he passed away, and I know a lot of people have weighed in. You know how we roll here at Democracy Americana (especially while I am nominally on vacation…): This is not the place for immediate commentary. It is unlikely I will ever be among the quickest to offer my take. But I believe there is value in letting the dust settle a little bit and then go deeper.</p><p>This piece is about Lindsay Graham and, more importantly, about the broader questions his case rases: About the trajectory of the Republican Party and the conditions that made Trump’s rise possible; about what made Trump attractive to conservative elites and why they are sticking with him; about the relationship between opportunism and ideology, cowardice and reactionary conviction; about the logic of escalation that is fueled by a sense of having burned all bridges; and, ultimately, about the permission structure that has governed rightwing politics for decades.</p><p>Unless we understand that, we understand nothing. Not how the Republican Party got to this point. And not where it is most likely going next.</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/da2ea08b-e35c-427b-b190-66a2fc097abb">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/da2ea08b-e35c-427b-b190-66a2fc097abb/uploads/images/2aaajbk7dm/A329E50B-E73D-41EB-AF1A-88E48575E2E8_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/da2ea08b-e35c-427b-b190-66a2fc097abb</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">da2ea08b-e35c-427b-b190-66a2fc097abb</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 26 Jul 2026 09:50:10 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[A World-Historic Chance]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The Right is freaking out because we could be on the brink of proving that egalitarian, pluralistic democracy is possible. A glass-half-full interpretation of our moment.]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The Right is freaking out because we could be on the brink of proving that egalitarian, pluralistic democracy is possible. A glass-half-full interpretation of our moment.</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, July 13, 2026</em></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/812a42b1-dc13-4e26-b659-736ce7c146b9/uploads/images/tgl57lwpmz/iStock-627319786.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>credit: evenfh / iStock</figcaption></figure><p><em>Let me remind you that I have launched a version of this newsletter </em><strong><em>in German</em></strong><em>. Same content, same analysis – </em><strong><em>only in German</em></strong><em>. If that is of interest to you, head over to </em><a href="https://steady.page/de/demokratie-americana/posts"><strong><em>Demokratie Americana</em></strong></a><em> (where all pieces should be available within a few hours of publication on here). Please help me spread the word!</em></p><p><strong><em>Also: Please support Democracy Americana!</em></strong></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is a publication </em><strong><em>solely funded by readers</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p><em>Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. </em><strong><em>If you can become a paid member, please do.</em></strong><em> As a member, you receive many additional essays, and you </em><strong><em>gain access to the audio versions</em></strong><em> of everything I publish (members can find the audio at the end of the piece or available for download in the podcast player of your choice).</em></p><p><em>I need your support to continue this work. Thank you!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership?</em></p><p><em>You can </em><strong><em>unlock this article for free</em></strong><em> by subscribing to the free version of this newsletter (via the registration wall below).</em></p><p></p><p>This moment will stick with me for a while. Last week, I was invited to give a talk at the “Academy by the Sea” on Sylt, the largest of Germany’s islands in the North Sea. The Academy is part of a network of adult education centers across the country, offering people the chance to enroll in a large variety of courses or engage with any topic imaginable via public lectures and events. My talk was scheduled as an evening lecture as part of the Academy’s summer program. Enrollees spend several days, perhaps even weeks at the Academy, which is located in the island’s northwest, far away from Sylt’s busy, overly crowded tourist hotspots; it is nestled in the dunes, feels beautifully secluded from the rest of civilization, with direct access to miles and miles of some of the most gorgeous beaches you’ll ever see.</p><p>To be honest, I almost felt bad about giving my talk – to force people who come to the island to combine vacation and education to think about Donald Trump. Or rather: Where Trump’s rise sits in the larger context of U.S. history. For 45 minutes I talked about the struggle over national identity and who gets to define “America,” who gets to belong, and who gets to be included in “We the People.” And as you might imagine, it wasn’t exactly an uplifting conversation. The discussion went long; we were about two hours in when the Academy’s director wanted to call it a night. But that’s when a woman sitting in the first row, right in front of me, spoke up. I had noticed several times throughout my talk that she was visibly wrestling with the story I was presenting, clearly affected by what I was describing. And now she insisted that we couldn’t possibly end like this – after several questions dealing with the Supreme Court, and tech elites, the extremists who will come after Trump, and the so-called liberal international order that all prompted me to emphasize that there was not going to be a return to “normalcy” anytime soon, that America was going to face the challenge to rebuild and reconstruct (rather than merely restore) if and when Trump was finally removed from power. No, I couldn’t possibly release everyone into the night like this. She demanded I give the audience something else: There had to be something people could do, something to carry us all forward?</p><p>I admit my instinct normally is to reject these kinds of questions. I try hard not to overstep and stick to my actual expertise. I am not a politician; I don’t have any experience in organizing or political activism. I offer my analysis and hope to contribute to getting the diagnosis right, for whatever that’s worth. But in this moment, perhaps because the setting was so distinct from the kinds of environments where these talks usually take place, I did feel an obligation to offer something more. Not some clearcut answers I don’t possess, or simplistic recipes dressed up as “lessons from history,” and certainly not some willfully naïve progress gospel. But a reminder that the situation is not hopeless – that there is, in fact, a glass-half-full interpretation of our moment in world history. That we could be, as dangerous as this situation is, on the brink of proving, perhaps for the first time ever, that a truly democratic society under conditions of multiracial, multi-religious, gender-egalitarian pluralism is indeed possible. </p><p>And so, I made my case: The anti-democratic radicalization of the Right has not been fueled by a sense of strength, but by a pervasive sense of weakness. They are feeling their backs against the wall. And they are reacting to something real: Our “Western” societies have indeed become more pluralistic, less white, less overwhelmingly Christian. In that sense, it was not the perfectly stable liberal democracy that suddenly fell into crisis (because such an order had never existed), but white Christian patriarchal dominance – what the Right likes to call the “natural order” – that has been coming under pressure.</p><p>The fact is that reality has been moving away from those who refuse to imagine “America” as anything other than a land defined by white Christian patriarchal domination. And no matter how loudly they insist to be representing the “will of the people” in pushing back against these developments, their reactionary ideas are opposed by a stable majority. According to the latest survey conducted by the Public Religion Research Institute (PRRI) and published under the title <a href="https://prri.org/research/competing-visions-of-america-politics-religion-and-american-identity/">“Competing visions of America at 250,”</a> almost two thirds of Americans prefer religious pluralism over the idea of a Christian nation; almost eight in ten Americans want the country to be a racially diverse nation with people from all over the world as opposed to a nation of and for white people “with Western European heritage.”</p><p>These are impressive numbers, from a high-quality study and confirmed over and over again in other survey data. The clear majority don’t want to live in MAGA land. </p><p>Such data needs to be contextualized, certainly. We must wrestle with what it can and cannot tell us about the political and societal conflict, with how to relate it to the MAGA regime’s brutal rollback of racial and social progress and to broader tendencies of a reactionary sentiment in matters of race and gender beyond just the MAGA Right that have shaped American society recently.</p><p>But we must not dismiss these clear indications that a strong majority of Americans is opposed to MAGA’s war on pluralism. If we do, we not only fail to understand that the key threat emanates from a radicalizing minority. We also fail to counter the ubiquitous sense of decline and the temptations of despair and cynicism by reminding ourselves that we are confronted with a world-historic chance. In a way, we have never been closer to finally realizing the promise of egalitarian democracy that is entailed in the idea that “all men are created equal.”</p><p>So, let us grapple properly with the survey data that seeks to capture the majority’s affirmation of pluralism, with the countervailing forces of reaction and resentment that are tearing America apart – and let me try to make the best possible case that the glass is actually half-full. </p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/812a42b1-dc13-4e26-b659-736ce7c146b9">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/812a42b1-dc13-4e26-b659-736ce7c146b9/uploads/images/tgl57lwpmz/iStock-627319786.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/812a42b1-dc13-4e26-b659-736ce7c146b9</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">812a42b1-dc13-4e26-b659-736ce7c146b9</guid>
      <pubDate>Mon, 13 Jul 2026 21:53:23 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[From the Declaration to Donald Trump]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Wrestling with a history that is complicated, inspiring, frustrating, uplifting, and horrifying. A continuity of conflict, 1776-2026]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Wrestling with a history that is complicated, inspiring, frustrating, uplifting, and horrifying. A continuity of conflict, 1776-2026</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, July 5, 2026</em></p><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/3ed79187-f4a3-4d02-98ed-cd49f1762756/uploads/images/lu7t3x6tno/Declaration_Final.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><p><em>Before we start, let me remind you that I have launched a version of this newsletter </em><strong><em>in German</em></strong><em>. Same content, same analysis – </em><strong><em>only in German</em></strong><em>. If that is of interest to you, head over to </em><a href="https://steady.page/de/demokratie-americana/posts"><strong><em>Demokratie Americana</em></strong></a><em> (where all pieces should be available within a few hours of publication on here). Please help me spread the word!</em></p><p><strong><em>Also: Please support Democracy Americana!</em></strong></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is a publication </em><strong><em>solely funded by readers</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p><em>Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. </em><strong><em>If you can become a paid member, please do.</em></strong><em> As a member, you receive many additional essays, and you </em><strong><em>gain access to the audio versions</em></strong><em> of everything I publish (members can find the audio at the end of the piece or available for download in the podcast player of your choice).</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership?</em></p><p><em>You can </em><strong><em>unlock this article for free</em></strong><em> by subscribing to the free version of this newsletter (via the registration wall below).</em></p><p></p><p>“American history is longer, larger, more various, more beautiful, and more terrible than anything anyone has ever said about it.”</p><p>I have used this quote several times before in my writing. I think about it a lot. It is from a speech James Baldwin delivered in October 1963, titled <a href="https://www.zinnedproject.org/materials/baldwin-talk-to-teachers">“A Talk to Teachers”</a>. Baldwin was born in Harlem in 1924. His mother had fled the Jim Crow South. Baldwin himself left America as a young man in the late 1940s to flee the racist discrimination he experienced. For most of his adult life, France would remain his base; but often he returned to the United States to take part in the Black freedom struggle. Baldwin was a novelist and a poet, but also a political intellectual and civil rights activist. And he was a forceful, magnetic speaker. His perspective on U.S. history is among the most profoundly true and insightful things anyone has ever said about the United States. Anyone who works and thinks about America’s past, present, and future should adopt it as a guiding paradigm. And I believe it can also help us navigate this acutely perilous political moment in which we find ourselves right now. More various, more beautiful, more terrible. We need to grapple with all of these conflicting dimensions.</p><p>When big anniversaries came around, Americans at various points in the country’s history were asked to do a little bit of that grappling, perhaps; but mostly, they were invited to come together and celebrate the nation and its origins. In the past, such anniversaries tended to produce an outpouring of patriotic sentiment even after moments of immense strive – or perhaps precisely because these occasions seemed to justify papering over the cracks and the crises. That was an attractive proposition at least to those who were fortunate enough not to have their lives and livelihoods acutely threatened by the conflicts that continued to shape life in America.</p><p>In 1876, for instance, the United States celebrated its centennial a little over a decade after the most devastating war in the country’s history – a war fought within, against those who had betrayed the Union in service of what they believed was their right to enslave fellow human beings. As the celebrations took off, the South was officially still under military occupation. The attempt to impose biracial democracy in the former Confederacy was met with unspeakable levels of white supremacist violence. Out west, the U.S. army was fighting a brutal war to drive Native Americans off their land. And yet, at least white people in the North and the South displayed a patriotic spirit of reconciliation – eager to look forward, excited about the future. From May through November 1876, Philadelphia hosted the world’s fair and called it the <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/2026/06/america-centennial-exhibition-1876/686928/">Centennial Exposition</a>: About ten million people, roughly twenty percent of the population, came to embrace the technological marvels on display.</p><p>In 1976, the United States was coming off a period of escalating political violence and assassinations, riots, mass protest. The nation had just suffered a humiliating defeat in Vietnam, struggling to understand the destructions and war crimes America had inflicted upon a far-away land, all in the name of defending freedom, somehow – sacrificing tens of thousands of their own young men in the process. Watergate was still casting a dark shadow over American politics, Nixon’s many abuses of presidential power had shaken the belief in the political institutions and the stability of the rule of law. And yet, America’s bicentennial – perhaps the largest celebration in the nation’s history – once again sparked a spirit of reconciliation. “We have inherited a great tradition,” <a href="https://ford.blogs.archives.gov/2026/06/08/unity-and-progress-reflections-on-president-ford-and-the-bicentennial/">President Gerald Ford declared</a>, “but it is our job - older and younger people joining together - to see to it that when our ancestors (according to the National Archives, Ford really seems to have said “ancestors” and not “descendants” here? Hm.) meet here 100 years from now, they can say that what was done here on this date was the kick-off for a new century of unity, and progress, at home as well as abroad.” History as a call to unify around the shared American project and look towards the future in optimism.</p><p>This time around, however, in 2026 it is not working. America’s semiquincentennial is a bizarre spectacle, entirely overshadowed by the delusions and the authoritarian desires of a fundamentally ridiculous and profoundly dangerous man. Trump is utterly incapable of unifying, except around shared grievances directed at some “Other.” He spent the Fourth of July <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3mpunsccrb22x">raging against enemies</a> real and imagined. Otherwise, he is mostly occupied with imposing vain projects of self-aggrandizement on the nation: His ballroom, the triumphal arch he wants to erect – a self-monumentalization fundamentally incompatible with a democratic Republic.</p><p>Most Americans don’t want to celebrate. Not with Trump, certainly. His “Great American State Fair” on the National Mall, a <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/laurajedeed.bsky.social/post/3mpu3kktxpk2m">vehicle for deranged MAGA propaganda</a>, has not been well attended, to put it mildly. And overall, the mood is not very patriotic, at least not by American standards. The percentage of people who say they are “extremely or very proud” to be an American has fallen, <a href="https://news.gallup.com/poll/711938/american-pride-falls-year-record-low.aspx">according to Gallup</a>, from 85 twenty years ago to 53; if we isolate for people who say they are “extremely proud,” it has cratered from 59 percent in 2006 to merely 33 percent today.</p><p>And therein lies, potentially, one of the silver linings of the Trump era. What the country needs now is not some anniversary-induced nostalgia or unity based on willful ignorance. It needs a serious reckoning as the basis for what might hopefully be a new reconstruction. At the Quarter Millennium, Donald Trump is the President of the United States. And whatever else is true about the most powerful nation on earth, this fact alone forces a reckoning.</p><p><strong>Contested ideals and the origins of a national struggle</strong></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/3ed79187-f4a3-4d02-98ed-cd49f1762756">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/3ed79187-f4a3-4d02-98ed-cd49f1762756/uploads/images/lu7t3x6tno/Declaration_Final.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/3ed79187-f4a3-4d02-98ed-cd49f1762756</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">3ed79187-f4a3-4d02-98ed-cd49f1762756</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 05 Jul 2026 12:57:17 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Understanding Our Disruptive Moment in History – and What It Requires]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The old order is dead. The Right has a revolutionary theory of the moment that promises renewal. Unless we can counter it with a transformative vision, we will lose.]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The old order is dead. The Right has a revolutionary theory of the moment that promises renewal. Unless we can counter it with a transformative vision, we will lose.</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, June 29, 2026</em></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/59b197fa-1a03-44e5-b155-2c221e2a3c0e/uploads/images/xlltk3xfca/iStock-1273219765.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>credit: iStock / enjoynz</figcaption></figure><p><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is a publication </em><strong><em>solely funded by readers</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p><em>Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. </em><strong><em>If you can become a paid member, please do.</em></strong><em> As a member, you receive many additional essays, and you </em><strong><em>gain access to the audio versions</em></strong><em> of everything I publish (members can find the audio at the end of the piece or available for download in the podcast player of your choice).</em></p><p><em>Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work. Please know that I am immensely grateful for your generosity!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? </em></p><p><em>You can </em><strong><em>unlock this article for free</em></strong><em> by subscribing to the free version of this newsletter (via the registration wall below).</em></p><p></p><p>The old world is dying. Defending the status quo is no longer an option: It is neither an adequate response to the challenge we face nor is it viable electorally. We live in a profoundly disruptive moment. Restoration won’t do. A credible transformation is the only way forward.</p><p>I have not been able to do much work lately. Most of Europe has been suffering under an unprecedented heatwave. Friday broke the record for the hottest day ever recorded in German history: 41.3 degrees Celsius (a little over 106 degrees Fahrenheit) near Saarbrücken in the country’s south-west. It took just 24 hours <a href="https://www.tagesschau.de/inland/hitzerekord-deutschland-100.html">for the record to be broken</a> again: 41.5 degrees Celsius (106.7 Fahrenheit) were measured on Saturday in Saxony-Anhalt in eastern Germany.</p><p>I live in Hamburg, up north, which sits at the same latitude as Dublin, Ireland, Liverpool, UK, and Edmonton, Canada. It is a port city, close to the North Sea, shaped by a maritime climate. Extreme heat is supposed to be rare up here. We had <a href="https://www.zeit.de/news/2026-06/27/juni-hitzerekord-fuer-hamburg-geknackt">39.4 degrees Celsius</a> (103 Fahrenheit) on Saturday, smashing the previous record for the month of June.</p><p>Most of my readers live in the United States. Depending on where you are, you may look at these temperatures and think: It’s not <em>that</em> bad, is it? But remember, the vast majority of people here have to make it through the punishing heat without air conditioning. Schools and daycares, hospitals, public transportation… AC is rare. In private households, you will almost never find it. I am writing this after spending most of the past 72 hours in our little basement with my family. The rest of the house is basically uninhabitable. We are among the lucky ones: We have a basement.</p><p>Why does no one have AC, you may ask? Well, there are many reasons, I suppose – but the most profound one is that our homes and cities were built for a world that is no more. It’s simply not supposed to be this hot so early in the summer and for such a long period of time. But that’s the thing: The old rules don’t apply anymore. </p><p>I don’t want to push the symbolic significance of this heatwave too far. But it should serve as a reminder that we are facing major disruptions – politically, socially, technologically, economically, environmentally. And unless we come up with transformative answers that are commensurate with these challenges, we will suffer.</p><p>I had planned to write about the bizarre spectacle of America’s semiquincentennial last week – asking what, exactly, it is that we are asked to commemorate at the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence. That piece will be coming soon, hopefully still before the Fourth of July weekend. But today, I want to offer something else – a broader reflection on where this moment sits in history. If I have a core message, it might be this: We are not witnessing some accidental departure - but we are living through a profound disruption nevertheless, one that makes any attempt at “politics as usual” largely obsolete.</p><p>I am not just talking about Trump, who is himself more a manifestation than the cause of a long-standing anti-democratic radicalization of the American Right. Nor am I merely referring to the political situation in the United States more broadly, which is best understood as the latest iteration of a struggle that stretches back all the way to the Founding. I believe we are at an inflection point not just in the history of the American Republic, but indeed in recent global history.</p><p>I know this all sounds rather abstract: A grand reflection on historical continuity and disruption... And I understand this may seem frustratingly removed from the more immediate, more pressing tasks of the day. But bear with me: I believe it is precisely because the challenges ahead are so profound that we better come up with a good answer to the question of where this moment sits in history. What are the broader historical forces that got us here, that are tearing the present apart and shaping a future whose contours we cannot yet grasp? </p><p>Unless we get that diagnosis right, we are doomed to fumble about in the dark. Unless we grasp the assignment, our response is destined to fall woefully short of the task ahead.</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/59b197fa-1a03-44e5-b155-2c221e2a3c0e">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/59b197fa-1a03-44e5-b155-2c221e2a3c0e/uploads/images/xlltk3xfca/iStock-1273219765.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/59b197fa-1a03-44e5-b155-2c221e2a3c0e</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">59b197fa-1a03-44e5-b155-2c221e2a3c0e</guid>
      <pubDate>Mon, 29 Jun 2026 11:26:30 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[When the Republic Almost Fell]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[What we can learn from new reporting on how the Trumpists have been contemplating despotism, the fault lines within the regime, and the prospects for a post-Trump MAGA]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>What we can learn from new reporting on how the Trumpists have been contemplating despotism, the fault lines within the regime, and the prospects for a post-Trump MAGA</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, June 17, 2026</em></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/71475e17-b44e-43ec-83de-f17533e5bf92/uploads/images/6lvznahxrn/iStock-2195563053.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>credit: iStock / mammuth</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></strong></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is a publication </em><strong><em>solely funded by readers</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p><em>Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. </em><strong><em>If you can become a paid member, please do.</em></strong><em> As a member, you receive many additional essays, and you </em><strong><em>gain access to the audio versions</em></strong><em> of everything I publish (members can find the audio at the end of the piece or available for download in the podcast player of your choice).</em></p><p><em>I need your support to continue this work. Thank you!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership?</em></p><p><em>You can </em><strong><em>unlock this article for free</em></strong><em> by subscribing to the free version of this newsletter (via the registration wall below).</em></p><p><strong><em> </em></strong></p><p>The day after Donald Trump subjected the nation to his deranged birthday party spectacle of violence, the <em>New York Times</em>, on Monday, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/06/15/us/politics/trump-scharf-habeas-corpus-insurrection-act.html">dropped new reporting</a> that sheds light on how the MAGA government internally contemplated radical steps that would have potentially ended the American Republic.</p><p>The reporting focuses on two key moments: First, in late April 2025, White House deputy chief of staff and leading white nationalist ideologue Stephen Miller pushed for the president to suspend habeas corpus for unauthorized immigrants in order to speed up the regime’s mass deportation efforts. Secondly, in late January, Miller and Vice-President JD Vance were urging for Trump to invoke the Insurrection Act and deploy federal troops to suppress the protests against the ongoing paramilitary occupation of Minneapolis carried out by ICE and Border Patrol.</p><p>There are no earth-shattering pieces of news in the reporting – the new information generally aligns with how the regime was acting publicly. But we gain a significantly clearer and more detailed picture. And there is also value in having confirmed, with loads of testimony and written evidence, what we reasonably suspected. </p><p>(As an aside: The<em> New York Times</em>, with its access and unmatched resources, can produce such reporting – and that is tremendously valuable. It is also, at the same time, tremendously shameful for star reporters Maggie Haberman and Jonathan Swan to <em>not</em> report this information immediately and instead sit on it until it is time to juice sales for their upcoming book, which will be published next week…)</p><p>The reporting, crucially, provides us with an opportunity to take stock and reflect on three broader questions that determine our understanding of this regime and the state of American democracy:</p><p>1) The timeline: When, exactly, did the Trumpists come closest to instituting despotism – and why did they ultimately fail to implement and/or decided against taking the extreme steps they were debating?</p><p>2) Internal dynamics and fault lines: What does the reporting tell us about the different factions within the MAGA government, the exact fault lines between them, and the role of Trump himself in the decision-making process?</p><p>3) The future of the MAGA government and movement: What are the implications of this internal strive for what comes after Trump?</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/71475e17-b44e-43ec-83de-f17533e5bf92">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/71475e17-b44e-43ec-83de-f17533e5bf92/uploads/images/6lvznahxrn/iStock-2195563053.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/71475e17-b44e-43ec-83de-f17533e5bf92</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">71475e17-b44e-43ec-83de-f17533e5bf92</guid>
      <pubDate>Wed, 17 Jun 2026 22:44:23 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Big News: Democracy Americana Now Also Available in German]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[No worries: Nothing changes over here on the main feed. I am just adding a second channel – same content, same analysis, but accessible in an additional language]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>No worries: Nothing changes over here on the main feed. I am just adding a second channel – same content, same analysis, but accessible in an additional language.</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, June 13, 2026</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/e2a20ac6-c976-46a5-88a5-3528bc96b800">Listen on Steady</a></p><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/e2a20ac6-c976-46a5-88a5-3528bc96b800/uploads/images/phgzpxfrs4/SocMediaBanner.png?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><p><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is my main source of income as an independent writer. If you are reading the free version of this newsletter, I sincerely appreciate your time and effort engaging with my work. Please share it widely to help me reach new readers.</em></p><p><em>And if you can, please consider becoming a </em><strong><em>paid member</em></strong><em>. You will gain access to special benefits – including many additional essays and the chance to download the audio versions of all my pieces in podcast form.</em></p><p><em>Most importantly, Democracy Americana is a publication solely funded by readers. I need your support to continue this work. Thank you!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p></p><p>Dear all,</p><p>Just a quick update today with some exiting news: I have launched a German version of this newsletter. Please welcome: <a href="https://steady.page/en/demokratie-americana/posts">Demokratie Americana.</a></p><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/e2a20ac6-c976-46a5-88a5-3528bc96b800/uploads/images/ph5xobh7b3/BannerImage.png?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/demokratie-americana/posts">To Demokratie Americana</a></p><p><strong>What is it?</strong></p><p>“Demokratie Americana” – that’s not exactly a super imaginative name. But it is fitting, I believe, because it’s not going to be a different newsletter. Just this newsletter here made available in a different language. Same analysis, same content. Just Democracy Americana in German.</p><p>And to be absolutely clear: Nothing changes over here at all. I am not taking anything away from Democracy Americana. Just adding a second language track, if you will.</p><p>The reason why I am not simply sending out the German version via this channel is that I don’t want to bother the vast majority of you, who are reading the English original, with more posts and mor emails in German; likewise, I think it’s better if those who are interested in reading / listening in German get their own thing. Frankly, having the German version as what is technically a separate newsletter will also help with the visibility: It will make it easier for people to find, easier to promote, easier to build an audience.</p><p>For those of you who are interested in accessing the German version, I do want to make the transition as easy as possible. And that means two things:</p><p>1) If you are a paid member of Democracy Americana, I am not trying to sell you anything extra. No one has to pay double. If you want access to all the member-exclusive content in the German version, you’ll just have to alert me, so that I can get you equipped with a German membership at no extra cost to you. Easiest way to do that is to leave your name and email in the little survey I have set up below:</p><a href="https://tally.so/embed/44Gvdd?alignLeft=1&amp;hideTitle=1&amp;transparentBackground=1&amp;dynamicHeight=1">https://tally.so/embed/44Gvdd?alignLeft=1&amp;hideTitle=1&amp;transparentBackground=1&amp;dynamicHeight=1</a><p>(or, if you prefer, you can also just email me directly or leave a comment under this post)</p><p>2) If you are a free subscriber over here and just want to read the free version of the German newsletter, I guess the easiest approach is to just subscribe over at Demokratie Americana. However, if you prefer, you can also leave your email in this second survey below and I will happily migrate you over, no need for you to do anything else:</p><a href="https://tally.so/embed/KYRDZD?alignLeft=1&amp;hideTitle=1&amp;transparentBackground=1&amp;dynamicHeight=1">https://tally.so/embed/KYRDZD?alignLeft=1&amp;hideTitle=1&amp;transparentBackground=1&amp;dynamicHeight=1</a><p>Either way: If you are running into any kind of trouble, please don’t hesitate to reach out and let me know. I am sure we can figure it out together.</p><p><strong>Why am I doing this?</strong></p><p>Since you are all subscribers or even paid members, I don’t need to repeat Democracy Americana’s mission statement. But I do want to share the thought process behind this decision to launch a German version.</p><p>I have been writing Democracy Americana since November 2022. Until now, I was very reluctant to even consider making it available in German. It’s just a lot of extra work – and I’ll admit that makes me a little nervous.</p><p>However, since moving over here to Germany last summer, I have been more directly and immediately confronted with the German America discourse. There is tremendous interest on this side of the Atlantic, and rightfully so, in all things USA. And it’s not like there is a paucity of voices chiming in. In fact, I’d say there is <em>too much</em> breathless coverage. Whatever German newspaper you’ll look at, whatever news broadcast you’re watching, whatever political radio show you are listening to: There will be Trump, Trump, Trump… But it’s often frantic, more reproducing the endless outrageousness of our moment rather than helping to digest it. What is lacking is perspective, context, depth. This is where I believe I can have an impact with Democracy Americana. Although I do regularly write for German media, it is only here, in my own independent publication, where I get the chance to tackle the issues I believe need tackling, in as much depth as I believe they require.</p><p>So far, my German-speaking audience is rather limited, actually – making up less than five percent of all readers of Democracy Americana. I am guessing there are plenty of reasons for that. But it seems plausible that a big one is the fact that the newsletter has only ever been available in English. Most people over here who are interested in U.S. politics and history do read and understand English, of course. But it is still a different hurdle to engage with the type of long-form essay I am writing in a language other than your native tongue. The barrier to entry is just higher. And I fundamentally believe that I should make every effort to lower those barriers as much as possible and make my work accessible to anyone who is interested.</p><p>Finally, I will also admit that I am hoping to be able to intervene a little more forcefully in the German America discourse once my work is available in German as well.</p><p>(I am not sure if that needs to be said, but I want to say it, for the record: What I am offering is 100 percent AI-free – here as well as over at Demokratie Americana. The research, structuring, writing, audio recording, and now also translating not just into a different language, but also for a different audience is all being done by me. No AI. Ever.)</p><p>I will admit this is an experiment that makes me nervous a little bit. I hope the German version will find an audience. My own established audience in Germany / among German-speakers is comparatively limited. Please help me find whoever might be interested and whoever might benefit!</p><p><strong>What’s coming up next?</strong></p><p>I want to end on two quick notes. First of all, my sincere apologies for the lighter posting schedule in June so far. I have had to take care off a lot of “business” stuff – the price to be paid when you are a full-time author who is trying to put out an independent publication by yourself… Now that the German newsletter is launched, we should be getting back to our normal schedule.</p><p>Secondly, I have been working on some exciting stuff. Last week, I got to discuss “What’s next, America?” with historian Adam Tooze and former German Vice-Chancellor Robert Habeck in front of a large live audience in Berlin (the conversation is now available in both <a href="https://www.berliner-ensemble.de/magazin/was-wird-aus-amerika">podcast</a> as well as <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EcBcCQsvHFc">video form</a>). It was a clarifying discussion, and I want to reflect a little bit on what we agreed about, where we disagreed, and what the main takeaways might be from what turned into a wide-ranging discussion about the state of democracy on either side of the Atlantic. </p><p>The other thing I have been working and writing on is a proper deep dive into all the many ways the “polarization” narrative obscures far more than it illuminates. Really, if only we could stop talking about “polarization.” I’ll make the case to you why we need to finally move beyond that utterly misleading tale.</p><p>Thank you, as always, for your time – and for allowing me, metaphorically speaking, a seat at your table as we are all trying to figure out what is happening around us and what to do about it.</p><p>Take care, Thomas</p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/e2a20ac6-c976-46a5-88a5-3528bc96b800/uploads/images/phgzpxfrs4/SocMediaBanner.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/e2a20ac6-c976-46a5-88a5-3528bc96b800</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">e2a20ac6-c976-46a5-88a5-3528bc96b800</guid>
      <pubDate>Sat, 13 Jun 2026 11:12:33 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[America Is Going Backwards - and Falling Apart]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The country is facing rapidly encroaching minoritarianism, vastly unrepresentative political institutions, and an escalating crisis of legitimacy]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>After the end of the voting rights era, the country is facing rapidly encroaching minoritarianism, vastly unrepresentative political institutions, and an escalating crisis of legitimacy</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, June 1, 2026</em></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/859d67c6-fa2f-4059-b4da-f93dec85c0a6/uploads/images/7xuovwe3qy/4C77D923-482E-4FB7-8C4F-C6169CA3A0C4_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>A photo of the MLK Memorial in Washington, DC, taken on a cold morning in January 2024</figcaption></figure><p><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is a publication </em><strong><em>solely funded by readers</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p><em>Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. </em><strong><em>If you can become a paid member, please do.</em></strong><em> As a member, you receive many additional essays, and you </em><strong><em>gain access to the audio versions</em></strong><em> of everything I publish (members can find the audio at the end of the piece or available for download in the podcast player of your choice).</em></p><p><em>I need your support to continue this work. Thank you!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership?</em></p><p><em>You can </em><strong><em>unlock this article for free</em></strong><em> by subscribing to the free version of this newsletter (via the registration wall below).</em></p><p></p><p>A little over one month ago the Roberts majority on the Supreme Court gutted what was left of the 1965 Voting Rights Act and functionally ended the civil rights era. Since the moment the decision came down, Republicans have been furiously attempting to undo whatever democratizing progress has been achieved since the 1960s, curtail minority political power, and extinguish multiracial pluralism wherever they are in charge. </p><p>With so much at stake in the upcoming Congressional elections, it is understandable that much of the discussion has centered around the question of what this all means for the midterms. As they are frantically redrawing the maps across the South to gerrymander majority-minority districts out of existence, Republicans have suddenly gained <a href="https://newrepublic.com/article/210284/week-republicans-may-stolen-midterms">six to eight additional seats</a> that were guaranteed go to the Democratic Party. The GOP now goes into the elections with a more significant structural advantage than before the Supreme Court’s Callais decision, the margin Democrats need to get to a majority in the House has gone up to probably <a href="https://www.gelliottmorris.com/p/2026-05-10-dem-house-pop-vote-threshold-gerrymandering">around four percentage points</a>. Because Trump and his party are so disastrously unpopular, Democrats <a href="https://smotus.substack.com/p/democrats-are-still-likely-to-flip">remain favored</a> to win at least the House. But this is now more likely to be a narrow election result. And that is dangerous. Much like after the 2020 election, Trump’s attempts to manipulate his way to victory will depend on whether or not he can get enough people in enough positions of influence to go along with his schemes. If the election is not really close, and the chances of getting away with nullifying the results are therefore low, people are less likely to accept the personal risk involved in helping Trump; if it’s tight, the calculus might change for people who believe in the “Big Lie” or simply don’t accept that Democratic governance could ever be legitimate.</p><p>All of this is important. And yet, the significance of what is now happening – of what is being done to whatever is left of American democracy – goes so far beyond the midterms, far beyond the partisan struggle in a narrow sense. The intention behind what Republicans are doing is not just to win in November. They are trying to transform the country’s political landscape and remake the face of the Republic.</p><p>Let’s make sure we fully understand the political, economic, and social consequences of this annihilation of minority representation; how it further undermines the trust in the country’s political system; how it deepens an ongoing crisis of legitimacy, as the political institutions become ever less responsive and representative; how it exacerbates a process that is tearing the country apart, as the gap between “Red America” and “Blue America” is rapidly widening.</p><p>If we want to have any chance of coming up with a response that is commensurate with this challenge, we must first grapple in earnest with the true impact of the end of the civil rights era – and with what the second white reactionary “Redemption” will do to America. </p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/859d67c6-fa2f-4059-b4da-f93dec85c0a6">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/859d67c6-fa2f-4059-b4da-f93dec85c0a6/uploads/images/7xuovwe3qy/4C77D923-482E-4FB7-8C4F-C6169CA3A0C4_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/859d67c6-fa2f-4059-b4da-f93dec85c0a6</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">859d67c6-fa2f-4059-b4da-f93dec85c0a6</guid>
      <pubDate>Mon, 01 Jun 2026 22:36:58 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Rise and Fall of the Second Reconstruction, 1964/65 – 2025/26]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Putting the end of the civil rights era in historical perspective: How it transformed the nation, how it was toppled by a raging reaction, and what comes next.]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h1>The Rise and Fall of the Second Reconstruction, 1964/65 - 2025/26</h1><p><strong>Putting the end of the civil rights era in historical perspective: How it transformed the nation, how it was toppled by a raging reaction, and what comes next</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, May 17, 2026</em></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/8f16b18f-41d5-41f9-884b-f76a13852986/uploads/images/gkmys4lhwa/12328_2006_001_pr.jpg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>After crossing the Edmund Pettus Bridge, John Lewis and other civil rights activists marching for voting rights are stopped and threatened by Alabama state troopers and local police in Selma, Alabama on “Bloody Sunday,” March 7, 1965 (National Archives Identifier 16899041, credit: Spider Martin)</figcaption></figure><p><em>This is Part II of my history of multiracial democracy in America. In last week’s Part I, </em><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/b0eafc14-f68d-4499-8108-b440bad1af7f"><em>which you find here</em></a><em>, I focused on the fate of the first attempt at biracial democracy after the Civil War, and on the political implications of the Reconstruction era for today.</em></p><p><em>In this Part II, I look at America’s Second Reconstruction that was codified in the civil rights legislation of the 1960s, reflect on why this had such a transformative impact on politics and society – and examine why this current moment really marks a profound cesura in U.S. history: The end of the civil rights era.</em></p><p><em>This is coming out a little later than I had hoped or anticipated – and for that, I want to apologize. But I really wanted to do this story justice. It is fitting, therefore, that this is by far the longest essay I have ever published on Democracy Americana. An attempt to really put into perspective what a profoundly important – and disturbing - moment in U.S. history we are currently witnessing.</em></p><p><strong><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></strong></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is a publication </em><strong><em>solely funded by readers</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p><em>Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. </em><strong><em>If you can become a paid member, please do.</em></strong><em> As a member, you receive many additional essays, and you </em><strong><em>gain access to the audio versions</em></strong><em> of everything I publish (members can find the audio at the end of the piece or available for download in the podcast player of your choice).</em></p><p><em>Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work. Please know that I am immensely grateful for your generosity!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership?</em></p><p><em>You can </em><strong><em>unlock this article for free</em></strong><em> by subscribing to the free version of this newsletter (via the registration wall below).</em></p><p></p><p>It has been a horrifying, yet entirely predictable spectacle. Since the Supreme Court functionally nullified the 1965 Voting Rights Act on April 29, Republicans have rushed to gerrymander majority-minority districts out of existence. The euphoric zeal they are displaying while extinguishing Black political representation across the South reveals precisely what is going on here.</p><p>Finally, Bennie Thompson’s <a href="https://x.com/tatereeves/status/2054570406216978489?s=20">“reign of terror”</a> over Mississippi’s second congressional district was coming to an end, Mississippi Governor Tate Reeves declared on May 13. Thompson is the sole Black person and the only Democrat among the state’s congressional delegation. He has represented his majority-Black district in Congress since 1993, regularly receiving two thirds of the vote. But that doesn’t matter to Governor Reeves: Thompson’s “reign” is illegitimate because the people who vote for him don’t count, or they shouldn’t, and now that the Roberts Court has opened the door for that, Republicans in Mississippi will make sure they won’t.</p><p>In Alabama, Governor Kay Ivey <a href="https://governor.alabama.gov/newsroom/2026/05/governor-ivey-celebrates-major-court-victory-in-states-redistricting-battle-calls-special-election-for-alabama-drawn-congressional-map/">celebrated</a> the chance to dilute and obliterate Black voting power because “Alabama knows our state, our people and our districts best,” and this “win for Alabamians,” as she put it, “enables our values to be best represented in Congress.” It is certainly not a “win” for the 27 percent of the population that are Black – but those simply don’t count among the “Alabamians” Ivey cares about. Two out of the state’s seven congressional districts are currently represented by Black Democratic lawmakers. That will now change. “Our state.” “Our people.” “Our values.” People of color not included.</p><p>“For too long,” Tennessee Representative Andy Ogles <a href="https://x.com/AndyOgles/status/2052465629454815591?s=20">raged on May 7</a>, “Tennessee politics has been dominated by cosmopolitan communists and race hustlers imposing their corrupt will on a deeply rural and conservative state.” Tennessee is about 77 percent white and 17 percent Black. Eight out of its nine Congressional districts are represented by white Republicans. It is Tennessee’s ninth district that Ogles was enraged about, the one around Memphis: 60 percent of the population is Black, about 9 percent Hispanic. Kamala Harris received around 70 percent of the vote here in 2024. And over 70 percent sent Stephen Ira Cohen to Washington, a white Democratic progressive, the first Jewish person to represent Tennessee in Congress. That’s who Ogles refers to when he bemoans “cosmopolitan communists”; and the “race hustlers,” that’s just people of color. Their numbers are irrelevant; majorities built on their votes don’t count. And so they won’t: Republicans have already <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/may/15/tennessee-democrat-steve-cohen-ends-re-election-bid">enacted a new map</a> that carves up the ninth district, distributing minorities across three districts in a way that leaves only white-dominated ones. One of the new districts stretches about 200 miles north-east all the way to the outskirts of Nashville: That’s how far they had to go to find enough white people to make sure Black voting power was sufficiently diluted.</p><p>None of this is subtle. None of it is new. And even the rhetoric has always been the same. White supremacists presented exactly these arguments to justify their struggle to undo Reconstruction after the Civil War: They were fighting against an evil imposition of Northern tyranny, against outsiders and intruders illegitimately put in charge of the South. Those who fought against de-segregation and civil rights in the 1950s and 60s made the same claims. In his <a href="https://digital.archives.alabama.gov/digital/collection/records/id/468/">inaugural address</a> as governor of Alabama in January 1963, George Wallace vowed to defend “segregation now, segregation tomorrow, and segregation forever” not because of racism, no! But to defend the “freedom” of the South and its true people. “Let us rise to the call of freedom-loving blood that is in us,” Wallace declared, “and send our answer to the tyranny that clanks its chains upon the South.” Yet again, just like after the Civil War, when “the South was set upon by the vulturous carpetbagger and federal troops,” it was time to take a stand and “sound the drum for freedom.” It is a particular kind of freedom, Wallace was concerned with – the same “freedom” Reeves, Ivey, and Ogles are defending now: The freedom of white people to dominate and rule, and to curtail the freedom of others.</p><p>The first task for observers, analysts, and citizens alike is to understand, acknowledge, and describe clearly and honestly what is happening around us. And here I will allow myself to write angry…</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/8f16b18f-41d5-41f9-884b-f76a13852986">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/8f16b18f-41d5-41f9-884b-f76a13852986/teaser_image/1779016240?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/8f16b18f-41d5-41f9-884b-f76a13852986</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">8f16b18f-41d5-41f9-884b-f76a13852986</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 17 May 2026 11:14:37 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Multiracial Democracy is Young and Fragile]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[A history of the struggle to reconstitute a nation built on racial hierarchy around the principle of equality – Part I: Lessons from the rise and fall of Reconstruction]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>A brief history of the struggle to reconstitute a nation built on racial hierarchy around the principle of equality – Part I: Lessons from the rise and fall of Reconstruction</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, May 6, 2026</em></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/b0eafc14-f68d-4499-8108-b440bad1af7f/uploads/images/j6rw37lr2h/Reconstruction.webp?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>An illustration from Harper’s Weekly from 1867: Black men voting in a state election in the South – credit: Hulton Archive/Getty Images</figcaption></figure><p><em>This is Part I of a two-part series on the history of multiracial democracy in America. Not a total history, of course, but something that can serve as a framework for how to think about this long struggle over how much democracy, and for whom, there should be in this country, the core dynamics that have shaped it, and the various stages and eras is has experienced.</em></p><p><strong><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></strong></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is a publication </em><strong><em>solely funded by readers</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p><em>Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. </em><strong><em>If you can become a paid member, please do.</em></strong><em> As a member, you receive many additional essays, and you </em><strong><em>gain access to the audio versions</em></strong><em> of everything I publish (members can find the audio at the end of the piece or available for download in the podcast player of your choice).</em></p><p><em>I need your support to continue this work. Thank you!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? </em></p><p><em>You can </em><strong><em>unlock this article for free</em></strong><em> by subscribing to the free version of this newsletter (via the registration wall below).</em></p><p></p><p>Before the Voting Rights Act of 1965, America was not a democracy. It was certainly not what we, in widely accepted parlance today, call “democracy.” It absolutely had no reasonable claim to be considered a <em>multiracial</em> democracy.</p><p>I know this may all sound awfully “political,” in the sense that it comes with a fairly straightforward partisan valence. But that is entirely a function of the fact that democracy itself has become a partisan issue, as the Republican Party is fully at war with pluralistic society and the principle of equal citizenship.</p><p>The Voting Rights Act set the United States on a path to becoming something that it had not been until the civil rights revolution of the 1960s: A multiracial, pluralistic democracy. And because the staunchly anti-egalitarian, anti-pluralistic forces that have always shaped the American story didn’t just vanish into thin air but instead engaged in a comprehensive countermobilization against modern democracy, the conflict over whether or not it should be allowed to endure and prosper has been the central fault line in U.S. politics ever since.</p><p>In that sense, and in that sense only, last week’s Supreme Court decision to essentially nullify what remained of the Voting Rights Act is helpful: It clarifies both the nature and the stakes of the political conflict. The question at the core of this struggle is this: Can a society built on racial hierarchy be transformed into a multiracial democracy? Or, put differently: Must America be forever defined by strict hierarchies of race, gender, religion, and wealth – or can the nation finally realize its promise of egalitarian pluralism?</p><p><strong>The Roberts Court ends the Second Reconstruction</strong></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/b0eafc14-f68d-4499-8108-b440bad1af7f">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/b0eafc14-f68d-4499-8108-b440bad1af7f/uploads/images/j6rw37lr2h/Reconstruction.webp?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/b0eafc14-f68d-4499-8108-b440bad1af7f</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">b0eafc14-f68d-4499-8108-b440bad1af7f</guid>
      <pubDate>Wed, 06 May 2026 10:48:14 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Why the Tech Billionaires Are Aligned with Trump]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Fueled by profit motives, ideological radicalization, and elite self-victimization, America’s tech barons are aggressively taking the side of authoritarianism. Why now?]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Fueled by profit motives, ideological radicalization, and elite self-victimization, America’s tech barons are aggressively taking the side of authoritarianism. But why now?</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, April 26, 2026</em></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/7b369a88-108e-4535-be65-b0faebebe324/uploads/images/wk4l4wo4sd/139DBD9C-FFB5-4B5F-998E-CE11DF74C53D_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>One of the Palantiri, the seeing-stones, from Peter Jackson’s movie adaptation of JRR Tolkien’s Lord of the Rings</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></strong></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is a publication </em><strong><em>solely funded by readers</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p><em>Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. </em><strong><em>If you can become a paid member, please do.</em></strong><em> As a member, you receive many additional essays, and you </em><strong><em>gain access to the audio versions</em></strong><em> of everything I publish (members can find the audio at the end of the piece or available for download in the podcast player of your choice).</em></p><p><em>Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work. Please know that I am immensely grateful for your generosity!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership?</em></p><p><em>You can </em><strong><em>unlock this article for free</em></strong><em> by subscribing to the free version of this newsletter (via the registration wall below).</em></p><p></p><p>Perhaps Alexander Karp, the CEO of Palantir, just wanted to remind the world how much he and the company he defines are aligned with the MAGA regime. On April 18, Palantir released <a href="https://twitter-thread.com/t/2045574398573453312">a 22-point manifesto</a>, basically the abstract version of the book “The Technological Republic” Karp and co-Palantiri Nicholas Zamiska published a year ago. “Look at us!”, it yells, “look how all in we are on America First nationalism and the Trump agenda!”</p><p>Palantir was co-founded by Karp and Peter Thiel in 2003. They named the company after the elven-made seeing-stones in J.R.R. Tolkien’s Middle-earth saga, magical crystal balls used for telepathic communication and information gathering across vast distances. Palantir offers data analysis software and AI-powered <a href="https://www.wired.com/story/alex-karp-goes-to-war-palantir-big-interview/">“operational intelligence,”</a> as Karp puts it – especially to the military, law enforcement, and intelligence services. </p><p>Why does a publicly traded tech company need such a manifesto? Because Karp, like so many of today’s tech lords, fancies himself a philosopher-CEO. They are convinced they have some profound insight to offer, and they are determined to make the world listen. And so, we get “The Technological Republic, in brief,” a document that reeks of cultural chauvinism. “Some cultures have produced vital advances; others remain dysfunctional and regressive,” we learn. Palantir, therefore, is deeply opposed to “the shallow temptation of a vacant and hollow pluralism” – makes sense, from a Western supremacist perspective: We must not dilute the “culture”! The manifesto also sprinkles in some revanchism, demanding that “the postwar neutering of Germany and Japan must be undone,” complaining that the “defanging of Germany was an overcorrection.”<strong> </strong>Why is a company that, above all else, embraces the militant nationalism of America First concerned with such matters? Because the America First mandate includes a commitment to fighting for Western supremacy everywhere and elevating rightwing nationalists abroad. Raging against the “neutering” and “defanging” of Germany as one of history’s great injustices is just standard repertoire for the post-1945 German far right.</p><p>In any case, the manifesto calls on America to not get soft. Enough with all the “woke” self-critique and cancel culture: The nation must get back to relishing its own superiority and punish its enemies with “hard power”! And for that, it needs a global surveillance machinery that Palantir is happy to supply. Get rid of the deep state and those pesky civil servants with their outrageous attempts to sabotage that project: In Palantir’s vision, the government and the totally unaccountable tech elite become one – an all-powerful fusion in service of American supremacy and the defense of Western “culture.”</p><p>The Palantir manifesto is a stark reminder: The Silicon Valley tech billionaires are fully aligned with Trump.</p><p>Remarkably, it wasn’t all that long ago that many of them were cozying up to Obama and the liberal establishment.  After the 2016 election, for instance, the <em>Washington Post</em>, the paper Amazon founder Jeff Bezos had purchased in 2013, famously vowed to stand against the Trumpist assault under the motto <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2019/national/democracy-dies-in-darkness/">“Democracy Dies in Darkness.”</a> Yet when Trump was inaugurated in January 2025, <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cvgpqeq82rvo">Bezos was right there with him</a> – and <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2025/feb/26/jeff-bezos-washington-post-opinion">officially declared</a> it was time for the <em>Pos</em>t to stop all this “democracy” talk; <a href="https://www.cjr.org/the_media_today/exodus-washington-post-wapo-storied-paper-dying-jeff-bezos-donald-trump.php">a mass exodus of liberal voices</a> from the <em>Post </em>followed quickly thereafter.</p><p>Or take Palantir CEO Alex Karp: He was seen as a liberal, a progressive, even a proper leftist until just a few years ago. In 2024, he still supported Joe Biden and Kamala Harris. But then he donated for Trump’s inauguration and is helping to pay for Trump’s bizarre ballroom plans. Karp is now calling Palantir the first company <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/11/10/opinion/alex-karp-palantir-trump.html">“to be completely anti-woke.”</a></p><p>What happened?</p><p>Considering how much power – over our politics and our private lives – these guys are amassing, we better find a proper answer to that question. This is, without a doubt, one of the defining, and most dangerous, stories of our time. Let’s tackle it step by step by investigating:</p><p>(1) Why this is not <em>just</em> a story of capitalists attempting to maximize profit by sucking up to the authoritarian regime - but also a tale of political and ideological radicalization</p><p>(2) Why it was a mistake to equate technological futurism with social progressivism, as the fundamental worldview in the tech elite circles has always had inherently anti-democratic tendencies, leading so many of them to conclude that <a href="https://www.cato-unbound.org/2009/04/13/peter-thiel/education-libertarian/">“freedom and democracy are incompatible”</a></p><p>(3) The role of extremist thinkers like Curtis Yarvin in intellectualizing the anti-democratic impulses, and the spread of a staunchly authoritarian ideology that is best described as either “reactionary modernism” or tech-fascism</p><p>(4) How and why these long-standing anti-democratic impulses and reactionary tendencies are being activated <em>now</em>, and the escalating sense of elite self-victimization that fuels people like Alex Karp and Marc Andreessen who considered themselves “liberals” or even “leftists” until quite recently.</p><p>We need to understand why they are now giving themselves permission to make common cause with the rightwing extremist assault on democracy – because we will all be suffering the consequences.</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/7b369a88-108e-4535-be65-b0faebebe324">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/7b369a88-108e-4535-be65-b0faebebe324/uploads/images/wk4l4wo4sd/139DBD9C-FFB5-4B5F-998E-CE11DF74C53D_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/7b369a88-108e-4535-be65-b0faebebe324</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">7b369a88-108e-4535-be65-b0faebebe324</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 26 Apr 2026 10:37:44 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Why Hungary Matters]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Six big-picture conclusions from Orbán’s smashing defeat – and what it all means for the transnational struggle against rightwing authoritarianism]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Six big-picture conclusions from Orbán’s smashing defeat – and what it all means for the transnational struggle against rightwing authoritarianism</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, April 13, 2026</em></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/84239935-e835-46fe-b97a-24e551c1658c/uploads/images/6g7aa2oh3p/3190fef_ftp-1-dzdpq00eh5it-5753875-01-06.png?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>People celebrating Orbán’s defeat in front of the Parliament building in Budapest on April 12, 2026 – credit: Ferenc Isza / AFP</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></strong></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is a publication </em><strong><em>solely funded by readers</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p><em>Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. </em><strong><em>If you can become a paid member, please do.</em></strong><em> As a member, you receive many additional essays, and you </em><strong><em>gain access to the audio versions</em></strong><em> of everything I publish (members can find the audio at the end of the piece or available for download in the podcast player of your choice).</em></p><p><em>Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work. Please know that I am immensely grateful for your generosity!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership?</em></p><p><em>You can </em><strong><em>unlock this article for free</em></strong><em> by subscribing to the free version of this newsletter (via the registration wall below).</em></p><p></p><p>It is rare that the political discourse across the “West” is dominated by one single event. And when it happens, it’s often not a good sign: Wars and natural disasters can have that effect, or perhaps the latest victory of an extremist party in what can sometimes feel like a steady march towards inevitable authoritarian triumph.</p><p>But yesterday, all our attention was focused on what turned out to be a massive defeat for the global Far Right: In Hungary, Viktor Orbán lost the parliamentary election. And it was a blowout.</p><p>Orbán’s Fidesz party got only 38 percent – Tisza, the party of his main opponent Péter Magyar received 53 percent. Crucially, this result translates to a two-thirds supermajority, 138 out of 199 seats, for Tisza in Parliament, which could enable them to actually undo much of the authoritarian system Orbán has entrenched.</p><p>Perhaps never before have so many people paid so much attention to a parliamentary election in a small, economically weak, and geostrategically unassuming (at least in a traditional sense) country. Across the political spectrum, Viktor Orbán is rightfully seen as the symbol of the rise of “illiberalism”: He has undoubtedly been one of the defining figures in the transnational authoritarian assault on democracy and the rule of law. And after sixteen years in power, Orbán’s time as prime minister of Hungary is about to end. The people of Hungary have had enough, and they found a way to make that count.</p><p>I am not going to pretend I am an expert on Hungarian society and politics. But as my work focuses on democracy and its discontents in the United States, and how the American conflict over democracy is connected to the inter- and transnational struggle between authoritarian ethno-nationalism and democratic pluralism, I want to reflect on the broader meaning of what transpired yesterday, on the conclusions we can draw and the lessons we may or may not be able to learn. </p><p>As I am writing this, less than 24 hours have passed since the first results from the Hungarian election were made public – so take this as a preliminary attempt to provide perspective on what I believe was a truly significant outcome. More specifically, let’s discuss:</p><p>-       Why we need to remember, amidst all the well-earned celebration, that this struggle is not over, and there is no such thing as a decisive “turning point”</p><p>-       What we have learned about the nature and inner dynamics of regimes that are best described as forms of competitive authoritarianism</p><p>-       Why the American Right has been so obsessed with Orbán in the first place</p><p>-       What that transnational fixation on Orbán can tell us about the world-historic stakes in this broader struggle over democracy</p><p>-       And why we must never give in to defeatism or the temptation to perpetuate rightwing assertions of liberal democracy’s supposedly inevitable fall.</p><p>Nothing about rightwing authoritarianism is inevitable.</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/84239935-e835-46fe-b97a-24e551c1658c">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/84239935-e835-46fe-b97a-24e551c1658c/uploads/images/6g7aa2oh3p/3190fef_ftp-1-dzdpq00eh5it-5753875-01-06.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/84239935-e835-46fe-b97a-24e551c1658c</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">84239935-e835-46fe-b97a-24e551c1658c</guid>
      <pubDate>Mon, 13 Apr 2026 16:48:43 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Donald Trump Does Not Have a Plan]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[He has dictatorial desires. But not everything is a brilliant distraction or part of a cunning masterplan. Incompetent agents of malice are not omnipotent supervillains.]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>He has dictatorial desires. But not everything is a brilliant distraction or part of a cunning masterplan. Let’s not turn incompetent agents of malice into omnipotent supervillains.</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, April 11, 2026</em></p><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/70c12168-9b07-44a1-aadc-a4ced5a2d5aa/uploads/images/wstfhfh5qz/351C4F83-E5D2-43CC-86F3-2ABC9E3451E8_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><p><strong><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></strong></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is a publication </em><strong><em>solely funded by readers</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p><em>Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. </em><strong><em>If you can become a paid member, please do.</em></strong><em> As a member, you receive many additional essays, and you </em><strong><em>gain access to the audio versions</em></strong><em> of everything I publish (members can find the audio at the end of the piece or available for download in the podcast player of your choice).</em></p><p><em>Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work. Please know that I am immensely grateful for your generosity!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership?</em></p><p><em>You can </em><strong><em>unlock this article for free</em></strong><em> by subscribing to the free version of this newsletter (via the registration wall below).</em></p><p></p><p>To start the week, the President of the United States threatened to erase “a whole civilization.” It doesn’t feel right to simply move on. As Donald Trump’s madness will continue to ramp up and - excuse me for sounding dramatic - threaten humanity, it is urgently important we grapple honestly with what is happening here.</p><p>As Trump kept escalating his threats, prominent elected officials and political observers suggested there was some method to what he was doing – that it was either all <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/warnock.senate.gov/post/3mivyc744ax2n">a cunning distraction</a> from matters Trump wanted to obscure or perhaps all part of a <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/timothysnyder.bsky.social/post/3mirjzigrjc2i">devious long-term scheme</a> that would ultimately lead to a Trump dictatorship.</p><p>I strongly disagree.</p><p>This regime and its unstable leader are not systematically implementing a masterplan. I don’t say this to downplay the threat. In fact, it is imperative we confront the distinct dangers we face. What we are dealing with is chaotic destruction wrought by an increasingly delusional wannabe-dictator who leads a comically incompetent government and a movement drowning in its own conspiratorial hyperreality. They will continue to escalate because they are ideologically, temperamentally, and psycho-politically incapable of anything else. But there is no strategic genius at work here.</p><p>If we suspect coherence and foresight as the main drivers behind what Trump and the extremists around him are doing, we fail to understand the inner thinking of this regime. If we insist there must be strategic deliberation underneath the escalating chaos, we risk sanitizing what this government is doing and what fuels the man who leads it. Although borne out of an understandable impulse to emphasize the authoritarian threat, this nevertheless constitutes a form of sanewashing that does not help us counter the Trumpist threat. The man who is president is acutely dangerous; his dictatorial desires are limitless. But he does not have a plan.</p><p>So, let’s first examine why the assumption that everything this regime does is strategic in nature, either deliberately deceptive or part of a devious masterplan, is utterly implausible – and why other frameworks are a lot more helpful in grappling with the escalating chaos. And let us then investigate why so many pundits and commentators are nevertheless clinging to the idea that everything the MAGA regime does is a clever distraction or comes out of a carefully executed “playbook” – and what makes the assumption that there must be a secret scheme behind Trump’s actions so attractive, despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary?</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/70c12168-9b07-44a1-aadc-a4ced5a2d5aa">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/70c12168-9b07-44a1-aadc-a4ced5a2d5aa/uploads/images/wstfhfh5qz/351C4F83-E5D2-43CC-86F3-2ABC9E3451E8_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/70c12168-9b07-44a1-aadc-a4ced5a2d5aa</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">70c12168-9b07-44a1-aadc-a4ced5a2d5aa</guid>
      <pubDate>Sat, 11 Apr 2026 10:01:08 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[No Right Is Ever Safe – but Progress Is Possible]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The outrageous assault on birthright citizenship should prompt us to reflect on the fragility of democratic progress - and our own responsibility to defend it]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The outrageous assault on birthright citizenship should prompt us to reflect on the fragility of democratic progress - and our own responsibility to defend it</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, April 4, 2026</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/0999474f-9069-4edc-8afa-14ba857741fa">Listen on Steady</a></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/0999474f-9069-4edc-8afa-14ba857741fa/uploads/images/lkog7gvujk/iStock-1138674928.png?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>credit: iStock / zimmytws</figcaption></figure><p><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is my main source of income as an independent writer. If you are reading the free version of this newsletter, I sincerely appreciate your time and effort engaging with my work. Please share it widely to help me reach new readers.</em></p><p><em>And if you can, please consider becoming a </em><strong><em>paid member</em></strong><em>. You will gain access to special benefits – including many additional essays and the chance to download the audio versions of all my pieces in podcast form.</em></p><p><em>Most importantly, Democracy Americana is a publication solely funded by readers. I need your support to continue this work. Thank you!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p></p><p>“We shall repeal the twentieth century.”</p><p>In January 1992, libertarian economist Murray Rothbard delivered a rousing speech before a group of prominent rightwingers <a href="https://thebaffler.com/salvos/the-year-the-clock-broke-ganz">gathered in a hotel near Washington, DC</a>. It was a momentous occasion. Something was brewing on the far right. The radical wing of the Republican Party was uniting behind self-identifying “paleoconservative” Pat Buchanan and gearing up for a revolt against the establishment. Buchanan had just announced he was challenging President George H.W. Bush for the Republican presidential nomination in the upcoming GOP primaries. He was the guest of honor and the keynote speaker for the event. But that night near DC, this was Rothbard’s crowd.</p><p>Murray Rothbard was a fairly obscure figure for most of his life. He was too extreme for institutions that had any ambition to reach the mainstream, and so he lingered on the fringes. But as the paleo-revolt gained momentum, Rothbard rose with it as one of its intellectual mentors and one of Buchanan’s close advisors.</p><p>Rothbard often described himself as a “paleo-libertarian” – but most importantly, he was not a “conservative.” That label he rejected. In fact, he despised the conservative establishment and the formerly liberal neo-conservatives almost as much as he hated what he called the “loony left.” Rothbard was a man of the “radical right,” he insisted, a “radical reactionary.”</p><p>In the speech he delivered that night – later published in essay form under the title <a href="https://mises.org/library/book/irrepressible-rothbard">“A Strategy for the Right”</a> – Rothbard outlined his truly radical vision and what he imagined as the pathway to implement it. The problem, as Rothbard saw it, was that the “loony left” (the liberals, social-democrats, socialists, Marxists, Communists… they were basically all the same to him) had taken over America and destroyed everything that was worth conserving. To undo the damage, Rothbard demanded the “total abolition of the New Deal state”; he also wanted to abolish modern democracy and the civil rights order – which he considered an outrageous federal overreach in service of an ideology of “victimology.”</p><p>The problem, Rothbard explained, was that the leftists and liberals had completely taken over all elite institutions, and those liberal elites were now controlling the masses with the help of intellectuals and professors. In response, the Right needed to unite behind a “charismatic leader who has the ability to short-circuit the media elites, and to reach and rouse the masses directly.” Once such a leader was found, anything was possible. Rothbard felt inspired by the fall of the Soviet Union which had officially dissolved mere weeks before he gave his speech: It seemed to indicate that even the evilest systems could indeed be brought down. As Rothbard’s speech reached its crescendo, he revealed his vision of counter-revolutionary change: “We shall break the clock of social democracy. We shall break the clock of the Great Society. We shall break the clock of the welfare state. We shall break the clock of the New Deal. We shall break the clock of Woodrow Wilson&#39;s New Freedom and perpetual war. We shall repeal the twentieth century.”</p><p>It is not a coincidence that Rothbard, who passed away in 1996 at the age of 69, had a revival on the alt-right and among far-right thinkers just when Donald Trump rose to be the Right’s standard-bearer. What Rothbard outlined thirty-five years ago succinctly captures both the strategy of “rightwing populism” as well as the animating vision of the Trumpist Right. “We shall repeal the twentieth century.” It sounds outlandish. To most people who aren’t professionally obligated to analyze the extreme Right, it must seem bizarre that anyone would really be devoted to such a brutally retrograde idea. But the forces that elevated Donald Trump to political power are indeed committed to precisely this project. As they currently control the government of the United States, one of the two major parties, and about half the states, no measure of social, political, and legal advancement of the past one hundred and fifty years – nothing the mainstream would broadly consider “progress” – is safe. </p><p><strong>The assault on birthright citizenship</strong></p><p>I kept thinking about this as the Trumpist regime’s outrageous attempt to change the constitution and nullify a core element of the 14th amendment was debated before the nation’s highest court this week. On Wednesday, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Trump v. Barbara, considering an executive order Trump issued on his first day back in the White House that excludes the children of undocumented immigrants from birthright citizenship.</p><p>The good news is that this seems <a href="https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2026/04/trump-shows-up-supreme-court-birthright-citizenship-fail.html">a bit much even for this Roberts Court</a>. Four of the six rightwing justices seemed rather skeptical of the preposterous arguments the Trump administration was presenting (while Thomas and Alito appear, of course, open to run with whatever Trump puts before them).</p><p>We’ll take whatever win we can get. But the fact that this is now a debate at all is bizarre. The whole thing is obscene: Trump’s blatantly unconstitutional order, his attempt to rewrite the Constitution via presidential decree, as well as any attempt <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/04/01/opinion/birthright-citizenship-supreme-court-14th-amendment.html">to launder this white nationalist assault</a> on pluralism and equality into respectability.</p><p>The assault on birthright citizenship is obviously part of the Right’s much broader attempt to redefine citizenship and national identity in service of an exclusionary white nationalist vision.</p><p>It is, at its core, not merely a policy dispute or a disagreement over constitutional interpretation. It is a battleground in the struggle over what this nation should be, what its identity, its defining aspiration should be going forward. </p><p>In a narrow sense, the birthright citizenship clause – the first sentence in Section 1 of the 14th Amendment – was intended to guarantee citizenship for freed slaves. But those who amended the Constitution knew exactly that its implications went far beyond that. It constituted a repudiation of the Supreme Court’s 1857 decision in Dredd Scott that Black people couldn’t be citizens because they were inferior and they didn’t have the necessary hereditary connection – and, more generally, a profound rejection of the notion that some people, because of heritage and blood, had more of a claim to being “American” than others.</p><p>The Trumpist assault is so preposterous not only because the text of the Amendment is clear – but also because the framers explicitly debated the fact that this clause would bestow guaranteed citizenship not just upon freed slaves, but to lots of other groups as well. No tiered citizenship in America: That is what the 14th Amendment declares. But a polity that excludes anyone who doesn’t fit certain ethno-religious criteria or relegates them to lesser status is exactly the vision that animates the Trumpist Right.</p><p>Even if it looks like the white nationalist assault will, for now, fail: Birthright citizenship is no longer safe. Something that was – and should have remained! – entirely removed from the realm of contestation, unchallenged as the fundamental law of the land, is now very much contested. And that is an urgent warning: No right is safe.</p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><strong>Rolling back progress</strong></p><p>It’s not like we needed another reminder that all the hard-fought rights and civil liberties that turned the United States into anything approaching a pluralistic democracy are at risk – or that taking refuge in the idea that “they wouldn’t go <em>that</em> far” is utterly foolish.</p><p>Right until the Roberts Court stripped roughly half the population of reproductive freedom and the right to bodily self-determination in the Dobbs decision in the summer of 2022, “they won’t go <em>that</em> far” was the reflexive position an industry of self-described Very Serious People had taken for literally decades. With Dobbs, America joined the very <a href="https://www.axios.com/2022/05/05/only-3-countries-have-rolled-back-abortion-rights-since-1994">short list of countries</a> that have restricted existing abortion rights since the 1990s, when the overall trend internationally certainly had been towards a liberalization of abortion laws. It was a basically unique development in U.S. history: While the Supreme Court had often upheld and codified a discriminatory status quo, it had <a href="https://heathercoxrichardson.substack.com/p/may-3-2022?s=r">never actively and officially abolished</a> what had previously been recognized as a constitutionally guaranteed right.</p><p>The overturning of Roe v. Wade and Planned Parenthood v. Casey really shouldn’t have come as a surprise to anyone. It constituted the culmination of half a century of conservative legal activism, and rejecting Roe had been a key element of conservative political identity for decades. But so much time had passed: The matter seemed not only settled legally but had come to define lived reality. Would they really dare to upend that? We got our answer.</p><p>Dobbs was part of a comprehensive counter-mobilization against the drive towards multiracial, pluralistic democracy. The Right is targeting the post-1960s civil rights order and the legislation it was built on. And they have been massively successful at hollowing out both the 1964 Civil Rights Act as well as the Voting Rights Act of 1965.</p><p>Since the minute it was passed, the modern Right has searched for ways to undermine the Voting Rights Act – with the Supreme Court often acting as the spearhead of those attempts. In Shelby County v Holder in 2013, finally, the Roberts Court threw out much of Section 5 of the VRA, which required jurisdictions with a history of racial discrimination to acquire pre-clearance from the federal government for any change in voting laws. Even though the 15th amendment clearly instructs Congress to pass legislation to prevent racial discrimination in voting, Roberts simply declared that the legislation Congress had passed – and had just extended for another 25 years by <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2006/07/21/washington/21vote.html">a vote of 98-0 in the Senate in 2006</a>! – exceeded the powers of Congress. Just like that. In response, Republican-led states have since passed hundreds of discriminatory voting laws.</p><p>And the Roberts Court isn’t done yet. We will get a decision in Callais v Louisiana before the summer. <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2025/oct/16/supreme-court-voting-rights-act">Based on how the oral arguments in October went</a>, we can expect the Court to throw out what’s left of the VRA, the prohibition of racial gerrymandering to dilute the Black vote. The Voting Rights Act will be functionally nullified.</p><p>Meanwhile, the MAGA government is hard at work nullifying the 1964 Civil Rights Act – by simply <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/06/27/magazine/trump-civil-rights-law-discrimination.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share&amp;referringSource=articleShare">no longer enforcing it</a>. In fact, this government now considers any attempt to enforce it a form of illegal discrimination against white people. They are not merely targeting any specific nondiscrimination measures or regulations. They are <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2025/02/28/doge-trump-civil-rights-office-closing-eeoc/?pwapi_token=eyJ0eXAiOiJKV1QiLCJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJyZWFzb24iOiJnaWZ0IiwibmJmIjoxNzQwNzE4ODAwLCJpc3MiOiJzdWJzY3JpcHRpb25zIiwiZXhwIjoxNzQyMDk3NTk5LCJpYXQiOjE3NDA3MTg4MDAsImp0aSI6IjQ2MWYzMWZmLTdjYmUtNDQxMS1iNzA4LWI3MTA2MmE3OWU3MSIsInVybCI6Imh0dHBzOi8vd3d3Lndhc2hpbmd0b25wb3N0LmNvbS9uYXRpb24vMjAyNS8wMi8yOC9kb2dlLXRydW1wLWNpdmlsLXJpZ2h0cy1vZmZpY2UtY2xvc2luZy1lZW9jLyJ9.QJkamYpMdxpDhqxZtHvtDS6vPHqc6K7-exiIMntAcwI">systematically demolishing the whole apparatus</a> created to implement the Civil Rights Act. Across the federal government, offices tasked with enforcing civil rights and anti-discrimination laws are being dismantled. Anything that could serve as an instrument to level discriminatory hierarchies must be destroyed. With the civil rights revolution of the 1960s, the federal government assumed the role of an engine of democratization, often in direct conflict with the states. But no more: The federal government is now in the hands of the reaction.</p><p>Where will this end? “We shall repeal the twentieth century.” Activists, influencers, and pundits on the Right are more and more openly demanding <a href="https://www.liberalcurrents.com/women-should-make-babies-not-vote-why-some-on-the-far-right-want-to-repeal-the-19th-amendment/">the 19th amendment be repealed</a>: Their project of subjugating women and entrenching patriarchal dominance won’t be complete until women have lost the right to vote. The modern state and all its attempts to shield the people from the worst excesses of the modern capitalist economy: That also needs to go. On the state level, Republicans are hellbent on <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/mar/22/child-labor-protections-republicans">rolling back child labor laws and regulations</a> – the majority of Republican-led states have already enacted such <a href="https://www.epi.org/research/child-labor/">“deregulations.”</a></p><p>The goal, ultimately, is to undo the very foundations of the social and political progress America has experienced over the past century and a half. That is why the Right is assaulting the 14th amendment, in particular. They want to turn the clock back to <em>before</em> the Reconstruction Amendments. That doesn’t mean re-instituting slavery, exactly. But it means re-orienting the government towards privileging the rights and powers of certain (white, Christian, patriarchal) groups, of those who are already at the top – and away from acting (very broadly speaking) as an engine of racial and social progress and egalitarianism, which was only possible on the basis of the amendments passed in the wake of the Civil War. </p><p>No right, no measure of progress is safe. And here we need to widen our focus even more, beyond civil rights and civil liberties: This is also how Robert Kennedy Jr.’s bizarre crusade against America’s public health infrastructure ties into the broader project of the Right. At its core, “Make America Healthy Again” is an assault on modern medicine, modern science – on some of the pillars of modern society itself.</p><p></p><p><em>Before you continue, can I bother you for a minute?</em></p><p><em>Today, you are reading a free article that I am making available to everyone. I would love to continue to offer these essays for a broad audience. However, long-form pieces like this take a ton of time and effort to research, write, and edit.</em></p><p><em>As an independent writer, I rely on the revenue generated by paid memberships as my main source of income. If you are a frequent reader of Democracy Americana, I am certain you will benefit greatly from a paid membership. I publish additional member-exclusive essays every week - and members can also download the audio versions of all my writing in podcast form wherever you get your podcasts.</em></p><p><em>Most importantly, if you value this independent work, please know that it is your support and your generosity that is making it possible.</em></p><p><em>And if a paid membership is currently not an option for you, there are other ways to help: Word-of-mouth is essential, and personal recommendations have an enormous impact. So, please share this piece on social media or tell a family member, a friend, a neighbor, a colleague about Democracy Americana. Thank you!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p></p><p><strong>Why no measure of progress is ever safe</strong></p><p>The anti-democratic, anti-modern forces on the Right have been able to advance much further, and much more rapidly, than even most critical observers would have expected. That should prompt us to reconsider certain pillars of the liberal understanding of America’s history and society – and I am using the term “liberal” in the broadest sense here to include anyone who has subscribed to a certain mainstream perspective on America’s past and present.</p><p>First of all, we need to adjust what you might describe as a progress-liberal theory of change. It is imperative we grapple with the fact that the democratizing achievements since the 1960s have not been manifestations of a broad societal consensus. They didn’t follow “organically” from successful efforts to persuade all but the fringe. They had to be imposed against massive reactionary resistance.</p><p>The question of whether or not the nation should even aspire to be a pluralistic democracy has continued to define the political conflict since the 1960s, and those who rejected that vision have not been confined to the fringes. The Civil Rights Act <em>not</em> as the culmination of noble egalitarian ambitions but as a fateful turn in the wrong direction: That is the defining position on today’s political Right far beyond the rabid MAGA base. Versions of this are articulated constantly by rightwing activists and politicians. It has become dogma in the reactionary intellectual sphere as well, where it has been quite in vogue to write <a href="https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/The-Age-of-Entitlement/Christopher-Caldwell/9781501106910">whole books</a> about why the Civil Rights Act is bad and needs to be rolled back. The Trumpists didn’t depart from a previously stable democratic consensus. They represent the radical wing of a rightwing coalition that was never on board with egalitarian principles and democratic pluralism.</p><p>Secondly, mainstream America has long underestimated the strength of anti-modern beliefs and resentments. In a much-cited essay titled <a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/2167281?seq=1">“The Problem of American Conservatism,”</a> historian Alan Brinkley warned in the mid-1990s that a liberal perspective assuming America to be a consensually “modern” nation had significant blind spots. A fundamentally anti-modern worldview as well as a social reality and political culture defined by anti-modern sentiment, Brinkley argued, was much more prevalent than most people cared to acknowledge. These weren’t just the “losers” on the fringes either, those merely slow to adapt or simply frustrated because they felt left behind socio-economically. There was a whole segmented part of society that was truly and authentically not on board with “modern” society and all its many progressive achievements – a different America “so profoundly at odds with what many Americans have come to believe are the uncontested assumptions of modern Western society.”</p><p>We should always remember that these forces of reaction do not have the support of the majority. They may claim to be representing the “will of the people” all they want, but they are ultimately pursuing a minoritarian project. Abortion bans, for instance, are not popular at all. At the time of the Dobbs decision, for instance, <a href="https://www.prri.org/spotlight/most-oppose-overturning-roe-v-wade-widespread-confusion-over-a-post-roe-world/?utm_source=pocket_mylist">about two thirds of the population</a> wanted to keep Roe and believed abortion should be legal at least in some cases; <a href="https://twitter.com/billscher/status/1522670972909805569?s=21&amp;t=Wo8jRQ8cZMb9gemZfOinRg">a clear majority supports</a> a law legalizing abortion nationally. Meanwhile, a complete ban – a position many Republican-led states are taking – is favored by less than ten percent of Americans, and that has basically not changed since at least the 1990s. Alas, the Right cares little about the lack of majority support and has proven quite adept at using the counter-majoritarian structural features of America’s political system plus the deep-seated ideas of a white Christian norm (manifesting in all the “heartland” talk, for instance) to its advantage.</p><p><strong>Progress is possible</strong></p><p>Do not mistake any of this to mean that progress is impossible. There has been tremendous progress in certain areas and certain eras of American history!</p><p>The Reconstruction period immediately after the Civil War through the mid- to late 1870s, for instance, was an unprecedented experiment in biracial democracy – brief, but breathtaking in its impact. Amongst white Americans, there was a widespread expectation that formerly enslaved people would probably not know what to do with their newly acquired rights, that it would take time. But in reality, voter turnout among Black people was extremely high. About 2,000 Black men were elected to public office on all levels – Mississippi even sent two Black senators to Congress. South Carolina, the heart of the former Confederacy, elected a majority Black state legislature in 1868. And beyond just politics in a narrow sense, African American social and cultural life soared in those years. Here was the glimpse of what an actually democratic society might look like.</p><p>It did not last, however. America’s first attempt at biracial democracy was quickly drowned in ostensibly “race-neutral” laws and almost unimaginable levels of white reactionary violence.</p><p>However, the constitutional amendments on which that democratization was built had a more lasting impact, no matter how hard the white nationalist reaction tried to ignore them. As the historian Eric Foner put it, the Reconstruction amendments “transformed the Constitution from a document primarily concerned with federal-state relations and the rights of property into a vehicle through which members of vulnerable minorities could stake a claim to substantive freedom and seek protection against misconduct by all levels of government.” Foner convincingly argues that this transformation was so profound that it amounted to what he calls the <a href="https://wwnorton.com/books/the-second-founding">“Second Founding.”</a></p><p>The civil rights revolution of the 1950s and 60s was built on those amendments. It certainly did not magically turn the country into a democratic paradise overnight. But it both represented and sparked a serious, prolonged effort to extend the democratic promise beyond just white America.</p><p>If you want to consider a less precise, but in many ways tangible measurement of racial and social progress: Watch movies and TV shows from the 1980s and 90s. There are exceptions, of course. But the base level of casual homophobia, sexism, and racism that permeated cultural production and all spheres of American life even just a few decades ago was stark.</p><p>You know who understands that racial and social progress has been real? The American Right. Their radicalization has been fueled by a pervasive sense of being under siege. That’s the paradox at the heart of the current political situation: Yes, democracy is in grave danger because reactionary forces are on the offensive. But they are not attacking out of a sense of strength, but because they are feeling their backs against the wall. And they are reacting to something real. America has indeed become less white, less Christian, more pluralistic – it had, in many ways, moved closer to fulfilling the promise of multiracial, pluralistic democracy. That is precisely why the leaders of the Right are obsessed with the idea that they have so little time left to save the nation from the leftist assault – and why there is no line they don’t feel justified to cross.</p><p><em>Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work. Please know that I am immensely grateful for your generosity!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><strong>Rethinking progress</strong></p><p>Let us rethink our idea of progress in history so that we will be better equipped to defend it. The realization of how fragile democratizing progress is should make us appreciate and celebrate it more, not less. Only if we value the progress that has been achieved do we understand what we must defend. But nothing is ever guaranteed, there is no linear progression, no end goal we are somehow destined to reach.</p><p>You may object that in the long run, things do certainly get better, do they not? Well, even that is a matter of perspective and timeframe. If you compare the 1890s or even 1950s to today (or to pre-January 2025, at least), then yes, absolutely, America is a much more democratic, fairer society. But what if we set the temporal parameters differently: What if we compare the situation of anyone who was not white in 1930, 1940, or even 1950 to the height of Reconstruction? Tens of millions of people lived their entire lives in those decades. The America they experienced was not a democracy; it wasn’t getting better. In fact, they would have been told stories of that brief but marvelous moment, right after the Civil War, when “We” experienced democracy (a very different “We” then the exceptionalist “We” that speaks of America’s glorious democratic tradition going back hundreds of years).</p><p>Let us also grapple properly with the fact that no progress is irrevocable. There is a pervasive idea of history unfolding in “breakthroughs” – that once society has reached a certain line, it has passed a point of no return. In the dominant mainstream narrative about U.S. history, the civil rights revolution of 1964/65 is generally framed as such a moment. Wasn’t this, finally, when the country came to a conclusive decision to go full steam ahead towards true democracy? But, again, there is something to be learned from those who rejected that progress. The staunchly anti-democratic, anti-egalitarian, anti-pluralistic forces didn’t vanish into thin air or meekly accept defeat. They mobilized.</p><p>The actual takeaway here is that we must not assume directionality in history at all. There is no arc, and there definitely is no ironclad law of the universe that says “We” can’t slide back – or slide forward into a new kind of authoritarianism.</p><p>Courageous people have achieved marvelous things, often at incredible risk and devastating personal cost.<strong> </strong>But we must accept that things can change – in either direction: It really could get much, much worse. But it could also get better. There is nothing inevitable about either doom or progress. We are neither fated nor guaranteed to experience the status quo for all eternity. There is something deeply unsettling about this realization: There is no moral arc of the universe, progress can always be reversed, victories are never guaranteed to last. But it should also be empowering and, at the very least, create the sense of urgency that is needed to defend democracy and propel America forward.</p><p><strong>No “end of history”</strong></p><p>At the end of the Cold War, just when Murray Rothbard proclaimed that the time was ripe for the radical Right to “repeal the twentieth century,” the political establishment bought into a complacent sense of liberal democracy’s inevitability.</p><p>Whatever else there is to say about Francis Fukuyama famously (or infamously) diagnosing the <a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/24027184">“end of history”</a> as the Berlin Wall was about to fall, he captured something crucial about this particular moment in the “West”: It was hard for mainstream observers to imagine anything but a liberal democratic future, a perpetuated status quo; most contemporaries quickly discounted the upheavals of the early 1990s as just a blip. The political center eagerly bought into the posthistorical framework, the center-left parties that rose to power on either side of the Atlantic in the first post-Cold War decade certainly acted and governed as if the grand ideological struggles for a better world were a thing of the past, and all that was left to do was to manage efficiently, with the right kind of expertise – a non-ideological, non-political politics.</p><p>The biggest blind spot of the pervasive post-historical thinking was that it vastly overestimated the extent to which liberal democracy, in the form it existed across the “West,” was actually satisfying every individual’s desire to be recognized as equal. In the early nineteenth century, German philosopher Georg Friedrich Wilhelm Hegel had defined history as a series of conflicts or contradictions over what idea, what societal and political order would best satisfy this human desire for recognition. In his 1989 essay (and three years later in a book), Fukuyama argued that this struggle was over, as humanity had found the answer in liberal democracy, and no serious competitor remained that could reasonably claim to have any sort of comparably universal appeal for humankind. Therefore, with the end of the Cold War, humanity was witnessing the “end of history.”</p><p>But this diagnosis underestimated the severity of the conflict surrounding the claims for true equality, and how much resistance, “backlash,” and counter-mobilization the idea of equality engendered once it was extended beyond straight white men and beyond a formalistic understanding of equality to all spheres of life: the family, the public square, gender relations. It is not an external authoritarian foe, but the internal conflict over whether or not all human beings – regardless of race, gender, religion, and wealth – should indeed have a right to be recognized as equal that is threatening the democratic project itself. A sizeable portion of the electorate in most “Western” countries is evidently not on board with that vision, drawn to illiberal ideas that maintain certain hierarchies: between white people and people who are not white; between men and women; between Christians and people who are not Christian, between those who adhere to a binary understanding of gender and those who don’t.</p><p>Far from enshrining liberal democracy forever, the end of the Cold War actually created the conditions for a more open, more explicit anti-democratic politics to (re-) gain mainstream credibility. For the assembled paleo-conservatives who were enthusiastically cheering on Murray Rothbard’s speech in 1992 just as for the leaders of Trumpism today, democracy – any attempt of leveling what they insisted were “natural” hierarchies – was and is the real enemy. To them, liberal democracy wasn’t the end of history, it was the end of the only version of America they were willing to accept. </p><p>And so, they resolved to fight it. Let us believe them when they say they want to “repeal the twentieth century.” Now it is up to those who abhor such a retrograde order to respond. The fate of democracy may well be decided by whether enough people can be convinced to defend the vision of democratic pluralism with equal ferocity and conviction.</p><p> </p><p><strong><em>Thank you for reading – and please know that I am deeply grateful for your support and your generosity!</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Democracy Americana is my main source of income as an independent writer. Want to support my work? Consider becoming a paid member:</em></strong></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/0999474f-9069-4edc-8afa-14ba857741fa/uploads/images/lkog7gvujk/iStock-1138674928.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/0999474f-9069-4edc-8afa-14ba857741fa</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">0999474f-9069-4edc-8afa-14ba857741fa</guid>
      <pubDate>Sat, 04 Apr 2026 11:20:53 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[What I am Learning from You]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[A reflection on what you have told me this week – about a sense of exasperation with politics, the search for ways out of this mess, and the longing for optimism]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>A reflection on what you have told me this week – about a sense of exasperation with politics, the search for ways out of this mess, and the longing for optimism amidst all the dark chaos</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, March 27, 2026</em></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/81aeedda-914b-4278-9577-7c2850965471/uploads/images/a36in37d6s/iStock-1294554911.png?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>credit: iStock / tonefotografia</figcaption></figure><p><em>The intro to this piece is free for everyone. If you want to read more than the preview or gain access to the audio version of the newsletter, please consider becoming a paid member of Democracy Americana, which is solely funded by readers and constitutes my main source of income as an independent writer.</em></p><p><em>Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work. Please know that I am immensely grateful for your generosity!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p>Dear all,</p><p>This is not a regular post, but a quick follow-up to the piece I wrote earlier this week – and an attempt to respond to the many messages I have received from you. I promise I’ll try to keep it somewhat brief.</p><p>As you’ll recall, after six months of writing Democracy Americana full time, I was giving you an update on how it’s been going, on the state of the newsletter, and on the challenges of making it work as an independent writer. I have received a ton of messages in response. Between all the comments under the piece, direct messages across all the social media sites, and emails, I believe I have heard directly from over ten percent of my paying subscribers / members. That may not constitute a representative sample in a strict statistical sense, but it certainly is a significant response. And there are certain recurring themes in what you have told me that I find extremely important. I wasn’t planning on writing a follow-up, but as I have been making may way through all the messages (and if you haven’t heard back from me, I promise: you will!), I am feeling the urge to reflect a little bit on what you are telling me.</p><p>Let me start here: Almost all the messages I have received have been extremely kind and supportive. Some of the feedback was critical – but in a thoughtful, considerate, productive way. And so many of you have really put in significant time and effort to engage with me. I could not possibly ask for more. I am humbled and grateful. A little overwhelmed, honestly – mostly in a good way, because I am frankly not used to this kind of outpouring of support. And I just want to say: Thank you. I hope that you all know that your support means a lot to me. I feel honored to write for you, and I take that responsibility very seriously.</p><p>I am also a little bit overwhelmed because there is so much to grapple with, so much to ponder in your replies and comments. I am very much still in the middle of reflecting on everything you have told me. Here are some recurring themes in your messages: A general news fatigue and a sense of being exasperated with politics (and the political media landscape), a frustration with “How we got here” pieces that don’t address the question of how we get out, and a longing for hope and optimism amidst all the dark chaos. If you’ll indulge me, I’d like to share some thoughts on what I am learning from you - and what I am taking away from your feedback.</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/81aeedda-914b-4278-9577-7c2850965471">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/81aeedda-914b-4278-9577-7c2850965471/uploads/images/a36in37d6s/iStock-1294554911.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/81aeedda-914b-4278-9577-7c2850965471</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">81aeedda-914b-4278-9577-7c2850965471</guid>
      <pubDate>Fri, 27 Mar 2026 12:22:06 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[I Need Your Support]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[On the state of Democracy Americana after six months, the pitfalls of the newsletter economy – and what the future holds for this independent publication]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>On the state of Democracy Americana after six months, the pitfalls of the newsletter economy – and what the future holds for this independent publication</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, March 24, 2026</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/1be0a062-ec92-4944-9eca-4d601ce8ae26">Listen on Steady</a></p><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/1be0a062-ec92-4944-9eca-4d601ce8ae26/uploads/images/od7o2el4q6/SocMediaBanner.png?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><p>Dear Readers,</p><p>It has been exactly six months since I started a new career as an independent writer – since I made Democracy Americana the focus of my work and the main source of my income.</p><p>I set out on this new path in the midst of a series of life-changing transitions. Last summer, my family and I left the United States where we had lived the past five – and six of the past seven – years; we left the only house my two kids remembered as home. And I left academia after eleven years as a full-time professor and almost 18 years of teaching at the university level.</p><p>As we decided to follow my wife’s career and settle in Hamburg, in the north of Germany, I made a big bet that this newsletter would provide the basis for a sustainable independent career. At the outset, I gave myself twelve months to figure out if I could make it work. I am now halfway through this first year, and I would like to give you an update on the state of this experiment, on what I am – what we are, together – trying to build here, and on why, as of this moment, the future of Democracy Americana is still uncertain.</p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p>These kinds of personal reflections are inevitably somewhat self-indulgent, and I know that’s not for everybody. I promise I will do this sparingly (and not again until at least six months from now), and we’ll return to our regular programming later this week. If this isn’t your cup of tea, let me suggest that you just read the abstract / TL;DR version below – and then jump straight to Part II at the bottom of this post, where I am outlining some of my plans for the future of Democracy Americana and what topics, questions, and themes I will be focusing on over the next few months.</p><p>I you are continuing to read, please know that I am grateful for your interest and patience. Since I am asking you for your financial support, I think it is only fair to be as transparent as possible. And along the way, I believe my own experience may also provide some insight into the newsletter industry as well as the economic, technological, and online platform realities that are shaping / constraining the landscape for independent writers and journalists.</p><p><strong>So, here is the short / TL;DR version of where things stand:</strong></p><p>After six months, Democracy Americana has not reached sustainability yet – and as of right now, it is an open question if I can get it there. The newsletter has really struggled to attract new subscribers since I left Substack last September - while the monthly churn (existing subscribers canceling their subscriptions) has gone up significantly. My readership now shrinks with every piece I publish. You don’t need to know much about the newsletter business to see how that math doesn’t work over the long-term.</p><p>Meanwhile, I am still gaining new <em>paid</em> subscribers – or “members,” as they are called on Steady, the platform that hosts Democracy Americana; but the growth of members is also slowing down considerably. Even if I figure out a way to stabilize the subscriber base, I would need to bring up the conversion rate of free-to-paid subscriptions to about five percent of all subscribers paying for a membership. Right now, I am fairly far off that goal of five percent. To compensate, I would need to grow the overall pool of subscribers to get to the necessary number of paid subscriptions even at a lower conversion rate. Alas, the opposite is currently happening.</p><p>Over the next six months I will need to figure out a way to reverse those trends. If you regularly read Democracy Americana, please consider helping me do that. I totally understand not everyone can afford to chip in. But there are other ways to help: Word-of-mouth is essential, and personal recommendations have an enormous impact. So, please tell a family member, a friend, a neighbor, a colleague about Democracy Americana.</p><p>And if you are in a financial position to do so, please consider becoming a paid member.</p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><strong>The state of Democracy Americana, Part I: On being an independent writer (and the pitfalls of the newsletter business)</strong></p><p>When I re-launched Democracy Americana at a new platform called “Steady” last September and started my new life as a full-time independent writer, <a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/ab02af47-9e87-4143-ba51-afa2d1804c1c">I wrote about</a> the changes in my private and professional life that had led me to that point. However, a lot of new subscribers have joined since. And many of those who had already been on board when I sent out what you might call my mission statement may have still missed it, since we encountered some rather unfortunate server issues in the beginning, which meant the launch post only ever went out to a fraction of my readership. So, please allow me to re-introduce myself.</p><p>I was trained as a historian and have spent almost my entire adult life studying, researching, and teaching political history in Germany, England, and the United States. Before I decided to take the leap and become a full-time writer last summer, I taught international history as a Visiting Professor at Georgetown University in Washington, DC for five years; before that, I was Assistant Professor for contemporary history at Freiburg University in Germany. I received my PhD from Freiburg in 2015 and my MPhil from Cambridge University in England in 2007.</p><p>My academic work focused on anti-democratic tendencies and impulses on the American Right as well as the relationship between mainstream conservatism and the Far Right since the 1930s. As you might imagine, when Trump first took over the Republican Party and then rose to the presidency, I had thoughts… or rather questions that I believed were of more than purely academic interest: Where did Trumpism come from? How can we situate it in the longer-term context of U.S. history? Where does our moment sit in the contested history of the struggle over how much democracy, and for whom, there should be in America? And how is the situation in the United States connected to the inter- and transnational struggle between authoritarian ethno-nationalism and democratic pluralism?</p><p>About halfway through the first Trump administration, I decided it was time for me to intervene publicly and offer whatever I could to help make sense of what was happening around us. I became very active on social media, wrote op-eds, gave public talks, started a podcast... Finally, in November 2022, I launched Democracy Americana as a way to provide regular long-form commentary and offer historically informed deep dives into our current political and societal conflict. As long as I received a salary from Georgetown, the newsletter was always entirely free.</p><p><strong>Leaving the academy</strong></p><p>At the end of May 2025 my contract at Georgetown University ran out. By that point, I had grown disillusioned with academia. Not with what happens inside the classroom: I have always found teaching to be an immediately rewarding experience. And not with the actual doing research either – that was the best part: the chance to learn, discover, grow as a result. But the academic job market is a mess. I was never tenured or on a tenure track. I couldn’t even tell you exactly how many short-term contracts and appointments I’ve cycled through: I crossed into the double digits many years before I finally left. </p><p>When I became a father for the first time in 2017, I set certain red lines for myself. I wasn’t going to ask my wife to consider her professional and private aspirations as secondary. I wasn’t going to uproot my boys several more times, chasing yet more short-term contracts here or fellowships there.</p><p>At some point over the past few years, I can’t even point to an exact moment, we decided that the best path forward for us as a family was for me to go independent, become a full-time writer, and thereby gain the flexibility to go where my wife’s career would take us and where my kids would have the best possible life growing up.</p><p>This was not an easy decision. I’m a first-generation academic from a tiny village in rural southwest Germany. Getting a PhD, the chance to be a historian for a living, to work and learn with students - it all felt light years away from where/how I grew up. I thought this was going to be my life. But as big of a cesura as this has been for me both professionally as well as biographically, I do not regret my decision, nor do I mourn my academic career. In fact, I feel more content with where I am and what I am doing today than probably ever before.</p><p>I have long admired people who believed in what they had to offer, took the leap to independence, and built their own careers around what drove them. I wasn’t sure if I had that kind of leap in me. I am glad the circumstances gave me a little extra push.</p><p><strong>Leaving America</strong></p><p>It was, strictly from a professional perspective, probably not ideal that I launched my career as a full-time writer focused on American history and politics right after we left the United States. But life in America was simply no longer tenable for us.</p><p>There was a bunch of reasons why we decided to move back to Germany – I want to be clear that this was not solely, or even primarily, about politics. But the political situation certainly played a role.</p><p>Authoritarianism is never distributed evenly. As a straight white man, I was obviously not among the key targets of this regime. But as a foreign national, I increasingly felt my choice was to either continue to intervene publicly, at the increasing risk of potentially making myself and my family a target; or to fall silent, accommodate, ignore the political reality. Don’t go to protests, don’t add your name to any initiative that defends democracy, don’t publish anything too harsh, be careful what you say in the classroom… Unacceptable. Untenable.</p><p>In that situation, we were in an immensely privileged position: As German citizens, we could leave. It is, of course, a choice that is not available to those in the United States directly targeted by the regime, those most vulnerable to MAGA’s aggrieved aggression. When we left last summer, I felt mostly relief and gratitude for the privileged position we were in - mixed with a deep sense of despair, sadness, and anger.</p><p><strong>Leaving Substack</strong></p><p>I needed to move forward. But not on Substack.</p><p>It is well documented that Substack serves as the platform for a whole host of unsavory characters. In late 2023, the work of independent journalist <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/11/substack-extremism-nazi-white-supremacy-newsletters/676156/?gift=QOMQv_-OzUwtM49NPzkD3qrbGPZCc7jGHcdGDSsLNWk&amp;utm_source=copy-link&amp;utm_medium=social&amp;utm_campaign=share">Jonathan Katz</a> uncovered what has since been <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/media/2026/feb/07/revealed-how-substack-makes-money-from-hosting-nazi-newsletters">confirmed over and over again</a>: That a bunch of literal, self-identifying Nazis and white supremacists are using Substack to make money off disseminating their violent ideology. Yet <a href="https://substack.com/@hamish/note/c-45811343?r=1l2ykb&amp;utm_medium=ios&amp;utm_source=notes-share-action">Substack’s leadership</a> proved very reluctant to do anything about it, even describing the continued platforming of such ideas and people as a heroic act of defending “free speech.” That never made any sense, as Substack was always in the business of moderating content, of suppressing and prohibiting some forms of speech while actively elevating others. The most charitable interpretation, at this point, is that Substack has a rather lax attitude towards hosting hate speech, and a tendency to be actively lenient towards the rightwing extremist scene.</p><p>Frankly, I find the politics of the Substack leadership rather abhorrent. And the problem is not <em>just</em>, as Substack defenders will say, a handful of extremist newsletters on the margins. My biggest issue is that Substack insists on actively supporting leading far-right activists and propagandists like Christopher Rufo, Curtis Yarvin, and Richard Hanania – not only platforming, but <a href="https://post.substack.com/p/the-active-voice-richard-hanania">actively promoting</a> them as important thinkers.</p><p>Unsurprisingly, Substack has also pushed Bari Weiss’ “The Free Press” to becoming one of the most successful publications on the platform – enabling Weiss, a disingenuous reactionary grievance entrepreneur, to become one of the regime’s chief apologists. It makes sense that the Silicon Valley tech elite that stands behind Substack has recently <a href="https://davekarpf.substack.com/p/yeah-so-substack-im-out">teamed up with the gambling / betting machine</a>: Never pass on an opportunity to make money by poisoning society some more, I guess.</p><p>I think all of this is bad. And it didn’t feel right to contribute to the success of such a platform.</p><p>I will say, however, that six months after my decision to leave, I am more convinced than ever that people can be a little too quick and casual with their critique of individual writers who publish on Substack. There are wonderful people producing extremely valuable work on Substack. There are <a href="https://donmoynihan.substack.com/">academics</a> who have found a broad public audience for their scholarly insight; <a href="https://www.unpopularfront.news/">leftwing intellectuals</a> who offer the most incisive commentary out there; <a href="https://www.lawdork.com/">independent journalists</a> who provide invaluable coverage of what is happening around us. Some of the <a href="https://www.gelliottmorris.com/">best data and polling analysis in the world</a> is being hosted on Substack.</p><p>These are serious people, with a serious commitment to the democratic struggle. The reason why they have stuck around is, I am assuming, that Substack works. There is no question that it has made life as an independent writer or journalist viable for a lot of people who otherwise almost certainly would not have had that option. If you have built a substantial audience via Substack, and your livelihood depends on it, leaving that behind comes with a risk. If you think I am being overly dramatic, let me tell you that it is still unclear whether Democracy Americana will withstand the significant hit that came with leaving Substack behind – and I’ll come back to that point later.</p><p>However, I still believe leaving was the right thing to do. As <a href="https://www.pbump.net/o/the-power-we-use-and-the-power-we-give/">Philip Bump</a> put it so succinctly in a piece he wrote last August in which he explained why he was <em>not</em> joining Substack: This is about “building power.” Bump had just left the <em>Washington Post</em>, as all good people have; and it would have been easy for him to generate quite a decent income quickly by launching a newsletter on Substack. But Bump insisted: “There is value in helping institutions that are doing good, important work to build their power” – rather than helping Substack and the Silicon Valley elite behind it build its institutional power.</p><p>So, I looked for alternatives and found one in <a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts">Steady</a>. Founded by a group of independent German journalists, Steady is based in Berlin and operates with a small, international team. It is a privately owned, self-funded business, a real refuge from Silicon Valley venture capitalist domination. That felt right to me, as I was hoping to gain a little distance from the near-monopoly of Substack and seeking to de-risk, basically, from my dependence on U.S. tech feudalists.</p><p><em>Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work. Please know that I am immensely grateful for your generosity!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><strong>Democracy Americana is struggling</strong></p><p>So, how has this experiment been going so far?</p><p>Before I break down the hurdles Democracy Americana is facing, let me emphasize something that is very important to me: I do not feel entitled to anyone’s financial support. I feel privileged to be doing this work. And the reality is that this is a tough business, and there is no reason why it shouldn’t be tough for me. I am not trying to guilt and coerce anyone into giving me money they don’t think I deserve or aren’t in a position to give. My goal is to make sure my readers have an adequate understanding of the realities that determine the future of my work.</p><p>As of this morning, Democracy Americana goes out to about 20,000 subscribers, with a little over three percent of them supporting the newsletter financially as paid members. This is almost exactly the same number of total subscribers (free and paid) as six months ago – and that is not good news.</p><p>After three years of consistent growth on Substack, the growth has stalled. In fact, since an initial spike in subscribers last September, fueled by my launch announcement and a lot of support from friends and colleagues who helped me spread the word, the overall number of subscribers has been in steady decline. What happens is that every time I send out a new piece a large number of people unsubscribe in reaction. To some extent, that’s just what happens when you drop a newsletter in people’s email inboxes: You inevitably remind some of them they have a subscription they may not want anymore. But the number of “unsubscribes” that follows every post has drastically gone up since I left Substack. Meanwhile, I am finding it much harder to attract new subscribers.</p><p>What’s changed? Some of this is difficult for me to decipher. Why the number of people who click on “unsubscribe” every time I send out a piece is something like six to seven times higher now, on Steady, than it had previously been on Substack is utterly beyond me, for instance. I just don’t understand it. I have not changed the type of essays I write nor the frequency with which they go out – and yet…</p><p>It seems undeniable to me that the change of platforms played a significant role. Substack very likely exaggerates the effect of its reference and recommendation system - but that system does generate growth. Most importantly, I believe, is the fact that so many millions of people are already on Substack, where subscribing to another newsletter is just one click away. And if someone already has their payment information stored on Substack, upgrading to a paid subscription also takes one click only.</p><p>Meanwhile, I have been trying to convince people to set up an account and enter their information at yet another platform, one that my overwhelmingly American audience is highly unlikely to be familiar with. That has proven to be a much more significant hurdle than I anticipated.</p><p>This may also explain why social media attention no longer translates into new subscribers. I have built a relatively substantial social media presence, and there used to be a direct correlation between successfully promoting a piece or even just posting a thread with some observations on social media and an increase in subscribers. That is no longer the case at all. I always thought people found me on social media and that animated them to subscribe. But that probably wasn’t quite right. The more likely explanation is that social media attention only reminded people who were already on Substack to subscribe to <em>my</em> Substack newsletter as well – while it is much harder to get people to follow you from social media to a new platform.</p><p>One particularly frustrating change I have had to institute is the use of paywalls. When I started, my plan was to continue publishing most of my writing for free and only reserve occasional extra content for paid subscribers. I was hoping, perhaps naively, that with a sizeable (and supposedly growing!) subscriber base of 20,000, enough people would still want to support my work, even if they didn’t <em>have to</em> in order to access it. That has, unfortunately, not worked at all. For quite some time now, free pieces have generated hardly any new paying members – not even enough to replace those who cancel their paid subscriptions. What is especially nasty is that free pieces still cause the same high number of “unsubscribes” – while not even generating any more free subscribers either. It is very hard to justify sending out free pieces, therefore. But while putting most of my writing behind a paywall does generate revenue, it also means I am drastically curtailing my audience. If you believe that you work matters, in whatever small ways – and as a political writer, you must! How on earth could I be doing this work if I didn’t think it had any significance at all? –, this is a big issue.</p><p><strong>Is this newsletter worth your money?</strong></p><p>Some of you may be thinking: We are already thousands of words in, and the author hasn’t even addressed the key questions yet – Is Democracy Americana <em>worth</em> your money? I hesitate. This is a totally fair question. But I truly don’t believe I can properly answer it for you. Let me share my own thinking on this matter.</p><p>First of all, a paid membership gets you additional benefits. While I still intend to publish free pieces regularly, the majority of my writing is now reserved for those who support Democracy Americana financially. Members also have access to the audio versions of all my writing in podcast form – either via an RSS feed that enables you to get the audio version in the podcast player of your choice or via a premium Spotify feed. Members also have the option to discuss all the posts with me and other readers in the comment section. If you are feeling especially generous and consider a “Democracy Ambassador” tier membership, you will get all that – plus two free “Ambassador” passes that you can share with / gift to whoever you think might benefit from reading Democracy Americana.</p><p>Does that package mean a Democracy Americana membership is “worth” the cost? Purely in transactional terms, who am I to make that assessment for you? Sometimes, people reach out to me to tell me they don’t believe Democracy Americana is worth $9 per month or $90 per year when that also gets you a <em>New York Times</em> subscription. And if that is your calculus, then fair enough! </p><p>The question I am most concerned with is this: Does my work add something of value to the political discourse? And that question I feel justified answering with a confident Yes!</p><p>Not counting this piece here, over the past six months I have published about 92,000 words here on Democracy Americana. That means an average essay comes in at about 4,000 words (the median at about 3,900). These are not opinion pieces (for those, a newspaper will usually give you around 900 words or so), I am not firing off some quick takes. These are proper deep dives. Intended for a broader audience, yes – but I take pride in researching and writing them in a way that stands up to academic scrutiny. Others will always be faster or cover the news more broadly. But I don’t think anyone will be more thorough.</p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><strong>The state of Democracy Americana, Part II: Future plans</strong></p><p>This has all been rather gloomy thus far, and that’s not the note I want to end on. Because despite all these very real concerns about the sustainability of what I am trying to build here, I also feel a great deal of excitement about the next steps in this journey. A big reason why the past few months have been such a grind is that I had to deal with so much bureaucracy and spend so much time on the business side of this one-person enterprise – something I had zero experience with and also not something I can claim any great talent for. It’s been a lot of trial and quite a bit of error. But my sense is that I am getting the hang of this, which hopefully frees up time and resources to build Democracy Americana into what I am envisioning it to be.</p><p>I know these long-form essays are a hard sell for some people. Sometimes, I wonder if there is something outrageous about asking people to spend so much time with my work every week. In fact, one of my oldest and closest friends flat-out told me two weeks ago that he stopped reading the newsletter months ago because he simply didn’t have the energy or the nerve to read such pieces. Fair enough.</p><p>I do have some ideas for complimentary formats, both video and audio, that I would love to offer in addition to the long-form essays (more on that soon, in a separate post). But the core identity of Democracy Americana has always been – and will always be – the deep dive.</p><p>The idea behind this newsletter is to offer extensive, historically informed explorations of our current political and societal conflict. So much is happening, on so many levels – it often feels overwhelming, almost disorienting. We need to find ways to gain perspective, a sense of the big picture. I truly believe the mission of Democracy Americana is more important than ever.</p><p>Something I am really excited about is to launch, in addition to the week-to-week reflections on the political conflict, several ongoing series of essays that focus on broader questions and specific themes. The first of these I am tentatively calling: <strong>“Core Texts of Trumpism.”</strong> I will announce the start of this series in more detail soon in a separate post. But basically, I want to look at speeches, essays, and books by rightwing politicians, intellectuals, and activists that I believe anyone should know, because they capture core ideas and sensibilities of today’s Right, because they can help us understand the permission structure that governs rightwing politics. I want to select texts that can provide a window into key dynamics that have shaped the past and present of the modern Right and the relationship between mainstream conservatism and the far right. In every entry in this series, I will choose one such text and explain why it is important, what it helps us understand better about the modern Right since the 1950s or so. Over time, I am hoping to build a virtual library of sorts, focusing on accessible, shorter texts so that you can read them yourselves and follow along as I explore what they can unlock about Trumpism and its antecedents on the Right.</p><p>A second such recurring series I would like to tentatively call <strong>“How Progress Happens in American History.”</strong> Where “Core Texts of Trumpism” is very much preoccupied with the question of how the hell we got to where we are now, this series is about where we might go next, and what we can learn from America’s past about the kind of democratic transformation that the country so desperately needs. My idea is to explore the moments when transformative change happened – after the Civil War, for instance, during the New Deal, or in the 1960s Civil Rights era – and explore what made those leaps possible; the structural conditions that made them feasible; the key actors that seized the moment; the possibilities and limits of imagination in such moments of acute crisis-turned-transformation. Conversely, I also want to look at moments when such transformative change, even though it may have been possible, did not occur – and explore the reasons why the potential was squandered.</p><p>A third idea for a series (and then I’ll leave it at that, as this piece is already far too long!): <strong>“Why We Fight Over the Past.”</strong> This series will closely track the Trumpist assault on history that has already been ramping up – and is certainly about to escalate as we are getting deeper into this anniversary-heavy year. I want to situate this latest escalation in the context of the twenty-first century “history wars,” as “history” – the stories we tell about the past, how we teach it, how we commemorate it – has been at the forefront of the political debate for quite some time. The struggle over “history” is a conflict over national identity and who gets to define it, who gets to define what “America” is and who gets to belong here. As such, the assault on history is an essential part of the Trumpist agenda. These “history wars” have been going on for a long time, of course (the term itself was popularized in the 1990s), and it is worth exploring the longer-term continuities as well as the more recent radicalizations. There is also a transnational dimension here, as similar contestations over the national story have been escalating all across the “West” and wherever authoritarian movements have been on the rise. Understanding the U.S. “history wars” in this broader context will help us understand the stakes in this struggle – and how to respond to the rightwing assault. </p><p><strong>Onward. Forward.</strong></p><p>If you have hopefully made it this far, let me say that I am feeling an overwhelming sense of gratitude: Being able to do this work that I believe is meaningful is deeply gratifying. It is the best job I can imagine, and I promise you I will work as hard as I possibly can to keep building Democracy Americana into something that is worthy of your time, your engagement, and your support. It is your generosity that is making all of this possible.</p><p>Thank you!</p><p>Take care, Thomas</p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/1be0a062-ec92-4944-9eca-4d601ce8ae26/uploads/images/od7o2el4q6/SocMediaBanner.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/1be0a062-ec92-4944-9eca-4d601ce8ae26</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">1be0a062-ec92-4944-9eca-4d601ce8ae26</guid>
      <pubDate>Tue, 24 Mar 2026 11:28:29 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[How the Hell Did We End Up Here?]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[From the failed ethno-nationalist revolt in the early 1990s to the triumph of MAGA extremism - A history of the Republican Party, Part II]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>From the failed ethno-nationalist revolt in the early 1990s to the triumph of MAGA extremism - A history of the Republican Party, Part II</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, March 14, 2026</em></p><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/36887968-d0e1-4693-b4c1-4953912c8435/uploads/images/3lzhewrc3x/merge-jpgs.com_1772146440562.png?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><p><em>This is Part II of a two-part series on the history of the Republican Party. Not a total history of the GOP and the American Right since the 1850s, of course – but an attempt to identify some key moments and dynamics, to come up with a framework for how to think about that crucial question: How the hell did we get here?</em></p><p><em>Part I, which </em><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/ca9ee28e-8da8-48a2-ac80-7a59ddcc1443"><em>you find here</em></a><em>, covered a lot of ground from the GOP’s anti-slavery origins in the middle of the nineteenth century to the party emerging as the parliamentary arm of the American Right, dominated by the conservative movement, by the end of the Cold War. I obviously recommend reading Part I first – but if you want to jump right in here, don’t worry, this second part should also work as a stand-alone exploration of the past forty years of Republican history. So, strap in for: The ethno-nationalist revolt under Pat Buchanan and the GOP’s aggressive embrace of “culture war” politics in the 1990s; the mainstreaming of militant nativism, the hard turn against immigration, and the explicit embrace of the surveillance state after 9/11; the Right’s unhinged reaction to the first Black president and the rise of Donald Trump; and the question of what might become of the Republican Party in the future.</em></p><p><em>The extended intro to this piece is free for everyone. If you want to read more than the preview or gain access to the audio version of the essay, please consider becoming a paid member of Democracy Americana, which is solely funded by readers and constitutes my main source of income as an independent writer.</em></p><p><em>Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work. Please know that I am immensely grateful for your generosity!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p></p><p><strong>A radical revolt after the end of the Cold War</strong></p><p>By the early 1990s, the Republican Party had become a recognizably conservative force on an accelerating rightward trajectory, as the conservative movement had managed to define the GOP’s agenda and identity.</p><p>To an unsuspecting observer, it may not have appeared like that on the surface. After all, Ronald Reagan was succeeded by George H. W. Bush, a distinctly moderate political figure, certainly by today’s standards. However, Bush was very unpopular with the party’s ever ascending radical wing: His centrism on the domestic front they regarded as an anachronism, his foreign policy vision of a <a href="https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/documents/address-before-joint-session-the-congress-the-cessation-the-persian-gulf-conflict">“new world order”</a> characterized by multilateral cooperation they despised as a sellout of America’s true interests. Bush presided over a party whose center of gravity was shifting rapidly away from the mainstream of American society on many key political, social, and cultural issues. Spurred on by the Religious Right, for instance, it was adopting the position of militant anti-abortion activists; the GOP was also embracing a reflexive anti-environmentalism as a key part of its political identity – climate change denialism became a pervasive posture among Republican elected officials.</p><p>More and more, the GOP was devoted to the interests and sensibilities of two constituencies only that were united in a sometimes awkward alliance against liberalism and any attempt to level hierarchies of race, gender, religion, and wealth: A white conservative base that tended to define America – “real America” – as a predominantly white, Christian, patriarchal nation; and a relatively small elite of business people and wealthy donors. Strategically, the Republican Party faced a dilemma: In a pluralizing society that was generally moving away from such a vision for the country, the GOP would either have to find a way to broaden its appeal – or be destined to struggle finding a democratic majority. Republicans, however, were neither willing to widen their focus nor accepted the prospect of relinquishing power. It was the hour of those who favored a third option and identified the constraints of democracy itself as the real problem. They were determined to transform the political system in a way that would allow them to hold on to power without majority support, even against the explicit desire of a growing numerical majority of the electorate.</p><p>Immediately after the end of the Cold War, ethno-nationalist forces inside the Republican Party believed their time had come to stage a revolt against the GOP establishment. Uniting behind Pat Buchanan as their standard bearer, they challenged incumbent President George H. W. Bush in the 1992 Republican primaries. Rightwing pundit Joe Sobran, one of Buchanan’s closest confidants and advisors, <a href="https://thebaffler.com/salvos/the-year-the-clock-broke-ganz">described the project</a> of the self-proclaimed “paleo-conservatives” like this: “Now that democracy has overthrown communism, we can turn to the problem of how to overthrow democracy.”</p><p>Buchanan openly professed an aggressive nationalism and explicitly embraced a vision of white Christian domination. His hostility towards the party leadership endeared him to a conservative movement that emerged frustrated from twelve years of Republican rule in the White House. Instead of actually implementing the rightwing agenda, conservatives bemoaned, Reagan and Bush had caved to establishment pressure and appeased liberal domination.</p><p>But the party elite’s tentativeness and lack of conviction had not been the only obstacle, according to those around Buchanan. They came away from Republican rule in the 1980s convinced that controlling the executive was insufficient on a more profound level: Politics, they believed, was ultimately downstream from culture, so to change the country’s trajectory and roll back the ongoing liberalization of American life before it was too late, the Right needed to change course. Buchanan was instrumental in shifting the Right’s focus more explicitly to what came to be called the “culture wars.”</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/36887968-d0e1-4693-b4c1-4953912c8435">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/36887968-d0e1-4693-b4c1-4953912c8435/uploads/images/3lzhewrc3x/merge-jpgs.com_1772146440562.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/36887968-d0e1-4693-b4c1-4953912c8435</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">36887968-d0e1-4693-b4c1-4953912c8435</guid>
      <pubDate>Sat, 14 Mar 2026 10:48:08 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[From Abraham Lincoln to… Donald Trump?]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[A history of the Republican Party – Part I: From anti-slavery origins to white conservative domination, 1850s to 1990]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>A history of the Republican Party – Part I: From anti-slavery origins to white conservative domination, 1850s to 1990</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, March 8, 2026</em></p><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/ca9ee28e-8da8-48a2-ac80-7a59ddcc1443/uploads/images/n3ztz74xui/merge-jpgs.com_1772146440562.png?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><p><em>This is Part I of a two-part series on the history of the Republican Party. Not a total history of the GOP and the American Right since the 1850s, of course – but an attempt to identify some key moments and dynamics and come up with something that may serve as a framework for how to think about that crucial question: How the hell did we get here?</em></p><p><em>The extended intro to this piece is free for everyone. If you want to read more than the preview or gain access to the audio version of the essay, please consider becoming a paid member of Democracy Americana, which is solely funded by readers and constitutes my main source of income as an independent writer.</em></p><p><em>Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work. Please know that I am immensely grateful for your generosity!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p>It was such a deranged spectacle. On February 24, Donald Trump delivered a speech to a joint session of Congress that combined delusional ravings about his many imaginary achievements with vile threats against MAGA’s enemies – especially against the enemy within, the Democratic Party, who Trump derided as “sick people.” The longest State of the Union address in history – one hour and forty-five minutes of unhinged raging by a bigoted authoritarian with an unsound mind.</p><p>And the party that elevated this man to the most powerful political office in the world? They ate it all up. Congressional Republicans reacted with standing ovations, cheers, and aggressive chants of “U-S-A! U-S-A!” They joined Trump’s vile attacks on Democrats with jeering, booing, and heckling. A party defined by an authoritarian cult of personality. No trace of any residual sense of commitment to something even remotely recognizable as a democratic political culture.</p><p>There are many reasons why the U.S. political system is under pressure, why societal frustration is so widespread, why the trust in the traditional institutions of American political and civic life <a href="https://www.pew.org/en/trend/archive/fall-2024/americans-deepening-mistrust-of-institutions">has been plummeting</a>. But if we want to understand why the republic is on the brink, we must start with the fundamental reality of American politics today: The struggle over whether or not the country should actually be a pluralistic democracy maps onto the conflict between the two major parties. Democracy itself has become a partisan issue. As of right now, the Democratic Party is the country’s sole (small-d) democratic party – while the GOP is firmly in the hands of an ethno-nationalist movement and oligarchic interests that are determined to impose their reactionary vision by increasingly authoritarian measures.</p><p>It is difficult to remember now, but it wasn’t all that long ago that prominent Republican leaders warned against indulging the Trumpian temptation in stark terms: “If we nominate Trump, we will get destroyed,” Republican senator Lindsay Graham infamously <a href="https://x.com/LindseyGrahamSC/status/727604522156228608">posted on Ex-Twitter</a> in May 2016, when Trump was already certain to emerge from the GOP primaries as the Republican presidential nominee, “and we will deserve it.”</p><p>Almost a decade later, Donald Trump is still dominating the Republican Party. He has been the undisputed standard bearer of the American Right for over ten years. And Lindsay Graham? He is still in the Senate and strongly supports Trump. Like most of the Republican officials and operatives who were initially skeptical or even downright hostile towards Trump, Graham quickly fell in line; those who didn’t either retired, retreated from public life, or were swiftly ostracized from the party.</p><p>Today’s GOP is defined by a grotesque cult of personality, bizarre conspiracy theories, and pervasive extremism on all levels – from the base up to the party’s leadership. <a href="https://prri.org/spotlight/after-three-years-and-many-indictments-the-big-lie-that-led-to-the-january-6th-insurrection-is-still-believed-by-most-republicans/">About two thirds</a> of Republican voters say they are convinced Democrats “stole” the 2020 presidential election. The <a href="https://www.americanprogressaction.org/article/a-list-of-maga-republicans-who-took-the-great-replacement-theory-mainstream/">„Great Replacement“ theory</a> – a conspiracy postulating that sinister leftist, “globalist” elites are orchestrating a nefarious plot to “replace” white people, to conduct a “white genocide,” mostly by bringing non-whites to America via uncontrolled immigration, by interracial marriage, by discriminating against whites in general, has long been mainstreamed in the party. Open <a href="https://www.miamiherald.com/news/politics-government/article314928484.html?giftCode=e112c9055466aac4b23e0014dec7577a7c048c1435f2058d1ad02a3b01623558">white supremacism and neo-Nazi</a> ideology are widespread, particularly among a <a href="https://www.politico.com/news/2025/10/14/private-chat-among-young-gop-club-members-00592146?fbclid=IwY2xjawNdIFRleHRuA2FlbQIxMQABHrSn6ozZbtyF3XPmHXp4X_i9ChxqMfiBX1GMPJOp8krhVlFv_oQvTDc5mywp_aem_zaVyqqFdDL-XzS8Orl-j_w">younger cohort of Republican</a> staffers and operatives. They are only following the example set by their leaders. Vice-president JD Vance has close personal ties not only <a href="https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2024/07/18/jd-vance-world-view-sources-00168984">to far-right intellectuals</a> who fantasize about restricting the franchise to men and reintroducing slavery, but also to the extremist online scene.</p><p>The boundaries between the mainstream and the extreme Right have always been porous – but in the Trump era, they have been obliterated completely. Trump himself never left any doubt that he considered the extremists a vital part of his movement. Not when he <a href="https://www.c-span.org/clip/public-affairs-event/user-clip-trump-does-not-repudiate-david-dukes-endorsement/4613272">refused to reject</a> the endorsement of David Duke, the former grand wizard of the Ku Klux Klan, during the Republican primaries in early 2016; not when he signaled <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JmaZR8E12bs">sympathy for the neo-Nazis</a> who violently marched through Charlottesville, Virginia under the banner of “Unite the Right” in the summer of 2017; not when he pardoned the insurrectionists who had stormed the Capitol on January 6, 2021 on his first day back in office. The Republican Party’s political culture, identity, personnel, and ideology are now fully dominated by MAGA.</p><p>I think we can safely ignore the idea that Trump’s rise was merely the result of a temporary delusion, just an accident, a momentary aberration. It has been a while. And the Republican Party steadfastly refuses to take any of the off-ramps that have presented themselves. There was a brief moment of hesitation among party elites after January 6 – but even then, it didn’t take long for Republicans to close ranks behind the man whose months-long attempt to nullify the results of a democratic election had just ended with a violent assault on Congress.</p><p>How did we get here? Or, as an editor at the newspaper <em>Die Zeit</em> put it to me a while ago, as we were discussing the most pressing issues I should be tackling in a regular column I am writing for a German audience: How the hell did the Republican Party go from Abraham Lincoln to Donald Trump?</p><p>I like being confronted with such big-picture questions because they force us to zoom out and step all the way back from the eternal chaos of the Trump experience. It demands perspective, that thing we too often neglect. From Lincoln to Trump. Or, as my friend and fellow historian <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/sethcotlar.bsky.social/post/3mclkovvv7k2k">Seth Cotlar put it in January</a>: From “Radical Republicans ca. 1871: We’re sending federal troops into states in order to curb the power of white supremacy” – to “Radical Republicans ca. 2026: We’re sending federal troops into states in order to advance the cause of white supremacy.”</p><p>It really is quite the trajectory: The party that was founded to fight slavery in the middle of the nineteenth century is now fully in the hands of a white nationalist movement devoted to restoring and entrenching white Christian patriarchal domination across all spheres of American life.</p><p>My goal is obviously not to provide an all-encompassing answer or a total history of the Republican Party and the American Right since the 1850s. Let’s identify some key moments and dynamics – something that may serve as a useful framework for how to think about that crucial question: How the hell did we get here?</p><p>This is the story of how a party with anti-slavery origins first became a “big tent,” then came to be dominated by Modern Conservatism, and has since gone the way of the conservative movement: Taken over by extremists who had always been part of the rightwing coalition, but never so powerful. This outcome was not determined. The anti-democratic tendencies that have come to dominate the GOP have pulled the party to the right for decades. But there were alternative paths available. Republican elites, in particular, had agency – but chose to go along with or actively further the rise of extremism.</p><p>And here we are now, with a Republican Party that has pushed the republic to the brink.</p><p><strong>“Grand Old Party“</strong></p><p>For about a century and a half, the Republican Party has carried the moniker “Grand Old Party.”</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/ca9ee28e-8da8-48a2-ac80-7a59ddcc1443">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/ca9ee28e-8da8-48a2-ac80-7a59ddcc1443/uploads/images/n3ztz74xui/merge-jpgs.com_1772146440562.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/ca9ee28e-8da8-48a2-ac80-7a59ddcc1443</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">ca9ee28e-8da8-48a2-ac80-7a59ddcc1443</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 08 Mar 2026 08:56:28 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[MAGA Unreality vs the World]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The U.S. government is in the hands of people who are fully detached from reality. That is a major weakness for the regime – but also a source of further radicalization.]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The U.S. government is in the hands of people who are fully detached from reality. That is a major weakness for the regime – but also a source of further radicalization.</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, March 4, 2026</em></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/55dc578f-c914-4239-8dc9-e2bbef1fe5c6/uploads/images/6dddr5l4wk/EA569B69-6570-4101-ADF7-E1BCAD77B713_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>Donald Trump delivering the State of the Union address on February 24 – credit: Kenny Holston/The New York Times</figcaption></figure><p><em>The first part of this piece is free for everyone. If you want to read more than the preview or gain access to the audio version of the essay, please consider becoming a paid member of Democracy Americana, which is solely funded by readers and constitutes my main source of income as an independent writer.</em></p><p><em>Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work. Please know that I am immensely grateful for your generosity!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p>In a deranged way, the speech Donald Trump delivered to a joint session of Congress last week did a masterful job of capturing <a href="https://apnews.com/article/donald-trump-transcript-state-of-union-2026-c13e2a07df999b464b733f4a6e84dbd4">the State of the Union</a>. It was a frightening window into the pretend-reality in which this regime exists – the unreality it now attempts to impose on America and the world: A reminder that the U.S. government is in the hands of a disturbed authoritarian who is surrounded by people who either share his delusions, are too sycophantic to confront him, or believe the president’s warped perception of the world serves just fine as a vehicle for their own zealotry and ideological extremism.</p><p>The defining question from here is: How much of their unreality can they impose on the world, and how much damage will they be causing in the process?</p><p>To understand where America might go next, we must examine Trump’s delusions both as a massive weakness for a regime that is proving incapable of acting strategically and adapting to the setbacks, constraints, and resistance it encounters; but also as a source of radicalization, as it is precisely the mounting frustration over the gulf between the authoritarian unreality and the real world that is fueling the frantic search for ways to assert the kind of dominance they so desperately desire. We must grapple with MAGA’s unreality as both a major impediment to the Right’s authoritarian project as well as an acute threat for the republic, the international order, and, at the risk of sounding dramatic, literally everyone else on the planet.</p><p>This certainly isn’t the first authoritarian regime that, when faced with frustrations and public pressure, ramps up the demonization and persecution of vulnerable groups at home and throws itself into military “adventures” abroad. When delusion, authoritarian desires, ideological zealotry, and mounting desperation all combine, things are bound to escalate further.  </p><p>And by the time the Trumpists are finally removed from power, America and the world will be left with the rubble.</p><p><strong>Authoritarian delusions</strong></p><p>“Our nation is back: Bigger, better, richer, and stronger than ever before,” Donald Trump boasted early on in his State of the Union address: “And we’ve seen nothing yet. We’re going to do better and better and better. This is the golden age of America.”</p><p>Delusions of grandeur, presented in the unique idiom of a man who has built his fame on selling scams by slapping his name in big, fat golden letters on them, hoping enough people might be driven by folly or desperation to buy into the fake promise of celebrity and wealth:</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/55dc578f-c914-4239-8dc9-e2bbef1fe5c6">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/55dc578f-c914-4239-8dc9-e2bbef1fe5c6/uploads/images/6dddr5l4wk/EA569B69-6570-4101-ADF7-E1BCAD77B713_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/55dc578f-c914-4239-8dc9-e2bbef1fe5c6</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">55dc578f-c914-4239-8dc9-e2bbef1fe5c6</guid>
      <pubDate>Wed, 04 Mar 2026 12:22:35 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[How Conservatives Gave Themselves Permission to Go MAGA]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[In 2016, leading conservatives came out “Against Trump” – but soon let their disdain for “the Left” override all else. It's the story of Modern Conservatism in a nutshell]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Ten years ago, leading conservatives came out “Against Trump” – but soon let their disdain for “the Left” override all else. It is the story of Modern Conservatism in a nutshell.</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, February 24, 2026</em></p><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/cc8aefed-942a-4d82-a2ee-65856400e889/uploads/images/tli4cbpury/B3C9521F-F754-4135-8840-9A2843FED3DD_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><p><em>The first part of this piece is free for everyone. If you want to read more than the preview or gain access to the audio version of the essay, please consider becoming a paid member of Democracy Americana, which is solely funded by readers and constitutes my main source of income as an independent writer. Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work. Please know that I am immensely grateful for your generosity!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p>For almost exactly a decade, Donald Trump has dominated the Republican Party and acted as the de facto standard bearer of American political conservatism, defining the identity of today’s Right. How did it come to that?</p><p>Two diametrically opposed tales quickly emerged in response to Trump’s rise: There is the story of Trumpism-as-aberration, according to which the venerable tradition of principled American conservatism has been hijacked by an utterly unprincipled demagogue; Trumpism, in this interpretation, is fundamentally not conservatism at all, its triumph an accident, the recent trajectory of the Right a departure from what came before. Conservatives were seduced, or they were cowards in the face of an insurrection, a hostile takeover of the true conservative tradition.</p><p>The counter-interpretation holds that Trump’s rise was really no big surprise at all: This is what American conservatism, at its core, had always been – a movement fueled and defined by racial and cultural grievance, held together by anti-liberal sentiment. Everything else was just a front, a veneer of intellectual depth and respectability; there had been no venerable tradition to begin with, rather a fairly straight line from William F. Buckley (or perhaps even much earlier than that) to Ronald Reagan to Pat Buchanan and Newt Gingrich to Sarah Palin to, finally, Donald Trump.</p><p>How did we get here? If we want to get the diagnosis right, the most plausible interpretation lies somewhere in-between these tales of either total aberration or complete continuity (though that does not mean exactly in the middle). The challenge is to grapple seriously with long-standing traditions and continuities while also acknowledging and investigating the more recent radicalization.</p><p>Let me take you back exactly ten years to investigate a very interesting moment in that story. On January 22, 2016, about a week before the Republican primaries were to start, the conservative magazine <em>National Review</em> came out <a href="https://www.nationalreview.com/magazine/2016/02/15/">“Against Trump”</a>: That was the title of a special issue published first online and then, in mid-February, in print. <em>National Review</em> is widely regarded – or certainly regards itself – as the flagship of “serious,” high-brow conservative commentary. It has served as a central organ of Modern Conservatism since it was founded in 1955. As it was clear that Donald Trump, who led in the polls, was threatening to emerge as the Republican candidate, <em>National Review</em>, led by editor (now editor-in-chief) Rich Lowry decided to make a stand against the man they called, <a href="https://www.nationalreview.com/2016/01/donald-trump-conservative-movement-menace/">in a blistering editorial</a>, “a menace to American conservatism.” To support the magazine’s stance, the editors also brought together <a href="https://www.nationalreview.com/magazine/2016/02/15/conservatives-against-trump/">twenty-two leading conservative intellectuals</a>, media personalities, and activists to make the case “Against Trump” in essays of 300 to 500 words each.</p><p>“Against Trump” came out to great fanfare. Every <a href="https://edition.cnn.com/2016/01/21/politics/national-review-magazine-opposes-donald-trump">major news outlet</a> and <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2016/01/22/the-story-behind-the-national-reviews-big-anti-donald-trump-issue/">paper</a> in the country covered it like it was a big deal. Trump, who had zero political experience and had risen to prominence within the Republican Party as the chief proponent of the racist “birther” conspiracy theory, had obviously gotten very far. But perhaps this would, finally, mark the end of the line for him – the moment when honorable people on the Right stood up and said: Enough?</p><p>Some of the people who were part of “Against Trump” have indeed been steadfast in their opposition – with several of them, like Bill Kristol and Mona Charen, coming together at <em>The Bulwark</em> as the “Never Trump” conservatives’ central platform. But they were the exceptions.</p><p>Would you believe it, most of the people who contributed to “Against Trump” either quickly turned full-on MAGA or they committed to an aggressive anti-anti-Trumpism, a position that is often functionally indistinguishable from a more open endorsement of MAGA as it is devoted to making the case that Donald Trump’s opponents are <em>at least</em> as bad as whatever he may have to offer.</p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p>There are, to give you just a few examples, rightwing talk radio hosts and all-around-pundits Erick Erickson and Glenn Beck, who proudly proclaimed they, as “constitutional conservatives” (Beck) who took their “conservatism seriously” (Erickson) could not justify supporting Donald Trump… only to then start supporting him soon thereafter. Begrudgingly, of course, as Erickson would often emphasize, at least <a href="https://www.npr.org/2019/02/21/696532375/vocal-critic-explains-why-he-now-supports-president-trump">when he was talking to</a> mainstream media outlets; or perhaps not so begrudgingly, as Beck <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pog6BROgjg4">has praised Trump</a> rather effusively since.</p><p>Or take L. Brent Bozell III., a prominent rightwing commentator at the time who, in “Against Trump,” declared “Trump might be the greatest charlatan of them all.” Bozell comes from conservative royalty: His father was L. Brent Bozell Jr., the ghostwriter of the 1960 book “The Conscience of a Conservative,” a core text in conservative history published under the name of Barry Goldwater, which helped catapult the Arizona senator to rightwing stardom and ultimately the Republican presidential nomination in 1964; his mother was Patricia Buckley Bozell, sister of <em>National Review</em> founder William F. Buckley, the godfather of the modern conservative movement. Bozell III. has since, uhm, reconsidered his position on Trump the charlatan, <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/investigations/council-national-policy-video/2020/10/14/367f24c2-f793-11ea-a510-f57d8ce76e11_story.html">declaring in the fall of 2020</a> that “the Left” was preparing to “steal the election” from Donald Trump, planning to “usher in totalitarianism.” Bozell currently serves as Trump’s ambassador to South Africa – where he certainly has no issue representing the regime’s white nationalist agenda, as he always opposed the anti-Apartheid movement.</p><p>Finally, there is <em>National Review</em> editor-in-chief Rich Lowry himself, the driving force behind “Against Trump.” By the time his 2019 book “The Case for Nationalism” came out, Lowry was pretty much all in on America First, <a href="https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2019/11/22/20952353/trump-nationalism-america-first-rich-lowry">declaring that</a> “Trump instinctively believes in our country first and our interests first.” Lowry was also impressed how Trump had supposedly “delivered” on all the key issues: “On some really important matters of substance to conservatives of long-standing, he’s been a rock.” And in typical anti-anti-Trump manner, Lowry also decided that the “Left” was simply worse. So much so that, in August 2024, he made the case in <em>The</em> <em>New York Times</em> that <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2024/08/26/opinion/advice-for-trump-win.html">“Trump Can Win on Character”</a> – an area where Lowry claimed Trump had the advantage over his Democratic opponent Kamala Harris.</p><p>As we just passed the tenth anniversary of “Against Trump,” I believe it is very much worth revisiting this document that can provide a window into a key moment in the Right’s radicalizing trajectory – and the permission structures that have governed rightwing politics for decades.</p><p>“If Trump were to become the president, the Republican nominee, or even a failed candidate with strong conservative support,” <em>National Review</em> asked in its 2016 editorial, “what would that say about conservatives?” It’s an excellent question, isn’t it?</p><p>To some extent, the answer is rather banal and boring, of course. There is quite a bit of careerism and cynical opportunism at play here, combined with a hefty dose of hypocrisy. Whatever noble principles the “Against Trump” contributors may have invoked in early 2016: To most of them, they evidently weren’t all that fundamentally important – certainly not important enough to be a deal-breaker once Trumpism rose to power.</p><p>But there is a story here not <em>just</em> about ignoring principles – but about a radicalizing tendency inherent in the defining principles of Modern Conservatism itself, in the way the political identity of Modern Conservatism, the movement that coalesced in the middle decades of the twentieth century, was defined from the beginning not as small-c conservatism in the colloquial sense, but by a reactionary devotion to anti-liberalism and fueled by disdain for “the Left.”</p><p>For a political movement so constituted, the question has always been: Is there a limiting principle – or just a principled commitment that demands you do whatever it takes? Is there a line a “Modern Conservative” (as opposed to a small-c conservative) is not permitted to cross in the struggle against the forces of leftism, even if it meant accepting the liberalization and pluralization of American life?</p><p>The answer the leaders of the modern Right have given themselves and us, over and over again, is: No, there is not.</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/cc8aefed-942a-4d82-a2ee-65856400e889">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/cc8aefed-942a-4d82-a2ee-65856400e889/uploads/images/tli4cbpury/B3C9521F-F754-4135-8840-9A2843FED3DD_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/cc8aefed-942a-4d82-a2ee-65856400e889</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">cc8aefed-942a-4d82-a2ee-65856400e889</guid>
      <pubDate>Tue, 24 Feb 2026 12:10:52 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[What is “Un-American”?]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[We must acknowledge America’s history of state authoritarianism and racial violence – but also dare to claim its aspirational tradition. Make MAGA un-American, finally.]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>We must acknowledge America’s history of state authoritarianism and racial violence – but also dare to claim its aspirational tradition of egalitarian democracy. Let’s Make MAGA un-American, finally.</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, February 15, 2026</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/27faead7-855d-4228-a4ea-5cc01a2221eb">Listen on Steady</a></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/27faead7-855d-4228-a4ea-5cc01a2221eb/uploads/images/v4wlaww5ro/iStock-1205229937.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>credit: iStock / paseven</figcaption></figure><p><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is my main source of income as an independent writer. If you are reading the free version of this newsletter, I sincerely appreciate your time and effort engaging with my work. Please share it widely to help me reach new readers.</em></p><p><em>And if you can, please consider becoming a </em><strong><em>paid member</em></strong><em>. You will gain access to special benefits – including many additional essays and the audio versions of all my writing in podcast form.</em></p><p><em>Most importantly, Democracy Americana is a publication solely funded by readers. I need your support to continue this work. Thank you!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p></p><p>“This is Un-American. This is not who we are.”</p><p>We have all heard these phrases many times. From politicians, journalists, friends, neighbors… I am sure many of us will have expressed a similar sentiment ourselves at some point in some form or context.</p><p>It certainly has been a constant refrain throughout the Trump era. Outside of the MAGA Right, the assault on the Capitol on January 6, for instance, was widely described as <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K4KKuuDKJp8">“fundamentally un-American”</a>; and the lawless violence committed by masked agents of the state terrorizing the people of Minnesota, this <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/normeisen.bsky.social/post/3mej6tc36lc2k">“un-American overreach”</a> of an authoritarian government, has often elicited a similar response in mainstream circles.</p><p>It is striking how much this lament is a recurring theme in the American political discourse. It is an indication of how deeply ingrained in the country’s collective imagination certain ideas about the <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/sep/10/president-biden-finally-is-sounding-the-alarm-about-democracy-good">“soul of the nation”</a> are: For something to be “un-American” in the way the term is usually deployed (rather than just wrong, illegal, or immoral), it must violate an essence defined by a set of ideals and values, something that is non-negotiable as a tenet of what “America” is and what it means to be “American”: A supposedly eternal commitment to liberty and freedom, to democracy based on the notion that “all men are created equal.”</p><p>The reality of U.S. history, society, and politics has never been aligned with such ideals, of course. As a result, racism and other forms of bigotry have, certainly in the recent past, been constantly declared “un-American” while also continuously acting as organizing principles of American life; similarly, Americans have often reacted with a reflexive “This is not who we are!” to violent abuses of state power at home and abroad while those continued to shape the nation and its place in the world.</p><p>As the “Not who we are” lament reached its latest crescendo after the murder of Renee Good and Alex Pretti in Minneapolis, the critique of this particular way of metabolizing the stark discrepancy between ideal and reality also grew louder. At the risk of paying too much attention to social media: There was a lot of angry shouting in my Bluesky circles towards the end of January, with some people expressing their exasperation with what they saw as a form of ignorant, complacent, and self-congratulatory mythologizing of U.S. history, even declaring all the talk about ICE and Border Patrol violence as “un-American” as an outrageous form of gaslighting. Meanwhile, others dismissed this line of criticism since it seemed obvious, to them, that declaring racialized state violence “un-American” was a form of aspirational speech – not an attempt to whitewash history, but to remind the nation that it should finally live up to the ideals that have so prominently shaped its collective imagination.</p><p>(I have decided not to link to specific participants in this debate, by the way, as I would rather focus on the bigger questions surrounding this online spat and have no interest in getting into a social media confrontation with any particular people. But if you are interested, you’ll find plenty of examples easily enough if you simply type “This is un-American” into the Bluesky search bar, as <a href="https://bsky.app/search?q=This+is+un-American">I have done here</a>; you’ll also see that elected officials have weighed in on both sides of this debate, either calling the paramilitary occupation of Minneapolis <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/repaprildelaney.bsky.social/post/3mdtlcubxq22r">“un-American”</a> or insisting that it was, in fact, <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/repsummerlee.bsky.social/post/3meeera7o2c2j">“deeply American.”</a>)</p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p>I don’t really care about this particular round of social media discussion. But it did trigger something in me – or rather relate to something I have been thinking about a lot lately: About more or less helpful ways to interrogate U.S. history, learn from it, bring it to bear in our current moment; about how to mobilize aspects of the nation’s collective imagination in support of a vision of democratic pluralism rather than, as the Right does, in service of faux-patriotic, exclusionary “real Americanism”?</p><p>My point is this: What the MAGA government is doing does not constitute some accidental departure from an otherwise heroic democratic tradition. America has a long tradition of racial violence perpetrated and condoned by the state, of state authoritarianism in service of a white supremacist vision and an exclusionary ethno-nationalist understanding of who gets to belong. There exists a willfully ignorant, self-exculpatory exceptionalism that mythologizes U.S. history into an easily digestible, triumphant tale that is as ahistorical as it is politically useless. Worse than useless, actually, as it engenders a self-satisfied, naïve, and dangerously unimaginative complacency that has for too long hampered the (small-d) democratic response to the radicalizing threat of rightwing authoritarianism. We should have discarded whatever notion of “It cannot happen here” was still floating around a long time ago.</p><p>But to insist that America – its history, identity, and political tradition – is solely defined by these continuities of racist authoritarianism and white patriarchal domination is equally ahistorical. From the start, the American experiment was also shaped by an egalitarian promise, by an aspiration to realize the idea that “all people are created equal” in a pluralistic democracy. That aspirational tradition isn’t any less authentically American than the idea of a white Christian “homeland” defined by hierarchies of race, gender, religion, and wealth. That is the thing about our existential crisis: It is the latest iteration of a conflict between two fundamentally incompatible visions of what “America” is supposed to be that has defined the nation since its inception.</p><p>There has never been a consensual answer to the question of “who we are.” The definition of what is (un-)“American” is constantly in flux, endlessly contested – it exists in eternal tension between past and present, between reality and aspiration. It is a constant struggle over the national story, national identity, the boundaries of the nation and who gets to define them – over the ideas and values that should guide “America.”</p><p>The MAGA Right claims that “real America” was only ever intended to be, only ever existed, and therefore must continue to exist as a white Christian ethno-state. To renounce America’s aspirational tradition of egalitarian pluralism as pointless, superficial, and purely hypocritical is to help them perpetuate the idea that the injustices of the past and present, which they idolize as a manifestation of the “natural order,” represent the one true essence of the nation.</p><p>If we can get rid of the willfully naïve exceptionalism that glorified America as inherently benevolent, virtuous, and free, let us not replace it with its dark mirror equivalent that only serves to confirm MAGA’s tale – but with an aspirational creed, fueled by an acknowledgment of injustice, as our common understanding. America’s egalitarian promise, although never realized yet, is as authentically American as anything the Trumpists could ever muster.</p><p><em>Today, you are reading a free article that I am making available to everyone. I would love to continue to offer these essays for a broad audience. However, pieces like this - almost 5,000 words! - take a ton of time and effort to research, write, and edit.</em></p><p><em>As an independent writer, I rely on the revenue generated by paid memberships as my main source of income. If you are a frequent reader of Democracy Americana, I am certain you will benefit greatly from a paid membership. I publish additional member-exclusive essays every week - and members also have access to the audio versions of all my writing in podcast form wherever you get your podcasts.</em></p><p><em>Most importantly, if you value this independent work, please know that it is your support and your generosity that is making it possible.</em></p><p><em>If a paid membership is currently not an option for you, the best way to support Democracy Americana is to share this piece on social media - and recommend my work to people you think might be interested. Thank you!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><strong>Traditions of authoritarianism</strong></p><p>In June 2021, leading Never Trumper Bill Kristol <a href="https://x.com/BillKristol/status/1399722431221309443">posted on ex-Twitter</a>: “We’re the world’s oldest democracy. It’s hard for us Americans to take threats of coups and even the dangers of authoritarianism seriously. But it’s time to do so.”</p><p>I’m not bringing this up to single out Kristol, specifically: I wish I had a dollar for every time I have encountered versions of this argument in conversations with journalists, politicians, and private acquaintances (and Kristol, at least, acknowledged it was high time to abandon these ideas and has certainly acted accordingly since).</p><p>Such notions reflect a deep-seated mythology of American exceptionalism. In its purest form, it holds that Americans are essentially immune to authoritarianism of any kind – the “soul of the nation” won’t allow it, or the country’s DNA, or the freedom-loving national character… The political mainstream has generally – or at least rhetorically – moved to a slightly more nuanced understanding of the American story. But exceptionalism lingers. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve been approached by American media with a request to talk about the threat of authoritarianism because “You, as a German” understand what “We,” because of America’s supposedly stable democratic tradition, can only struggle to grasp. </p><p>These are the central themes of the exceptionalist mythology that has long blunted the response to the Trumpist threat: “We” have always been a democracy; therefore authoritarianism cannot thrive here; and in any case, “we” simply don’t have any experience with how to handle it if it ever arose.</p><p>But the defining question in U.S. history has always been: Who is “We”? For most of America’s existence, and until quite recently, those who lived within the nation’s borders and happened not to be white men had plenty of experience with state authoritarianism. Significant parts of the country existed first as a slavocracy and then, after a brief interlude during Reconstruction, as a one-party apartheid regime during the so-called Jim Crow era. During the same period, Native Americans were disenfranchised, dispossessed, and persecuted by the American state. It is certainly true that even before the civil rights legislation of the 1960s, the American political system was fairly democratic, at least by contemporaneous international comparison, if a person happened to be a white Christian man – but it was something else entirely if they were not.</p><p>This is not some ancient history. There are a lot of people who voted in the last presidential election who remember disenfranchisement and state-enforced racial segregation all too well as the defining features of their own youth. Nor was American authoritarianism ever just a regional issue, it was never confined to “just” the South. Slave-holding elites exerted a dominating influence over the Republic before the Civil War, and Southern segregationists were immensely powerful in national politics until the 1960s. Moreover, there is a strong domestic tradition of white nationalist, white supremacist extremism across the country. The Ku Klux Klan was very much a national organization in the 1920s; 20,000 people attended a Nazi rally at Madison Square Garden in New York City in February 1939; in the 1960s, George Wallace quickly realized that his fight against racial equality resonated with white voters far beyond the South; and a well-established far-right grassroots activism has shaped political culture on the ground across post-war America.</p><p>Put differently, Trumpism as an authoritarian project fueled by white male grievance stands in continuity with several key strands of the American political tradition: With a conception of “freedom” defined as the power to curtail the freedom of others – an idea invoked by white settlers, apologists of slavery, and opponents of Black civil rights as justification for their quest to dominate; with an aggressive minoritarianism that claims the right to overrule the political process, ignore election results, and nullify the law should the prerogative of a certain “worthy” (white, male) minority ever be threatened – an ideology that fueled the secession of the Southern States in defense of their right to enslave others; an exclusionary blood-and-soil nationalism that animated nativist movements, America Firsters, and paleo-conservative thinkers all the way to Stephen Miller and Donald Trump.</p><p><strong>Visions of democratic progress</strong></p><p>I generally believe a more critical understanding of U.S. history has taken root outside of hardcore rightwing circles: A decade of Donald Trump dominating American politics has soured most intellectually mature people on the notion that all you need to know about America’s past is that it was gloriously heroic. My sense is that any mainstream audience is a lot more open today than it was even ten years ago to grappling in earnest with the fact that the United States had no reasonable claim to be a functioning liberal democracy in the modern sense before the Voting Rights Act of 1965, that until then America had been quite democratic by contemporaneous standards if you happened to be a white man – but something else entirely if you were not. </p><p>However, in the established mainstream imaginary, 1965 came to mark a moment of democratic re-birth that supposedly set the country on an entirely different path. A story emerged that combined a relatively unsparing critique of American history pre-1965 with a nostalgic insistence that the country left that history behind with the civil rights revolution of the 1960s. It was a kind of updated version of the liberal consensus of the immediate post-1945 era: All was not well yet, but the country was getting there; the system was fundamentally healthy and would be able to deal, in good time, with whatever vestiges of injustice still plagued the nation. In this tale, the moral arc of the universe was bending towards justice, and the country was irreversibly moving towards “post-racial” democracy. Such a framework of liberal progress made it easier for people to discard the continuities of racial violence and state authoritarianism – to regard racist police violence as an unfortunate aberration rather than a defining feature, for instance; or to largely ignore the inhumanity of America’s immigration system and the staunchly lawless, violent machinery that was set up to impose it.</p><p>Unfortunately, the passing of the civil rights legislation in the 1960s did not actually usher in democratic consensus. A hierarchical ethno-state dominated by white Christians or a pluralistic democracy with sincere egalitarian aspirations? That conflict was not resolved in 1776. It wasn’t settled in 1865. And it remained an open question after 1965 as well.</p><p>The forces who rejected the vision of egalitarian pluralism were not confined and condemned to an existence on the fringes of society. They have instead engaged in a comprehensive counter-mobilization. The Civil Rights Act <em>not</em> as the culmination of noble egalitarian ambitions but as <a href="https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/The-Age-of-Entitlement/Christopher-Caldwell/9781501106910">a fateful turn in the wrong direction</a>: That is the defining position on today’s political Right far beyond the rabid MAGA base. The Trumpists didn’t depart from a previously stable democratic consensus. They represent the radical wing of a rightwing coalition that was never on board with egalitarian principles and democratic pluralism to begin with.</p><p><em>Help me continue this work and become a paid member of Democracy Americana:</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><strong>Authoritarianism rising</strong></p><p>The past thirteen months have done a lot to dispel whatever notion of “It cannot happen here” mainstream opinion was still clinging to. Perhaps, if we allow ourselves that little bit of optimism, this might ultimately constitute a lasting legacy of Trumpism? Early on, as America’s elites and elite civic institutions displayed a pervasive tendency to acquiesce and align themselves with the regime, as it seemed the vaunted guardrails were comprehensively failing and American democracy was proving a lot less resilient than most observers had expected, Americans turned <a href="https://www.foreignaffairs.com/united-states/path-american-authoritarianism-trump">to those who had studied</a> the rise of authoritarianism elsewhere to explain what was going on. Scholars who had devoted their lives to studying autocracies around the world in a comparative perspective – people like <a href="http://www.foreignaffairs.com/united-states/american-authoritarianism-levitsky-way-ziblatt">Steven Levitzky, Lucan Way, and Daniel Ziblatt</a> – rose to the status of leading public intellectuals. That is a) good, because these are serious, smart, insightful people, and b) diagnostically interesting, because it tells us something about changes in the collective imagination. We now routinely apply insights that emerged from this comparative work to the situation in the United States: Like the concept of “competitive authoritarianism” to describe a regime that exists somewhere between democracy and full-blown autocracy; or the idea of a “playbook” authoritarian movements tend to follow upon taking power. The rise of such concepts signals how much we have moved away from a purely exceptionalist understanding of America’s past and present. Why would anything that happened in Russia, Hungary, Turkey, or India be of relevance to the situation in the United States if the nation was inherently different from other countries and its “soul” immune to the rise of authoritarianism? The idea that there is something to be learned from the experience of these societies builds on a repudiation of American exceptionalism; in a relatively short span of time, we went from “It cannot happen here” to “We better start paying attention to what’s been happening elsewhere because that is exactly what is happening here.” I’d call that progress.</p><p><strong>Dark exceptionalism is bad, too</strong></p><p>At this point, however, I do believe we need to be careful not to let the pendulum swing too far in the other direction – and replace one form of exceptionalism with another. A dark exceptionalism seems to be on the rise, no less essentialist than what it seeks to replace: Whereas the traditional exceptionalist tale presented America as intrinsically good, noble, and democratic, this mirror narrative views the nation as inherently incapable of anything but hierarchical violence. There is indeed an eternal “soul of the nation,” it seems to proclaim, only it is not defined by an unconditional love for liberty, freedom, and justice, but by a brutal commitment to dispossess, dominate, and subjugate. There never was democracy in these United States – and there never will be.</p><p>I believe such dark mirror exceptionalism is deeply mistaken. It seems almost certainly counterproductive politically. It’s hard to see how such a message should motivate and mobilize enough people to go out into the streets, organize, protest, and resist? But I admit I am not a strategist. As a historian, however, I do want to caution that such essentialist notions of national character are fundamentally ahistorical.</p><p>Most importantly, we must distinguish between acknowledging traditions of racial violence and state authoritarianism on the one hand – and reducing the nation’s history to those traditions on the other. “American history is longer, larger, more various, more beautiful, and more terrible than anything anyone has ever said about it,” James Baldwin declared <a href="https://www.zinnedproject.org/materials/baldwin-talk-to-teachers">in a speech</a> he delivered in October 1963. It is among the most profoundly true and insightful things anyone has ever said about the United States. Anyone who works and thinks about American history should adopt it as a guiding paradigm. And I believe it can also help us navigate this acutely perilous political moment in which we find ourselves right now. More various, more beautiful, more terrible. We need to grapple with all of these conflicting dimensions.</p><p>A profound – and oftentimes violent – division over the very nature of what “America” is supposed to be has been the historical norm. The American experiment, if that is the right term, was always shaped by incompatible visions, ideas, and traditions. Competing forms of nationalism: One conceived of America as a credal nation. Anyone can be an American, in this understanding, as long as they subscribe to certain ideals and aspirations: Freedom, liberty, and that “all men are created equal.” Another rejected the aspirational creed as the basis of the nation and instead defined America in racial and religious terms, as an ethno-state in which wealthy white Christians deserve to rule and have a right to draw the boundaries of who gets to be “American.”</p><p>It is simply not true that the latter, with all the brutal subjugation it fueled and legitimized, is the sole true political tradition while the former is just hypocritical theater intended to distract us from that reality. That is certainly not how those who, throughout American history, appealed to the aspirations of freedom and equality saw it – those who worked tirelessly to make the country into the land it never had been yet, by reminding the nation of its egalitarian promise. Those who fought to abolish slavery and free themselves and their fellow human beings; those who reconceptualized the nation in the wake of the Civil War by amending the constitution so profoundly that it constituted <a href="https://wwnorton.com/books/9780393358520">a “second founding”</a>; the women who demanded the right to participate in the political process as equals; those who protested against the injustice of racial segregation and marched for their right to vote; and yes, those who took to the streets in Minneapolis in solidarity with their neighbors, no matter what the color of their skin may be or what gods they may worship.</p><p>They all took inspiration from the egalitarian promise which they insisted was as real and authentic an American political tradition as anything the Trumpists can deploy. I believe it should inspire us too. All people are created equal: A society in which the status of the individual is no longer shaped by their race, gender, religion, or wealth. Isn’t that the grandest idea humanity has ever come up with?</p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><strong>Who gets to be a patriot?</strong></p><p>Who gets to tell the national story? Who gets to define national identity – and thereby determine the boundaries of what counts as “American” and who belongs in America? The Right understands precisely that this is what the political conflict is all about. And no matter how much the Democratic consultant class insists we should all ignore what they discard as “culture war issues”: There is no way around this fight. It has to be fought, and if democracy is to prevail, it has to be won.</p><p>It is time, as grandiose as that may sound, to reclaim patriotism from the Right. Too long have rightwingers been allowed to drape their grievances and bigotries in the nation’s collective symbols, to call on the patriotic mythology of the nation in order to pretend that their desire to dominate is somehow an expression of the timeless essence of the nation. The American “Left,” very broadly defined, has struggled to contest this terrain. I count myself among those who are – rightfully, I believe! – wary of any political project that wraps itself in the flag, of anything that could, perhaps even unwittingly, help sanitize the nation’s history and legitimize the destructive forces of nationalism. But this reluctance, the tendency to abdicate and surrender the field of patriotism to the Right has allowed a bunch of ethno-nationalist extremists to present themselves as the guardians of the national mythos.</p><p>This is one reason why the “No Kings” protests were so effective. The slogan, in all its simplicity, referenced a founding myth, now mobilized in defense of democratic self-government – not in service of perpetuating lazy, self-satisfied exceptionalist ideas but as an affirmation of democratic aspirations, even if America has certainly never fully lived up to them yet.</p><p>Such efforts to activate the national mythos in defense of democratic pluralism will at times feel clunky and “cringe.” But we should not shy away from invoking that part of the American story: As a reminder to ourselves and the authoritarians who control the government that their claim to be the sole representatives of “authentic” Americanism has no historical basis, that there is an American tradition of egalitarian pluralism that puts their vicious, exclusionary domination fantasies to shame.</p><p>I often think back to a remarkable moment in early August 2024, during a democratic campaign rally in Eau Claire, Wisconsin. Three members of the band Bon Iver, whose frontman Justin Vernon grew up and still lives in Eau Claire, <a href="https://www.thenation.com/article/politics/kamala-harris-tim-walz-bon-iver-wisconsin-rally/">played a rendition of “Battle Cry of Freedom”</a> – one of the most popular, feistiest Civil War songs, an anthem of abolitionism, written in 1862.</p><p>“We’re gonna close out with a nice, old patriotic song that’s been roaming around in my head these last few months,” <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uF3yUlCajVs">Vernon said, before singing:</a></p><blockquote><p>Oh we’ll rally round the flag, boys, we’ll rally once again, <br/>Shouting the battle cry of freedom,<br/>And we’ll rally from the hillside, we’ll gather from the plain,<br/>Shouting the battle cry of freedom.</p></blockquote><p>Then Vernon launched into the chorus:</p><blockquote><p>The Union forever, hurrah! boys, hurrah!<br/>Down with the traitors, up with the stars;<br/>While we rally round the flag, boys, we rally once again,<br/>Shouting the battle cry of freedom!</p></blockquote><p>Vernon then sang the third verse – “And although he may be poor, no man (a variation from the original ‘he’) shall be a slave” – before closing with the chorus one more time. “Shouting the battle cry of freedom.”</p><p>I know everything to do with the cursed 2024 election is anathema to a lot of people on the liberal-left. And believe me, I don’t bring up this moment to re-litigate the Harris campaign – but because it was, although fleeting, driven by what I believe is the right instinct: An urge to finally, aggressively assert a different patriotism, one that opposes the Right’s claim to the red, white, and blue. We are the Union, we represent a nation that is defined by egalitarian ideas of multiracial, democratic pluralism – and we are willing to defend it against those who betray and sully those ideas.</p><p>I thought about this moment when I saw video footage of an anti-ICE protest in Minneapolis in late January centered around clergy coming together to sing <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/clancyny.bsky.social/post/3md4dwhjyhs2n">“Down to the River to Pray.”</a> I’m assuming many people will have been introduced to this song, like I was, via a memorable scene in the Coen brothers movie <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FbwUSOw_7qU">“O Brother, Where Art Thou?”</a> that came out in 2000. But it’s actually an <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/earlymodjustice.bsky.social/post/3md4ghdvyks23">abolitionist song from the 1840s</a> that was also sung among enslaved people. As the historian <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/bdproctor.bsky.social/post/3md4hf3tadc2a">Brad Proctor noted</a>, commenting on the protest in Minneapolis: “The song exists in the historical record as history of defiance to slave catchers, to family separation, to immoral detention and capture and forced migration.”</p><p>What could be more appropriate as a historical reference for this moment, as the nation must now decide which of these American traditions will get to shape the country going forward. We must never forget that the Right’s vision of white Christian patriarchal domination is indeed deeply rooted in U.S. history. To counter and overcome it, all those who want these United States to finally become the land it never has been yet should take heart from that other American tradition, that gloriously democratic promise of egalitarian pluralism.</p><p>Let’s Make MAGA un-American, finally.</p><p><strong><em>Thank you for reading – and please know that I am deeply grateful for your support and your generosity!</em></strong></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/27faead7-855d-4228-a4ea-5cc01a2221eb/uploads/images/v4wlaww5ro/iStock-1205229937.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/27faead7-855d-4228-a4ea-5cc01a2221eb</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">27faead7-855d-4228-a4ea-5cc01a2221eb</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 15 Feb 2026 11:45:59 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Why the Resistance Matters]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Anti-authoritarian “neighborism” and cross-racial solidarity from below are a massive problem for the regime, exposing Trumpism’s weaknesses and ideological blind spots]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Anti-authoritarian “neighborism” and cross-racial solidarity from below are a massive problem for the regime, exposing Trumpism’s structural weaknesses and ideological blind spots</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, February 8, 2026</em></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/d7e07dc3-dad1-41e3-992a-28b4aa4e0b47/uploads/images/63wkxdjw3s/D0346290-813D-4622-830C-782957AAFB19_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>credit: Adam Gray/AP</figcaption></figure><p><em>The first part of this piece is free for everyone. If you want to read more than the preview or gain access to the audio version of the essay, please consider becoming a paid member of Democracy Americana, which is solely funded by readers and constitutes my main source of income as an independent writer. Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work. Please know that I am immensely grateful for your generosity!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p>Minneapolis was supposed to serve as a warning to the rest of the nation. But as the resistance is holding, the paramilitary occupation of the city is turning into something different: A window into the weaknesses of the MAGA regime, a case study of the potential limits of violent authoritarianism, and a reminder of what democratic solidarity can achieve.</p><p>The raids on Minneapolis started in early December. Then, on January 6, the Department of Homeland Security announced “Operation Metro Surge,” the largest federal “immigration enforcement” operation ever. Acting as the regime’s paramilitary arm, ICE and Border Patrol would impose MAGA dominance on the ground. Yet all the brute force and all the cruel violence have not been able to vanquish the locally organized resistance or break the will of the people of Minnesota. Meanwhile, most of the public has reacted with horror to the images of heavily armed, masked agents of the state terrorizing an American city. <a href="https://www.gelliottmorris.com/p/trumps-immigration-tipping-point">Support for Trump</a> on immigration has tanked; <a href="https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/ice-gets-worse-ratings-polling-after-prettis-fatal/story?id=129859236">ICE is vastly unpopular</a>, even among self-identified independents. The occupation of Minneapolis is galvanizing the resistance against the regime across the country.</p><p>The Trumpists have miscalculated. The outcome of the broader struggle against the authoritarian assault remains very much undetermined. But there is no question that the MAGA government has so far failed to achieve its goals in Minneapolis. We can learn a lot from that: About the condition of the regime and the state of societal opposition, about different forms of resistance and how they can succeed. The resistance the Trumpists are encountering in Minnesota – and in more and more places around the country – is a serious threat to the authoritarian project.</p><p><strong>Plenty of protests</strong></p><p>The day after Donald Trump’s inauguration in 2017, half a million people marched through Washington, DC to protest the new president. The first Women’s March brought out millions across the United States. In the days after Trump’s return to the White House in January 2025, by contrast, the streets of the capital remained mostly empty.</p><p>On the surface, this discrepancy seemed to confirm what had been firmly established as gospel in the mainstream political discourse well before Trump’s inauguration on January 20: There would be no large-scale resistance but instead a <a href="https://www.newyorker.com/news/the-lede/what-happened-to-the-trump-resistance">“distinct lack of dissidence.”</a> Even at the time, there was plenty of reason to be skeptical of such a lament, as the <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/02/07/opinion/trump-resistance-public.html">“Resistance, Where are thou?”</a> narrative was set basically the minute Trump won the 2024 election. People were tired of protesting Trump, we were told – liberal America was <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/dec/02/trump-protest-fatigue">“struggling for the energy to resist.”</a></p><p>The gleeful aggression with which pundits from across the political spectrum jumped on the chance to declare that <a href="https://arcmag.org/the-resistance-is-dead/">“the resistance is dead”</a> should have been a clear indicator that there was quite a bit of score-settling going on here – and pundits vying for relevance by presenting grand reckonings rather than careful empirical assessments. There was also a gendered dimension to the critique – a distinctly sexist dismissiveness towards “wine moms” as the backbone of the opposition to Trump: Their political activism from the Women’s Marches to the outrage over the Supreme Court’s Dobbs decision was derided as <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2025/10/no-kings-protest-good-cringe-resistance/684595/?gift=mTq34Ny-ZVr996jdTJS9TlTHxD5P8MpSgMFKJgUzcOM&amp;utm_source=copy-link&amp;utm_medium=social&amp;utm_campaign=share">“cringe,”</a> the <a href="https://www.currentaffairs.org/news/america-needs-resistance-not-resistance">“Liberal resistance was a joke.”</a> Liberal hysteria, so the argument went, had finally exhausted itself. </p><p>Most importantly, perhaps, the notion that there were no protests, no potent resistance to Trump, aligned perfectly with the idea that the 2024 election had signaled a lasting rightward realignment, that Trump had a broad <a href="https://www.npr.org/2024/12/16/g-s1-38003/trump-mandate-presidents">“mandate”</a> to impose his vision on the country. If you’ll recall, the election was actually very close. Trump won with a narrow 1.5-point margin in the popular vote. And yet, the idea that America had experienced a political <a href="https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2025/02/the-rise-and-fall-of-the-new-liberals-how-the-democrats-lost-their-majority/">“earthquake”</a> that demanded far-reaching interpretations became gospel almost immediately. Within days, the country’s leading newspapers and most influential commentators attempted to outdo each other with ever more sweeping narratives, mostly built on vastly inadequate, unreliable data – and a whole lot of personal preference. Trump’s victory, we were confidently told, was the result of <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2025/01/trump-reelection-voter-demographic-change/680752/">lasting societal shifts</a> and signaled a profound reordering of American politics, an <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2025/05/american-realignment/682924/">“American realignment”</a> – perhaps even the <a href="https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2025/02/the-rise-and-fall-of-the-new-liberals-how-the-democrats-lost-their-majority/">end of political liberalism</a> and the beginning of a permanent Trumpist era in U.S. history.</p><p>The thing is: The argument that America had undergone a massive rightward shift was less a factual contention and more an ideological assertion, an article of faith. It has proven to be <a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/7edb91f9-c681-4769-b3cb-6eaebcc8ad4b">a stubbornly resistant myth</a> that is exceedingly hard to kill. And the same is true for the idea that “there are no protests.” Yes, Democratic Party leadership was still busy deciding whether or not they wanted to fight at all; yes, the pervasive tendency among America’s elites and elite civic institutions to acquiesce was pathetic. But anyone who cared to look at the empirical evidence that was literally gathering in the streets around the country could have seen quite quickly that a lot of ordinary people cared little about the punditry’s handwringing and got organizing.</p><p>While it didn’t initially take the form of mass protest in Washington, DC, there is no question that protest picked up significantly during the first year of Trumpism in power. For instance, Harvard University’s Crowd Counting Consortium, established right after Trump first rose to power under the leadership of political scientist Erica Chenoweth to observe the societal opposition to Trump, counted <a href="https://wagingnonviolence.org/2025/06/american-spring-nonviolent-protest-accelerating/">more than 10,000 organized protests</a> by the end of 2025 – more than twice as many as in 2017. These included <a href="https://wagingnonviolence.org/2025/08/new-data-shows-no-kings-was-one-of-the-largest-days-of-protest-in-us-history/">nation-wide mass events</a> like the “Hands Off” protests against the DOGE-led destruction of the administrative state in April and the two “No Kings” marches in June and October – the latter turning out around seven million people, making it the largest single-day protest in recent U.S. history.</p><p>There have also been, very much right from the start last January, smaller protests in thousands of towns across America. These protests have been <a href="https://ash.harvard.edu/resources/the-resistance-reaches-into-trump-country/">far more numerous and far more sustained</a> than anything we saw during Trump I – far more geographically widespread also, penetrating even the most rural, Republican-dominated areas. Yet for the longest time, they took place almost entirely below the radar of a political discourse that remained invested in lamenting the supposed lack of resistance.</p><p><strong>New forms of resistance</strong></p><p>The first year of Trumpism in power also saw the emergence of different forms of societal resistance that aren’t adequately captured by the term “protest.”</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/d7e07dc3-dad1-41e3-992a-28b4aa4e0b47">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/d7e07dc3-dad1-41e3-992a-28b4aa4e0b47/uploads/images/63wkxdjw3s/D0346290-813D-4622-830C-782957AAFB19_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/d7e07dc3-dad1-41e3-992a-28b4aa4e0b47</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">d7e07dc3-dad1-41e3-992a-28b4aa4e0b47</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 08 Feb 2026 13:28:25 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Turning Points and Authoritarian Escalations]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Is America’s descent into autocracy accelerating or is Trump struggling to break through the democratic defenses? In Minneapolis, MAGA's worldview is being refuted.]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Is America’s descent into autocracy accelerating or is the Trump regime struggling to break through the democratic defenses? In Minneapolis, the tenets of the white nationalist worldview are being refuted.</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, February 2, 2026</em></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/38dc5fd1-0e5a-4047-b8f0-0da0e2416c38/uploads/images/z6iz3dleou/iStock-2241499226.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>Credit: iStock /blulz60</figcaption></figure><p><em>The first part of this piece is free for everyone. If you want to read more than the preview or gain access to the audio version of the essay, please consider becoming a paid member of Democracy Americana, which is solely funded by readers and constitutes my main source of income as an independent writer. Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work. Please know that I am immensely grateful for your generosity!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p>The past week may have brought us some of the most extreme narrative swings of the Trump era. The public discourse ranged from “Trump is pivoting to moderation” to “Trump is smashing through the last constraints, escalating into full-own autocracy” – from “Trump is definitely losing” to “America’s inevitable descent into authoritarianism is accelerating.”</p><p>We seek certainty. But perhaps the best thing we can do is to grapple with the ambiguity, the murkiness, the contradictions of this moment. The situation is highly volatile. And yet, I do believe we can filter out some of the noise and the nervous excitement of the daily news cycles, take stock of where America stands.</p><p>Forget all the nonsense about Trump “pivoting” to moderation. This regime is ideologically and psycho-politically incapable of that. They will continue to escalate, hoping to intimidate people and institutions into compliance and submission. But in Minneapolis, people are holding the line. And that matters greatly, because the stakes in this confrontation are extremely high. What the regime was intending to be a warning to the rest of the nation is turning into something very different. It is not only MAGA’s ability to consolidate authoritarian rule in the face of sustained resistance that is being put to the test here. In Minneapolis, the tenets of the white nationalist worldview are on trial: The Trumpists claim that multiracial pluralism is a dangerous lie, it is weak, it lacks cohesion, it stands no chance against the strength of the autocratic ethno-state. But what they are encountering on the ground is a population mobilizing in defense of their non-white neighbors. A multiracial community exercising solidarity, galvanized by the authoritarian assault. Nothing could be more dangerous to Trumpism as a political project.</p><p><strong>No “pivot” – but a significant defeat</strong></p><p>To recap: After initially doubling down, just like they had after the murder of Renee Good, slandering and vilifying the victim as a “domestic terrorist,” the regime started the week after the execution of Alex Pretti by modifying its public approach. Trump momentarily changed his tone, going so far as to signal <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3mdgc7eqasx2q">sympathy</a> with Pretti’s family. The regime sidelined border patrol “commander-at-large” Greg Bovino, the face of the ICE/CBP occupation, replacing him with border czar Tom Homan. There were reports of <a href="https://newrepublic.com/article/205788/trump-advisers-quietly-turn-stephen-miller-brutal-ice-poll-hits">internal strife and finger pointing</a>, as not everybody in the Trump White House was overly happy with how DHS secretary Kristi Noem and America First chief agitator Stephen Miller had been handling the situation. All of this prompted some mainstream <a href="https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/minneapolis-sees-little-change-on-the-streets-despite-trump-suggesting-an-easing-of-tensions">media outlets</a> to <a href="https://popular.info/p/how-legacy-media-fell-for-trumps">diagnose a “pivot”</a> towards “easing tensions.”</p><p>Let’s be frank: The idea that the Trumpists would henceforth pursue a strategy of moderation and de-escalation, that perhaps Donald Trump was sincerely affected by the violence in Minneapolis and therefore seeking a more conciliatory approach, was obviously stupid. It takes a significant level of foolishness and/or (willfull) ignorance to indulge such notions – a complete lack of understanding of who and what Trumpism is.</p><p>Sure enough, the “pivot” didn’t last. Or rather: It had never actually materialized on the ground to begin with. <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3mdgjohren22q">Certainly not in Minneapolis</a>, where the federal occupation force continued its strategy of terrorizing the people. The “softer” rhetoric didn’t stick either – by the middle of the week, Trump was back to raging against <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3mdnti2k23t2q">“insurrectionists and agitators”</a> in Minneapolis. In fact, while the “pivot” talk was still ongoing, ICE was already <a href="https://www.pressherald.com/2026/01/23/ice-watchers-in-maine-say-they-were-threatened-by-federal-agents/">expanding</a> its aggressive raids <a href="https://www.bostonglobe.com/2026/01/27/metro/maine-ice-arrests-mother-of-kindergartener/?s_campaign=audience%3Abluesky&amp;utm_sf_post_ref=660448822&amp;utm_campaign=globe%3Abluesky&amp;utm_sf_cserv_ref=did%3Aplc%3Ayfmsl73ryoitvecltfl6lkjd">in Maine</a>. As I am writing this, it looks like the Trumpists are preparing a campaign of <a href="https://www.liberalcurrents.com/terror-returns-to-springfield/?ref=extra-writing-newsletter">ethnic cleansing against the Haitian migrants</a> in Springfield, Ohio. Vice-president JD Vance and Trump tried to <a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/fd6042ca-dfa6-4693-85a1-b9552e6488f5">incite a pogrom</a> against them during the presidential campaign in the fall of 2024 – and MAGA seems to be itching to make that community their next target. As an exclamation mark, the regime ended the week after the murder of Alex Pretti by <a href="https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/don-lemon-washington-minnesota-trump-b2910936.html?utm_term=Autofeed&amp;utm_medium=Social&amp;utm_source=Bluesky#Echobox=1769779645">arresting journalists</a> for the crime of having reported from Minneapolis.</p><p>Based on these developments, it is easy to mock the idea of a “turning point” – another term that has been prominently floating around lately. I have seen lots of angry ridicule directed at the idea that the resistance in Minnesota had meaningfully impacted the course of events. Aren’t we actually witnessing <a href="https://www.ft.com/content/b474855e-66b0-4e6e-9b73-7e252bd88938?accessToken=zwAGSbCfepa4kdO0dIVeZrBObtObc34lK9iJOA.MEQCICsl-wnbkT-zHL1ucGdIU4o9IzZ1_M0Vy0qdxb7vUAtFAiBjN9PiR_5XQC1WmAKGp19wO2ppR9PaHyvusfIJqCZHaA&amp;sharetype=gift&amp;token=bd398d72-3953-4f44-a757-0fc09ad1c3ed">an acceleration</a> of America’s descent into full-on autocracy?</p><p>Here I want to caution against throwing the baby out with the bathwater. I believe that assessing the events in Minneapolis by whether or not they actually induced some sense of moderation in the regime is entirely the wrong framework. We shouldn’t dismiss the significance of the resistance on the ground because it failed to trigger a sincere change of heart in a regime that is utterly incapable of such enlightenment. The fact remains: The resistance the Trumpists are encountering in Minnesota is a serious threat to the authoritarian project – and the ideological foundations on which it is built.</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/38dc5fd1-0e5a-4047-b8f0-0da0e2416c38">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/38dc5fd1-0e5a-4047-b8f0-0da0e2416c38/uploads/images/z6iz3dleou/iStock-2241499226.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/38dc5fd1-0e5a-4047-b8f0-0da0e2416c38</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">38dc5fd1-0e5a-4047-b8f0-0da0e2416c38</guid>
      <pubDate>Mon, 02 Feb 2026 12:16:45 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The People Struggle Against Tyranny]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Another execution of an American citizen. A regime that has no strategy but to lash out. The struggle against Trumpist authoritarianism is only going to get bloodier.]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Another execution of an American citizen. A regime that has no strategy but to lash out. The struggle against Trumpist authoritarianism is only going to get bloodier.</strong></p><p><strong><em>By Thomas Zimmer, January 25, 2026</em></strong></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/fccbc0fe-2ec6-4507-92ce-73c50964fdee">Listen on Steady</a></p><figure><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/live/2026/01/25/us/minneapolis-shooting-ice"><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/fccbc0fe-2ec6-4507-92ce-73c50964fdee/uploads/images/6yaypik5wm/24minneapolis-ice-victim-topart-fhlp-superJumbo.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/></a><figcaption>Credit: David Guttenfelder / The New York Times</figcaption></figure><p><em>Before we get into it: Democracy Americana is my main source of income as an independent writer. I you are reading the free version of this newsletter, I sincerely appreciate your time and effort engaging with my work! Please share it widely to help me reach new readers. If you are not subscribed yet, you can </em><strong><em>subscribe for free</em></strong><em> and you will get these long-form essays delivered straight to your inbox whenever they come out.</em></p><p><em>And if you can, please consider becoming a </em><strong><em>paid member</em></strong><em>. You will gain access to special benefits – including many additional essays.</em></p><p><em>Most importantly, Democracy Americana is a publication solely funded by readers. I need your support to continue this work. Thank you!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p>Another state-sponsored murder in broad daylight. Another execution of an American citizen. Carried out by paramilitary goons tasked with terrorizing the people. Sent by a regime that is at war with the majority of its own population.</p><p>On Saturday morning, Alex Jeffrey Pretti, 37 years old, an ICU nurse at the local VA hospital, was killed by federal agents in the streets of Minneapolis.</p><p>There are so many parallels to the murder of Renee Good just 17 days earlier. So much that needed to be said then and needs to be said again now. Yet again, we know exactly what happened. ICE and Border Patrol want to operate in semi-secrecy. But the people in Minneapolis won’t let them. We have multiple <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/jan/24/alex-pretti-killing-witness-testimony">witness accounts</a> as well as <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/joshuaeakle.com/post/3md76ihzrg22y">video evidence</a> showing us what happened <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/muellershewrote.com/post/3md6usscb2k23">from multiple angles</a> and <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/oalexanderdk.bsky.social/post/3md6nnacpyk2c">perspectives</a> – multiple <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/01/24/us/minneapolis-shooting-alex-pretti-timeline.html">frame-by-frame breakdowns</a> as well. And just like in the case of Renee Good, every new piece of evidence proves the authorities are lying and supports the same interpretation. Masked agents of the state executed an American citizen.</p><p>These are the last 60 seconds in the life of Alex Pretti. We see him standing in the middle of the street, attempting to direct traffic away from ICE and CBP. He is holding a mobile phone, filming, observing, bearing witness. He did nothing to initiative the physical confrontation. But all of a sudden, federal agents attack another observer who had been on the street. Pretti tries to help her, hold her. Then they attack another woman, push her to the ground. Pretti attempts to help her up, putting his body in-between the woman and the agents. They pepper spray him in the face immediately. At this point, Pretti and the women he was trying to help are not obstructing the road in any way anymore. The agents could have just stopped. Walked away. Instead, seven masked agents swarm Pretti, tackle him to the ground, start beating him mercilessly. It is only when he is already on the ground that they realize he is carrying a gun – legally, we now know: He had a permit. And crucially, Pretti was not pulling or brandishing the weapon at any point. Throughout the entire ordeal, he is not the aggressor even once, simply attempting to protect himself against the blows that are raining down on him. One of the agents disarms him – we can see him walk away with Pretti’s gun. Then they shoot him. Ten shots, in a matter of a few seconds, from at least two DHS agents.</p><p>They shot a man <em>after</em> disarming him, having tackled him to the ground, who couldn’t have possibly posed a threat. It was an execution. About 60 seconds have passed since he stood in the street, calmly directing traffic.</p><p>And then the federal agents just walked away. No effort to help the victim. No effort to preserve the crime scene. Because in their understanding, this is not a crime scene – there had not been a crime at all. This is a battlefield. They killed an enemy of the state in the middle of the battlefield. Nothing to investigate.</p><p><strong>How we got here</strong></p><p>The timeline of events is important. Two months ago, Minneapolis was a peaceful city. There was no crisis, no widespread unrest – no need for armed agents of the state to intervene at all. All of the violence is the result of the Trump regime opportunistically jumping on a vile smear campaign against Somali immigrants in Minnesota. </p><p>On November 26, a 29-year-old Afghan national attacked two West Virginia National Guard members deployed to Washington, DC, killing one and severely wounding the other. The Trump government wasted no time using the attack as justification to escalate its crusade against immigrants and anyone who doesn’t belong in MAGA’s conception of “real America.” The president immediately started raging against Somali immigrants in Minnesota, who had nothing to do with the DC shooting, of course, but had been the target of racist agitation led by <a href="https://www.city-journal.org/article/fraud-minnesota-somali-immigration-debate">rightwing activists and think tanks</a> who had been focused on welfare fraud among some Somalis in Minnesota. </p><p>In several grotesquely racist rants, the president<a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m72352mo522x"> called them</a> human “garbage” who “come from hell and do nothing but bitch. We don’t want them.” Trump always made sure to include Minnesota Representative Ilhan Omar in <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m6znie6z4c2u">his attacks</a>: “We’re gonna go the wrong way if we keep taking in garbage into our country. Ilhan Omar is garbage. She’s garbage. Her friends are garbage.” Spokespeople of the regime quickly added a bunch of lies and <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m73suo6x2h2z">insinuated</a> there may have been some connection to the attack on National Guard troops in DC, even going so far as to claim the Somali community formed a <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m7apk46wpb2z">“nexus of terrorism.”</a> The legal status of the targeted immigrant population did not matter at all to the regime. When asked on television why ICE was going after Somali immigrants when the vast majority of them are U.S. citizens or legal residents, Trump’s border czar <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m7fovwxvxz2u">Tom Homan casually asserted</a> that “there’s a large illegal Somali community there.”</p><p>The raids on Minneapolis started in early December. Then, on January 6, the Department of Homeland Security announced it would massively ramp up its activities – “Operation Metro Surge,” they call it, sending out 2,000 federal agents, likely the largest federal “immigration enforcement” operation ever. By mid-January, the contingent of ICE agents concentrated in Minneapolis-St. Paul had swelled to around 3,000 – a number only possible because DHS has been pulling resources from all over the country, focusing a large portion of ICE’s operative capacity here.</p><p>All of the carnage in Minneapolis: The direct result of a paramilitary occupation fueled by a racist smear campaign and the desire of the extremists around Donald Trump to escalate the conflict with blue communities. After yet another public execution, the city is very close to going up in flames.</p><p><em>Help me continue this work and become a paid member of Democracy Americana:</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><strong>Enemies of the state</strong></p><p>Alex Pretti was a 37-year-old white man. A U.S. citizen. By those metrics, he was part of the demographic that is least vulnerable to the Trumpist assault. But as long as MAGA is in control of the levers of state power, anyone can quickly become a target. Pretti objected, he annoyed the regime, he showed solidarity with those under attack – in an immediate sense by coming to the aid of his fellow observers, and in a broader sense by protesting the kidnapping and abduction of people the Trumpists deem “illegals.” That was enough to make him an enemy of the state. Cross-racial solidarity is something a white nationalist regime cannot tolerate. This, I am certain, further fuels the regime’s frustration and the aggression of its armed agents on the ground: That the predominantly white population in Minnesota refuses to act like “real Americans” – rejecting the Trumpist quest to purge the nation and instead choosing to act in solidarity with their non-white neighbors. To this regime, they are traitors.</p><p><strong>Regime propaganda</strong></p><p>While the world was finding out about yet another murder of an American citizen, the Trump government was already producing the exact type of propaganda that had followed the killing of Renee Good. There is no act of violence committed by the agents of the state they won’t defend – no victim they won’t slander and vilify. <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/dbernstein.bsky.social/post/3md6tnqn4ts24">Stephen Miller</a> immediately called Pretti a “domestic terrorist” who “tried to assassinate federal law enforcement.” Border Patrol commander <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3md6wedy4zh2h">Greg Bovino</a> told the press that Pretti, who didn’t initiate the confrontation and never made an attempt to draw his gun, “wanted to do maximum damage and massacre law enforcement.” The regime’s spokespeople are not trying to convince and persuade anyone. They are not making factual contentions at all. They are presenting purely ideological assertions about how they want the world to work. And in this sense, their vile lies provide a window into how they see the world: Miller and Bovino truly regard Pretti – and anyone who dares to object in the streets of Minneapolis – as a terrorist. Here is the clearest encapsulation of Trumpism as a political project: Redraw the lines of who belongs, who is legitimate, who is part of the “Volk.” If you are, you get to rule, dominate, exploit. If you are not, because you deviate from MAGA’s vision of what “real America” is supposed to be, you have forfeited not only your rights and protections as a citizen, but also your humanity, your very right to live. To Miller, Bovino, and the masked goons roaming the streets in Minneapolis, Renee Good and Alex Pretti were not fellow citizens. They were enemies. Their humanity was to be discounted. They needed to be eliminated – one way or the other. They had it coming. They deserved to be killed.</p><p><strong>What is happening in Minneapolis?</strong></p><p>A key challenge throughout the Trump era has been to grapple honestly with what is happening instead of searching for ways to describe it as anything other than what it so clearly looks like. Luckily, those who are in charge of the government have a tendency to be rather transparent about their ambitions. As part of the regime’s overall strategy to militarize the political conflict, for instance, the Department of Homeland Security has embarked on what it calls a “wartime recruitment” strategy: Via targeted advertisement campaigns, they are trying to, as the <em>Washington Post</em> put it in an <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2025/12/31/ice-wartime-recruitment-push/?pwapi_token=eyJ0eXAiOiJKV1QiLCJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJyZWFzb24iOiJnaWZ0IiwibmJmIjoxNzY3NzYyMDAwLCJpc3MiOiJzdWJzY3JpcHRpb25zIiwiZXhwIjoxNzY5MTQ0Mzk5LCJpYXQiOjE3Njc3NjIwMDAsImp0aSI6ImZjMzMxZTM5LTkzMjEtNDVjMi05NTA0LTJjNzQzMTQ4ZmNiYyIsInVybCI6Imh0dHBzOi8vd3d3Lndhc2hpbmd0b25wb3N0LmNvbS90ZWNobm9sb2d5LzIwMjUvMTIvMzEvaWNlLXdhcnRpbWUtcmVjcnVpdG1lbnQtcHVzaC8ifQ.R93UIvpDUKqtJ_WxMJOKOMousqYDY8H_nDKQoR6_FlQ">investigative report</a>, “recruit gun rights supporters and military enthusiasts.” They have been bolstering the ranks of ICE and Border Patrol with people “who have attended UFC fights, listened to patriotic podcasts, or shown an interest in guns and tactical gear.” In other words, the government is actively looking for rightwing manosphere dudes they can count on to be ideologically loyal. The $100 million campaign uses explicitly fascistic iconography to make sure it attracts the right clientele: “Defend the Homeland” is the key slogan – America is at war, under siege, come helps us fight off those “foreign invaders” and the enemy within.</p><p>What these agencies are doing in Minneapolis doesn’t look like “enforcing immigration law” because that is fundamentally not what it is. ICE agents are not acting like federal officials trying to serve the community - because that’s not what they are doing. In Minneapolis, the federal government is laying siege to an American city. Trump has sent a violent goon squad of masked agents who believe they can kill with impunity. They serve as the paramilitary arm of the regime, harassing and terrorizing the local population. This is not law enforcement. It is an occupation.</p><p>ICE and Border Patrol have long been infamous, even among American law enforcement agencies, for their internal culture of aggression and violent impunity. The combination of a government not only enabling, but actively demanding escalation and a mass influx of bottom-of-the-barrel recruits will only make it worse. A terrorizing force of goons who are both drunken on the power the regime has bestowed upon them, but also perpetually insecure, frustrated, and aggrieved. Weaponized MAGA in masks. There will be more victims of state terrorism in the streets.</p><p>A society that has any aspiration to be free and democratic cannot - it must not! - tolerate the existence of an agency like ICE. In both personnel and institutionalized culture, ICE is a stronghold of violent authoritarianism, simply incompatible with the fundamental values of a democratic society. There is no technical or administrative fix for this, this is not a question of improving their training. This isn’t about policy at all. As a matter of democratic self-defense, ICE must not be tolerated. The people responsible for this occupation and the violence Minnesota is suffering – both those who are carrying it out in the streets as well as those who planned and ordered it – must be prosecuted and held to account.</p><p><strong>What happens next?</strong></p><p>Don’t listen to anyone making firm predictions about what happens next. The situation is highly fluid and volatile. This is a government spurred on by the most deranged far-right online corners. It is in the hands of people who perceive the world almost exclusively through the prism of a hermetically sealed rightwing information environment. Things could get out of hand quickly.</p><p>As a default, we should assume the government will keep escalating – not as part of a grand masterplan, but because they have no other strategy and nowhere else to go. The Trumpists came into power convinced they would quickly overwhelm what they believed was a liberal system so rotten that it would offer little resistance. That initial strategy failed, and MAGA has no coherent idea of how to get from where we are now to consolidated autocracy.</p><p>In that situation, frustrated ineptitude, extremist ideology, and MAGA psychology are all conspiring to make escalation almost inevitable. MAGA is ideologically and psycho-politically incapable of moderating. It is a hysterical movement that exists in a constant state of imagined emergency: Under siege, enemies everywhere – there is no room for compromise or restraint. Every crisis, every defeat only heightens their sense of being under siege. </p><p>To the extent they have a plan, it is coming from the Stephen Miller wing of the MAGA coalition: Incite violent confrontations in blue urban centers, then use that state-induced violence as a pretext to declare an emergency, invoke the Insurrection Act, start deploying regular troops. The president, it is true, has quite a bit of leeway over when and why to invoke the Insurrection Act (although that certainly doesn’t mean he has a right to do it whenever and for whatever reason, so we could surely expect the courts to get involved, for whatever that’s worth). But even if there are troops patrolling the streets of Minneapolis: What happens then? From there, the fever dreams of Trump and Miller are not self-executing. Miller surely imagines mass detentions and a comprehensive crackdown on all protest. The Insurrection Act, however, does not suspend the constitution and civil liberties, it does not establish martial law or a military dictatorship. It would allow Trump to put regular troops in the streets to serve as law enforcement. But the question we must insist on asking is: What is the path from there to a consolidated autocracy? What are the logistics and the mechanisms that would get the Trumpists from deploying troops in a mid-sized city to the regime eliminating all political, legal, and societal resistance? Let us force ourselves – against all fears of impending doom, as understandable as they are – to really think this through.</p><p>We can also turn the question around: Why hasn’t Trump invoked the Insurrection Act yet? After all, he has been talking about it, threatening it for years. He <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2024/02/trumps-immigration-plan-is-even-more-aggressive-now/677385/">brought it up repeatedly</a> during the 2024 campaign. Since returning to the White House, he has often claimed that he has the power <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m4dkndrkwk2j">“to enact a certain act”</a> whenever he wants to. So, if invoking the Insurrection Act is akin to waving a magic wand that makes Trump omnipotent and lets him install a dictatorship in an instant, why hasn’t he done it yet? The people who control the government are certainly not the most patient or a particularly prudent bunch. As a matter of practical reality, the idea that the minute Trump invokes the Insurrection Act all resistance is futile, Trump has won, Game Over is nonsense. That’s just regime propaganda. Perhaps the Trumpists, underneath all the bluster, know this too? Could it be that some in the administration are concerned that once they actually invoke the Insurrection Act, they can no longer use it as a constant threat? And if that doesn’t get their enemies to surrender, what do they have left?</p><p>The occupation of Minneapolis is binding a significant portion of the operative resources of the regime’s paramilitary units. What has Trump achieved with such a costly campaign so far? ICE certainly hasn’t broken the spirit of the people on the ground – it has actually galvanized the opposition. Local authorities are showing more resolve now than a month ago. Public opinion has been swinging hard against the regime. What is the path forward? The government is trying to break the will of the people in Minneapolis, hoping it will serve as a warning to rest of the nation. But if that fails, what’s next: Reduce Minneapolis to rubble? And how would that help them consolidate their rule across a country the size of Continental Europe if such violence is not coupled with a comprehensive strategy across all spheres of politics and society?</p><p>The Trumpist strategy, to the extent there is one, is centered around an assertion of absolute power. They hope they can convince enough people and institutions that resistance is either illegitimate (because Trump is supposedly representing the “will of the people”) or futile. A crucial part of the struggle against encroaching authoritarianism is to reject rather than perpetuate such notions. Don’t lie down, don’t acquiesce. Make them earn it. </p><p>I do not believe the violent occupation of Minneapolis is an effective strategy towards consolidating authoritarian rule. Alas, while it may (and I mean this sincerely: <em>may</em> – nothing is determined, nothing is guaranteed) not lead to a stable Trump autocracy, it is certainly enough to cause tremendous harm and bloodshed. The regime has made it clear that it will continue to lash out, react to every frustration with further escalation, ratchet up the violence every time they run into an obstacle. I do not say this lightly: From here on out, the struggle against Trumpist authoritarianism is only getting bloodier.</p><p><strong>The defense of the Republic</strong></p><p>“Where are the protests?” I have been getting this question in almost every interview and conversation I have done with international media, politicians, and diplomats. I remember how I was asked, live on German television, mere days after No Kings II: “Why are there no protests?” And three months later, as the people of Minneapolis are standing in solidarity against the outrageous occupation of their city, I’m still getting that question all the time.</p><p>A few days ago, I mentioned <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/thomaszimmer.bsky.social/post/3mcwmhbmkac2z">on social media</a> how hard it was to kill the idea that Americans weren’t standing up to the regime. This caused really strong reactions from two sides: Many people took offence, and rightfully so; but others – not just Germans, but a lot of Americans too – kept insisting that protest was largely negligible, and certainly insufficient. I believe the European perspective on the situation in the United States is, in this particular question, increasingly warped by misconceptions about the political structure as well as the geographic reality of America. Protests are mostly decentralized, often sustained for many weeks or even months, in thousands of locations across the country.</p><p>But most importantly, I wish people who still insist “there are no protests” would take another look at the cities that have been raided by ICE: Where the communities engaged in mass resistance – normal people who must know they risk getting attacked and detained, who are willing to sacrifice their freedom and their bodies. Let’s allow ourselves to be inspired by the heroism that is on display here.</p><p>Right now, it is not an exaggeration to say, Minnesotans are putting their lives on the line to fight for their city, protect their neighbors, and defend the Republic against tyranny.</p><p><em>Democracy Americana is my main source of income as an independent writer. Want to support my work? Consider becoming a paid member:</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/fccbc0fe-2ec6-4507-92ce-73c50964fdee/uploads/images/6yaypik5wm/24minneapolis-ice-victim-topart-fhlp-superJumbo.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/fccbc0fe-2ec6-4507-92ce-73c50964fdee</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">fccbc0fe-2ec6-4507-92ce-73c50964fdee</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 25 Jan 2026 22:07:35 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Limits of Violent Authoritarianism]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Trump’s authoritarian desires are boundless. But the past year proves that his ability to impose them on America is not.]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Trump’s authoritarian desires are boundless. But the past year proves that his ability to impose</strong> <strong>them on America is not. Even invoking the Insurrection Act would not magically change that.</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, January 20, 2026</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/a565b0ad-62e5-4f07-9e9b-2522407dae4b">Listen on Steady</a></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/a565b0ad-62e5-4f07-9e9b-2522407dae4b/uploads/images/bdydikerxs/iStock-1480868752.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>credit: iStock / John Webb</figcaption></figure><p><em>The first part of this piece is free for everyone. If you want to read more than the preview or gain access to the audio version of the essay, please consider becoming a paid member of Democracy Americana, which is solely funded by readers and constitutes my main source of income as an independent writer. You make this work possible with your support and generosity!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p>It has been a bleak start to the new year. In the first few weeks of 2026, the Trumpist government has drastically escalated its assault: On the international order and the idea of national sovereignty, to the point where Western European NATO allies are deploying troops to Greenland to deter an impending U.S. invasion; on truth and history, publishing a regime-mandated <a href="https://www.whitehouse.gov/j6/">propaganda version</a> of January 6 on the anniversary of the attack on the Capitol that presents the insurrectionists as martyrs and the Democratic opposition as evil traitors; on the foundations of the constitutional order, launching a paramilitary occupation of an American city and sending armed goons to spread state-sponsored violence against the local population.</p><p>One year since the man who campaigned on the promise of erecting a vindictive autocracy returned to the presidency. What would you have thought if someone had told you, twelve months ago, that this is what America would look like by January 2026?</p><p>What is the main takeaway from the first year of Trumpist rule? Under the impression of the latest developments, the intuitive reaction might be to describe the past year as a series of escalations that inexorably moved the country towards autocracy; a relentless authoritarian advancement and a pitiful retreat of the democratic system, pushing the Republic to the brink of obliteration.</p><p>However, I do not think this is the story of the past year - or an adequate assessment of where America stands.</p><p>Because it misses one key pattern: Several times over the past twelve months, the regime pushed the country right up to the edge of the kind of authoritarian escalation that would have taken America across the line into full-blown autocratic territory… but then failing and/or proving unwilling to actually go there. Several times the Trumpists seemed poised to vanquish the democratic opposition, break through whatever obstacles the constitutional order was still placing in their path, and wipe away the system entirely – but then were either unable or didn’t dare to force that next step.</p><p>This happened last spring, about two months into Trumpist rule, when the government announced it would henceforth ignore the courts entirely – but then didn’t; it happened in the early summer, when the deployment of National Guard troops to Los Angeles seemed to suggest the regime was ready to use emergency powers to quash the resistance in urban centers – but then pulled back from several major cities at the end of 2025; it happened after the murder of Charlie Kirk in September, when the Trumpists laid the pseudo-legal groundwork for a sweeping criminalization of all political and societal opposition – but then didn’t actually implement the type of comprehensive oppression the Right has been clamoring for.</p><p>These three moments crystallized a dynamic that stands in contrast to the idea of Trumpism’s steady, irresistible march towards consolidated authoritarian rule. And here I will try to preempt the criticism that I know I am guaranteed to encounter: Pointing out a pattern over the past twelve months is not the same as making a firm prediction of what might happen next. I am not trying to tell you that things are fine. The situation is acutely dangerous. The outcome of the current struggle against the authoritarian assault on democratic self-government remains undetermined. At the start of 2026, America is no longer a democracy. My goal is certainly not to diminish the damage the Trumpists have already caused, the harm they have done – and will continue to do! – to so many people, especially to the most vulnerable groups in American society.</p><p>What I am arguing is that being lawless, immoral, and violent does not make the Trumpists omnipotent. Their authoritarian desires are limitless, but their ability to impose them on the country is not. Let us not adopt and perpetuate the propagandistic assertion of inevitability. There remains a vast gulf between Trump’s authoritarian aspirations on the one hand and the realities of a complex modern state and society on the other. Obscuring that distinction is an act of defeatism that only serves the regime.</p><p>So, this is my assessment of the state of the Republic: Let us, first, look at those three moments when the Trumpists failed or did not dare to do what they threatened – when they encountered pushback they proved unable to overcome. Secondly, even though I am arguing that the violent spectacle the regime is staging is not an effective way towards consolidating authoritarian rule, we must also acknowledge how unpredictable the situation is and examine why the potential for a spiraling escalation is so high. Finally, I want to reflect on how this assessment of the state of American politics would change if Trump were to invoke the Insurrection Act, as he is (yet again) threatening to do: While it would undoubtedly constitute a dangerous escalation, the Insurrection Act is not some all-powerful cheat code that would instantly establish MAGA dictatorship. Part of what the Trumpists are trying to do is to break the will of the American people by asserting that resistance is futile. We must not let them.</p><p><strong>2025 in review: Identifying the limits of the autocratic assault</strong></p><p>Spring 2025: Trump vs the Courts</p><p>From the start, the Stephen Miller types were claiming the courts had no right to undermine Trump’s agenda because the MAGA president represented the “will of the people.” By late March, it seemed the government was ready to ignore the courts entirely.</p><p>At that point, the legal battles over the disappearing of Venezuelan migrants and the illegal deportation of Kilmar Abrego Garcia were at the center of the escalating conflict between the Trump regime and the courts. In mid-March, the Trump administration had rounded up hundreds of migrants from Venezuela, declared them members of the Tren de Aragua criminal organization based on no credible evidence whatsoever, then declared Tren de Aragua a terrorist organization and <a href="https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/03/invocation-of-the-alien-enemies-act-regarding-the-invasion-of-the-united-states-by-tren-de-aragua/">invoked the Alien Enemies Act</a> to remove them all from the country without due process. They were flown out to El Salvador on March 15 and dumped in what is best described as a labor camp, to be incarcerated indefinitely in one of the most brutal, most inhumane environments imaginable, subjected to physical and mental torture. Kilmar Abrego Garcia was on one of those planes with them (although in his case, the administration did not invoke the Alien Enemies Act, specifically).</p><p>Publicly, the Trumpists had long adopted a maximally aggressive posture. Trump had called the presiding judge at a district court in Washington, DC a <a href="https://www.npr.org/2025/03/18/nx-s1-5332086/trump-lawsuits">“radical left lunatic”</a> and called for his impeachment. Speaker of the House Mike Johnson had even brought up the idea that maybe the Republican-led Congress should <a href="https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/congress/speaker-mike-johnson-floats-eliminating-federal-courts-rcna197986?utm_source=firefox-newtab-en-us">“eliminate”</a> those federal courts that proved unruly. And hardly a day went by without Deputy White House Chief of Staff, Homeland Security Advisor, and MAGA nativist zealot Stephen Miller ranting against the <a href="https://x.com/stephenm/status/1905791054558744582?s=46&amp;t=1xecvNVImNo8TKt3oEvqnA">“tyranny”</a> those <a href="https://x.com/stephenm/status/1902698650519687264?s=46&amp;t=1xecvNVImNo8TKt3oEvqnA">“rogue Marxist judges”</a> were imposing on America, and his desire to quash what he called a <a href="https://x.com/stephenm/status/1905783803731493011?s=46&amp;t=1xecvNVImNo8TKt3oEvqnA">“far-left judicial riot.”</a></p><p>But in court, the government’s lawyers had, in the first two months after Trump’s return to the White House, pursued a different strategy, oscillating between open acts of defiance on the one hand and an attitude of obscuring and evading without openly defying on the other. This incoherence was the result of different MAGA factions pushing competing ideas for how to handle the courts: Some wanted to preserve plausible deniability and preferred a strategy of autocratic legalism, remaining within the confines of the law, at least nominally; others, like Miller, desired to properly go to war with the courts.</p><p>In late March, it seemed pretty clear that the overall trajectory pointed towards escalation. Even in court filings, the Department of Justice increasingly adopted an aggressive language towards judges. And on March 24, the DoJ informed the district court in Washington, DC that the government would not provide any further information regarding the deportation of the Venezuelan migrants and instead declared that the regime’s authority, because it derived from the <a href="https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2025/03/trump-boasberg-constitutional-crisis-latest-doj-king.html">“mandate of the electorate,”</a> superseded and nullified any right of the court to intervene.</p><p>Had they actually gone through with that and started ignoring the courts entirely, we would be in a very different situation today. But they did not.</p><p>For instance, the Department of Justice did return Kilmar Abrego Garcia to the United States on June 6. Twice the regime detained him afterwards – twice a court ordered him released. And release him they did. What he and the Venezuelan migrants who suffered torture in CECOT had to endure has certainly nothing to do with justice. But it is also not the case that the Trumpists went ahead and abolished the whole “liberal” court system, much to the frustration of extremist agitators on the Right <a href="https://graymirror.substack.com/p/you-cant-handle-the-truth">like Curtis Yarvin</a>.</p><p>And this is where we are right now: No matter how many times Stephen Miller may declare all dissident judges to be <a href="https://edition.cnn.com/2025/10/06/politics/republican-federal-judges-trump">insurrectionists</a> and domestic terrorists: The federal courts continue to act as the most effective bulwark in defense of democratic self-government and the rule of law. <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2025/us/trump-administration-lawsuits.html">Hundreds of lawsuits</a> have been filed against the administration, and in the vast majority of those, federal district courts have sided against the government, with federal judges issuing injunctions or restrictions that have undoubtedly slowed down the authoritarian assault. And the administration is still participating in the judicial system. They are still sending lawyers to argue in court, they are appealing to the Supreme Court, thereby acknowledging some legitimacy of the process. Despite all the posturing, the threats, the authoritarian propaganda about the “will of the people” forbidding the courts from intervening: They haven’t really pulled the trigger.</p><p>Summer 2025: The National Guard</p><p>In June, when Trump deployed the National Guard to Los Angeles, the path towards autocracy seemed clear: The regime would use the aggressive immigration raids conducted by ICE and Border Patrol to provoke violent confrontations in blue urban centers, then use that state-induced violence as a pretext to declare an emergency, invoke the Insurrection Act, start deploying regular troops…</p><p>But so far, that hasn’t happened. Instead, the regime’s strategy of deploying the National Guard quickly reached an impasse. After Trump sent the National Guard to Washington, DC in August, Portland and Chicago were supposed to be next. But yet again, the courts intervened – and the regime begrudgingly complied. In October, a district court blocked the deployment to Chicago. The administration wanted the Supreme Court to step in and overrule. But shortly before Christmas, the Roberts Court sided against Trump. While National Guard troops are still deployed to Memphis, New Orleans, and DC, Trump <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/12/31/us/politics/trump-national-guard.html">ended the year by announcing</a> he would no longer be attempting to send them into Chicago and Portland.</p><p>Fall 2025: The aftermath of the Charlie Kirk murder</p><p>I know I keep harping on this moment and have written about it frequently – but I really think it is crucial to remember the vast gap between the regime’s proclamations and its actions in the wake of the murder of Charlie Kirk in September.</p><p>On the Right, the calls to classify the Democratic Party as a “<a href="https://bsky.app/profile/gelliottmorris.com/post/3lyj3ztf4e222">domestic terrorist organization</a>” erupted immediately: All “leftist” organizations, the rightwing activist scene demanded, should be <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/whstancil.bsky.social/post/3lyjrmamlzs2p">criminalized, all their members arrested</a>. The Trumpist government quickly tried to seize the moment. Just days after the murder, they used all channels to declare their intention to crack down on liberal America and anyone they consider to be a leftist enemy. Hosting Charlie Kirk’s talk radio show on September 15, for instance, <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/videos/ckge487nr6ro">Vice President JD Vance</a> vowed to “go after the NGO networks,” and Stephen Miller promised to use the power of the state to <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/videos/ckge487nr6ro">“uproot and dismantle these terrorist networks”</a> and bring down the <a href="https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/white-house/trump-administration-says-will-target-far-left-groups-kirks-assassinat-rcna231605">“vast domestic terror movement”</a> that was the American Left.</p><p>A week later, the Trumpists attempted to lay the pseudo-legal groundwork for their crackdown.</p><p>On September 22, Trump signed an <a href="https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/09/designating-antifa-as-a-domestic-terrorist-organization/">executive order</a> designating “Antifa” as a “domestic terrorist organization,” wanting to use “Antifa” as a master signifier for everything and everyone who dares to dissent. Just three days later, on September 25, Trump issued <a href="https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/09/countering-domestic-terrorism-and-organized-political-violence/">National Security Presidential Memorandum 7</a> (NSPM-7) on “Countering Domestic Terrorism and Organized Political Violence,” instructing the entire machinery of the federal government to employ an incredibly expansive definition of “domestic terrorism” to go after any organization or individual associated with leftist “anti-fascism.” These documents were obviously intended to function as flexible instruments to go after the “enemy within.” They opened the door for virtually anyone in the United States – certainly anyone who is critical of Trump – to be harassed by the state as a domestic terrorist. </p><p>This is terrifying stuff. But as important as it is to recognize the threat, we must also remember that the regime has so far been either unwilling or unable to actually start implementing such comprehensive oppression. In fact, the American people responded to the regime’s bloodlust with some of the largest protests in modern U.S. history.</p><p>On October 18, the second No Kings protests brought about six to seven million people out into the streets, united in opposition to Donald Trump, in thousands of demonstrations across the country. The protests came after several weeks of the Trumpist government engaging in an all-out propaganda campaign to declare all dissent illegitimate and demonize all those on the “Left,” defined vaguely as anyone not on board with MAGA, as domestic terrorists or at least terrorism-adjacent. Yet when the day came, the authoritarian movement that controls the levers of state power and had preemptively declared the No Kings protests illegitimate and unacceptable… did nothing.</p><p>In September, the idea that the murder of Charlie Kirk was the “<a href="https://bsky.app/profile/willbunch.bsky.social/post/3lyjh3t5zuc2k">American Reichstag fire</a>” quickly made the rounds in rightwing online circles. On February 27, 1933, just weeks after the Nazis had come to power, the German Reichstag, the seat of parliament, was set on fire. The Nazis used this event as pretext to nullify civil liberties and conduct mass arrests of political opponents – a key step in destroying whatever was left of the formerly democratic Weimar Republic and towards erecting dictatorship. That is also what rightwing radicals envisioned for America. Four months have since passed. Yet again, the regime has so far proved unwilling and/or unable to fulfill the fever dreams of its most extreme supporters.</p><p><strong>The occupation of Minneapolis</strong></p><p>To start the year 2026, the federal government is laying siege to an American city. Trump has sent a violent goon squad of masked agents to Minneapolis. They serve as the paramilitary arm of the regime, harassing and terrorizing the local population. This is not law enforcement. It is an occupation.</p><p>But in Minneapolis, as in every other urban center these masked goons descend upon, the local community is rallying in solidarity. Not only are ICE and Border Patrol failing to meet their quota of detentions. Minneapolis is a mid-sized city. And even though ICE is withdrawing agents from other parts of the country, focusing much of its resources on the Minneapolis-St. Paul metropolitan area, they are proving incapable of establishing the type of control they desire. ICE wants to terrify people into submission and compliance so that they can operate with impunity, unimpeded, in semi-secrecy. It is not working. The violent spectacle the regime is producing may get them the applause of the rightwing online scene. But what the regime is doing in Minneapolis is <a href="https://www.gelliottmorris.com/p/ice-is-a-70-30-issue-against-trump">extremely unpopular</a>. Public support for ICE has plummeted. Even the most staunchly authoritarian regime must care about its public standing. America still has competitive elections. And more generally, in a complex modern society, the government – no matter the regime type – inevitably depends on millions of people following along to some degree. They depend on some measure of consent from institutions and individuals alike. They could, potentially, ramp up oppression dramatically in the face of popular discontent; but the Trumpists do not have the apparatus to do that, certainly not yet, and such a strategy also has inherent limits: The regime still needs millions to comply in order to keep the machine going.</p><p>Laying siege to an American city is not an effective way to consolidate authoritarian control over a country that is roughly the size of continental Europe.</p><p><strong>So, is Trump losing? It’s the wrong question to ask.</strong></p><p>Towards the end of 2025, there was a flurry of <a href="https://www.vox.com/politics/472346/trump-democracy-2025-haphazard-authoritarian">“Trump is losing”</a> assessments. <a href="http://www.doomsdayscenario.co/p/donald-trump-is-losing">They all</a> pointed to <a href="https://www.liberalcurrents.com/we-are-going-to-win/">crucial developments</a>: Trump’s hold over the Right and the Republican Party had been weakening since the fall; all the infighting on the Trumpist Right – the much-discussed <a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/279fc0c5-26c5-4057-b986-fd0f16717aa7">“MAGA civil war”</a> – was an indication that Trump’s coalition was disintegrating; societal resistance had been hardening, and the regime evidently struggled to come up with strategies for how to overcome it.</p><p>While I share the general assessment that the MAGA assault has been running into trouble, I maintain that binary categories of Trump “winning vs losing” are not particularly helpful. They tend to reproduce mood swings more than they help generate plausible analysis. Every Trumpian embarrassment is destined to cause a new round of “Trump is weak, he is losing” pieces; every authoritarian escalation is accompanied by a chorus of “Democracy is dead, MAGA won” post-mortems. As unsatisfactory as that may feel, we should allow ourselves to grapple with the murkiness of what is a highly ambiguous, even contradictory moment in U.S. history.</p><p>One particular issue I have with the “Trump is losing” framework is that it tends to underestimate how quickly things could get out of hand. I don’t just mean that in a “Something bad could always happen” kind of way – everyone acknowledges that sort of general contingency. I am more concerned with how ideology and ineptitude may conspire to make escalation almost inevitable. MAGA is ideologically and psycho-politically incapable of moderating: It is a hysterical movement that exists in a constant state of imagined emergency: Under siege, enemies everywhere – there is no room for compromise or restraint. Every crisis, every defeat only heightens their sense of being under siege, legitimizing and amplifying calls to hit harder, more aggressively. That is the Stephen Miller mindset. Add on top of that the fact that the Trumpists came into power convinced they would quickly overwhelm what they thought to be a liberal system so rotten that it would offer little resistance. That initial strategy failed, and MAGA has no coherent idea of how to get from where we are now to consolidated autocracy. In that situation, Stephen Miller keeps yelling to escalate – as it is what he desires to do and also, within the narrow universe of pathways MAGA is willing to consider, the only option they are left with.</p><p>There are also structural reasons why the escalation has taken the form of a paramilitary occupation on the domestic front and quasi-imperialist invasions internationally. As the courts keep stalling MAGA’s domestic agenda and frustration over societal resistance mounts, it becomes more attractive to the regime to focus on areas where their desire to dominate, plunder, and punish is more easily put into practice. Trump has an instrument of personal grievance in the Department of Justice, and so he uses it to go after his enemies and critics. The regime has built ICE into a quasi-paramilitary arm, and so they are sending them out into the streets. The president’s power is a lot harder to restrain in matters of foreign policy, and so he revels in fantasies of global conquest. This certainly isn’t the first authoritarian regime that, when faced with frustrations and public pressure, ramps up the demonization of vulnerable groups at home and throws itself into military “adventures” abroad.</p><p>Things are bound to escalate further. And even if it is the case, as I have argued, that the Trumpists are falling short of their own ambitions, Trumpism in power has still caused – and will continue to cause – massive damage not only to the lives of hundreds of thousands, perhaps millions of people, but also to the system and its institutions. While this government may not succeed at erecting a Trump dictatorship, they will keep trying. And by the time they are finally removed from power, America will be left with the rubble.</p><p><strong>What the Insurrection Act would do to America</strong></p><p>As I am writing this, Trump has ramped up the threat to invoke the Insurrection Act. Wouldn’t that make everything I have outlined here, about the Trumpists running into obstacles they have been unable to overcome, obsolete? I do not think so.</p><p>There’s no point in making firm predictions. Trump has been talking about invoking the Insurrection Act for years; he <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2024/02/trumps-immigration-plan-is-even-more-aggressive-now/677385/">brought it up repeatedly</a> during the 2024 campaign. Since returning to the White House, he has often claimed that he has the power <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m4dkndrkwk2j">“to enact a certain act”</a> whenever he wants to.</p><p>The Insurrection Act basically creates an exception from the <a href="https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/research-reports/posse-comitatus-act-explained">Posse Comitatus Act of 1878</a>, which bars federal troops from being deployed domestically for law enforcement purposes. It allows the president to, as the Brennan Center puts it in <a href="https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/research-reports/insurrection-act-explained">a very helpful explainer</a>, “suppress rebellion or domestic violence or to enforce the law in certain situations.” What situations? Well, this is where it gets tricky. Unfortunately, the president has quite a bit of leeway over when and why to invoke the Insurrection Act. According to the Brennan Center: “In theory, the Insurrection Act should be used only in a crisis that is truly beyond the capacity of civilian authorities to manage. However, the Insurrection Act fails to adequately define or limit when it may be used and instead gives the president significant power to decide when and where to deploy U.S. military forces domestically.” Throughout U.S. history, it has been invoked about 30 times – most recently when President George H.W. Bush sent federal troops to Los Angeles during the Rodney King riots in the spring of 1992, at the request of both the governor of California and the mayor of Los Angeles.</p><p>It is obvious why the Insurrection Act appeals to Trump: He undoubtedly imagines it as a kind of cheat code that would give him <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m3kjyarncn2b">“unquestioned power”</a> – including to suppress protests, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kQYW_ITznX4">to “just shoot them,”</a> as he believes he should have been able to order the military to do during the George Floyd protests in the summer of 2020.</p><p>But here it is imperative we push back against such notions that present the Insurrection Act as the ultimate weapon in the hands of the authoritarian regime. Leave aside, for a moment, the question of how the courts would react (and how the regime would react to a court intervening, which would almost definitely happen): While this step would undoubtedly constitute a major escalation – one Trump has so far been reluctant to force, despite all the bluster and unhinged rhetoric –, invoking the Insurrection Act is not akin to waving a magic wand that vanquishes all opposition.</p><p>In an immediate sense, the Insurrection Act would allow Trump to militarize the conflict even further, to put more people with guns in the streets of Minneapolis. It could potentially establish an extremely dangerous precedent, eroding the barriers against using the Insurrection Act as a vehicle to suppress protest. But the Insurrection Act, as much as Trump wants us to believe otherwise, does not suspend the constitution and civil liberties, it does not establish martial law or a military dictatorship. Federal troops patrolling the streets would still be constrained by the law, restricted to regular law enforcement powers.</p><p>I hesitate to write this, but isn’t it reasonable, at this point, to expect federal troops to be more restrained than the bottom-of-the-barrel goon squad that is ICE? Might we not assume that the officers who command those troops feel more constrained by the law than the masked paramilitaries who know they have been sent to Minneapolis to terrorize the people?</p><p>Do not misconstrue what I am trying to say here: I am not telling you not to worry. I hope you do. There is ample reason to be alarmed. The fact that we even have to entertain such questions is powerful evidence for how far down the path to autocracy the country already is. But right now, a key part of the struggle against encroaching authoritarianism is to reject rather than perpetuate the Trumpist assertions of absolute power, to push back against the notion that resistance is futile. The government is trying to break the will of the people in Minneapolis, hoping it will serve as a warning to rest of the nation. But if the resistance prevails, the paramilitary occupation of this city will become something else: A reminder of democratic freedom and solidarity.</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/a565b0ad-62e5-4f07-9e9b-2522407dae4b">Listen on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/a565b0ad-62e5-4f07-9e9b-2522407dae4b/uploads/images/bdydikerxs/iStock-1480868752.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/a565b0ad-62e5-4f07-9e9b-2522407dae4b</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">a565b0ad-62e5-4f07-9e9b-2522407dae4b</guid>
      <pubDate>Tue, 20 Jan 2026 12:32:51 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[When the State Terrorizes the People]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The killing of Renee Good reveals, yet again, Trumpism’s violent, authoritarian essence. MAGA is at war with the reality of American society.]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The killing of Renee Good reveals, yet again, Trumpism’s violent, authoritarian essence. MAGA is at war with the reality of American society.</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, January 11, 2026</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/4b2f8d7a-55ba-4a6b-a523-1a1ee780fd69">Listen on Steady</a></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/4b2f8d7a-55ba-4a6b-a523-1a1ee780fd69/uploads/images/7e43xkkgz2/dims.apnews.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt="We see through the open passenger door into Good’s SUV. The glove compartment is overflowing with toys and stuffies. But next to it, the deployed airbag is drenched in blood."/><figcaption>Credit: Ellen Schmidt/MinnPost via AP</figcaption></figure><p><em>Before we get into it, can I bother you for a minute?</em></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is my main source of income as an independent writer. I you are reading the free version of this newsletter, I sincerely appreciate your time and effort engaging with my work! Please share it widely to help me reach new readers. If you are not subscribed yet, you can </em><strong><em>subscribe for free</em></strong><em> and you will get these long-form essays delivered straight to your inbox whenever they come out.</em></p><p><em>And if you can, please consider becoming a </em><strong><em>paid member</em></strong><em>. You will gain access to special benefits – including additional essays.</em></p><p><em>Most importantly, Democracy Americana is a publication solely funded by readers. I fully rely on your support and generosity to make this work possible. Thank you!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p>Renee Nicole Good, mother of three children, died mere blocks away from where she lived with her wife and her youngest son, who is 6 years old.</p><p>On Wednesday, January 7, Good and her wife, after dropping of their kid at school, were observing and protesting an ICE and Border patrol raid in their neighborhood. It was part of a surge of about 2,000 federal agents the Trump government had sent into the city to target Somali immigrants, specifically, as the Trumpist quest to “purge” the nation via mass deportation continues.</p><p>The SUV Good was driving was sideways on the street: She was perhaps attempting to block traffic – although there was plenty of space for other vehicles to go around her. We know exactly what happened next, because we have <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/video/us/100000010631041/minneapolis-ice-shooting-video.html">video evidence</a> from different angles that now even includes the killer’s perspective. The ICE agent who killed Good filmed the whole thing on his cellphone; <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/thetnholler.bsky.social/post/3mbz3va3en22e">the footage</a> was leaked to a far-right website, presumably in an attempt to exonerate the agent. That is astonishing, actually, as the footage so clearly supports what all the other videos already suggested: Good was executed in public.</p><p>The last moments in the life of Renee Good: While the ICE agent who is about to kill her films the car, Good’s wife lightly taunts him; Good herself says: “That’s fine, dude. I’m not mad at you,” as he comes around to film her. Good and her wife are not acting aggressively, there is no credible threat whatsoever, absolutely no need to escalate. But escalation is the only thing these masked agents of the state desire: Another ICE officer enters the scene, aggressively approaching the vehicle. Good tries to get away, steer the car away from the agents. She does so quite slowly, actually; she is obviously not trying to ram or endanger anyone. What happens if the ICE agent who has been filming on his cellphone does nothing in this situation? Nothing. Good drives off, no one gets hurt. But instead, he immediately fires three shots from close range. “Fuckin’ bitch,” he utters, before walking away.</p><p>There are different ways to adequately describe what happened there on the streets of Minneapolis: A murder, a wanton killing, a public execution of an American citizen by an agent of the Trumpist regime. We are left with one of the defining images of Trump’s authoritarian assault: On photos taken shortly after the killing, we see through the open passenger door into Good’s SUV. It’s a bit messy, as family cars always are: The glove compartment is overflowing with toys and stuffies. But next to it, the deployed airbag is drenched in blood. Another life taken, another family destroyed.</p><p><strong>Blood martyrs and domestic terrorists</strong></p><p>Renee Good was the victim of a government that is perpetually at war with a large portion of the American population. She was murdered one day after the Trump regime presented its official “reinterpretation,” to use a euphemistic term, of the January 6 Insurrection. On the anniversary of the assault on the Capitol, the White House <a href="https://www.whitehouse.gov/j6/">launched a website</a> that outlines the regime-official version of the events. In this state-mandated tale, “it was the Democrats who staged the real insurrection by certifying a fraud-ridden election, ignoring widespread irregularities, and weaponizing federal agencies to hunt down dissenters.” It was a “peaceful march” of patriotic Americans, we are told, until Capitol Police escalated the situation and Ashli Babbitt was “murdered in cold blood.” More traitorous injustice, the White House claims: “Betrayal of the President,” “Stolen election certified,” “President Trump silenced,” “Mass arrests of patriotic protesters.” But, finally, when Donald Trump returned to the presidency: “Triumph over tyranny.”</p><p>Ashli Babbitt and Renee Good: Two young women shot and killed by federal officers. The former because she was part of a violent insurrection – the latter because she peacefully protested the masked agents of the state sent into her city to kidnap her neighbors. But in the upside-down world of MAGA, Babbitt is the hero, the patriot, the martyr; Good is a “domestic terrorist.” Such a clear crystallization of Trumpism as a political project: Redraw the lines of who belongs, who is legitimate, who is part of the “Volk.” If you are, you get to rule, dominate, exploit. If you are not, because you deviate from MAGA’s vision of what “real America” is supposed to be, you have forfeited not only your rights and protections as a citizen, but also your humanity, your very right to live. The America MAGA wants to impose is one of brutal hierarchies. It is ugly and violent. Dominate or be dominated.</p><p><strong>MAGA lies and violent truths</strong></p><p>The government and its supporters started viciously lying about what happened in Minneapolis right away. In a deranged <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/drewharwell.com/post/3mbufgs2iz22f">social media post</a>, Trump blamed the “radical Left” and attacked Good who “violently, willfully, and viciously ran over the ICE officer.” The Department of Homeland Security immediately <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/itsvanaken.games/post/3mbtzxgj5a225">released a statement</a> calling Good a “domestic terrorist.” “One of those violent rioters weaponized her vehicle, attempting to run over our law enforcement officers in an attempt to kill them,” a <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/chrislhayes.bsky.social/post/3mbtzl46lbs23">DHS spokesperson</a> added – “an act of domestic terrorism,” DHS secretary <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3mbumibs7ox25">Kristi Noem</a> declared. If there is a campaign going on to justify violence against a declared enemy of the MAGA regime via lies and dehumanization, you can always count on Vice President JD Vance to chime in: He would only talk about Good as “that woman” who Vance claims was “brainwashed” by “left-wing ideology.” According to Vance, <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/thebulwark.com/post/3mbwqfwlc3425">“this is classic terrorism,”</a> committed by the “far-left fringe.”</p><p>It is not exactly breaking news that the U.S. government is in the hands of shameless liars who have zero regard for truth or morality. But it is important to emphasize that this is not merely the “normal” spin almost all politicians engage in, but regime propaganda entirely detached from the facts and utterly unconcerned with objectively observable reality. It is the duty of every democratic citizen to call it out, reject it, push back.</p><p>At the same time, however, let us not waste energy trying to convince anyone on the MAGA Right with facts. Don’t engage with the vile regime propaganda as if it was advanced in good faith. It was never meant to stand up to scrutiny, only to muddy the waters, give the rightwing media machine its marching orders, and tell the MAGA faithful what to believe. Trump, Noem, and Vance are not making factual contentions at all. They are presenting purely ideological assertions about how they want the world to work.</p><p>The only way we can find truth amid this endless stream of lies is if we see the propaganda as a window into the Trumpist psyche. What stands out is the combination of pathetic self-victimization and faux bravado. MAGA is simultaneously obsessed with their own strength: Manly men with guns who dominate and conquer and take what they want! But also fearful victims, persecuted and oppressed, suffering under the yoke of evil “wokeism,” scared to death by an unarmed woman in a family SUV. “I demand you revere me as a brave alpha male while also indulging my every insecurity,” MAGA-Man says. A toxic, dangerous mix of wounded masculinity and delusions of superhero dominance. A similar dynamic also defines MAGA in power: As the regime’s legitimacy depends as much on the notion of a persisting threat as on demonstrating the ability to act in response, there can never be a stable equilibrium or compromise. Even though the regime constantly claims success and victory in defending the nation, the homeland is endlessly under siege and can never be safe.</p><p><strong>What MAGA has wrought</strong></p><p>What really stands out about the regime’s response and the way the MAGA Right has reacted to the killing of Renee Good is the complete lack of empathy. They are not even pretending. And that may be the most honest thing about this movement. They don’t regret what happened in Minneapolis because they don’t regard people like Renee Good and anyone who dares to object to their idea of “real America” as fellow citizens. They are enemies, their humanity is discounted. The United States government is in the hands of people who simply don’t think Renee Good’s life was worth all that much.</p><p>Since Wednesday, Republican elected officials have publicly stated more or less explicitly that they believe Good deserved to be killed. Florida representative Randy Fine, for instance, <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3mbw6zeogqh2l">went on Newsmax</a> to declare: “The Left believe they can do anything they want and we’re just supposed to sit down and take it. It’s time for Americans to say ‘enough,’ and if you get in the way of the government repelling a foreign invasion, you’re gonna end up just like that lady did yesterday.” If you “get in the way,” and you prove to be a nuisance to the regime, you deserve to be killed by the state.</p><p>Meanwhile, the regime’s propaganda machine has been hard at work reminding their audience that they are supposed to hate and fear <em>those</em> people: <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3mbv3a2pevm2l">On Fox News</a>, for instance, Jesse Waters told his viewers that Good had “pronouns in her bio” and had a “lesbian partner”; rightwing online extremist <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/joestieb.bsky.social/post/3mbypqjamhs2k">Matt Walsh</a> made sure to remind his audience that Good was a “lesbian agitator.” The message is clear: The state committing violence against such obnoxious deviants is good and necessary – they are the “Other” that must be subjugated and punished.</p><p><em>Help me continue this work and become a paid member of Democracy Americana:</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><strong>Violence as a tool to impose “order”</strong></p><p>For years, all strands of the Right – elected officials, the media machine, the intellectual sphere, the base – have been openly embracing and clamoring for state and vigilante violence if it is directed against anything and anyone associated with “the Left.” It is fitting that none other than violence grifter Kyle Rittenhouse sensed an opportunity to get some attention from the far-right crowd. “After thinking about it, should I travel across the state line to Minnesota?” he <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/sethcotlar.bsky.social/post/3mbv76i4m6s2u">posted on Ex-Twitter</a> on Wednesday (he added a grinning face emoji too, because it’s really funny when a mother of three gets shot in the face, isn’t it?). In August 2020, you will remember, Rittenhouse killed two men and wounded a third during the protests after the police shooting of Jacob Blake in Kenosha, Wisconsin. For his actions, he was widely celebrated on the Right as a patriotic hero. He was interviewed by Tucker Carlson, met with Donald Trump, far-right extremists inside Congress were dreaming about welcoming Rittenhouse as one of their own, jostling for the opportunity to have him as an intern, to promote and encourage his rise to political stardom.</p><p>The glorification of people like Rittenhouse sends a clear message: The use of violence against anything and anyone associated with “the Left” is not only justified - it is an urgently necessary “patriotic” act. Beyond just functioning as a tool for upholding political power in a narrow sense, the violence also serves as a way to enforce the underlying vision for a society in which some people – white men, in particular – have the absolute right to defend their place, status, and “comfort.” America is built on a social order that gives white men, specifically, the power to use whatever form of violence they deem necessary to “defend” themselves against all threats from “others,” real and perceived. This order is predicated on an expansive idea of what constitutes a “threat.” Black people, for instance, are seen as inherently threatening; or, in this case: An unarmed woman in a family SUV. </p><p><strong>Masked goons roaming the streets</strong></p><p>The Right is defined by a political and social culture of white grievance, ethno-religious nationalism, gun fundamentalism, desire for male domination, glorified militancy, and paranoid conspiratorialism. It is bound to produce people who believe it is their patriotic duty to use violence.</p><p>These are exactly the people the regime is now actively recruiting for ICE and Border Patrol, in an effort to create a quasi-paramilitary force to serve as the regime’s violent enforcers in the streets. As part of the regime’s overall strategy to militarize the political conflict, the Department of Homeland Security has embarked on what it calls a “wartime recruitment” strategy: Via targeted advertisement campaigns, they are trying to, as the <em>Washington Post</em> put it in an <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2025/12/31/ice-wartime-recruitment-push/?pwapi_token=eyJ0eXAiOiJKV1QiLCJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJyZWFzb24iOiJnaWZ0IiwibmJmIjoxNzY3NzYyMDAwLCJpc3MiOiJzdWJzY3JpcHRpb25zIiwiZXhwIjoxNzY5MTQ0Mzk5LCJpYXQiOjE3Njc3NjIwMDAsImp0aSI6ImZjMzMxZTM5LTkzMjEtNDVjMi05NTA0LTJjNzQzMTQ4ZmNiYyIsInVybCI6Imh0dHBzOi8vd3d3Lndhc2hpbmd0b25wb3N0LmNvbS90ZWNobm9sb2d5LzIwMjUvMTIvMzEvaWNlLXdhcnRpbWUtcmVjcnVpdG1lbnQtcHVzaC8ifQ.R93UIvpDUKqtJ_WxMJOKOMousqYDY8H_nDKQoR6_FlQ">investigative report</a>, “recruit gun rights supporters and military enthusiasts.” They want to bolster the ranks of ICE and Border Patrol with more people “who have attended UFC fights, listened to patriotic podcasts, or shown an interest in guns and tactical gear.” In other words, the government is actively looking for rightwing manosphere dudes they can count on to be ideologically loyal. The $100 million campaign uses explicitly fascistic iconography to make sure it attracts the right clientele: “Defend the Homeland” is the key slogan – America is at war, under siege, come helps us fight off those “foreign invaders” and the enemy within.</p><p>ICE and Border Patrol have long been infamous, even among American law enforcement agencies, for their internal culture of aggression and violent impunity. The combination of a government not only enabling, but actively demanding escalation and a mass influx of bottom-of-the-barrel recruits will only make it worse. A terrorizing force of goons who are both drunken on the power the regime has given them, but also perpetually insecure, frustrated, and aggrieved. They don’t think of themselves as federal officers serving the people – they act like an occupation force, treating an American city as hostile territory and everyone in it as the enemy. Weaponized MAGA in masks. There will be more victims of state terrorism in the streets.</p><p><strong>“Domestic terrorism”</strong></p><p>It has been a bleak start to 2026. Much like when the regime first deployed National Guard troops in Los Angeles in early summer or when the Right was screaming for blood after the murder of Charlie Kirk in September, it feels like the country might be on the brink of crossing the line to a whole different level of authoritarian oppression. We must grapple honestly with the fact that this is indeed one realistic scenario: That the Trumpists will use the violence they have provoked and perpetrated in Minneapolis to justify further escalation.</p><p>Just like after the Kirk murder, the regime has been quick to demonize Renee Good and anyone daring to protest or object to ICE occupation in any way as members of a terrorist conspiracy. “The deadly incident that took place yesterday in Minnesota yesterday,” White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt declared, “occurred as a result of a larger, sinister left-wing movement that has spread across our country where our brave men and women of federal law enforcement are under organized attack.” This has been the Sword of Damocles hanging over what’s left of the American Republic since September, when the Trumpists used the murder of Charlie Kirk as pretext to lay the pseudo-legal groundwork for a comprehensive crackdown. On September 22, Trump signed an <a href="https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/09/designating-antifa-as-a-domestic-terrorist-organization/">executive order</a> designating “Antifa” as a “domestic terrorist organization,” wanting to use “Antifa” as a master signifier for everything and everyone who dares to dissent. Just three days later, on September 25, Trump issued <a href="https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/09/countering-domestic-terrorism-and-organized-political-violence/">National Security Presidential Memorandum 7</a> (NSPM-7) on “Countering Domestic Terrorism and Organized Political Violence,” instructing the entire machinery of the federal government to employ an incredibly expansive definition of “domestic terrorism” to go after any organization or individual associated with leftist “anti-fascism.” These documents were obviously intended to function as flexible instruments to go after the “enemy within.” They opened the door for virtually anyone in the United States – certainly anyone who is critical of Trump – to be harassed by the state as a domestic terrorist.</p><p>As important as it is to recognize the threat, we must also remember that the regime has so far been either unwilling or unable to actually start implementing such comprehensive oppression. In fact, over the past year, we have observed a pattern of the regime taking the country right up to the edge of full-blown autocracy… but then failing and/or proving unwilling to actually go there. Meanwhile, political and societal resistance has hardened – and MAGA has shown signs of disintegrating as Trump’s hold over his movement has weakened. The Trumpist lust for authoritarian control is limitless – but their capability to implement their desires against the realities of a pluralistic modern society and a complex political system is not. The people who control the levers of state power are lawless and cruel. But that doesn’t make them omnipotent.</p><p><strong>What comes next?</strong></p><p>I will leave you with three thoughts on where America might go from here. First of all, prosecuting these goons who are roaming the streets to terrorize the people must be the priority of the next Democratic administration. If and when America finds a way out of authoritarianism, not only will ICE have to be abolished: All these people will need to be held accountable in a court of law for the monstrosities they are committing – those who are ordering them as well as those who are carrying them out. I hope Democrats understand that if and when they get back to power, defaulting to “unity” politics and empty reconciliation without any real accountability would not only be morally abhorrent, but also politically suicidal: The desire for at least some semblance of justice will be overwhelming.</p><p>Secondly, the Trumpists want to project strength and dominance. But as much as they are causing – and will continue to cause! – horrible harm, I do not believe the spectacle of cruelty they are producing is helping them consolidate authoritarian rule. This is a regime driven by the desire to create social media content for their hardcore fans on the extreme Right. That is why the guy who killed Renee Good was filming everything on his phone; that is why Trump and Hegseth were <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/2026/01/trump-venezuela-memes/685525/">monitoring reactions on Ex-Twitter</a> as the raid on Venezuela unfolded. On the one hand, this is an immensely dangerous situation: This is a government spurred on by the most deranged far-right online corners. But this also hampers their ability to act in tactically sound, cunning, rational ways. Trump is surrounded by people who perceive the world almost exclusively through the prism of a hermetically sealed rightwing information environment. That helps explain why they are vastly overestimating how much support they have for their cruel spectacle. <a href="https://www.gelliottmorris.com/p/support-for-abolishing-ice-is-at">ICE is extremely unpopular</a>, support for abolishing it is quickly rising. A <a href="https://prri.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/2025-AVS-Presentation_Brookings-Event.pdf">stable majority</a> of Americans believes immigration ultimately strengthens the country and favors a path to citizenship even for people who entered illegally. We have ample evidence, of course, that a lot of people are willing to support or tolerate a cruel immigration policy if it is framed as “getting the bad guys out” – they are willing to look away if they have the impression that whatever happens is being done in “orderly” fashion. But it is simply not true that a majority of Americans looks at the video of ICE shooting an unarmed woman in the face and goes: “Yeah, that seems fine.” If you only consume Fox News and hang out in far-right online spaces, as most of the people in charge of this government do, you will believe Americans are clamoring for more state violence against anyone who dares to deviate. But that is not “the people” speaking. The murder of Renee Good is much more likely to galvanize the opposition against this regime.</p><p>Finally, it is Minneapolis again. Renee Good died just about a mile away from where George Floyd was murdered. Trump himself and the people around him have been obsessed with the summer of 2020 ever since, they openly regret not invoking the Insurrection Act in order to use the military to suppress the protests. They may be extra motivated to escalate the state violence. Already they are pulling resources from elsewhere, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/01/08/us/politics/border-patrol-minnesota-trump.html?unlocked_article_code=1.C1A.2M_R.Ub-kP_t6qBrF&amp;smid=nytcore-ios-share">deploying more ICE and Border Patrol agents</a> to Minnesota. This is a frightening situation. But the people are out in the streets nonetheless. “We had whistles. They had guns,” Becca Good, Renee’s wife, said in a statement she released on January 9. But whistles can be more powerful than guns. And the people who go out to meet those violent goons the regime is sending to terrorize their neighbors are proving it. They know they are putting themselves in danger. And yet they resist and bear witness. No matter what Donald Trump, the MAGA movement, the political Right, and the Republican Party may claim: The majority of Americans are not ready to give up on democracy just yet.</p><p><em>Democracy Americana is my main source of income as an independent writer. Want to support my work? Consider becoming a paid member:</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/4b2f8d7a-55ba-4a6b-a523-1a1ee780fd69/uploads/images/7e43xkkgz2/dims.apnews.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/4b2f8d7a-55ba-4a6b-a523-1a1ee780fd69</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">4b2f8d7a-55ba-4a6b-a523-1a1ee780fd69</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 11 Jan 2026 12:58:56 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Where Are You Going, America?]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[America is no longer a democracy. Authoritarianism has not won. But merely restoring the pre-Trump status quo won’t work. The country needs a democratic transformation.]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>America is no longer a democracy. That doesn’t mean authoritarianism has won. But merely restoring the pre-Trump status quo won’t work. The country needs a democratic transformation.</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, January 1, 2026</em></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/b8cd6881-e3c4-49b1-996c-cb25f6ec18bf/uploads/images/w6umxrmegu/iStock-1840110703.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>Credit: iStock / Jorm Sangsorn</figcaption></figure><p><em>Happy New Year! I wish all of you health, strength, and good fortune in 2026. Let’s hope we can make it a better year than what we’ve just been through…</em></p><p><em>The first half of January will be all about taking stock: I’ll have pieces coming out daring to make some predictions for 2026, a reflection on the state of Democracy Americana, and a Q+A attempting to answer the most pressing questions from readers. But I wanted to start the new year with a proper deep dive into the state of affairs after almost one year of Trumpism in power. It will hopefully help us clarify where America stands and where the country might be going.</em></p><p><em>The first part of this piece is free for everyone. If you want to read more than the preview or gain access to the audio version of the piece, please consider becoming a paid member of Democracy Americana, which is solely funded by readers whose support and generosity make this work possible.</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p>At the start of 2026, almost one year into Trumpist rule, America can no longer be counted among the world’s democracies.</p><p>Even if that statement probably doesn’t come as a total surprise to readers of Democracy Americana, we should sit with this diagnosis for a little bit. This is not some fringe position, but an assessment widely shared among scholars of authoritarianism in the United States as well as abroad. “The United States has descended into competitive authoritarianism,” political scientists Steven Levitsky, Lucan Way, and Daniel Ziblatt, for instance, unequivocally state in a much-discussed essay in <em>Foreign Affairs</em> that was published online on December 11.</p><p>Under the title <a href="https://www.foreignaffairs.com/united-states/american-authoritarianism-levitsky-way-ziblatt">“The Price of American Authoritarianism: What Can Reverse Democratic Decline?,”</a> the authors argue we need to put the United States in the same bucket as the regimes erected by Chávez in Venezuela, Erdogan in Turkey, Orbán in Hungary, or Modi in India – systems “in which parties compete in elections but incumbents routinely abuse their power to punish critics and tilt the playing field against their opposition.” In fact, as Levitsky, Way, and Ziblatt emphasize, America’s “authoritarian turn was faster and farther-reaching than those that occurred in the first year of these other regimes.” However, as concerning as the current state of affairs certainly is, the authors still end on a mildly optimistic note. They believe the damage caused by the Trumpist assault is very much reversible – “the prospects for returning to democratic rule remain good.”</p><p>Grappling with “The Price of American Authoritarianism” presents an excellent opportunity to take stock of where America stands one year into Trumpist rule, and where the country might be going next. Levitsky, Way, and Ziblatt get a lot right. Even though the authoritarian assault on the system has caused tremendous damage, democracy’s fate is not sealed. The fight is not over. Its outcome will be largely determined by whether or not the pro-democracy forces in America can get their act together. The authors present a crucial warning: Going forward, the danger lies as much in underestimating the threat to democracy emanating from the Trumpist regime as in overestimating its strength – the former resting on some form of ignorance and exceptionalist misconception of America’s supposed immunity from authoritarianism, the latter falling for the regime’s assertions of dominance, leading to preemptive acquiescence, resignation, and demobilization.</p><p>Levitsky, Way, and Ziblatt are spot on when they emphasize the many ways in which the Trumpists have fallen short of their own authoritarian ambitions and have failed to consolidate authoritarian rule across all spheres of American life. I share their assessment that the chances of fighting off this particular iteration of the authoritarian assault remain high – they have good reason to feel slightly more optimistic now than in the spring, as the societal resistance has hardened, MAGA shows signs of disintegrating, and widespread frustration has gripped the Right. And yet, I also believe the authors’ perspective on American democracy might be too narrow. Levitsky, Way, and Ziblatt are focused on the question of <em>returning</em> to democratic rule, in the sense of heaving the country back across the line that separates still-a-democracy from not-a-democracy-anymore. But what if such a reversal simply won’t be enough? What if we need to assess the chances not merely of a restoration of the pre-Trump status-quo, but of a comprehensive transformation of the political system? What if the only way for democracy to survive in America after the resounding delegitimization of the system that allowed Trump to rise in the first place and after the devastations wrought by Trumpism in power is to properly transform the political system and culture?</p><p>In order to take these questions seriously, I will proceed in two parts. In this Part I, we will dive deep into “The Price of American Authoritarianism” to reflect on where we stand, how much damage has already been done, and assess the potential for democratic resistance. In Part II, I will outline why I believe a framework focused on restoring and returning to a status quo ante is insufficient, and why, as a matter of practical reality rather than utopian idealism, we will need to explore avenues towards transformation.</p><p><strong>Why get into it again</strong></p><p>In the weeks between the 2024 election and Trump’s inauguration, two of the authors, Steven Levitsky and Lucan Way, wrote a long essay for <em>Foreign Affairs</em> formulating their expectations for what would happen to American democracy. Published in early February, <a href="https://www.foreignaffairs.com/united-states/path-american-authoritarianism-trump">“The Path to Authoritarianism”</a> was perhaps the first canonical assessment of the Trumpist assault. It was grounded in the authors’ expertise in how twenty-first century authoritarian movements tended to act upon taking power, the “playbook” they generally follow to undermine democracy and force regime change. Much like their counterparts elsewhere and inspired by Viktor Orbán in Hungary, in particular, the Trumpists would focus on weaponizing state institutions, turning them into an instrument to punish enemies and protect supporters. Over the course of the next few years, Levitsky and Way expected, America would cross into competitive authoritarianism. However, Trump was unlikely to consolidate authoritarian rule, Levitsky and Way argued, and wouldn’t be able to install full-scale authoritarianism. Not because of some innate democratic disposition, but because American institutions and civil society seemed more stable than in places like Hungary.</p><p>“The Path to Authoritarianism” was enormously influential when it came out, significantly shaping the discourse in those early weeks of Trumpism back in power. It mattered that leading scholars of authoritarianism confirmed, in stark terms, that something extraordinary and consequential was happening; it provided the language and the vocabulary to capture and describe the authoritarian assault that was unfolding with frightening speed.</p><p>Now the authors are back – joined by Daniel Ziblatt, another academic heavy hitter – to give their verdict as we are approaching the one-year anniversary of Trump’s return to the White House. What they provide is probably as close as it gets to representing the academic consensus. And most importantly, they offer us a chance to reflect on the big picture. It often feels like there is no time to dwell on anything in the Trump era – the next egregious announcement, the next dangerous escalation is always lurking. It is easy to get lost in the outrageousness of it all. And yet a key challenge is to take a step back and grapple with what it all adds up to. Faced with a broadscale authoritarian assault, we must retain the ability to develop a holistic view: Where do we stand now? What should we expect going forward?</p><p>Back in the spring, grappling with “The Path to Authoritarianism” helped me catalyze my own thoughts and observations into a coherent analysis. <a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/0c39122d-246d-4b3c-a3c3-e0bcb0731018">I largely agreed</a> with Levitsky and Way, although it seemed clear that by the time their essay was finally published, the reality of the authoritarian attack had already overtaken their expectations. Levitsky and Way, it turned out, had underestimated the ferocity of the Trumpist assault – and, most importantly, overestimated the resilience of America’s political system and civic society, as those early months were characterized by a pervasive tendency in elite circles and institutions to acquiesce. That’s what gave the piece additional significance: Here were two observers who were under no suspicion of reflexive anti-alarmism, who understand authoritarianism like few others, who are far more immune to ideas of American exceptionalism than almost anyone commenting on U.S. politics. And yet, by the time I grappled with their assessment in mid-March, just weeks after it had been published, the Trumpist assault had already outpaced what they thought possible. It was right around that moment in March, Steven Levitsky has said <a href="https://www.newyorker.com/podcast/political-scene/how-bad-is-it-three-political-scientists-say-america-is-no-longer-a-democracy">in recent interviews</a>, that he felt most pessimistic about the fate of democracy in the United States.</p><p>A lot has happened since. Where are we now?</p><p><strong>Studying democracy’s fall and the rise of “competitive authoritarianism”</strong></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/b8cd6881-e3c4-49b1-996c-cb25f6ec18bf">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/b8cd6881-e3c4-49b1-996c-cb25f6ec18bf/uploads/images/w6umxrmegu/iStock-1840110703.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/b8cd6881-e3c4-49b1-996c-cb25f6ec18bf</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">b8cd6881-e3c4-49b1-996c-cb25f6ec18bf</guid>
      <pubDate>Thu, 01 Jan 2026 13:06:33 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[What the “MAGA Civil War” is Really About]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Different factions are fighting for supremacy on the Right. What will post-Trump MAGA look like – and how dangerous is Trumpism without Trump?]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Different factions are fighting for supremacy on the Right. What will post-Trump MAGA look like – and how dangerous is Trumpism without Trump?</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, December 19, 2025</em></p><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/279fc0c5-26c5-4057-b986-fd0f16717aa7/uploads/images/jq5pjhv4bx/5DFED455-BEB2-4770-ADAE-8E91F0FCE51D_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><p><em>The first part of this piece is free for everyone. If you want to read more than the preview or gain access to the audio version of the piece, please consider becoming a paid member of Democracy Americana, which is solely funded by readers whose support and generosity make this work possible (and if you read German: An earlier, German-language version of this piece was published in </em><a href="https://www.zeit.de/kultur/2025-12/maga-bewegung-donald-trump-plaene-buergerkrieg"><em>Zeit Online</em></a><em> in early December – this here is a significantly extended and updated version of that essay).</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p>A cabinet meeting in early December seemed to go as so many have since Donald Trump returned to the White House. The president was holding court – an opportunity for secretary after secretary to publicly worship the <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m6zhu7szjj2m">“greatest president ever”</a> and declare how <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m6zl2ahdjv2d">eternally grateful</a> they were to serve under this American hero. Trump, however, was struggling to stay awake throughout. And just when it was time for Marco Rubio, seated right next to him, to praise Dear Leader as the man who would bring peace to earth, the president was <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m6zm44p4dt2u">totally dozing off</a>.</p><p>It was a bizarre scene – and it captured the moment. On the one hand, it was a manifestation of how fully Trumpified the American Right is. Not only does the MAGA base revere Trump as a messianic figure. Political leaders are also practicing a grotesque cult of personality. Trump has installed a type of personalist regime within the Republican Party where influence and status are determined by the personal relationship with the autocratic leader.</p><p>On the other hand, Trump is evidently struggling, beleaguered and ailing in more than one sense. Not only is he often physically exhausted and seems to be <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2025/dec/18/donald-trump-health">struggling with his health</a>. Reports also indicate that he has largely <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/2025/12/trump-white-house-travel-rallies-isolated/685073/?gift=SCYx-5scVta3-cr_IlgTyWP3oHxowuOvo9p874ISqRI">retreated from the job</a> of actually governing. Rarely does he hold rallies anymore, even as <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2025/12/15/trump-base-maga-midterm-voters/">his advisers are urging him</a> to go out and meet the base. And since the fall, he has been encountering open resistance from within his own movement. Marjorie Taylor Greene, of all people, has emerged as the public face of MAGA discontent – she who rose to political stardom because of her unflinching loyalty to Trump (and fueled by a steady stream of nutty conspiracy theories). When Greene surprisingly <a href="https://x.com/mtgreenee/status/1992037226415554642?s=20">declared</a> she was leaving Congress in early January, she derided MAGA’s leaders for betraying the movement’s true ideals: Instead of toppling the elites, Greene complained, MAGA was becoming part of “the Political Industrial Complex of both Political Parties.” Greene has since reveled in being a constant thorn in Trump’s side. After Trump’s utterly deranged social media post on the murders of Rob and Michele Reiner, in which he insinuated that they were killed – and perhaps deservedly so! – for being mean to him, <a href="https://edition.cnn.com/2025/12/16/politics/marjorie-taylor-greene-dam-breaking-republican-party-trump">Greene attacked</a> the president as “classless” and called his behavior unbecoming of the office.</p><p>It’s another sign that Trump’s hold over his movement is weakening. Suddenly, we are into the twilight of the Trump era – the end of his reign as the Right’s leader is looming on the horizon. Prominent MAGA figures see opportunity in signaling distance from him. The fight over who will get to succeed him is on, the conflict between different factions seeking to lead MAGA is threatening to disintegrate the movement. But what comes after Trump? What happens to a Republican Party that has been fully Trumpified? What happens to a movement that has been defined by an authoritarian leader cult? Trumpism without Trump – is that even a thing?</p><p><strong>The “counter-revolution” is stuck</strong></p><p>At the end of this term, Donald Trump will be 82 years old. In a vacuum, it is not surprising that the political leaders of the Right are bringing themselves into position for a post-Trump era. What is remarkable, however, is that MAGA doesn’t have a plan or anything like a coherent strategic vision for what that imminent future is supposed to look like.</p><p>MAGA rose to power with a short-term strategy aimed at quickly overwhelming the system. It manifested, for instance, in the so-called <a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/2afb3c7a-3885-4cff-8607-90eadc17493c">“180-Day playbook,”</a> the sole part of Project 2025 that was never made publicly available. The “playbook” consisted mainly of dozens, perhaps hundreds of presidential executive orders, drafted in advance, ready to be deployed from Day 1 back in the White House. Within just a few months, the Trumpists sought to neutralize all meaningful political and societal resistance, forcing a comprehensive regime change. </p><p>But eleven months later, that strategy has failed, as societal resistance has been hardening since the summer. The regime’s attempts to carry out mass deportations and terrorize the local population into submission via aggressive raids into urban centers have been met with unrelenting defiance. In the fall, America experienced a significant mass mobilization culminating in the largest protests in its recent history. In early November, the president’s party was soundly defeated in elections across the country – Trump himself is unprecedentedly unpopular.</p><p>The conflict has entered a different phase, and the Trumpist Right is ill-prepared for the prolonged struggle that is next. MAGA’s leaders, whose perception and understanding of the world is now almost entirely shaped by a hermetically sealed rightwing media and information environment, had really bought into the idea of their supposedly irresistible strength. They believed, at least until recently, their own propaganda: Their approach was built on the notion that the rotten liberal system was ready to fall, that the broad majority of “real Americans” couldn’t wait to shake off the joke of “globalist” elites.  </p><p>As the MAGA revolution slows down, frustration spreads. Most importantly, as the mood in MAGA land sours, it becomes impossible for the Trumpist Right to ignore the considerable tensions between its different factions. As much as they may have agreed on the initial strategy to quickly overwhelm the liberal enemy, they are pursuing competing – and sometimes incompatible – long-term visions for America.</p><p><strong>Who gets to represent MAGA?</strong></p><p>As Donald Trump tends to monopolize all the attention, the mainstream discussion often ignores the fact that MAGA exists as an alliance of several separate factions.</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/279fc0c5-26c5-4057-b986-fd0f16717aa7">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/279fc0c5-26c5-4057-b986-fd0f16717aa7/uploads/images/jq5pjhv4bx/5DFED455-BEB2-4770-ADAE-8E91F0FCE51D_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/279fc0c5-26c5-4057-b986-fd0f16717aa7</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">279fc0c5-26c5-4057-b986-fd0f16717aa7</guid>
      <pubDate>Fri, 19 Dec 2025 12:57:06 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Trumpism Is at War with the Idea of a Citizenry of Equals]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The regime’s latest racist fury is tied to the Right’s much broader attempt to redefine citizenship and national identity in service of an exclusionary white nationalist]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The regime’s latest racist fury is tied to the Right’s much broader attempt to redefine citizenship and national identity in service of an exclusionary white nationalist vision</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, December 13, 2025</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/6fcf577b-7b04-4c7f-b8a6-39e75c6b8305">Listen on Steady</a></p><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/6fcf577b-7b04-4c7f-b8a6-39e75c6b8305/uploads/images/uipn3bdpso/Illustration.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><p><em>Please support Democracy Americana!</em></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is my main source of income as an independent writer. If you are reading the free version of this newsletter, I sincerely appreciate your time and effort engaging with my work. Please share it widely to help me reach new readers.</em></p><p><em>And if you can, please consider becoming a </em><strong><em>paid member</em></strong><em>. You will gain access to special benefits – including many additional essays and the audio versions of all my writing in podcast form.</em></p><p><em>Most importantly, Democracy Americana is a publication solely funded by readers. I need your support to continue this work. Thank you!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p></p><p>It is as if, to end the year, the Trumpists wanted to remind the world who they are, what fuels their political project, and what their vision for America is.</p><p>On November 26, a 29-year-old Afghan national attacked two West Virginia National Guard members deployed to Washington, DC, killing one and severely wounding the other. The Trump government wasted no time using the attack as justification to escalate its crusade against immigrants and anyone who doesn’t belong in MAGA’s conception of “real America.” Trump <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/nov/28/trump-says-he-will-permanently-pause-migration-from-third-world-countries-after-national-guard-shooting">quickly declared</a> he would “permanently pause migration from all Third World Countries” and “denaturalize migrants who undermine domestic tranquility, and deport any Foreign National who is a public charge, security risk, or non-compatible with Western Civilization.“</p><p>There it is: Anyone “non-compatible with Western Civilization” – as defined by the Trumpist Right – is out.</p><p>Trump also immediately started raging against Somali immigrants in Minnesota, who had nothing to do with the DC shooting, of course, but had been the target of an ongoing far-right smear campaign. In several grotesquely racist rants, the president <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m72352mo522x">has called them</a> human “garbage” who “come from hell and do nothing but bitch. We don’t want them.” Trump always makes sure to include Minnesota Representative Ilhan Omar in <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m6znie6z4c2u">his attacks</a>: “We’re gonna go the wrong way if we keep taking in garbage into our country. Ilhan Omar is garbage. She’s garbage. Her friends are garbage.”</p><p>Not to be outdone by the president, DHS secretary Kristi Noem <a href="https://x.com/Sec_Noem/status/1995642101779124476?s=20">added a monstrously racist rant of her own</a> on social media: “I am recommending a full travel ban on every damn country that’s been flooding our nation with killers, leeches, and entitlement junkies.” She continued to disparage immigrants as “foreign invaders” who “slaughter our heroes, suck dry our hard-earned tax dollars, or snatch the benefits owed to AMERICANS. WE DON’T WANT THEM. NOT ONE.”</p><p>In the midst of all this racist fury, the Supreme Court announced on December 6 it would hear a case over the legality of an executive order Trump signed on his first day back in the White House in January. It sought to effectively end birthright citizenship, thereby dramatically undermining the 14th Amendment of the Constitution. This gave Stephen Miller, the White House deputy chief of staff and homeland security advisor who also serves as the America First nativists’ chief loudspeaker, the <a href="https://x.com/StephenM/status/1997414190571806998?s=20">chance to go berserk</a> on the idea of birthright citizenship: “Of all the destructive and ruinous policies aimed at the heart of our Republic, few can compete with ‘birthright citizenship.’” Miller is – or pretends to be – angry all the time, but birthright citizenship in particular seems to be getting him all riled up: He called it “an atrocity flatly and flagrantly incompatible with any concept of nationhood.”</p><p>While all that has been going on, the Trump government also released a new <a href="https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/2025-National-Security-Strategy.pdf">National Security Strategy</a> in early December that is openly hostile towards the European Union and liberal democracies on the other side of the Atlantic. It is a document inspired by and infused with far-right talking points, much to the delight of the domestic extremist scene: Groyper leader <a href="https://www.mediamatters.org/nick-fuentes/nick-fuentes-says-trumps-national-security-policy-explicit-acknowledgement-white">Nick Fuentes, for instance, welcomed it</a> as “an explicit acknowledgment of white genocide.” The strategy demands the United States actively support far-right, nativist parties and movements in Europe, taking an aggressively antagonistic stance towards liberal democracy itself. The political scientist <a href="https://www.programmablemutter.com/p/america-has-identified-its-final">Henry Farrell has rightfully called it</a> “a program for regime change in Europe, aimed at turning it into an illiberal polity.”</p><p>Let’s take a step back. These aren’t just a few racist outbursts or isolated escalations. These are not separate policy initiatives. These are manifestations of a worldview defined by white nationalism as its organizing principle. They are tied to a much broader rightwing attempt to reconceptualize national identity and drastically narrow the boundaries of who gets to belong. They are actualizations of the Right’s defining project: To roll back any progress towards egalitarian pluralism, to vanquish the very idea that America should aspire to be a nation defined by equal citizenship in a pluralistic, multiracial society, and to fight instead for white Christian male supremacy at home and in the world.</p><p><strong>“What is an American?”</strong></p><p>You don’t have to take my word for it. To their credit, I guess, the political and intellectual leaders of today’s Right couldn’t possibly be more open and explicit about their goals. In fact, they have been obsessed with the question of who gets to be a citizen, who gets to define “America,” and who gets to belong. It’s worth diving into a few high-profile examples of rightwing leaders spelling out their vision:</p><p>Let’s start with the third night of the Republican convention in July 2024, when it was vice presidential nominee <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2024/07/17/us/politics/read-the-transcript-of-jd-vances-convention-speech.html">J. D. Vance’s turn to introduce himself</a> to the delegates and the nation. What, to J.D. Vance, is America? It is the “homeland,” as Vance called it repeatedly, for those who are bound to it by ancestry, across many generations, whose blood and bones, quite literally, are tied to the soil. And according to J.D. Vance, they alone have a right to decide who gets to come to this country, who gets to belong in America.</p><p>In his speech, Vance explicitly embraced an ethno-religious nationalism. While Vance agreed that “America was indeed founded on brilliant ideas,” he only counted the rule of law and religious liberty amongst those – while not mentioning equality at all. In fact, he specifically rejected the notion of America as defined by a unifying creed: “America is not just an idea. It is a group of people with a shared history and a common future.”</p><p>Who is part of this group of people? That is decided by ancestry and blood. Vance traced his own history back many generations to the mid-nineteenth century as proof that he belonged among those who are one with the “homeland” they inherited. “They love this country,” Vance proclaimed, “not only because it’s a good idea, but because in their bones they know that this is their home.” These “real Americans” have become one with the land – a Volk inseparable from their homeland.</p><p>Even when he was pretending to be embracing a form of pluralism, Vance outlined a vision that was irreconcilable with egalitarian ideals. “We welcome newcomers. But when we allow newcomers into our American family, we allow them on our terms.” Not everyone who is here gets to be equal. There is “We” who get to decide and there is “Them” whose status and citizenship is always conditional. “They” must accept “our terms.”</p><p><em>Help me continue this work and become a paid member of Democracy Americana:</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p>As Vice President, J.D. Vance continues to channel such blood-and-soil ideas he picks up from the far-right intellectual scene and provide them with the biggest possible platform. This past summer, on July 5, Vance focused on the same themes in a <a href="https://americanmind.org/salvo/american-statesmanship-for-the-golden-age/">speech at the Claremont Institute’s</a> 2025 Statesmanship Award dinner. A fitting stage, as Claremont is the institutional center for all those rightwing thinkers who are fully devoted to providing an intellectual justification for Trumpism. This time, Vance presented himself as a brave defender of “Western civilization” that is, supposedly, under assault from a “Western liberalism that is socially suicidal or parasitic – that tends to feed off of a healthy host until there’s nothing left.” In order to fight such an insidious force, Vance declared, the Right needed to develop a “unifying ideology” – a proper answer to the question of what an “American” was and how the “meaning of American citizenship in the 21st century” should be defined. Once again, Vance emphatically rejected the idea that agreement with “creedal principals” could provide the basis for American national identity:</p><p>“That definition is overinclusive <em>and</em> underinclusive. It would include hundreds of millions, maybe billions, of foreigners. Must we admit them tomorrow? But, at the same time, that answer would also reject a lot of people the ADL would label domestic extremists, even though their own ancestors were here at the time of the Revolutionary War.”</p><p>That’s quite the thing to say for the vice president of the United States: Foreigners, because of their ancestry, are definitionally excluded from the national community – or at the very least inherently relegated to lesser status within it, disqualified from becoming “real Americans” like the rightwing extremists who have been here long enough (or came from the same places and “cultures” as the people who have).</p><p>What is an American? That was also the title of a <a href="https://www.dailysignal.com/2025/09/02/schmitt-what-is-an-american/">remarkable speech</a> Eric Schmitt, the Republican Senator from Missouri, delivered at the National Conservatism conference in early September. These annual “NatCons” serve as a gathering of all the different intellectual factions and self-proclaimed thinkers on the Right who share an ethno-nationalist vision for America as well as a commitment to intellectualize Trumpism. Schmitt opened by raging against the “fundamentally post-American ruling class” that had been in charge of the country for too long and, as Schmitt saw it, included the Republican establishment as well neoconservative circles with a misguided devotion to spreading democracy abroad. They were all, the senator explained, engaged in a project to destroy the nation from within. What had facilitated their assault was the notion that America was just an idea which, according to Schmitt, turned America into “a vehicle for global liberalism”:</p><p>“We were told that the entire meaning of America boiled down to a few lines in a poem on the Statue of Liberty, and five words about equality in the Declaration of Independence. Any other aspect of American identity was deemed to be illegitimate and immoral, poisoned by the evils of our ancestors. The true meaning of America, they said, was liberalism, multiculturalism and endless immigration.”</p><p>Against such insidious notions, Schmitt presented a definition of America based on “Western heritage” – and a very narrow conception of who gets to claim it:</p><p>“The Continental Army soldiers dying of frostbite at Valley Forge, the Pilgrims struggling to survive in the hard winter soil of Plymouth, the pioneers striking out from Missouri for the wild and dangerous frontier, the outnumbered Kentucky settlers repelling wave after wave of Indian war band attacks from behind their stockade walls … They fought, they bled, they struggled, they died for us. They built this country for us. America, in all its glory, is their gift to us, handed down across the generations. It belongs to us. It’s our birthright, our heritage, our destiny.” </p><p>Go through all the groups Schmitt lists who “built this country for us” and think about who is not included, whose descendants are therefore not among “Us” and do not belong in this version of America: Native Americans, who Schmitt explicitly names as the savage enemy; enslaved Blacks, struggling for freedom; immigrants of color from all over the world, believing in the dream that if they worked hard, they might build a better life for themselves and their children.</p><p>This is not particularly subtle, is it? Outside of the most extreme rightwing fringes, you’ll rarely encounter such open, aggressive affirmations of white Western supremacy. Driven by a “restless, relentless, dynamic spirit,” the senator proclaims, “the West” achieved “heights of political, intellectual and technological achievement unmatched by any other civilization in human history.” And America, Schmitt announces, is “the most essentially Western nation” – in fact, “every great feat of the modern world bore American fingerprints.”</p><p>As Schmitt’s speech reaches its nasty crescendo, the senator from Missouri wants to leave absolutely no doubt who is and who is not included in this narrow conception of the nation: “We Americans,” he pleads, “are the sons and daughters of the Christian pilgrims that poured out from Europe’s shores to baptize a new world in their ancient faith.” Time to resist those forces of evil leftism that are seeking to destroy the nation from within by trying to teach those “real” Americans to be ashamed of themselves and their great history. But no more. “We are done being ashamed. We love our country, and we will never apologize for the great men who built it.” America, Schmitt reminds his audience, “does not belong to them. It belongs to us. It’s our home. It’s a heritage entrusted to us by our ancestors. It is a way of life that is ours, and only ours, and if we disappear, then America, too, will cease to exist.”</p><p>To Schmitt and his ilk, America is not merely changing culturally, demographically, politically. By pluralizing, it is dying.</p><p><em>Today, you are reading a free article that I am making available to everyone. I would love to continue to offer these essays for a broad audience. However, pieces like this - over 4,000 words! - take a ton of time and effort to research, write, and edit.</em></p><p><em>As an independent writer, I rely on the revenue generated by paid memberships as my main source of income. If you are a frequent reader of Democracy Americana, I am certain you will benefit greatly from a paid membership. I publish additional member-exclusive essays every week - and members also have access to the audio versions of all my writing in podcast form wherever you get your podcasts.</em></p><p><em>Most importantly, if you value this independent work, please know that it is your support and your generosity that is making it possible.</em></p><p><em>If a paid membership is currently not an option for you, the best way to support Democracy Americana is to share this piece on social media - and recommend my work to people you think might be interested. Thank you!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><strong>Attacking birthright citizenship</strong></p><p>The political movement Vance and Schmitt represent, the one that currently controls the U.S. government and the levers of state power, is evidently not on board with the idea that “all men are created equal.” It is defined by its rejection of any attempt to actualize the egalitarian aspiration that was enshrined most forcefully in the constitution with the Reconstruction amendments.</p><p>This is the context for the Trump regime’s attack on birthright citizenship. It is, at its core, not merely a policy dispute or a disagreement over constitutional interpretation. It is a battleground for what this nation should be, what its identity, its defining aspiration should be going forward, and who deserves to belong as equal.</p><p>Vance, Schmitt, and Miller want to abolish birthright citizenship because they understand precisely that what is enshrined in the 14th Amendment is fundamentally incompatible with their blood-and-soil nationalism. In a narrow sense, the birthright citizenship clause – the first sentence in Section 1 of the 14th Amendment – was intended to guarantee citizenship for freed slaves. But the framers knew exactly that its implications went far beyond that. It constituted a repudiation of the Supreme Court’s 1857 decision in Dredd Scott that Black people couldn’t be citizens because they were inferior and they didn’t have the necessary hereditary connection – and, more generally, a profound rejection of the notion that some people, because of heritage and blood, had more of a claim to being “American” than others. The Trumpist assault is so preposterous not only because the text of the Amendment is clear – but also because we know what the framers intended to do. They knew exactly what they were doing. They explicitly debated the fact that this clause would bestow guaranteed citizenship not just upon freed slaves, but to lots of other groups as well. No tiered citizenship in America – that is what the text declares, that was the intent of the framers.</p><p><strong>White nationalist propaganda and practice</strong></p><p>And yet, a polity that excludes anyone who doesn’t fit certain ethno-religious criteria or relegates them to lesser status is exactly the vision that animates the Trumpist Right. And they are fighting for it not just in speeches and pamphlets or in the courts. They are turning the assault on egalitarian pluralism and equal citizenship into policy that is being carried out in the streets by masked agents of the state, spurred on by the crudest, vilest state propaganda.</p><p>The official position of the Trump government is that assimilation and cultural pluralism are impossible. <a href="https://x.com/StephenM/status/1994247172129280225?s=20">Stephen Miller</a> calls it “the great lie of mass migration. You are not just importing individuals. You are importing societies. No magic transformation occurs when failed states cross borders. At scale, migrants and their descendants recreate the conditions, and terrors, of their broken homelands.” The same day Miller blurted this out, November 28, the official social media channels of the <a href="https://x.com/DHSgov/status/1994445836915253664?s=20">Department of Homeland Security</a> demanded “Remigration now” – endorsing a term that European rightwing extremists have widely adopted as a euphemism for a program of ethnic cleansing via the forced deportation of millions of people. The next day, the <a href="https://x.com/USDOL/status/1994563645322531057?s=20">Department of Labor</a> chimed in to declare that “The fight for Western Civilization has begun – and Americanism will Prevail.” The term “Americanism” has roots in the early twentieth century when the Ku Klux Klan and other extremist groups used it to propagate their vision of a purely white America.</p><p>No one gets to claim ignorance; there is no plausible deniability for anyone. </p><p>We even got a terrifying preview of what this white nationalist regime would attempt to do at the height of the 2024 election campaign, when the Right’s leaders tried to incite a pogrom against the community of Haitian immigrants in Springfield, Ohio. In early September 2024, J.D. Vance used his <a href="https://x.com/jdvance/status/1833148904864465117?s=46&amp;t=1xecvNVImNo8TKt3oEvqnA">social media</a> to rail against “Haitian illegal immigrants draining social services and generally causing chaos all over Springfield, Ohio.” He added: “Reports now show that people have had their pets abducted and eaten by people who shouldn’t be in this country.”</p><p>Vance was leaning into a long-established racist trope – They are eating our pets! –  used to vilify immigrant communities since at least the late nineteenth century. He wasn’t the only one to focus on immigrants from Haiti in Springfield, Ohio: <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/sep/14/neo-nazis-springfield-ohio-haitian-immigrants">Neo-Nazi groups</a> had been targeting them for quite some time. Leading Republicans quickly echoed Vance’s baseless claims, and the <a href="https://x.com/realchrisrufo/status/1834926318883852543?s=46&amp;t=1xecvNVImNo8TKt3oEvqnA">rightwing activist</a> sphere went all in as well. So did Trump himself, <a href="https://www.politico.com/news/2024/09/13/trump-haitians-ohio-pets-00179147">who claimed</a> that “illegal Haitian migrants have descended upon a town of 58,000 people destroying their way of life.”</p><p>This vile propaganda had its desired effect. City Hall, schools, and the DMV in Springfield had to be evacuated because of bomb threats. Acts of vandalism against the Haitian community followed. <a href="https://www.whio.com/news/local/bomb-threat-locks-down-springfield-hospital/CV3NS5VKUREVNGNYIDXPQE3J2Q/">Hospitals had to be evacuated</a> – so did <a href="https://www.springfieldnewssun.com/news/wittenberg-university-closes-all-sunday-events-activities-after-shooting-threat/6VVI2D5NNJGSRFYSVNNDO6V7TY/">universities</a>, as someone threatened to shoot members of the Haitian community on campus. <a href="https://www.springfieldnewssun.com/news/highway-patrol-greets-springfield-school-families-in-new-safety-effort/7PYQWUW47BCFNIWKHPXQIWB7NY/">Ohio State Troopers</a> had to sweep every building in every school in town, every morning before the start of classes, looking for explosives, because the bomb threats kept coming. Meanwhile, <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/clancyny.bsky.social/post/3l45ij3ll522o">neo-Nazis were marching through town</a> – the Proud Boys, and a group called Blood Tribe. Life in Springfield, Ohio upended. All based on a lie.</p><p>The parallels to the vile campaign against Somali immigrants are obvious. Once again, the administration picked up something that far-right circles had been pushing. In this case, <a href="https://www.city-journal.org/article/fraud-minnesota-somali-immigration-debate">rightwing activists and think tanks</a> had been focused on welfare fraud among some Somalis in Minnesota. After the attack on members of the National Guard in DC, spokespeople of the regime quickly added a bunch of lies and <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m73suo6x2h2z">insinuated</a> there may have been some connection, even going so far as to claim the Somali community formed a <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m7apk46wpb2z">“nexus of terrorism.”</a></p><p>This escalation of lies is reminiscent of what happened last fall, when Vance went quickly from “eating pets” to claiming a child had been murdered by “a Haitian immigrant who had no right to be here.” The senator from Ohio did not care that the child’s parents <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/sep/11/trump-vance-ohio-aiden-clark">begged him to stop using their boy</a>, who was killed in a car accident, to demonize immigrants. Vance even admitted on television that his claims did not stand up to scrutiny. And yet, he felt completely justified in spreading them. In a <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/phillewis.bsky.social/post/3l474ltvfj524">CNN interview</a>, he said: “If I have to create stories so that the American media actually pays attention to the suffering of the American people then that’s what I’m going to do.”</p><p>Last September, neo-Nazis hiding their faces descended on Springfield, Ohio. This time, it is ICE and Border Patrol – masked agents of the state functioning as the regime’s paramilitary shock troops. In both cases, the legal status of the targeted immigrant population does not matter to the Right. When asked on television why ICE was going after Somali immigrants when the vast majority of them are U.S. citizens or legal residents, Trump’s border czar <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m7fovwxvxz2u">Tom Homan casually asserted</a> that “there’s a large illegal Somali community there. There’s a large illegal alien community there.” That, again, is exactly how the Trumpists proceeded when confronted with the fact that the Haitian migrants were in Ohio legally. “I’m still gonna call them an illegal alien,” <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3l4hcpwmicq2w">Vance simply declared</a>. For blood-and-soil nationalists, there is a “Higher Truth” that overrides petty facts and superficial reality: The “homeland” is under siege, overrun with enemies who “poison the blood.” That’s also what Vance meant when he fabulated about Kamala Harris <a href="https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/fact-checking-jd-vances-claims-haitian-migrants-springfield/story?id=113844705">“waving the wand illegally”</a> to let Haitian migrants come. It was utter nonsense. Yet “true” in the sense that the ethno-nationalists regard any action that “poisons” the homeland as fundamentally illegitimate.</p><p><strong>They mean it</strong></p><p>What is unfolding here is not just a sideshow, not merely a distraction from the Right’s plutocratic agenda (although they certainly care about that as well). This is the manifestation of the Right’s defining political project. They really mean it. </p><p>That is true for Donald Trump himself also. He is not just a grumpy old man indulging in racist stereotypes, but a politician committed to a worldview shaped and organized by racism and white supremacy. What is on display here is not just personal bigotry. Donald Trump pursues a political project for which white nationalism serves as an organizing principle.</p><p>It is true that Trump is not an ideologue in a strict sense. He is certainly not the type who reads, let alone sits down to write a manifesto. He is also not strictly committed to a specific policy agenda. Trump is animated by a set of grievances. But those are not random. They are related to his view of how status and power ought to be distributed. Donald Trump is deeply convinced that powerful white men like him have a right to be at the top, that it is their prerogative to exert power over others. And how dare anyone object, complain, have the audacity to curtail the ability of men like him to do as they please. </p><p>To say that race is an organizing principle that structures the way Donald Trump perceives of the world is not to claim it is the only one. Gender is crucially important, as is wealth. What Donald Trump believes in is a political and societal order of sharp, brutal hierarchies. That’s why Trump is so perfect as an avatar for today’s Right and their anti-egalitarian, anti-pluralistic project that runs on radicalizing grievance. The white nationalism, the patriarchal domination, the oligarchic control, the Christian supremacism: They are all tied together.</p><p><strong>The America the Right wants</strong></p><p>Forget, for a moment, the question of what specific label to use for this Trumpist regime or the project it pursues. The most important task is to recognize and spell out what kind of society they want to create. If they succeeded, what would America look like?</p><p>The Trumpists desire to drastically narrow the boundaries of who gets to belong, they seek to purge all others from the “homeland.” Those who are left would be living in a society that is not only unequal but has ostracized egalitarian aspirations as heresy. The coercive powers of the state would be mobilized to curtail the rights of those who dare to deviate and entrench a tiered system of participation defined by hierarchies of race, gender, religion, wealth, and ancestry. A segregationist policy would restore white male dominance in elite institutions as well as across all spheres of American life.</p><p>As long as they acquiesce, some who don’t qualify as “real Americans” in this white Christian patriarchal ethnostate might be tolerated. But even their lesser status and second-class citizenship would always be conditional. And if they “bitch” too much, as Donald Trump says, or they aren’t sufficiently “grateful,” they will be punished, expelled.</p><p>America has never lived up to the egalitarian promise is has often claimed as reality. While we need to acknowledge how deeply flawed the democratic system was that made Trump’s rise possible in the first place, we must also recognize that MAGA doesn’t simply seek to preserve that system but replace it with an entirely different regime. Their “real America” would be a much nastier, much more dangerous, much more hostile place for anyone who dares to deviate from what the Trumpists insist is the “natural” order.</p><p><em>Democracy Americana is my main source of income as an independent writer. Want to support my work? Consider becoming a paid member:</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/6fcf577b-7b04-4c7f-b8a6-39e75c6b8305/uploads/images/uipn3bdpso/Illustration.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/6fcf577b-7b04-4c7f-b8a6-39e75c6b8305</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">6fcf577b-7b04-4c7f-b8a6-39e75c6b8305</guid>
      <pubDate>Sat, 13 Dec 2025 12:07:34 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Thank you!]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[And please submit a question for an upcoming Democracy Americana Q&A]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>And please submit a question for an upcoming Democracy Americana Q&amp;A</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, December 7, 2025</em></p><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/0f6202e9-31da-4167-9e05-6b392b96bed8/uploads/images/rhsfysdjqf/SocMediaBanner.png?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><p>Dear Readers,</p><p>Something a little different today: Not a proper essay, just an update about the state of the newsletter – an apology, an announcement, and a big fat thank you. This one goes out to paid members of Democracy Americana only, so allow me to write a little more openly and personally than I normally would.</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/0f6202e9-31da-4167-9e05-6b392b96bed8">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/0f6202e9-31da-4167-9e05-6b392b96bed8/uploads/images/r6wlifq7qb/DA_BannerImage.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/0f6202e9-31da-4167-9e05-6b392b96bed8</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">0f6202e9-31da-4167-9e05-6b392b96bed8</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 07 Dec 2025 12:12:17 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Myth of a Rightward Realignment]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Let’s discard some stubborn misconceptions about Trump’s support and what happened in the 2024 election that are obscuring our understanding of a profound de-alignment]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Let’s discard some stubborn misconceptions about Trump’s support and what happened in the 2024 election that are obscuring our understanding of a profound de-alignment</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, November 26, 2025</em></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/7edb91f9-c681-4769-b3cb-6eaebcc8ad4b/uploads/images/2jln563e7k/Combined_Illustration.png?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>Upper half: iStock / credit: bryanregan
Lower half: One of the illustrations used by the organizers of No Kings, taken from their website – credit: https://www.nokings.org/</figcaption></figure><p>It is Thanksgiving week – so let me start by expressing my deep gratitude to everyone who reads and supports Democracy Americana. Two months ago, I took a big leap into a new life as a full-time independent writer. It is still very much an open question whether this newsletter, which is my main source of income, can generate enough support to make this a viable career. But whatever comes next, I am grateful for the opportunity to think and write about the issues I care deeply about – and you honor me with your time, your trust, and your engagement.</p><p>To those of you in the United States: Happy Thanksgiving! I’m afraid I can’t offer anything that is particularly Thanksgiving-related. But I do think today’s essay might be helpful around the Thanksgiving dinner table, as I am taking aim at the most persistent myths around Trump’s support in American society and about what happened in the 2024 election. Perhaps you’ll feel better equipped to push back against and discard these pervasive misconceptions when you’ll inevitably encounter some of them in conversations with friends and family over the weekend.</p><p><em>The first part of the piece is free for everyone. If you want to read more than the preview, please consider becoming a member of Democracy Americana and support my work (and if you read German: An earlier German-language version of this piece was published in </em><a href="https://www.zeit.de/kultur/2025-11/donald-trump-unterstuetzung-beliebtheit-maga-bewegung-usa"><em>Zeit Online</em></a><em> last week).</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p>Donald Trump is historically unpopular. Only <a href="https://www.economist.com/interactive/trump-approval-tracker">about 40 percent</a> of Americans approve of the job he’s doing as president, and that number is trending down; about 55 percent disapprove. In modern U.S. history, <a href="https://news.gallup.com/poll/203198/presidential-approval-ratings-donald-trump.aspx">only one other president</a> had equally dismal numbers just months after being elected: That was Donald Trump himself, during his first term. The Republican Party suffered a devastating defeat in the November elections, losing ground <a href="https://www.gelliottmorris.com/p/trumps-winning-2024-coalition-has">almost everywhere, across all demographics</a>. Especially working-class voters, young people, and Latinos, whose larger-than-expected support had fueled Trump’s 2024 victory, strongly moved away from the president’s party. Those are facts.</p><p>But wait a minute, what about all the talk about a rightward realignment, about the American people sending a clear signal they preferred Trump’s agenda, about Trump having a broad <a href="https://www.npr.org/2024/12/16/g-s1-38003/trump-mandate-presidents">“mandate”</a> to impose his vision on the country?</p><p>If you’ll recall, the 2024 election was actually very close. Trump won with a narrow 1.5-point margin in the popular vote. And yet, the idea that America had experienced a political <a href="https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2025/02/the-rise-and-fall-of-the-new-liberals-how-the-democrats-lost-their-majority/">“earthquake”</a> that demanded far-reaching interpretations became gospel almost immediately. Within days, the country’s leading newspapers and most influential commentators attempted to outdo each other with ever more sweeping narratives, mostly built on vastly inadequate, unreliable data – and a whole lot of personal preference. Trump’s victory, we were confidently told, was the result of <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2025/01/trump-reelection-voter-demographic-change/680752/">lasting societal shifts</a> and signaled a profound reordering of American politics, an <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2025/05/american-realignment/682924/">“American realignment”</a> – perhaps even the <a href="https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2025/02/the-rise-and-fall-of-the-new-liberals-how-the-democrats-lost-their-majority/">end of political liberalism</a> and the beginning of a permanent Trumpist era in U.S. history.</p><p>Such narratives have proved stubbornly persistent. A year after the presidential election, they continue to shape the political discourse – in the United States and abroad – even though they have been thoroughly disproven empirically. We now possess comprehensive data that suggests a very different interpretation of what actually happened in November 2024. It is high time we revise our understanding of the political, social, and cultural dynamics that are defining the country. This question is far too important – we cannot afford to rely on myths and misconceptions: What is actually happening in this society that vaulted the man who had led a multi-month campaign to nullify the result of the previous election and incited a violent insurrection, the man who had campaigned on rage, intimidation, and vengeful violence, back to the most powerful political office in the world? </p><p>Let’s tackle three building blocks of the misleading “realignment” narrative: 1) The idea that U.S. society moved right in accordance with the broader outlines of Trumpism’s vision; 2) that Trump is the tribune of the working class, the champion of “regular folks”; 3) that he is building a stable multiracial coalition.</p><p><strong>Misleading Myth No. 1: “American society moved significantly to the right”</strong></p><p>Influential commentators are dogmatically clinging to the idea that the Democrats are a party of <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2024/11/06/briefing/donald-trump-victory-kamala-harris.html">detached elites</a>, aloof and arrogant; that they have <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2024/11/25/upshot/democrats-trump-working-class.html">“lost their base”</a> because they are captured by radical leftwing activists and their vastly unpopular demands; that they ignore the interests of the working class and regular folks. America, we were told after Trump’s victory, had just witnessed a <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2024/11/06/us/politics/trump-america-election-victory.html">“populist revolt”</a> against an elitist leftist project, a rejection of the aggressively <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2024/11/progressives-errors-2024-election/680563/">encroaching “wokeism”</a> the Democratic Party was supposedly propagating. Even a few weeks ago, right before the November 2025 elections, Ross Douthat proclaimed from his perch as America’s number one “respectable” conservative pundit in the <em>New York Times</em> that the Trump election had been <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/11/01/opinion/democrats-tea-party-ideology.html">“an ideological referendum, and progressivism lost.”</a> The next day, Ezra Klein used his <em>New York Times</em> platform as one of America’s best-know liberal voices to call on Democrats to finally accept that <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/11/02/opinion/democrats-liberalism-elections-crick.html">“much of the country disagrees with them.”</a> </p><p>The claim that Trump’s victory was a clear-cut expression – an immediate manifestation! – of the will of the people always stood in obvious tension with the narrow election result. Based on the empirical evidence we now have, the assertion that the electorate shifted right in accordance with Trump’s agenda is simply untenable. Let’s look at the picture that emerges from the latest <a href="https://prri.org/research/trumps-unprecedented-actions-deepen-asymmetric-divides/">American Values Survey (AVS)</a>, for instance. Since 2010, the AVS is conducted annually by the Public Religion Research Institute (PRRI) in partnership with the Brookings Institution. It’s a high-quality survey that stands out because it is not so much concerned with the day-to-day political business, but aims at exploring the underlying attitudes, values, and shifts in national identity. The latest AVS makes very clear why Trump is so unpopular: His economic policy is judged as a disaster (something basically <a href="https://www.gelliottmorris.com/p/donald-trump-is-joe-biden-now">every serious poll confirms</a>) – and his authoritarian ambitions are widely perceived as acutely dangerous. Even two thirds of self-proclaimed independents, those roughly 40 percent of the electorate who are not registered with either party, view Trump as a <a href="https://prri.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/PRRI-Sep-2025-AVS.pdf">“dangerous dictator.”</a></p><p>A <a href="https://prri.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/2025-AVS-Presentation_Brookings-Event.pdf">stable majority</a> of Americans – consistently between 55 and 65 percent, according to the AVS – are not only critical of Trump, but also reject core tenets of the rightwing agenda, preferring the vision of a pluralistic liberal democracy instead: They support a <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/fact-sheet/public-opinion-on-abortion/">right to abortion</a> in most cases and envision a country that is defined by religious pluralism rather than Christian domination; they reject Trump’s assault on the modern state and the free university; they believe immigration ultimately strengthens America and demand a path to citizenship even for people who entered the country illegally. On all of these issues, it is not just Democrats who stand against the Trumpist vision: About <a href="https://prri.org/research/trumps-unprecedented-actions-deepen-asymmetric-divides/">60 percent to two thirds</a> of independents do as well. Regardless of how many times the commentariat insists the Democratic Party is losing touch with “real America”: On substance, it is very clearly Republicans who are increasingly out of touch with the mainstream.</p><p><strong>Misleading Myth No. 2: „Trump is the tribune of regular folks and the champion of the working class”</strong></p><p>In the 2024 presidential election, Donald Trump narrowly won voters with a <a href="https://ropercenter.cornell.edu/how-groups-voted-2024">household income</a> under $50,000 per year as well as those under $100,000 – while Kamala Harris got slightly more votes from people with a household income above $100,000. Those are important numbers. They have provided the basis for the assertion that “the working class” united behind Trump out of a deep-seated frustration with the dysfunctional system, animated by disdain for the “woke” elites, and fueled by a pervasive economic anxiety.</p><p>But look more closely and the empirical evidence doesn’t actually align with the “economic anxiety” interpretation – probably the most persistent and most consistently wrong narrative to emerge from the Trump era. <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0261379419300691">Studies have long indicated</a> that Trump’s most ardent supporters do often not come from the poorest social strata: In areas that are struggling economically, we tend to find them among those who are relatively well off by local standards, even if they are not wealthy compared to the national economic distribution. They are “nationally poor,” but “locally rich.” That points to fear of a <a href="https://www.vox.com/politics/369797/trump-support-class-local-rich-arlie-hochschild">relative loss in status</a> as a motivation for supporting Trump – and a widespread sense that the system / the state is allowing the “wrong” kinds of people (immigrants, people of color, women) to ascend, at the expense of those in positions of established power who supposedly “deserve” their privilege. In their 2018 book <a href="https://press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691196435/identity-crisis?srsltid=AfmBOooQI90tEZ0qiZYbfElzYgs3OAEtSs3wSFvTQitJ0ArfwAbA40Ih">Identity Crisis: The 2016 Presidential Campaign and the Battle for the Meaning of America</a>, the definitive account of what happened in Trump’s first election, political scientists John M. Sides, Lynn Vavreck, and Michael Tesler convincingly outlined how cultural and racial resentment shaped the perception of the economic situation: Economic anxiety was downstream from cultural/racial/gender anxiety, not the other way around.</p><p>The idea that the “lower class” exists as a relatively homogeneous voting bloc that has moved right is simply not plausible either. Trump’s support is heavily concentrated among <a href="https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-4-working-class-votes/">the <em>white</em> working class</a>, which studies and polls, for the sake of simplicity, tend to define as people without a college degree; in 2024, Trump received about two thirds of their vote. By contrast, a little less than half of Latino voters without a college degree voted for Trump last year, and only about 15 percent of the Black working class. Race evidently shaped voting decisions as a crucial factor. As did religion: Trump got about 86 percent of the <a href="https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-4-working-class-votes/">white evangelical working-class vote</a> – but only about 45 percent of non-evangelical white working-class voters chose to support him.</p><p>The number one argument deployed in defense of the economic anxiety/elites vs working class interpretation – and against prioritizing “cultural” factors like race, religion, and gender – is “education polarization.” This is probably the closest thing we currently have to a widely accepted <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2021/09/08/us/politics/how-college-graduates-vote.html">master narrative</a> of what is happening in U.S. politics and society; it is supposedly <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/03/18/opinion/ezra-klein-podcast-david-shor.html">the root cause</a> underlying everything else that happens. And it is true that the percentage of people with a college degree among Democratic voters has steadily increased since the 1970s; since around the year 2000, they have been making up <a href="https://catalist.us/whathappened2024/#ib-toc-anchor-13">the majority of the Democratic coalition</a>. By contrast, since 2016, Trump has consistently won <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2025/06/26/voting-patterns-in-the-2024-election/">the white non-college-educated vote</a> by significant margins.</p><p>Once again, however, we need to look more closely and differentiate: To think of people with a college degree as a socially, politically, and culturally homogeneous group that is synonymous with a “liberal elite” makes no sense when that same group also includes people who graduated the many Christian-conservative colleges in the country. And once again, the phenomenon of education polarization is evident mostly among white people – while there isn’t much of a correlation between educational attainment and voting decision <a href="https://catalist.us/whathappened2024/#ib-toc-anchor-23">among Blacks and Latinos</a>.</p><p>Most importantly, studies that don’t simply correlate educational attainment and voting decision but include and control for other factors clearly indicate that the “education polarization” narrative vastly overestimates the impact of education. Study after study suggests that education functions mostly as a proxy for other factors that have a much greater impact on political attitudes and decisions. The most important among those by far is <a href="https://www.annualreviews.org/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-polisci-060418-042842#right-ref-B54">racial resentment</a>. As a concept, racial resentment is not necessarily the same as biological racism (meaning: the assumption that some races are <em>biologically</em> inferior/superior). Since the 1980s, for instance, the American National Election Studies (ANES) attempt to measure racial resentment <a href="https://electionstudies.org/data-tools/anes-guide/anes-guide.html?chart=racial_resentment_3">by asking people</a> whether they believe the significant wealth and income discrepancies between Black and white Americans are mostly a result of racist discrimination or rather a function of Black cultural deficiencies (a lacking working morale, perhaps, or pathologies of the Black family; or maybe Black people simply don’t try hard enough)? Based on their responses, people are placed on a scale from lower to higher levels of racial resentment. The correlation between where people fall on the racial resentment scale and their voting decisions is vastly stronger than that between voting and educational attainment. In the 2020 election, for instance, <a href="https://www.weekendreading.net/p/the-limits-of-education-essentialism">almost 90 percent</a> of the people with low racial resentment scores voted for Joe Biden; over 90 percent of those at the higher end of the racial resentment scale supported Donald Trump. Talk about “polarization.”</p><p>(By the way, if you want a brilliant dissection of the “education polarization” narrative, and why it falls short, with plenty of graphics and graphs to illustrate everything I am trying to describe here, please check out this excellent analysis of what he calls <a href="https://www.weekendreading.net/p/the-limits-of-education-essentialism">“The Limits of Education Essentialism”</a> by Michael Podhorzer.)</p><p>If you control for racial resentment instead of simply correlating education and voting decision, something remarkable happens: Education polarization, supposedly the root cause that explains everything, almost vanishes. <a href="https://laurenmgoldstein.substack.com/p/racial-realignment-or-diploma-divide">In the 2024 election</a>, people with high racial resentment scores strongly tended to vote for Donald Trump, regardless of their educational attainment; by contrast, people with low racial resentment scores strongly tended to support Kamala Harris, whether they had a college degree or not. Put differently: In a group of voters with the same educational attainment, their respective level of racial resentment allows a very strong prediction of their political leanings. But in a group of voters with the same level of racial resentment, we can’t really make an assumption about their voting decisions based on their respective levels of educational attainment. </p><p>If that is so (and it really is!), why does educational attainment correlate with support for Donald Trump – why does he consistently perform better among people without college education and worse among those with a college degree? Because statistically speaking, racial resentment and educational attainment are inversely correlated: As you go up the educational attainment scale, you tend to go down on racial resentment, and vice versa. It is a correlation that is documented beyond reasonable doubt, even if it has proven very difficult to fully explain it.</p><p>It really is remarkable: So much talk about the “diploma gap” – when the education polarization of the American electorate actually doesn’t support the notion of Donald Trump as the tribune of the working class and the champion of regular folks. Instead, it strengthens the interpretation against which it is usually deployed as a key witness: The political conflict in the United States is shaped and defined by fundamentally incompatible attitudes towards racial and cultural pluralism. It’s not the education, stupid – it’s the racism (and strictly hierarchical vision of how society should be ordered that comes with it).</p><p><strong>Misleading Myth No. 3: “Trump is building a stable multiracial coalition”</strong></p><p>The idea that Donald Trump has managed to unite a stable <a href="https://www.wsj.com/opinion/the-american-political-realignment-is-real-voter-patterns-election-af0ff62e?gaa_at=eafs&amp;gaa_n=AWEtsqcxhBiUltSVbyY9g8SRmZ_ULQfZsKL6ghBz1AkQriFccVXgHL7LVyGfEO_0N_I%3D&amp;gaa_ts=690d7984&amp;gaa_sig=ahOs2o1pUqweVARbB39KUC56Yc8JTid2jd3fFIdDKBMTiZNX8uXP2wmHrLyzedLuDhpNwuL1eIWZLEhoLepEPQ%3D%3D">multiracial coalition</a> is the third pillar of the narrative that proclaims a landslide “realignment” of American politics. Once again, there is a kernel of truth. Between 2016 and 2024, Donald Trump increased his support among people of color, especially among Latinos. In the last presidential election, he got <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2025/06/26/voting-patterns-in-the-2024-election/">almost half the Hispanic vote</a> – up from about a third in 2020.</p><p>Yet people often overestimate – or actively overinflate – the extent of Trump’s multiracial support. Even in 2024, <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2025/06/26/voting-patterns-in-the-2024-election/">about 80 percent</a> of his voters were white. And <a href="https://edition.cnn.com/2025/05/11/politics/gop-voter-coalition-2024-trump">already in the spring</a>, frustration among his Latino voters was high, many had quickly turned away from him once he took office. By the time of the election earlier this month, Trump <a href="https://www.gelliottmorris.com/p/trumps-winning-2024-coalition-has">had squandered</a> all his 2024 gains among Latinos that had significantly contributed to getting him back into the White House.</p><p>The most plausible interpretation is that Trump’s strong support among Latinos in 2024 was the result of an acute frustration with the economic situation that many voters, whatever macro-economic indicators might have suggested, subjectively perceived to be very bad: A majority listed the state of the economy as one of <a href="https://news.gallup.com/poll/651719/economy-important-issue-2024-presidential-vote.aspx">their main concerns</a> entering the election. Furthermore, Trump benefited massively from the fact that a significant number of people, including many people of color, simply <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2024/10/trump-believability-gap/680201/">refused to believe</a> he was serious about his mass deportation promises – or chose to believe they wouldn’t be targeted if such plans were ever put into practice.</p><p>There is one group of Hispanics where Trump’s support has not cratered: <a href="https://prri.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/PRRI-Sep-2025-AVS.pdf">Among protestants</a>, who make up about 25 percent of all Hispanics in the United States, Trump remains relatively popular – and especially among evangelicals. Yet again, this points to the crucial role that cultural and religious factors play in shaping political identities.</p><p>(At the risk of beating a dead horse: Isn’t it remarkable how much the mainstream discourse settled on education polarization as the preferred narrative, which supposedly refutes the idea that America’s political divisions are mostly about race, religion, and gender – when so much of the empirical evidence points precisely to those as the central organizing principles? This is a very strong case of the narrative taking precedence: Education polarization, in the way it is commonly understood and presented, serves to support the “Democrats so detached / Libs so elitist / wokeism running amok” tale to which so many center-right to center-left pundits are publicly committed. And so that’s what they are determined to stick with.)</p><p>What we are observing among America’s non-white population is a process that has fundamentally reshaped the political landscape for decades and is much further along among white people: A belated <a href="https://goodauthority.org/news/election-2024-racial-realignment-us-politics/">partisan sorting along ideological lines</a>. Among people of color, it is two groups, in particular, that have been trending towards the Republican Party: First, it is people whose religion connects them to the GOP institutionally – that is the case for evangelicals especially. Secondly, immigrants and people of color who – as counterintuitive as that may sound – are skeptical towards the idea of pluralism or even reject the vision of liberal society outright have found their political home in the Republican Party. <a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/american-political-science-review/article/reversion-to-the-mean-or-their-version-of-the-dream-latino-voting-in-an-age-of-populism/D5FDF66C474541B3AABB4498BA59184C">Among Hispanics, especially</a>, those who display a relatively high level of <a href="https://goodauthority.org/news/election-2024-racial-realignment-us-politics/">resentment towards Blacks</a> and prefer a draconian immigration control tend to support Trump.</p><p><strong>What comes after the dissolution of the old order?</strong></p><p>Trump does not have a stable conservative/right-leaning majority behind him; he does not represent the “will of the people.” America remains deeply divided, with a numerical majority rejecting the reactionary agenda and generally supporting the vision of liberal pluralism.</p><p>However, it is striking that both major parties are vastly unpopular. <a href="https://prri.org/research/trumps-unprecedented-actions-deepen-asymmetric-divides/">Less than 40 percent</a> of Americans currently have a positive opinion of either party, the percentage of people who <a href="https://news.gallup.com/poll/548459/independent-party-tied-high-democratic-new-low.aspx">register as independents</a> because they don’t want to identify as either Republican or Democrat is rising. There is significant discontent across the political spectrum – a resentment towards the political elites. And <a href="https://www.pew.org/en/trend/archive/fall-2024/americans-deepening-mistrust-of-institutions">trust in established institutions</a> more generally has been declining massively.</p><p>America is not experiencing a rightward realignment as much as it is going through a de-alignment of the established order.</p><p>Those are precisely the conditions under which Donald Trump has been able to thrive. Significant parts of the rightwing base have been bound to him – not the Republican Party. It is the personal loyalty of his supporters who do not feel allegiance to the GOP that has enabled him to dominate rightwing politics for a decade; institutionally, the Republican Party has been far too weak to offer meaningful resistance.</p><p>Perhaps that is changing now, as Trump’s power seems to be eroding, his hold over his own movement is weakening. For the first time since he became the standard-bearer of the Right, Trump has lately faced open, public resistance from within MAGA; his power to integrate the different factions of his coalition seems to be waning.</p><p>But if and when Trump leaves the scene, the country will still face a daunting task: Who can channel the disruptive political energies of a society in which the established institutions have lost the people’s trust into a (small-d) democratic direction?</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/7edb91f9-c681-4769-b3cb-6eaebcc8ad4b">Listen on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/7edb91f9-c681-4769-b3cb-6eaebcc8ad4b/uploads/images/2jln563e7k/Combined_Illustration.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/7edb91f9-c681-4769-b3cb-6eaebcc8ad4b</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">7edb91f9-c681-4769-b3cb-6eaebcc8ad4b</guid>
      <pubDate>Wed, 26 Nov 2025 23:55:27 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Into the Twilight of the Trump Era]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[What becomes of MAGA as Trump’s hold over the movement is weakening, his ability to integrate its different factions waning? A deep dive into the state of the fever swamp]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>What becomes of MAGA as Trump’s hold over the movement is weakening, his ability to integrate its different factions is waning? A deep dive into the state of the fever swamp</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, November 23, 2025</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/84aa4909-be51-4ebf-a3a4-422843ae56c6">Listen on Steady</a></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/84aa4909-be51-4ebf-a3a4-422843ae56c6/uploads/images/aey7nbmlgf/D79A6E79-8230-4EC7-879B-076A007A7498_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>Trump and Marjorie Taylor Greene when they were still friends, in March 2024 – credit: Elijah Nouvelage/AFP via Getty Images</figcaption></figure><p><em>Before we get into it, can I bother you for a minute?</em></p><p><em>Democracy Americana is my main source of income as an independent writer. If you are reading on a </em><strong><em>free subscription</em></strong><em>, I sincerely appreciate your time and effort engaging with my work! Please share it widely to help me reach new readers.</em></p><p><em>And if you can, please consider becoming a </em><strong><em>paid member</em></strong><em>. You will also gain access to special benefits – including additional essays.</em></p><p><em>Most importantly, Democracy Americana is a publication solely funded by readers. I fully rely on your support and generosity to make this work possible. Thank you!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p></p><p>I admit, until quite recently, I remained skeptical the Epstein scandal (if you’ll allow the use of this rather euphemistic term) would really hurt Donald Trump. It was clear Trump was struggling to shake it off when it roared back onto the agenda in the summer. But when things quieted down between July and November, it once again seemed like Trump was getting away with it, his supporters were falling in line.</p><p>When the government shutdown ended on November 12, however, it all exploded. After a pressure campaign by Democrats and, remarkably, some of MAGA’s more prominent political figures, Congress <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cly2y40lj5go">almost unanimously passed</a> legislation demanding the release of the files stemming from federal investigations into Epstein, forcing Trump to sign the bill immediately. It seems undeniable now that Trump’s power has been eroding, his hold over his own movement is weaker than it has ever been since he became the standard-bearer of the political Right almost exactly a decade ago.</p><p>This time, he was not able to impose his will, even though he so aggressively tried. Instead, MAGA Republicans broke with him over Epstein, even going directly and publicly against him. Not only are prominent MAGA figures actively preparing for a post-Trump future: They seem to have decided that the best way to position themselves was to signal distance from Trump, rather than to rise through sycophancy and fealty.</p><p>Something has shifted in the relationship between Trump and MAGA. As hesitant as I am to write this, I believe we are now entering the twilight of the Trump era. But do not misread this moment: This is no revolt of the “moderates” on the Right that is bringing Trump down, no uprising of the decent. As Trump’s power to integrate the different factions of the MAGA coalition seems to be waning, all the energy in the struggle for control of the Right remains with the more extreme, most conspiratorial factions. Whatever form MAGA takes in the coming post-Trump era, the idea that American politics will soon experience a return to “normalcy” is dangerously fanciful.</p><p><strong>“Teflon Don” no more</strong></p><p>As Trump emerged as a contender for the Republican presidential nomination over ten years ago, the media quickly applied the nickname <a href="https://www.politico.com/story/2015/08/teflon-don-121587">“Teflon Don”</a>, capturing the perception that this man seemed to rise unscathed from one scandal after another that would have ended anybody else’s political ambitions. The nickname was most infamously applied to New York mafia boss John Gotti in the 1980s when several trials against him ended in acquittals. But it turned out it wasn’t quite true that nothing ever stuck to Gotti: In April 1992, he was finally convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment. And Donald Trump was never quite immune from the effects of his many scandals either. While they didn’t bring him down, they always tended to hurt his public standing; there has always been a dynamic with Trump where people like him less the more they actually hear about him, the more he is actually present in their lives. Then again, nothing ever seemed to affect his hold over his base or threaten the personal loyalty that binds the MAGA faithful to him; as a political movement, MAGA has been defined by an authoritarian cult of personality that has grown ever more bizarre; and over the past decade, the Republican Party has ostracized anyone who dared to stand publicly against Trump.</p><p>Until now? Trump’s rise on the Right was fueled by conspiracy theories. He entered the political scene as the most prominent proponent of the racist “birther” conspiracy, claiming that Barack Obama had forged his birth certificate and therefore had no right to be president at all. It was never about the details of Obama’s biography but about declaring the first Black president an illegitimate “Other” who could never represent “real America.” That was one part of Trump’s appeal on the Right: He would mobilize whatever force necessary to restore a white Christian patriarchal order and relegate those “Others” to a lesser status. The other part crystallized in his promise to “drain the swamp,” weaponizing a widespread anti-elite sentiment that had radicalized on the far right into the truly deranged fever dream of a satanic cabal of pedophiles controlling the country. Trump was supposed to be the messiah who would deliver the nation. He had trafficked in those very elite circles, of course, but that only meant he knew what America was up against; but he was never, as the MAGA base saw it, one of “them” – he shared their disdain for these elites, was animated by the same grievance. That’s what made him “authentic” in their eyes.</p><p>Trump’s involvement with Epstein and the way he has acted to prevent the release of the “Epstein files” that had long acquired mythical status among his supporters have directly undermined this “authenticity.” All the many deranged things Trump says and does: The racism, the sexism, the many forms of bigotry, the assault on basic decency and dignity – to his disciples, Trump was just lustfully owning the Libs. The more open and brazen his transgressions, the more he seemed to be taunting that “system” they detested so much. But his secrecy around the Epstein stuff, that’s different. That’s what those evil elites do!</p><p><strong>Will Trump lose his base?</strong></p><p>On the MAGA base, the picture remains murky. How much potential is there really for this to sever the ties between Trump and his supporters? One way to approach that question is to get a sense of how many base Trumpists hold QAnon-esque views that might prime them to care about Epstein and view Trump’s behavior as a personal betrayal. We may not talk about QAnon as a distinct movement as much anymore as during the first Trump presidency. But just as Christian nationalism has become so pervasive that it constitutes something of a foundational ideology of Trumpism, we encounter core claims of the QAnon conspiracy far beyond the fringes of the Right. QAnon has festered, spread below the surface, seeped into the foundations of MAGA political identity. Two years ago, in the summer of 2023, the <a href="https://prri.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/PRRI-Oct-2023-AVS-1.pdf">American Values Survey</a> attempted to measure the prevalence of QAnon by asking a representative sample of people whether they agreed with three tenets of the conspiracy theory: “(1) The government, media, and financial worlds in the U.S. are controlled by a group of Satan-worshipping pedophiles who run a global child sex trafficking operation; (2) There is a storm coming soon that will sweep away the elites in power and restore the rightful leaders; (3) Because things have gotten so far off track, true American patriots may have to resort to violence in order to save our country.” These questions did not sanitize this inherently violent conspiracy theory – they capture how out there, how deranged and extreme this stuff is. And yet, judged by their answers to these questions, 29% of Republicans qualified as QAnon believers, up from 23% two years earlier – with the survey defining “believers” as: “Respondents who completely or mostly agreed with these statements.” As always with this kind of survey data, it is probably not productive to fixate on the exact percentages, which are inevitably influenced by the specific phrasing of the questions. But I see little reason to doubt the general magnitude of the problem or the devastating trends over recent years.</p><p>(As an aside: While support was lower on the Democratic side, the survey encountered the same trends there as well, as the number of Democratic QAnon believers had doubled – doubled! – since March 2021, from 7% to 14%. At least as worrying was the fact that over the same time, the proportion of Democrats who completely rejected QAnon had decreased from 58% to 43%. In general, these results are indicative of a deeply troubled society – a fundamentally unhealthy social and political culture. In a healthy political environment, all those in power, across party lines, would regard this as a national emergency and mobilize all available resources of the state and civil society in an all-out effort to reverse those trends. In America, that is evidently not happening.)</p><p>The fact that these beliefs are prevalent does not mean it is guaranteed Trump’s support will crater in these circles. QAnon types obviously have a high tolerance for cognitive dissonance and a remarkable ability to ignore whatever empirical evidence does not align with their claims – that’s what makes it a conspiracy theory. They might just continue to exempt Donald Trump from their rage.</p><p>We do not have much yet in terms of concrete empirical evidence regarding the impact of the latest Epstein developments on Trump’s base. But <a href="https://www.ms.now/opinion/msnbc-opinion/trump-epstein-emails-files-republican-allies-rcna243787">as Philip Bump has pointed out</a> recently, there seems to be a groundswell of frustration among his supporters. Already in August, even among Republicans, where his approval remains very high (in the mid-80s), only a minority was satisfied with how he was handling the Epstein stuff, about a third declared to be properly dissatisfied, and about 20 percent didn’t know where they stood.</p><p>If we attempt to map Trump’s base and how they might react, I believe most people will find a way to rationalize their continued support. I expect most of the people who are either committed to a specific ideological project – the ardent white nationalists, for instance – or have institutionalized ties to MAGA, perhaps via evangelical churches, to take this path.</p><p>But there will also be people who aren’t willing to take this leap with and for Trump. I know I am painting in broad strokes here, but it might be helpful to distinguish two groups: The highly engaged QAnon-types vs the low-information, low-trust people who certainly don’t like “the elites” and “the system” either but haven’t really centered their private and political identities around QAnon-esque assumptions and are generally not highly engaged in politics. Among those groups, some might pull back from politics entirely, too disappointed to care at all anymore as their chosen messiah turns out to be just another one of those corrupt elites. Others might radicalize further, perhaps concluding that if not even the MAGA insurrection could be trusted to vanquish the evil elites, the only thing left to do is to burn it all down, declare war on the system and all forms of organized politics.</p><p><em>Help me continue this work and become a paid member of Democracy Americana:</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><strong>Who will lead MAGA after Trump?</strong></p><p>While the outcome remains unclear, there is no question that the struggle for post-Trump supremacy among the different MAGA factions has begun in earnest. For the first time, political leaders on the Right are acting as if they expect Trump’s reign to end soon. This became particularly obvious when Trump pressured the four Republican Representatives in the House – Thomas Massie, Nancy Mace, Lauren Boebert, and Marjorie Taylor Greene – who supported the Epstein discharge petition. The White House seemed to identify Boebert and Mace, in particular, as the weakest links: Both had never displayed any political commitment but fealty to Trump and a desire to be what the mainstream media loves to call a “MAGA firebrand.” And yet, they wouldn’t budge. Mace wants to run for governor in South Carolina. She evidently decided that siding against Trump in this matter was not going to sabotage her plans – or perhaps even help her.</p><p>To some extent, this is just a “normal” political dynamic: This is what happens to lame-duck presidents, especially those who are unpopular. Anyone who wants to be anything in their own party starts to seek distance and strengthen their own profile by separating themselves from the president. The reason why this sort of “normalcy” is remarkable is that the Republican Party, under Trump, had almost entirely stopped functioning according to “normal” rules and conventions, acting like an authoritarian movement defined by a cult of personality instead. In that sense, this sort of “normal” jockeying for position is an indication of Trump’s hold weakening.</p><p>But there is also more going on. The overall vibe on the Right has not been great lately. The Republican Party’s resounding defeat in the November election is souring the mood; Trump himself is historically unpopular. Whatever gains he made with young voters and Hispanics, in particular, in the 2024 election <a href="https://www.gelliottmorris.com/p/trumps-winning-2024-coalition-has">he has squandered</a>. It is obvious now that the much-discussed rightwing “realignment” was a myth. And it’s not just about election results and poll numbers either: The No Kings protests in October and the way the local population in urban centers is rising up to fight back against the immigration raids by masked agents of the state are evidence that societal resistance has been hardening. </p><p>Against this background, the long-simmering MAGA Civil War has been heating up – several warring factions are now openly claiming the right to ostracize others from the rightwing coalition. There are different overlapping ideological camps: The America First nativists are fighting the tech right; the white supremacists who are propagating a more aggressive form of Christian antisemitism – think Tucker Carlson, Marjorie Taylor Greene, and Nick Fuentes – are attempting to extinguish whatever influence neoconservatism may still exert and they are also fighting against the pro-Israel forces on the evangelical Right. Another axis in these intra-MAGA conflicts is more dispositional than ideological: Between those like Stephen Miller who have been itching to escalate the political conflict much more drastically, especially in the wake of Charlie Krik’s murder, and move to open repression of “the Left” vs those who don’t quite share this appetite for escalation or find it, at the very least, politically unwise.</p><p>The tensions between these different factions are not new. MAGA has never been a monolith. As Trump returned to the White House, a key question concerned MAGA’s internal dissent: Would the different factions get along and be able to cooperate within the regime? Or would their infighting and rivalries constitute a serious impediment to Trumpist rule? For the most part, over the past ten months, all factions got to enact their agenda and act out their fever dreams. All at the same time. They were integrated via escalation – by ramping up the fearmongering against a real or perceived enemy and by channeling all internal discontent into aggression towards that enemy. But as the revolutionary zeal tires out and the frustrations are mounting, this doesn’t seem to be working anymore. Most importantly, Trump himself has functioned as an integrating force on the MAGA Right over the past decade. Because he wasn’t tied to any specific ideological position (and didn’t care enough about any particular ideological program), he appealed to all factions simultaneously. But that doesn’t work in the Epstein case, as the fault line within MAGA became, for the first time: Are you with Trump or not?</p><p><strong>MAGA is anxious</strong></p><p>A nervous, anxious energy defines the Right today. <a href="https://graymirror.substack.com/p/you-cant-handle-the-truth">Prominent MAGA figures</a> are publicly losing their nerves, whining about how Trumpism isn’t going far enough, how they fear the vengeance of their enemies as Trump is failing to destroy them.</p><p>Marjorie Taylor Greene <a href="https://x.com/mtgreenee/status/1992037226415554642?s=20">announcing her resignation</a> will add to the bad vibes. On November 22, Greene surprisingly declared she was leaving Congress in early January. Why now, just after she achieved a big victory over Trump in the Epstein case? Much of this might come down to idiosyncratic personal reasons. Greene seems to be disappointed that Trump wouldn’t support her Senate aspirations in Georgia. It’s also probably not a coincidence that she stays just long enough in Congress to secure a lifelong federal pension after exactly five years in office.</p><p>If we assume there is more going on here, it is easy perhaps, to interpret her resignation as evidence that all the talk of Trump’s demise is premature. The list of Republicans breaking with Trump and being forced to resign is long; those who attempted to stay in GOP politics after falling out with Trump, like Liz Cheney, found out that winning a Republican primary as Trump’s declared enemy has basically been impossible. However, Greene doesn’t fit the list of Republican establishment figures capitulating before Trump. She comes from the hardcore MAGA camp herself. Her retreat is not a sign of MAGA ascending, but, more likely, of the MAGA coalition fracturing. I certainly think it is still very difficult for any individual in the Republican Party to win a primary without Trump’s endorsement. He remains the single most influential force on the Right. But the front line has shifted, from MAGA vs “normal” Republicans to MAGA vs MAGA.</p><p>Greene’s <a href="https://x.com/mtgreenee/status/1992037226415554642?s=20">resignation letter</a> is quite revealing. For defending the movement’s real Christian-nationalist, America First, anti-“globalist” convictions, Greene claims, she was “cast aside by MAGA Inc and replaced by Neocons, Big Pharma, Big Tech, Military Industrial War Complex, foreign leaders, and the elite donor class.” Look beyond the whiny self-aggrandizement, this is one long complaint about MAGA not living up to the promise of toppling the elites, instead becoming part of “the Political Industrial Complex of both Political Parties.” We have not heard something like this from one of MAGA’s most prominent proponents yet. The different factions are no longer aligned behind Trump, integrating them by personality cult or raging against “the Left” isn’t quite working anymore.</p><p><strong>Twilight of the Trump era?</strong></p><p>There is no realistic path that leads to a quick restoration of “normalcy,” no magic bullet that solves the problem of Trumpism. The Republican Party has been remade in Trump’s image, by forces that pulled the party ever further to the right long before Trump entered the political arena. The political culture on the Right is a militant, paranoid, authoritarian disaster.</p><p>Whatever comes next, the movement that controls the levers of state power remains acutely dangerous. What does an authoritarian leader do when he feels his grip on power weakening? Last time Trump was in such a situation, he tried to nullify the result of a democratic election and incited a violent insurrection. One path forward for MAGA, the one people like Stephen Miller desperately demand, is to escalate: Provoke more “emergencies” as pretext, follow through on the threat to criminalize all political and societal opposition for which the regime has given itself <a href="https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/09/countering-domestic-terrorism-and-organized-political-violence/">a pseudo-legal basis</a> in September, hope to re-integrate the different factions on the Right by radicalizing the “counter-revolution.”</p><p>Trump’s rise was not some accidental aberration or the result of a momentary delusion. The forces that made it possible for him to take over on the Right won’t simply disappear as we are entering the Twilight of the Trump era. There are no “moderates” left in a position to recapture the Republican Party. The pressure on Trump isn’t coming from whatever is left of the GOP establishment. In the Epstein case, it came from the MAGA faction so truly bound to their conspiratorial beliefs (or so fully captured by the conspiratorial part of the base) that they overrode their allegiance to Trump. The radicalizing dynamic that has shaped the Right still applies. We are now witnessing the next step on that trajectory.</p><p><em>Democracy Americana is my main source of income as an independent writer. Want to support my work? Consider becoming a paid member:</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/84aa4909-be51-4ebf-a3a4-422843ae56c6/teaser_image/1763909917?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/84aa4909-be51-4ebf-a3a4-422843ae56c6</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">84aa4909-be51-4ebf-a3a4-422843ae56c6</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 23 Nov 2025 14:25:49 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[MAGA Will Rule or Ruin]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[A roundup of the latest developments in America’s authoritarian crisis: How the Trumpists plan to bring down the Republic – and how they might react to electoral defeat]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>A roundup of the latest developments in America’s authoritarian crisis: How the Trumpists plan to bring down the Republic – and how they might react to electoral defeat</strong></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/83d6c925-87ed-41ee-a1f3-3bd201c68dc9/uploads/images/fsx35qlvfo/iStock-1307758874.png?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>credit: iStock / zimmytws</figcaption></figure><p><em>This is a regular feature for paid members wherein I round up the latest developments in America’s ongoing authoritarian crisis, with a focus on what is happening on the Right. The first part of the piece is free for everyone. If you want to read more than the preview, please consider </em><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/about#js-publication_plans"><em>becoming a member</em></a><em> of Democracy Americana and support my work.</em></p><p>If this were a normal administration, they would change course immediately. Just three weeks ago, millions of people mobilized in the streets to protest Trump’s authoritarian agenda. The president is extremely unpopular. And the people just dealt his party a devastating electoral blow. The message couldn’t be clearer.</p><p>But the reason why America is in this situation in the first place is that this is not a “normal” administration, but a government in the hands of a radicalizing, authoritarian movement. And the GOP rarely acts like a normal modern political party at all anymore: It is defined by a bizarre cult of personality and a base drowning in conspiracy theories.</p><p>There are very few “normal” people left in and around this administration. I don’t mean “normal” as in “moderate” – just people whose brains haven’t been poisoned by engaging with the world entirely through the prism of the rightwing media machine; who are still seeking and computing empirical information even if it contradicts the bizarre contortions of their ideological bubble; who still feel bound to something resembling the game of democratic politics instead of believing they have a right to end the game once and for all.</p><p><em>Want to support my work? Consider becoming a paid member of Democracy Americana:</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p>This is not a “normal” administration, and that makes it significantly more difficult to assess what might come next. After Tuesday’s election, it was Donald Trump, of all people, who seemed to react with a recognizably “normal” political instinct: He knows the shutdown is a problem for him and his party and <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m4v5trww7s2p">called on Republican senators</a> to put an end to it: “If you read the pollsters, the shutdown was a big factor, negative for Republicans.” Could this potentially open the door for voices who understand that the rules of “normal” politics aren’t yet fully suspended, that the country hasn’t irrevocably turned MAGA, that Republicans are running the risk of getting wiped out in future elections unless they exercise some measure of tactical restraint? That seemed to be what animated someone like Texas senator <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/sahilkapur.bsky.social/post/3lz7fsf3y4k26">Ted Cruz</a> back in September when he publicly distanced himself from Brandan Carr, the chairman of the Federal Communications Commission, after Carr had openly threatened ABC/Disney and demanded they take Jimmy Kimmel’s late night show off the air. Again, this is obviously not about “moderation.” But there is still a fault line within the GOP between those who fear public backlash – and those like Stephen Miller who are so determined to establish a fully authoritarian order, and soon, that they cannot be bothered to care about public opinion.</p><p>Then again, Donald Trump’s brief glimpses of flirting with “normal” politics notwithstanding, the president is of course also the most delusional person of the whole bunch. He remains obsessed with the Big Lie, with the 2020 election that was “stolen” from him. He doesn’t like the shutdown fight – yet he is not looking for moderation or compromise. He desires authoritarian escalation instead. And unfortunately, if we look at what the regime and its supporters have been up to over the past two weeks or so, this is also where things are heading on the Right more generally.</p><p>Let’s reflect on some of the latest developments in American authoritarianism – including: All the talk about a third term for Trump; the attack on elections is heating up; the National Guard is forming “quick reaction forces” and the Right has been dreaming about the Insurrection Act since the summer of 2020; Border Patrol extremism and state-condoned January 6 terrorism; Trump officials act like they are at war with their fellow Americans; and, just briefly, there is a MAGA civil war brewing.</p><p><strong>“He’s gonna get a third term”</strong></p><p>On the Right, talk about Trump “deserving” or “needing” a third term isn’t new – but it has considerably picked up lately. <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m46fn3olj62i">Trump himself</a> has said he “would love to do it.” The reason why he has been asked about it a lot recently is that Steve Bannon gave a much-discussed interview to <em>The Economist</em> on October 23 in which he declared: “He’s gonna get a third term. So, Trump ’28. Trump is gonna be president in ’28. And people just ought to get accommodated with that.” (The full interview is <a href="https://www.economist.com/insider/the-insider/inside-the-mind-of-maga-a-conversation-with-steve-bannon">here</a>; and a shorter clip with most of the “third term” part of the conversation is <a href="https://www.youtube.com/shorts/8AVTxwwnh7c">here</a>.) Bannon also announced that “At the appropriate time, we’ll lay put what the plan is. But there’s a plan.”</p><p>Let’s start with the obvious: A third term for Trump would be utterly unconstitutional. There is no loophole, no good-faith debate: The people who wrote and ratified the 22nd Amendment in 1951 were entirely clear about their intent – they instituted a hard, non-negotiable two-term limit.</p><p>Those are the facts. And in order to circumvent them, to suspend this key provision in the Constitution, Bannon and Trump will have to do a lot more than just talk into microphones. Always remember, their lawlessness does not make them omnipotent. Absolutely no need to pre-emptively concede the idea that they can just snap their fingers and end the constitutional order.</p><p>Let’s also consider the source here. Bannon likes to hear himself talk. There is an element of grandstanding and self-aggrandizement in everything he says. He wants to be seen as the mastermind working in the background, pulling the strings. He also loves to provoke, anything that produces an outcry among the mainstream while proving his “hardcore” credentials to the rightwing base. Frankly, I bet this whole “we have a masterplan” stuff is utter horseshit.</p><p>And yet, we can’t simply ignore this third-term talk either, unfortunately. Because MAGA is definitely sincere about replacing the Republic with Trumpian autocracy. They are certainly not thinking they have a maximum of three more years until Trump exits the stage. “The country needs him to be the president of the United States,” Bannon said to <em>The Economist</em>: “We have to finish what we started.” </p><p>As outlandish as it sounds, Bannon outlined the fundamentals of MAGA’s claim to unfettered power quite clearly and openly in the interview.</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/83d6c925-87ed-41ee-a1f3-3bd201c68dc9">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/83d6c925-87ed-41ee-a1f3-3bd201c68dc9/uploads/images/fsx35qlvfo/iStock-1307758874.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/83d6c925-87ed-41ee-a1f3-3bd201c68dc9</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">83d6c925-87ed-41ee-a1f3-3bd201c68dc9</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 09 Nov 2025 16:26:07 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Escalation, Authoritarian “Normalization,” or a Democratic Turnaround?]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[One year after the election: What we can say with certainty about the state of the Trumpist assault, where uncertainty lies, and where America might go from here]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h1>Revolutionary Escalation, Semi-Authoritarian “Normalization,” or a Democratic Turnaround?</h1><p><strong>One year after the election: What we can say with certainty about the state of the Trumpist assault, where uncertainty lies, and where America might go from here</strong></p><p><em>By Thomas Zimmer, November 3, 2025</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/21880233-f204-4b87-9733-54d91cbcf247">Listen on Steady</a></p><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/21880233-f204-4b87-9733-54d91cbcf247/uploads/images/jqryu6yvjc/Official_Presidential_Portrait_of_President_Donald_J._Trump_(2025)_(3x4_close_cropped).png?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><p>One year ago, Donald Trump won the 2024 presidential election. I am assuming everyone remembers exactly where, when, and how they realized that the man who had led a multi-month campaign to nullify the result of the previous election and incited a violent insurrection, the man who had campaigned on rage, intimidation, and vengeful violence, was going to return to the most powerful political office in the world.</p><p>The anniversary of Trump’s election necessarily sparks a lot of attempts to take stock. I am scheduled to do several “Where does America stand?” events on November 4. And I do believe these exercises, when pursued with sincerity, are useful: They force us to take a step back from the constant onslaught of breaking news and reflect on how everything that has transpired over the past twelve months relates to what we had been expecting – and what that means for how we should calibrate our expectations going forward. I find it helpful to distinguish: What can we say with certainty about the state of American politics today – and what are the open questions that will determine the trajectory of the country?</p><p><em>Democracy Americana is my main source of income as an independent writer. Want to support my work? Consider becoming a paid member:</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><h4><strong>What we can assert with certainty</strong></h4><p><strong>The Trumpist vision</strong></p><p>When Donald Trump returned to the presidency, there should not have been any doubt about the intention of the Trumpist Right. Trump himself mostly wants power, impunity, and the ability to plunder. But he is also animated by a spirit of vengefulness and grievance, he has aggressively autocratic instincts and sensibilities. That aligns him very well with the movement that has coalesced behind him. They desire to transform America into some form of plebiscitary autocracy, constantly invoking the true “will of the people” and their “mandate” to restore former national glory while drastically narrowing the boundaries of who gets to belong and purging everyone they declare an “invader” or the “enemy within.” They seek to centralize power and neutralize the opposition, curtail the rights of those who dare to deviate, entrench a tiered system of participation defined by hierarchies of race, gender, and wealth, and restore white male dominance in elite institutions as well as across all spheres of American life. All of this they have been declaring openly and aggressively since long before Trump’s election.</p><p><strong>The Right has radicalized</strong></p><p>Trumpism didn’t fall from the sky, it’s not simply an accident or a departure from an otherwise noble conservative tradition. Trump’s rise was much more itself the result, rather than the cause, of a long-term radicalization of the Right, of anti-democratic tendencies that have come to dominate the GOP after pulling the party to the right for decades. At the same time, however, the Republican Party and the political Right more broadly have also significantly radicalized further since Trump emerged as their leader about a decade ago. The balance of power within the rightwing coalition has shifted dramatically, leading to a much more extreme threat. The idea that far more drastic action is urgently needed has quickly taken over the power centers of conservative politics. The summer of 2020, specifically, escalated this perception of imminent threat and the siege mentality that dominates on the Right: It has become a key element of rightwing political identity to view the protests that erupted after the murder of George Floyd as supposedly irrefutable proof that “the Left” has started its full-on assault, justifying calls for ever more extreme action in response. The Right’s most influential intellectuals and activists no longer present their own project in the idiom of “conservatism.” As there is supposedly nothing left to conserve and preserve, <a href="https://americanmind.org/salvo/why-the-claremont-institute-is-not-conservative-and-you-shouldnt-be-either/">“Conservatism is no longer enough”</a> has become their battle cry. Nothing short of a comprehensive counter-revolution will suffice. Heritage Foundation president Kevin Roberts merely expressed the new rightwing consensus when he said, on the Fourth of July last year, that America was in the midst of a <a href="https://www.mediamatters.org/project-2025/heritage-foundation-president-celebrates-supreme-court-immunity-decision-we-are">“second American Revolution”</a> that may well turn bloody, depending on whether or not “the Left” would accept total defeat and destruction.</p><p><strong>No more adults in the room</strong></p><p>Remember the infamous “adults in the room” from early on in Trump’s first presidency, people like John Kelly as White House Chief of Staff, Rex Tillerson as Secretary of State, James Mattis as Secretary of Defense, and H. R. McMaster as National Security Advisor? There was a great deal of wishful thinking behind the idea that they would keep things from spiraling and prevent anything dangerous from happening. In some ways, they did as much to legitimize and normalize Trump’s start as president as they did to constrain and contain him. And yet, it is also true that they were not Trumpist radicals willing to do whatever necessary to implement authoritarian extremism. They were mostly “normal” Republicans in the sense that they hadn’t poisoned their brains by consuming nothing but rightwing media for years, their perception of the political conflict wasn’t warped by existing entirely within the rightwing information environment for so long that anyone who disagreed looked like an “enemy within” and even the most outlandish conspiracy theory became just another facet of accepted un-reality.</p><p>In Trump’s first presidency, hardcore MAGA was much more dependent on seeking compromise with the GOP establishment. The choice of Mike Pence as vice president captured that reality. As a result, many of the people with direct access to Trump in and around the White House were “normal” politicians and political operatives. These aides, advisors, and counsels weren’t “moderates” themselves, but they were much more likely to curb Trump’s worst impulses. This time, Trump is surrounded by bloodhounds and arsonists, by people who are fully subservient to him and by radical ideologues like Stephen Miller. Escalatory rage everywhere.</p><p><strong>Gleichschaltung of the Republican Party</strong></p><p>It is difficult to remember now, but early on in Trump’s reign as the Right’s leader, there was actually some resistance, certainly some reluctance, from within the Republican Party and the conservative movement. But the GOP has been purged of anyone daring to oppose Trump. That doesn’t mean everyone in the rightwing coalition is now exactly on the same page on all issues (more on that later). But there is certainly no more place for voices openly critical of Trump. Elected leaders like Liz Cheney or Mitt Romney who publicly held the line that nullifying the results of a democratic election and engaging in a violent insurrection was disqualifying have been ostracized. The Trumpist regime can now count on a fully Trumpified party. And the radical Right is now clearly in control of the power centers of conservatism.</p><p>That’s what was so striking about the Right’s unhinged campaign to demonize the “No Kings” protests as a gathering of communists and domestic terrorists: No Republican of any consequence stood up and said: “I actually disagree with this characterization of large swaths of my fellow Americas as enemies.” Instead, people like majority whip Tom Emmer – who Trump didn’t want as Speaker in October 2023 because Emmer was considered too moderate (or, according to Trump, a <a href="https://www.politico.com/news/2023/10/24/i-killed-him-how-trump-torpedoed-tom-emmers-speaker-bid-00123329">“Globalist RINO”</a>) were all in. There was no measure of restraint at all. No trace of any residual sense of commitment to something even remotely recognizable as a shared democratic political culture.</p><p>As an immediate result of the full-on Trumpification of the Republican Party, the GOP-led Congress has entirely abdicated its role as a check on executive power.</p><p></p><p><em>Before you keep reading, may I ask you for your support?</em></p><p><em>This is a free post I am making available to everyone. If you want to keep reading on a </em><strong><em>free subscription</em></strong><em>, I sincerely appreciate your time and effort engaging with my work! Please share it widely to help me reach new readers.</em></p><p><em>And if you can, please consider becoming a </em><strong><em>paid member</em></strong><em>: As a member, you will gain access to additional benefits – including additional essays. But most importantly, Democracy Americana is a publication solely funded by readers and my main source of income as an independent writer. I rely on your support and generosity to make this work possible. Thank you!</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p></p><h4><strong>Ongoing conflicts, remaining obstacles, and open questions</strong></h4><p>For all these reasons, no one should have ever indulged the idea that a second Trump presidency would merely be a repeat of the first. It was always going to be something qualitatively very different. The real question was: How far would they be able to go? Nine-and-a-half months into Trumpist rule, we can identify areas where there is still conflict, where politics continues, where there is still a gap between the regime’s authoritarian pretensions and the reality of a complex political system, where there is still at least a plausible (though perhaps not very likely) scenario that the Trumpists might run into obstacles they can’t overcome and the Trumpist project might fail.</p><p> </p><p><strong>A judiciary at war with itself (or, rather: A rightwing Supreme Court majority at war with the rest of the judiciary)</strong></p><p>What role can the courts play in constraining the Trumpist assault on the constitutional order? The good news first: The federal courts have so far acted as by far the most effective bulwark in defense of democratic self-government and the rule of law. <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2025/us/trump-administration-lawsuits.html">Hundreds of lawsuits</a> have been filed against the administration, and in the vast majority of those, federal district courts have sided against the administration, with federal judges issuing injunctions or restrictions. And there really is no sign of them slowing down, even though it comes at great personal cost for those judges, as everyone who dares to rule against Trump knows they will face an avalanche of violent threat, fueled by high-ranking members of the government declaring all dissident judges to be <a href="https://edition.cnn.com/2025/10/06/politics/republican-federal-judges-trump">insurrectionists</a> and domestic terrorists.</p><p>Here is the bad news: Not only are the courts inevitably restricted to reacting to the actions of the Trump administration, meaning a lot of damage is being done before any ruling can attempt to reign in the assault; not only is the extent to which the Trumpists are complying with court decisions, or how long they will be complying at all, unclear; the key problem is that once these cases reach the Supreme Court, the rightwing majority overrules most of these injunctions and restrictions <a href="https://data4democracy.substack.com/p/the-supreme-court-is-at-war-with">and sides with the Trump administration</a> almost as often as the lower courts side against it.</p><p>Look, no one should have seriously entertained the idea that the Roberts Court might be meaningfully part of the resistance. Trump being able to count on a 6-3 rightwing majority was always going to be a game changer. Let’s remember this was not the case until Amy Coney Barrett’s ascension in late October 2020, towards the very end of the Trump presidency. Not that we needed more evidence, but the Court’s almost unprecedentedly extreme ruling to declare Trump functionally immune from criminal prosecution should have erased any lingering hope that the Roberts Court “would not go THAT far.”</p><p>We had never seen this Court operate with Trump in the White House and a Republican trifecta. Early on, in the first few weeks after Trump took power, it seemed they might – for tactical reasons or to preserve their own power, perhaps – keep a little more distance. But then they opted to be more aggressively aligned. I do think that if John Robert could choose, he would like the administration to pursue a strategy of autocratic legalism, moving within the boundaries of the law and the constitution at least on paper, rather than forcing the Court to greenlight blatantly illegal, unconstitutional stuff all the time. But ultimately, the rightwing justices want Trump to win because they are aligned on the fundamental claims on which the Trumpist project is built: They consider Trump the sovereign, an embodiment of the will of the people; only Republican power is legitimate; and they are fundamentally opposed to egalitarian pluralism. On that basis, the Court will go to great lengths to facilitate Trumpist rule, advancing the same rationale over and over again: That any “burden” placed upon the regime by insisting the constitution is still in effect, the separation of powers is still a thing, and the law is still the law, causes the government “irreparable harm.” The rightwing justices simply will not allow the lower courts to rein in this unprecedentedly lawless regime.</p><p><strong>Malevolencve vs Incompetence</strong></p><p>“Malevolence tempered by incompetence” was a prominent dictum in the early months of Trump’s first presidency, and there was definitely something to that. This was a genuinely open question going into the second Trump presidency: How much would they be shooting themselves in the foot, to what extent would their own incompetence hamper the realization of the Trumpist project?</p><p>I’d say the record so far has been decidedly mixed. On the one hand: Trump is still Trump – a lazy, undisciplined narcissist who insists on elevating people to positions of great power who have zero qualification other than that he liked them on Fox News, they are personally subservient to him, and they hate the same people he hates. That doesn’t mean people like Pete Hegseth or Kash Patel aren’t dangerous – they most definitely are. But they are also manifestly incompetent. We really shouldn’t pretend that there isn’t a clown show element to a lot of what this regime is attempting to do.</p><p>On the other hand, the problem is that there is no law of nature that says democratic self-government can’t be destroyed by a bunch of malevolent buffoons in power. And, crucially, they aren’t all clowns. Overall, this second Trump regime can count on a better prepared, more fully mobilized conservative movement. Trump world was definitely not ready in 2017. No one understood this more clearly than the extreme Right. The conservative machine had been late to endorse Trumpism and hadn’t been fully mobilized in time to provide the personnel or policy plans. They didn’t have any concrete strategies, not a clue how government worked. And the extremists didn’t have the personnel to bend the vast and powerful machine we call the state to their will and harness its powers. That is why they, during the Biden interregnum, they engaged in several far-reaching planning operations, Project 2025 most (in)famous among them. There is no doubt that a lot of what the Trumpists are doing – especially the assault on the modern state, the attempt to weaponize the parts of the state they don’t want to dismantle to go after their enemies, the purging of the civil service, the use of presidential executive orders to bypass Congress – follows the parameters outlined in Project 2025. Russell Vought, Trump’s director of the Office of Management and Budget in the White House and himself one of the key architects behind Project 2025, is probably the main driving force behind this authoritarian takeover of the state. Vought combines ideological zeal and operative competence. He is singularly focused on bending the entire government machine to Trump’s will – a fully committed extremist causing massive harm to millions of people. </p><p>Then again, sometimes people talk about Project 2025 as if it is some mythical cheat code the Trumpists now possess that will inevitably allow them to win. But that is just not how things work in practice. Take the Trumpist attempt to use the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) as a weapon to bring media institutions into line. It captures both why we are facing a different level of threat than in Trump I, but also how it’s not determined the Trumpists will succeed. While the Trumpists were never defenders of free speech, there was no systematic attempt after 2017 to nullify the First Amendment or use the levers of state power to suppress protest and public dissent. They simply didn’t know how to use the government in that way, and they didn’t have the people in place who could have systematically used the state machinery as an instrument of repression. This led to a pervasive frustration within MAGA, and it is precisely what animated the big planning operations the Right launched during the Biden era. In fact, Brendan Carr literally wrote the chapter on the FCC in Project 2025’s policy agenda – in which he envisioned using the agency exactly the way he has since taking over as chairman in January: As an instrument to put pressure on business and media, threatening regulatory action or lawsuits against anyone not sufficiently deferential to Trump’s will.</p><p>But the Jimmy Kimmel affair also demonstrated the limits of the Trumpist reach, at least for now: On September 17, Carr openly threatened to come after broadcaster ABC unless it canceled Jimmy Kimmel Live after the late-night host had criticized the Trumpist attempts to use the murder of Charlie Kirk as pretext to oppress “the Left.” In an interview on a rightwing podcast, <a href="https://edition.cnn.com/2025/09/17/media/jimmy-kimmel-charlie-kirk-trump-fcc-brendan-carr?cid=ios_app">Carr said</a>: “We can do this the easy way or the hard way. These companies can find ways to change conduct to take actions, frankly on Kimmel, or there’s going to be additional work for the FCC ahead.” Initially, that seemed to work – Kimmel was taken off the air. But the public backlash was swift. Already the next day, September 18, <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/jlray.bsky.social/post/3lz56xratss2q">polling</a> suggested that most people vehemently disagreed with the decision to cancel Kimmel and sharply rejected the threats ushered by the FCC chairman. By the weekend, it had become clear that Disney, which owns ABC, was paying a steep price for not standing with Kimmel, as a record-number of people decided to cancel their <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/gelliottmorris.com/post/3lzbrh2wm522q">Disney Plus subscriptions</a>. On Monday, September 22, Disney/ABC announced Kimmel would be back the next night. </p><p>One reason why the American public reacted so strongly to the Kimmel cancellation is that the Trumpists went about this in the most ham-fisted way. Here is a concrete example of how a more sophisticated, insidious approach might have gotten them a very different result. The FCC could have threatened ABC / Disney executives behind the scenes – yet Brendan Carr just had to play big, bad man on a rightwing podcast, likely because he thought it would endear him to the MAGA base. Trump could have used backdoor channels to make it known to Kimmel’s bosses what he wanted; yet he is Donald Trump, and so he went straight to talking into a microphone how the networks should have their <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/sep/18/jimmy-kimmel-show-trump">licenses revoked</a> if they were mean to him, and how he wanted to see two more late-night hosts, <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/yasharali.bsky.social/post/3lz32nywem22k">Jimmy Fallon and Seth Meyers</a>, fired too. It all added up to a spectacle that was so obvious, so easily recognizable as state repression; an assault that looked so much like “dictator stuff” to even casual observers that it sparked a rather basic response in people: That’s not ok.</p><p><strong>Internal dissent</strong></p><p>One of the biggest questions about the MAGA movement has been: Who would be in charge once they take power? Would the different factions – the “America First” nativists, the Christian nationalists, the pseudo-populist National Conservatives, the feudal tech right – get along and be able to cooperate within the regime? Or would their infighting and rivalries constitute a serious impediment to Trumpist rule?</p><p>The latter assumption got a big boost just weeks before Trump was set to take power when two of the defining Trumpist factions got into what was quickly dubbed the “MAGA civil war.” Remember <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/jan/12/steve-bannon-calls-elon-musk-racist">Steve Bannon going after Musk</a> and MAGA activists like Laura Loomer raging against the tech oligarchs? In a narrow sense, <a href="https://prospect.org/labor/2025-01-02-president-musk-american-workers-h1b-visas/">they quarreled over work visas</a>. It was an interesting window into two different conceptions of the future: America First white Christian ethno-nationalism vs tech feudalism. The rightwing tech lords maintained they should have unfettered access to cheap labor – if that brings a few brown people into the country, who cares? The tech right, to be clear, aren’t any less racist than the MAGA nativists. They are eugenicists who strongly believe in racialized and gendered hierarchies. But they aren’t quite as focused on the nation as the container for their eugenicist dystopia – at the very least, they believe the nation must make allowances for their business interests. Musk is not generally opposed to foreigners being here working for him for little money and with little rights; he is opposed to any political project of egalitarianism.</p><p>In that sense, the MAGA civil war was the public manifestation of real differences and friction. It was therefore reasonable to assume the Trump regime wouldn’t be able to keep everyone happy. Who would get their way? Who would have to take a step back? Who would be sidelined?</p><p>But since Trump took power, the answer, for the most part, has been: They all get to enact their agenda and act out their fever dreams. All at the same time. To some extent, this is a dynamic that often characterizes authoritarian regimes: They integrate different factions via escalation – by ramping up the fearmongering against a real or perceived enemy, for instance, and by channeling all internal discontent into aggression towards that enemy. We are seeing a version of that now. How do you keep the different factions on the MAGA right from turning on each other? You give them all the green light to go berserk on the system. So far, this has worked – in the sense that is has resulted in a sometimes chaotic, but overall comprehensive assault on the constitutional order. I don’t think, however, any of this is sustainable as a governing strategy – or even as a long-term strategy to integrate the different MAGA factions. It works only as long as they all feel a sense of radical excitement and euphoria. But the insurgency will inevitably slow down, there already are setbacks. MAGA is not a monolith, the differences between the different factions are real. The more the revolutionary zeal tires out, the more they will be reminded of those differences. </p><p>There is, moreover, internal dissent in the MAGA camp not only between different ideological factions – but also within and across the factions: Between those who believe a certain level of restraint is still necessary, even in the face of resistance vs those who would rather move to openly tearing down whatever is left of the system immediately. If you listen to Stephen Miller ranting, you know he wants to ignore the courts entirely and is frustrated the administration is still participating in the judicial process at all: Sending lawyers to argue in court, appealing to the Supreme Court… thereby acknowledging some legitimacy of the process. The administration has certainly flirted with ignoring the courts entirely, they have argued they would have the right to do so because of what they call their “mandate” to implement the “will of the people.” But they haven’t really pulled the trigger yet.</p><p>Or take the government shutdown. Wouldn’t it be the “smart” move to assume the role of the benevolent dictator: Dissolve Congress, address the people directly to tell them the system is failing them, but Trump, the tribune of the people, will take care of their needs? Why not print the money necessary to buy the people’s affection? I am perhaps being facetious a little bit. But the fact is that the administration is playing what might be called constitutional hardball in the shutdown fight (just as the opposition is); it is not, however, moving entirely past the constitutional system.</p><p><strong>The realities of the political system</strong></p><p>The shutdown fight is a good example of how something resembling the rules of “normal” politics still applies in certain areas. Conventional wisdom and previous experience would have predicted that the government takes the bulk of the blame in case of a shutdown. And that is exactly how this has played out so far, with <a href="https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/elections/poll-frustration-trump-gives-democrats-opening-year-midterms-rcna240551">most people blaming Republicans</a> rather than Democrats. </p><p>The shutdown fight has also demonstrated where the limits of the authoritarian assault on the modern state, at least for now, lie in financial terms. You’ll recall that in late October, Trump announced he was using a <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/oct/25/timothy-mellon-donor-military-pay-shutdown">$130 million donation</a> from a supporter to pay the troops during the shutdown. I don’t want to downplay how illegal and dangerous this is: It would be exactly the type of dictator-bypasses-the-system move that I discussed earlier. But the reality is that $130 million simply isn’t going to get them very far. For the fiscal year 2025, the Department of Defense requested a budget of almost $850 billion. In the last fiscal year, the federal government spent over $7 trillion dollars in total. No amount of private donor wealth can replace this type of public funding.</p><p><strong>Civil society between protest and acquiescence</strong></p><p>How has U.S. civic society responded to the authoritarian assault? Once again, the picture is not fully conclusive, but worrisome. The good news first: No matter how many times you’ll hear people ask: “Why are there no protests?”, no matter how much the <a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/fe5acc52-4f95-444f-9a11-f3cd6d72cfc2"><em>New York Times</em> may want to downplay</a> mass mobilization against Trump, there are protests, and they are more numerous and more sustained than during the first Trump presidency. The latest “No Kings” was the largest single-day protest in recent U.S. history! There is this <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2025/feb/13/donald-trump-resistance-protest-democrats">myth of widespread lethargy in the population</a>: It was propagated very early on in Trump’s second term, and it was mostly a narrative intended to indict the liberal “resistance” which had supposedly amounted to nothing in Trump’s first presidency and had therefore exhausted itself before he even got back into the White House.</p><p>But the really concerning tendencies are to be found elsewhere. A major factor why most <a href="https://www.foreignaffairs.com/united-states/path-american-authoritarianism-trump">academic observers who study authoritarianism</a> in an internationally comparative perspective assumed that US democracy would prove resilient, relatively speaking, was the idea that American civic institutions had more time to develop and civil society actors have a lot more resources at their disposal than, for instance, in post-communist Eastern Europe. But if the elites in charge of those institutions aren’t willing to even put up a proper fight, then how much does it really take to bring the system down? No, not all universities have surrendered like Columbia, not all media institutions have chosen complicity like the Washington Post or CBS. But the accommodationist mindset has been pervasive, making it dangerously easy for the Trumpists to get closer to consolidating authoritarian rule.</p><p><strong>Pathways towards dictatorship</strong></p><p>What does all this add up to? Unfortunately, I find it easier to chart a concrete path towards a complete breakdown of the constitutional order than to envision a democratic turnaround. The Trumpists have shown their hands – we already know the strategy they want to pursue. First of all: Escalate the conflict in the streets, create pretext to declare ever more emergencies, use emergency powers to move against the opposition. That is one major goal of the militarization of American cities: Create situations that are likely to result in violent escalation sooner or later. When those who are controlling the levers of state power are itching for violence, how long until mass violence follows? Secondly: Escalate the <a href="https://www.pbump.net/o/the-threat-to-elections-heats-up/">attack on the election system</a>, making the Big Lie the law of the land in time for the 2026 midterms and especially the 2028 presidential election. Finally: Follow through with the criminalization of all political opposition and societal dissent for which the Trumpists have already given themselves the pseudo-legal basis with the presidential <a href="https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/09/designating-antifa-as-a-domestic-terrorist-organization/">executive order</a> declaring Antifa a “domestic terrorist organization” and the <a href="https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/09/countering-domestic-terrorism-and-organized-political-violence/">National Security Presidential Memorandum 7</a> (NSPM-7) on “Countering Domestic Terrorism and Organized Political Violence” – both instruments widening the definition of leftwing “domestic terrorism” so much that it would potentially allow the state to persecute any act of resistance or disobedience as such.</p><p>And yet, as acutely dangerous as the situation is, the outcome remains undetermined. Let’s not forget that the unprecedentedly unpopular president is currently mired in a government shutdown that the majority of the population blames on his party; MAGA’s leaders have so far not been able to bridge the gap between their authoritarian assertions and the complicated political and societal reality they are facing. We don’t know what will happen next. I agree that assessment is frustrating, but it is, to me, the most adequate diagnosis for the current situation. An authoritarian, fascistic movement controls the government; they are trying – and to some extent succeeding – to build an authoritarian state; but they have not been able to extend authoritarian rule across society. A system that is democratic no more, but also not a consolidated autocratic regime yet.</p><p>The political conflict isn’t over, nor is democracy’s fate sealed for good. It is the openness of the current situation with which we need to grapple in earnest. In a stable democracy, the range of plausible outcomes for the near future should be narrow. But in America, it now includes, on one end of the spectrum, a democratic turnaround – and on the other, a complete democratic breakdown and full-blown authoritarian rule.</p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/21880233-f204-4b87-9733-54d91cbcf247/uploads/images/jqryu6yvjc/Official_Presidential_Portrait_of_President_Donald_J._Trump_(2025)_(3x4_close_cropped).png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/21880233-f204-4b87-9733-54d91cbcf247</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">21880233-f204-4b87-9733-54d91cbcf247</guid>
      <pubDate>Tue, 04 Nov 2025 00:13:43 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[A Constant Torrent of Authoritarian Arrogance, Corruption, Complicity]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[American politics is an exasperating, frenzied, and acutely dangerous mess. Let’s sort through the events of the past week to separate what matters from what does not.]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h1>A Constant Torrent of Authoritarian Arrogance, Corruption, and Complicity</h1><p><strong>American politics is an exasperating, frenzied, and acutely dangerous mess. Let’s sort through the events of the past week to separate what matters from what does not.</strong></p><p>By Thomas Zimmer, October 26, 2025</p><figure><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/10/22/us/politics/east-wing-white-house-demolition-trump.html"><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/fe5acc52-4f95-444f-9a11-f3cd6d72cfc2/uploads/images/rcy7jympkr/0146DACC-5A56-493D-84E7-40D761941515_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/></a><figcaption>The east wing of the White House, demolished – credit: Alex Kent for The New York Times</figcaption></figure><p><em>Democracy Americana looks a little different now! But no worries, nothing else has changed. It was just time to update the graphics. New look, same focus: The ongoing conflict over how much democracy, and for whom, there should be in America. Thank you for reading!</em></p><p>It’s an indication of how bad things are in America that we never get to dwell on anything. Millions took to the streets to protest the authoritarian assault of the Trumpist government last weekend. But the discourse quickly moved on. As the new week began, Trump started tearing down the east wing of the White House. He is now also collecting bribes he wants to use to <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/oct/26/trump-military-pay-government-shutdown">pay the military during the shutdown</a>, which is not only illegal, but also incredibly dangerous: The president is attempting to privatize the armed forces he has instructed to go after the “enemy within” – what could go wrong! The shutdown, lest we forget, is still going on, providing the pretext for an escalating sabotage of the modern state. Meanwhile, every day brings more images of people being <a href="https://www.propublica.org/article/immigration-dhs-american-citizens-arrested-detained-against-will">abducted and citizens being harassed</a> by masked agents of the state – fascistic goons, enabled by the authoritarian regime in power to go on a lawless rampage across the country. I had to look it up: It has only been ten days since the Supreme Court heard arguments in <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2025/oct/16/supreme-court-voting-rights-act">Louisiana v Callais</a>, the case the rightwing majority will likely use to nullify whatever is left of the 1965 Voting Rights Act. That feels like an eternity ago. So much is happening, on so many levels – even though this is literally my job, meaning I get to spend all day on this, attempting to keep up with U.S. politics often feels overwhelming.</p><p><em>Want to support my work? Consider becoming a paid member of Democracy Americana:</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p>I have been asking myself what I can do to help provide orientation, a sense of the big picture. As you know, here at Democracy Americana, I publish long-form essays that combine political analysis and historical perspective to explore the political conflict and situate it in the broader context of democracy’s contested history. But these pieces take time to research and write – they are generally a little more detached from the news and the day-to-day barrage with which we are being confronted. Therefore, I want to complement these deep dives with pieces that are a little quicker and nimbler, more geared towards commenting on the events as they unfold, intended less as an exhaustive exploration and more as a diary of sorts.</p><p>Today I am starting what will hopefully be a regular feature going forward: I want to sort through the frenzy of the past week, try to draw connections, assign meaning, provide context and hopefully orientation. If nothing else, it is my attempt to bear witness and perhaps create, over time, a record of our extraordinary moment. I hope it will help myself and my readers get some solid ground under our feet, allow us to anchor our sense of what is happening, maybe give ourselves something to look back at a month from now, six months, a year, and compare: What did we see clearly, what did we miss? It will never be a comprehensive list, obviously. Think of it as a selective chronicle, a reflection on what I believe deserves our attention, and perhaps an attempt to discern that which is significant amidst a whole lot of noise and fury.</p><p>In this first installment of what I tentatively call “For the Record”: The <em>New York Times</em> did not think the No Kings protests were all that significant – which is indicative of how much mainstream institutions have bought into the idea that only Trump and his supporters represent “real America”; Trump is demolishing the White House – which is far from the worst thing this regime is doing, yet significant nonetheless as it really captures Trump’s authoritarian pretensions; and finally, some thoughts on why the pervasive idea that Trump somehow deserves deference for what he is doing because that’s what “people voted for” gets the idea of democracy all wrong and merely perpetuates the Trumpist claim that they have a “mandate” to tear down the Republic.</p><p> </p><p><strong>According to the New York Times, only MAGA gets to represent “the people”</strong></p><p>As you may recall, about seven million people joined the No Kings protests last week, united in opposition to Trump’s authoritarian assault. It was the largest single-day protest since at least the early 1970s. That sounds like a pretty big deal, doesn’t it? Well, it turns out the nation’s paper of record disagrees. Remarkably, the <em>New York Times</em> decided the protests did not deserve to be featured prominently <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/smotus.bsky.social/post/3m3l3hccsms2i">on their home page</a> the day after and generally provided <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/larryglickman.bsky.social/post/3m3mr2kd7t22t">very little coverage</a>.</p><p>Before you say: “Who cares about the New York Times?”, remember that a lot of people, for better or worse, very much do. Its impact goes far beyond those who are subscribed or actively read it. Among its audience are a lot of people in positions to influence the interpretations and perceptions of others around them. And not just in the United States: In almost every interview I have done with international media (and it’s been a few this year!), I was asked to explain why there are, supposedly, no protests? Just this past week, right after No Kings last Saturday, I was asked some version of “Where are the protests?” in three separate conversations with German media. I guarantee you that the number one source of information, certainly the most trusted one, for all of them is the <em>New York Times</em>. </p><p>The decision to not cover No Kings as an enormously significant event is, first and foremost, a drastic journalistic failure. I am not talking about the <em>Times</em> failing to defend democracy. I don’t even think we need them to join the resistance. We need them to do their jobs. At its core, journalism is the task to select, from the myriad events and developments, those which deserve the attention of the public and decide on a presentation and framing that best contribute to an adequate understanding of what is shaping the polity. By any reasonable standard, they failed to do that here. </p><p>This should have been an easy one: Largest protests in recent history, a massive mobilization against a government that had declared all forms of dissent illegitimate… So, what happened?</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/fe5acc52-4f95-444f-9a11-f3cd6d72cfc2">Continue reading on Steady</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/fe5acc52-4f95-444f-9a11-f3cd6d72cfc2/uploads/images/rcy7jympkr/0146DACC-5A56-493D-84E7-40D761941515_1_201_a.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/fe5acc52-4f95-444f-9a11-f3cd6d72cfc2</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">fe5acc52-4f95-444f-9a11-f3cd6d72cfc2</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 26 Oct 2025 17:47:33 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[America As No-Longer-Democracy and Not-Yet-Dictatorship]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Where does the country stand after the largest day of protest in U.S. history? Putting “No Kings” in perspective]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Where does the country stand after the largest day of protest in U.S. history? Putting “No Kings” in perspective</strong></p><p>By Thomas Zimmer, October 20, 2025</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/a40ac673-b42b-4108-9756-feeae62ca5e8">Listen on Steady</a></p><figure><a href="https://www.nokings.org/"><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/a40ac673-b42b-4108-9756-feeae62ca5e8/uploads/images/vqcitp2ajo/Screenshot_2025-10-20_at_11.36.47.png?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/></a><figcaption>One of the illustrations used by the organizers of No Kings, taken from their website – credit: https://www.nokings.org/</figcaption></figure><p>Something significant happened on Saturday. The No Kings protests brought about six to seven million people out into the streets, united in opposition to Donald Trump, in thousands of demonstrations across the country. It was likely the <a href="https://www.gelliottmorris.com/p/second-no-kings-day-protests-likely">largest day of protest</a> in U.S. history, surpassing even the first Women’s March of 2017.</p><p>The protests came after several weeks of the Trumpist government engaging in an all-out propaganda campaign to declare all dissent illegitimate and demonize all those on the “Left,” defined vaguely as anyone not on board with MAGA, as domestic terrorists or at least terrorism-adjacent. Yet when the day came, the authoritarian movement that controls the levers of state power and had preemptively declared the No Kings protests illegitimate and unacceptable did nothing.</p><p><em>Want to support my work? Consider becoming a paid member of Democracy Americana:</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p>Let’s remember how shrill and deranged the campaign to demonize the No Kings protests, which the Trumpists called the “Hate America Rally,” was. Just a few examples: On October 10, Kansas senator <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m2tvpocdyo2k">Roger Marshall</a> declared: “This will be a Soros paid-for protest for his professional protesters. The agitators show up. We’ll have to get the National Guard out. Hopefully it will be peaceful. I doubt it.” Speaker <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m2u3jlqqau2n">Mike Johnson</a> chimed in the same day: “This Hate America rally that they have coming up for October 18? The antifa crowd, the pro-Hamas crowd, and the Marxists, they’re all gonna gather on the Mall. It is an outrageous gathering for outrageous purposes.” And with that, everyone on the Right – Republican politicians, rightwing activists, the media machine – had received their marching orders. What followed was a barrage of these same themes and talking points. Majority whip <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m3ai46kmiz2q">Tom Emmer</a> (who, if you’ll recall, Trump didn’t want as Speaker in October 2023 because Emmer was considered too moderate – or, according to Trump, a <a href="https://www.politico.com/news/2023/10/24/i-killed-him-how-trump-torpedoed-tom-emmers-speaker-bid-00123329">“Globalist RINO”</a>) added: “Clearly, the Democrat Party of today is not your grandfather’s Democrat Party. They care about one thing and one thing only – appeasing the radical pro-terrorist wing of their party.” White House press secretary <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m3darcsygp2f">Karoline Leavitt</a>: “The Democrat Party’s main constituency is made up of Hamas terrorists, illegal aliens, and violent criminals.” And, just for good measure, <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m3fhcvlyvw2q">one more from Mike Johnson</a>, on the day before the protests: “We refer to it by its more accurate description: The Hate America Rally. You’re gonna bring together the Marxists, the socialists, the antifa advocates, the anarchists, and the pro-Hamas wing of the far-left Democrat Party. That is the modern Democratic Party.”</p><p>What stands out about this demonization campaign is how unhinged it was. This isn’t just a bit of “mean” spin, just politicians doing politics. It is entirely untethered from reality. There’s no measure of restraint at all. No trace of any residual sense of commitment to something even remotely recognizable as a shared democratic political culture.</p><p>But not only did it completely fail to keep anyone from taking to the streets. When millions came out, the regime and its supporters just had to take it. The National Guard wasn’t deployed to dissolve the protests; there was no significant disruption by paramilitaries. We didn’t see Republican politicians addressing large crowds of pro-MAGA counter-protesters – because there were none; hardly a word from anyone of consequence on the Right. Instead we got Trump posting some <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/socialistdogmom.bsky.social/post/3m3j6usmsf22e">AI-generated video</a> on social media depicting him piloting a fighter jet while wearing a crown, dumping feces on protesters from the air. Utterly pathetic.</p><p>So, had all this unhinged rhetoric from the Right just been empty posturing? Had they never really meant it? Or were they simply overwhelmed by the force of democratic dissent – a weak regime, incapable of backing up its threats with anything tangible? Was all the talk about authoritarianism therefore overblown and alarmist? Or is it, to take a very different side, naïve to assign so much significance to No Kings? Were the protests just an empty spectacle, facile and trite, something that allows mainstream liberals to feel good about themselves and normie Americans to rest easy while not actually changing a single thing about America’s predicament?</p><p>Let’s put the No Kings protests into perspective.</p><p><strong>The Trumpists definitely meant it</strong></p><p>When leading figures in MAGA world rage against “the Left,” there is always an element of posturing. Such are the incentives on the Right: If you want to get Trump’s attention, endear yourself with the rabid base, and be successful in the rightwing media landscape that monetizes fear, outrage, and anger, you must seek out a camera and find ever more aggressive ways to proudly declare how much you hate large swaths of the American population. It’s a perverse arms race with disastrous consequences for America’s political culture.</p><p>But when the leaders of the American Right talk about millions of their fellow citizens as the enemy within, they also mean it. Frankly, we’d be in a less dangerous situation if they were all just cynical opportunists. Does Mike Johnosn <em>really</em> believe the millions of people marching were all communists, socialists, and anarchists? To some extent, he’s just trying to attach a scary label to the protests that is intended to mark them as “Un-American.” But there is also a founding belief on the modern Right that all versions of “leftism” and liberalism are merely variants of the same fundamentally illegitimate political project of leveling hierarchies of race, gender, religion, or wealth. That is why they derided Martin Luther King Jr as a Communist, why segregationists in the 1950s protested the integration of schools in the South holding signs that read <a href="https://www.loc.gov/pictures/item/2021792152/">“Race Mixing is Communism.”</a> Similarly, as bizarre as it is for Karoline Leavitt to claim that “The Democrat Party’s main constituency is made up of Hamas terrorists, illegal aliens, and violent criminals”: The idea that Democratic governance is fundamentally illegitimate because the Democratic coalition is made up of people who don’t qualify as “real Americans” and therefore shouldn’t be allowed to exercise meaningful political influence is dogma on the Right. And finally, protesting Donald Trump and “hating America” really are the same in the MAGA imagination: The Trumpist claim to unquestioned dominance is built on the idea that Trump embodies the nation. Because he channels the will of “the people,” dissent is disloyal, protest is tantamount to treason and must not be tolerated.</p><p><em>Before you keep reading, can I bother you for a minute?</em></p><p><em>This is a free post I am making available to everyone. If you want to keep reading on a </em><strong><em>free subscription</em></strong><em>, I sincerely appreciate your time and effort engaging with my work! Please share it widely to help me reach new readers.</em></p><p><em>And if you can, please consider becoming a </em><strong><em>paid member</em></strong><em>: As a member, you will gain access to additional benefits – including additional essays, as I start alternating between free posts, like this one here, and pieces reserved for paid members.</em></p><p><em>Most importantly, Democracy Americana is a publication solely funded by readers and my main source of income as an independent writer. I rely on your support and generosity to make this work possible. And I am very grateful.</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><strong>America as no-longer-democracy and not-yet-dictatorship</strong></p><p>If the Trumpists really meant it, but still didn’t dare to do anything about these protests, what does that say about the state of American politics and the struggle between democracy and authoritarianism? We are likely in for another round of grand proclamations: No Kings as definitive proof that the Trumpists are failing to consolidate authoritarian power! The democratic forces have turned the tide!</p><p>Let’s be a little more cautious and remember what’s happened since the first No Kings protests in June – not quite as big as the second round, but still around five million people on what is now the third-largest day of protests in recent U.S. history. And on Trump’s birthday, nonetheless, making his lame attempt at celebrating with a military parade in the nation’s capital look utterly pathetic in comparison. </p><p>But I find it really difficult to argue that we are in a less dangerous place now than four months ago. On the contrary, the Tumpists have since escalated the militarization of the political conflict. In several cities, people now live in a police state, confronted with rampant state terror carried out by masked agents accountable solely to Trump. The regime is also currently ramping up its assault on the modern state, using the shutdown as a pretext. And the<strong> </strong>“leftwing domestic terrorism” chimera remains immensely dangerous. The Trumpists have been laying the pseudo-legal groundwork for a drastic crackdown. On September 22, Trump signed an <a href="https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/09/designating-antifa-as-a-domestic-terrorist-organization/">executive order</a> designating “Antifa” as a “domestic terrorist organization.” This is rather bizarre on several levels. To start with, Antifa is not actually an organization, but a small movement with a decentralized structure consisting of loosely affiliated groups. There also exists no legal authority to designate groups as “domestic terrorist organizations.” But arguing the facts is really beside the point entirely: The Trumpists want to use “Antifa” as a master signifier for everything and everyone who dares to dissent – a “leftist” bogeyman that can be invoked to whip up the rightwing base. There is no broad “Antifa” threat – but there is now an “Antifa” Executive Order that is supposed to function as a flexible instrument to go after the “enemy within.”</p><p>Just three days later, on September 25, Trump issued <a href="https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/09/countering-domestic-terrorism-and-organized-political-violence/">National Security Presidential Memorandum 7</a> (NSPM-7) on “Countering Domestic Terrorism and Organized Political Violence” – which is intended to serve in exactly the same way. It is a breathtakingly authoritarian document. And it might just be the most dangerous step the regime has taken so far. The memo instructs the entire machinery of the federal government to employ an incredibly expansive definition of “domestic terrorism” to go after any organization or individual associated with “the Left.” It opens the door for virtually anyone in the United States – certainly anyone who is critical of Trump – to be harassed by the state as a domestic terrorist. It employs a definition of “domestic terrorism” that is entirely directed against the bizarre phantasma of “the Left” as it exists in the feverish mind of someone like Stephen Miller – even going so far as to explicitly declare all “activities under the umbrella of self-described ‘anti-fascism’” as likely to be terroristic. Meanwhile, the memo widens the definition so much – including “organized doxing campaigns, swatting, rioting, looting, trespass, assault, destruction of property, threats of violence, and civil disorder” – that it becomes difficult to identify what act of resistance or disobedience the state <em>couldn’t</em> persecute as “domestic terrorism.” </p><p>Will they actually follow through on any of this? We don’t know. But let’s assume they will try. On October 7, Missouri senator Eric Schmitt flat-out <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m2mm47j3yb2s">declared</a>: “We need a cleansing here. Let’s just be truthful about what’s happening. This left-wing political violence is not a both sides thing. It’s not.” The next day, secretary of homeland security Kristi Noem <a href="https://x.com/BulwarkOnline/status/1976014005870190897">professed</a> her desire to “route them out and eliminate them from the existence of American society.” She was referring to “Antifa,” which “is just as sophisticated as MS-13, as TDA, as ISIS, as Hezbollah, as Hamas, as all of them. They are just as dangerous.” Attorney general <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m2pg2yakmu2e">Pam Bondi</a> added: “Just like we did with cartels, we are going to take the same approach, President Trump, with antifa – destroy the entire organization from top to bottom. We are going to take them apart.”</p><p>Any form of dissent is now Antifa, and Antifa is like a foreign terrorist organization… It is not hard to see where this <em>could</em> be going, where the Trumpists want this to go. At the same time, the gulf between these authoritarian aspirations and violent desires on the one hand and the realities of a complex political system coupled with a population that predominantly rejects Trumpist dictatorship remains vast. I’ll repeat my contention that binary categories of Trump “winning vs losing” – or the regime being “weak vs strong” – are not particularly helpful right now. They tend to reproduce mood swings more than they help generate plausible analysis. Every Trumpian embarrassment is destined to cause a new round of “Trump is weak, he is losing” pieces; every authoritarian escalation is accompanied by a chorus of “Democracy is dead, Trump won” post-mortems. Better to grapple with the murkiness of this moment: A staunchly authoritarian movement is in power, but they haven’t been able to install a consolidated autocracy yet.</p><p><strong>Why No Kings matters</strong></p><p>The No Kings protests did not change anything in any immediate, tangible way. Critics mostly in some corners on the Left therefore tend to discard them as purely symbolic – a tame gathering of normie America that won’t affect the status quo, an inadequate response to the moment. Such critique misreads the political conflict. Yes, No Kings was a highly symbolic affair. But that doesn’t relegate the protests to the status of an ephemeral blip. I believe they mattered for three main reasons. </p><p>First of all, the Trumpists’ key assertion is that they represent “real America,” “authentic America,” that the November election was a referendum that installed not just a president, but an elected sovereign whose authority transcends precedent, the law, and even the foundations of democratic self-government. All opposition is illegitimate, therefore. If you oppose Trump, you stand outside the boundaries of who gets to belong. These assertions are shared not just by the MAGA coalition. Unfortunately, they have also long influenced the response to the Trumpist assault from both the nominal opposition party and the major institutions of American life. This has been Trump’s superpower for a long time, and especially since the last election: So many of mainstream America’s leading voices and most influential elites have insisted on treating him like he really is the tribune of the people, a leader with a broad mandate to implement his agenda who must be given wide latitude as the will of the true people must not be impeded. Anything that helps to dispel such notions – like seven million people marching in the streets when we have never seen anything remotely close from MAGA America – matters.</p><p>Secondly, I believe a broad coalition – a popular front of sorts, if you will – is needed to defeat Trumpist authoritarianism. Since 2016, the attempts to build such an anti-MAGA coalition from across the political spectrum have come under the banner of “defending democracy.” Such efforts, while occasionally very successful, have been hampered by two things: “Democracy” is a rather abstract concept that, for many people, doesn’t necessarily have a lot of tangible meaning and therefore the call to “defend” it might not have the desired mobilizing effect. And there is also a fundamental disagreement at the heart of this coalition over what the purpose of “defending democracy” should actually be: Is this supposed to be a truly transformative project aiming to propel the nation forward towards the kind of egalitarian pluralism it has often promised, but never achieved? Or a purely restorative endeavor, designed to take us back to the pre-2016 status quo ante? I firmly believe a mere restoration would be madness, as it would recreate the conditions that gave rise to Trumpism in the first place. But the point is, this conflict is real, and it can be hard to reconcile these positions. This is where the protests can have an impact. In thousands of places, Americans came together with their neighbors in a communal effort that created a shared experience beyond strategic or ideological disagreement. I choose to believe this can sustain, re-energize, and perhaps even ignite for the first time a resilient democratic culture. </p><p>Finally, the No Kings protests were also part of a much-needed effort to, as cringe as that may sound, reclaim patriotism from the Right. Too long have rightwingers been allowed to drape their grievances and bigotries in the nation’s collective symbols, to call on the patriotic mythology of the nation in order to pretend that their desire to dominate is somehow an expression of the timeless essence of the nation. The American “Left,” very broadly defined, has struggled to contest this terrain. I very much count myself among those who are – rightfully, I believe! – wary of any political project that wraps itself in the flag, of anything that could, perhaps even unwittingly, help sanitize the nation’s history and legitimize the destructive forces of nationalism. But this reluctance, the tendency to abdicate and surrender the field of patriotism to the Right has allowed a bunch of ethno-nationalist extremists to present themselves as the guardians of the national mythos. This is where the slogan “No Kings,” in all its simplicity, is effective. It is a reference to a founding myth – but mobilized in defense of democratic self-government; not in service of perpetuating lazy, self-satisfied exceptionalist ideas but as an affirmation of democratic aspirations, even if America has certainly never fully lived up to them yet.</p><p>This is also where the “normie” character of the No Kings protests becomes an asset. Too long have rightwingers been allowed to present themselves as “real Americans” and deride everyone who dares to dissent as “abnormal.” But all (small-d) democrats in America must dispute and reject this claim of “real American” white Christian conservative “normalcy,” and with it the Right’s justification for minority rule. The point is to reclaim and redefine what counts as “normal” in America – to replace a repressive norm of white Christian patriarchal dominance with a promise that this should be a country where the expected norm is an acceptance of pluralism and diversity in all spheres of life. It is time for (small-d) democrats to assert their right to define the boundaries of normalcy – and their claim to be defending the nation’s true ideals against the reactionary assault. The chasm between the traditional Republican assertion of representing “normal” America and the assortment of extremists, fraudsters, and weirdos in positions of influence and power has become brutally stark. It is time to pounce. Will it work? I don’t know. But it is certainly better than preemptively conceding ground to the Right’s claims that they deserve disproportionate power as representatives of “real” America.</p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/a40ac673-b42b-4108-9756-feeae62ca5e8/uploads/images/vqcitp2ajo/Screenshot_2025-10-20_at_11.36.47.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/a40ac673-b42b-4108-9756-feeae62ca5e8</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">a40ac673-b42b-4108-9756-feeae62ca5e8</guid>
      <pubDate>Mon, 20 Oct 2025 12:28:12 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[We need to talk about Russell Vought – But Properly]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Why certain mainstream outlets insist on sanitizing Vought as a devout “small government” conservative – and what actually animates his war against pluralistic democracy]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong>Why certain mainstream outlets insist on sanitizing Vought as a devout “small government” conservative – and what actually animates his war against pluralistic democracy</strong></h4><p>By <a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/about#js-publication_plans">Thomas Zimmer</a>, Oct. 09, 2025</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/08ca53da-bb0f-4eb4-aa08-c0648d2d9477">Listen on Steady</a></p><figure><a href="https://www.c-span.org/program/senate-committee/white-house-budget-director-nominee-russell-vought-testifies-at-confirmation-hearing/654448"><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/08ca53da-bb0f-4eb4-aa08-c0648d2d9477/uploads/images/jdyria6vob/BD7A5C1A-0AA9-4808-9C8E-E1CFA34E1424_1_201_a.png?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/></a><figcaption>Russell Vought during Senate confirmation hearing in January 2025 – credit: C-SPAN video</figcaption></figure><p><em>Before we get into it, can I bother you for a minute?</em></p><p><em>This is a free post I am making available to everyone. If you want essays like this delivered directly to your email inbox, please subscribe.</em></p><p><em>If you already are a subscriber and want to keep reading on a </em><strong><em>free subscription</em></strong><em>, I sincerely appreciate your time and effort engaging with my work! Please share it widely to help me reach new readers.</em></p><p><em>And if you can, please consider becoming a </em><strong><em>paid member</em></strong><em>: Democracy Americana is a publication solely funded by readers. As a member, you will also gain access to additional benefits – including additional essays, as I start alternating between free posts, like this one here, and pieces reserved for paid members.</em></p><p><em>As an independent writer, I fully rely on your support and generosity to make this work possible. And I am very grateful.</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p>Russell Vought is currently receiving a lot of public attention. You watch the news, or you open a newspaper, there is a decent chance right now that Donald Trump’s Director of the Office of Management and Budget is staring at you; you listen to a politics podcast, and there he is again. In the past ten days or so, there has been <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xfmOYypLZ4U">news report</a> after <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F9vIs1uzYsY">news report</a>: Who is Russell Vought? The <em>New York Times</em> published a <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/09/29/us/politics/russell-vought-trump-budget.html">long profile</a>, then followed that up with a whole episode on Vought in their main podcast <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/10/06/podcasts/the-daily/government-shutdown-vought.html">The Daily</a>, just days after <em>The New Yorker’s</em> <a href="https://www.newyorker.com/podcast/political-scene/how-russell-vought-broke-the-us-government">The Political Scene</a> podcast had done the same. International audiences are also told they should know about this man: The British <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c059ydyqe19o">BBC</a> has profiled him this week, so have <a href="https://www.morgenpost.de/politik/article410139670/shutdown-nur-vorgeschmack-der-architekt-von-trumps-autokratie.html">German newspapers</a>.</p><p>At first sight, it is perhaps surprising that a man who presents as a rather boring political operative and runs a rather obscure agency is being so heavily scrutinized. And the unfortunate reality is that a lot of the Vought discourse is just people repeating the same few lines about him over and over, providing abstracts of abstracts that are already out there. There is also something uncomfortable and slightly problematic about focusing on this one figure so much. It inevitably serves to elevate him in ways the Trumpists might enjoy: I am sure Russell Vought likes the idea that he could be the Left’s bogeyman.</p><p>Some of you will know that I say this having contributed myself, in whatever small measure, to focusing public attention on Vought. I initially wrote a very <a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/754b715c-48b7-4419-9b63-dbc5691fdd56">long profile here on Democracy Americana</a> focusing on his worldview and the ideological underpinnings of what he does last November; I then wrote an updated profile for German newspaper <a href="https://www.zeit.de/kultur/2025-09/russell-vought-donald-trump-office-of-management-and-budget-republikaner">Die Zeit</a> just a few weeks ago. And as a baseline, I think it continues to be a good thing that the broader public is paying attention to this man. He is a key figure in the world of Trumpism, with a rare – and dangerous – combination of ideological zeal and operative competence. As OMB Director, he is undoubtedly in a crucial position right now, determined to use the shutdown as pretext for escalating his assault on the modern state. Few people in this regime have as much power to cause – and are causing – as much harm as Vought.</p><p>However, the picture of Vought that is being presented in major mainstream outlets is, unfortunately, severely flawed and misleading in ways that will only serve the regime. I want to focus on The Daily, the news podcast produced by <em>The New York Times</em> that runs five days a week, as an instructive example. The Daily matters because, like it or not, that’s where literally millions of people get their news explained every day. It is easily one of the handful of most downloaded podcasts in the United States and around the world – and therefore, without exaggeration, one of the most influential political formats in existence. Even here in Germany, the first and often only contact people have with U.S. politics comes through The Daily (as a matter of fact, it was the editor of a German newspaper who alerted me to their episode on Vought). On October 6, The Daily published “The ‘Grim Reaper’ of the Government Shutdown” – a show entirely dedicated to Vought. Host Natalie Kitroeff spoke to Coral Davenport, Washington correspondent for the <em>New York Times</em>, who says she spent “weeks and weeks” reporting on Vought, interviewing 30 to 40 people, and also wrote <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/09/29/us/politics/russell-vought-trump-budget.html">a profile</a> the <em>Times</em> had published about a week before the podcast aired. </p><p>So, what does the <em>New York Times’</em> flagship podcast tell its millions of listeners about Russell Vought? They present him as a devout Christian with an incredible work ethic who grew up with parents struggling with the burdens placed upon them by an overbearing state and channeled that experience into working tirelessly to help the American people; a proper “small government” conservative who, while perhaps being a bit radical in his approach sometimes, loves the free market and therefore tries to rein in the sprawling government bureaucracy. Remarkably, I don’t think there is anything in The Daily’s profile that Vought himself wouldn’t agree with. They are accepting at face value everything Vought claims, resulting in a portrait of Vought that must be almost entirely in line with the regime’s preferred version of who he is and what he does.</p><p>The Daily’s bizarrely credulous approach to Vought matters because it is indicative of a much broader tendency to normalize the assault on the modern state, democratic self-government, and the constitutional order – to sanitize those who are responsible for it and the extreme ideas that are animating them. Russell Vought embodies the radicalization of the conservative movement; his example captures how far removed from democratic politics the Trumpist Right is. Vought is convinced to be fighting a noble war against a vast leftist conspiracy that has supposedly taken over the country and is destroying the nation. He dreams of a comprehensive “counter-revolution” and believes that <em>any</em> measure, regardless of how extreme, is justified in this struggle against the “leftist” enemy. But if you only listened to The Daily, you wouldn’t get any of that.</p><p>Let’s dive into what The Daily gets so wrong and why, how it is indicative of certain blind spots and fallacies that characterize the broader political discourse, and what we actually need to understand about Russell Vought. </p><p><strong>“A true believer” – but in what?</strong></p><p>“He is such a true believer,” the <em>New York Times</em> reporter says about Vought. And that’s actually a good start if we want to understand what animates a man who is entirely convinced that what he does is good and noble. But the question must be: A “true believer” in what?</p><p>The Daily offers two answers – focusing on one, only touching on another in passing. They put the emphasis firmly on Vought as a small-government conservative who loves the free market and is driven by the idea of cutting public spending in order to free “the people” from an overbearing state. That is his first belief, and he came to it, we are told, very early on, growing up in a blue-collar household: “I think he really genuinely sees the burden of paying for taxes and government as weighing so heavily on families like his own.”</p><p>We are also told that Vought is very religious – a devout Christian who “takes his faith really seriously.” And here we quickly arrive at a core problem with how The Daily approaches Vought. What holds these two beliefs – the desire to cut public spending, the free-market fundamentalism on one side, and the Christian faith on the other – together? It is certainly true that, in today’s political reality in the United States, the two often find themselves in a coalition; but is it not worth asking why a pious man would dream of slashing welfare programs and firing government workers? Why he would be so obsessed with the free market that he “even named his dog Milton for Milton Friedman”? The Daily’s host at least clocks one thing as slightly odd: Isn’t his devotion to Trump a little weird, considering that – amongst other things, one might add – the President “has a foul mouth,” as the NYT reporter admits, while Vought won’t ever curse? But all we get in response is: “I think just culturally, there was some discomfort with that fit.” And that’s it, let’s move on.</p><p>That’s indicative of what we are getting here. For the <em>Times</em>, presenting Vought as a “true believer” just means: He is a devout Christian who really believes in “small government” and has been working towards achieving his goal for a long time. </p><p>This perspective is useful as a reminder that Trumpism didn’t fall out of the sky and MAGA isn’t a complete aberration from some noble conservatism that came before. Vought’s professional biography points to the many ways in which Trumpism builds on long-standing tendencies and impulses on the Right and emerged from within the rightwing coalition. In many ways, Vought, 49 years old, has had a fairly “normal” path as a career operative who has held positions at almost every level inside and around the Republican Party in Washington, DC. Over the course of about two decades, he went from low-level staffer to high-level éminence grise; he was a congressional aide, a part of the think tank and lobbying machine, a campaigner, a member of the Trump administration.</p><p>But emphasizing <em>only</em> this part of the story can easily make it sound like nothing has changed on the Right or within the Republican Party. And that’s not true either. We also need to understand the significant radicalization that has shaped today’s Right and grapple with a fairly recent trajectory: From at least a rhetorical commitment to free-market, small-government libertarianism to embracing the rightwing populist culture war, and from at least pretending to be committed to restraining governmental power to aggressively mobilizing the coercive powers of the state to roll back pluralism.</p><p>The problem with the way The Daily tells the story is this: They offer absolutely no answer to why Vought and his fellow Trumpist leaders are so angry and aggrieved – how they are giving themselves permission to embrace authoritarianism and extremism?</p><p>Instead, one of the most influential political platforms in the world chooses to perpetuate what is perhaps the number one fallacy about the modern Right: That this is all about “small government.”</p><p>Small government, governmental restraint to guarantee individual liberty and freedom, to keep the state out of people’s private lives, to make sure it doesn’t meddle with private business. Such ideas have, at least rhetorically, always been a key element of the modern conservative political identity. But taking these claims at face value never led to a plausible interpretation. What emerged as the modern conservative political project in the middle decades of the twentieth century was in many ways defined by an alliance between two distinct factions. One the one hand, there were reactionary traditionalists and, especially from the 1970s onwards, a newly mobilized Religious Right. On the other, there were market-fundamentalist libertarian factions, staunchly opposed to the New Deal state and the reformulation of liberalism into a governing philosophy that embraced an active role for the state in creating the kinds of conditions in which individuals would be protected from the worst excesses of capitalism and be enabled to thrive as equal citizens. What united the different factions of the newly formed “modern conservative” alliance was the fight against communism, socialism, liberalism – terms conservatives tended to use synonymously. More specifically, they were aligned in the fight against any attempt at leveling traditional hierarchies of wealth, race, gender, and religion. In the context of this broader struggle, they have always been comfortable with “big government” in certain areas, if it served to uphold the “natural order” and traditional hierarchies. This has found its most obvious expression in the drastic expansion of the law enforcement apparatus as part of a “law and order” politics since the 1970s.</p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><strong>It&#39;s not about “small government”</strong></p><p>The idea that a “small government” conservatism is animating today’s Trumpist Right is rather bizarre. And to their credit, the leaders of the MAGA coalition are quite open about what is really behind their assault on the modern state. Heritage Foundation president Kevin Roberts, for instance, in a truly revealing passage of his <a href="https://static.heritage.org/project2025/2025_MandateForLeadership_FULL.pdf">Foreword to the Project 2025 policy agenda</a>, stated that the project of “dismantling the administrative state” was not about the actual size of government at all. The goal was to cut “the secret lifeblood of the Great Awokening.” All the leftist subversion, Roberts was certain, was orchestrated and funded by the government. The goal, therefore, had to be to “bring the Administrative State to heel, and in the process defang and defund the woke culture warriors who have infiltrated every last institution in America.”</p><p>A vast conspiracy. Enemies everywhere. Un-American forces have overtaken “every last institution” and especially the state. Radical countermeasures are urgently needed. That is also the starting point for everything Vought does. His end goal is not, as The Daily claims, to “shrink the federal government”, he is not merely “deeply driven by fiscal austerity and cutting budgets.” He is less concerned about the actual size of government and more about cutting and curtailing the parts that he thinks are aiding “the Left” and its “subversive” aims. That’s what he means when he is talking about “dismantling the administrative state” – while simultaneously attempting to mobilize and weaponize the coercive powers of the state in order to use the vast machinery that is the U.S. government to impose a reactionary order on American society.</p><p>It would be one thing for the <em>New York Times</em> to miss this and get this wrong if Vought and his ilk were cunningly obscuring their true project. But Vought, in particular, fancies himself an intellectual leader, prompting him to constantly articulate the ideas that define the radical Right and animate its escalating assault on democratic pluralism.</p><p>A piece Vought published in September 2022 in <em>The American Mind</em>, the online magazine of the rabidly Trumpist Claremont Institute, offers perhaps the clearest insight into Vought’s worldview and his understanding of our particular moment in U.S. history. It’s titled: <a href="https://americanmind.org/salvo/renewing-american-purpose/">“Renewing American Purpose: Statesmanship in a Post-Constitutional Moment.”</a> In <a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/754b715c-48b7-4419-9b63-dbc5691fdd56">my profile of Vought</a> from last November, I tried to provide a detailed analysis and contextualization of what Vought outlined in there and where it sits in the intellectual history of the Right. The shorter version goes something like this:</p><p>Key to understanding Vought’s worldview is the idea that the constitutional order - and with it the “natural” order itself - has been destroyed: The revolution has already happened, “the Left” won. Therefore, conservatives categorically err when they try to preserve what is no more. Vought certainly sees himself in the modern conservative tradition, but he also disdains the conservative establishment for their inability to understand and act upon the radical demands of the moment. Power, Vought claims, now lies with a “permanent ruling class” of leftist elites who control all major institutions of American life and especially the “woke and weaponized” agencies of the state. In order to defeat them, conservatives must become “radical constitutionalists” - and take radical action. While Vought traces the “leftwing revolution” back a hundred years, to the progressive era, there is no question that the election of Barack Obama was a radicalizing moment for him and many key thinkers on the radical Right - as were the multiracial protests in the summer of 2020. Vought is convinced that America is facing an existential threat, a situation he has likened to 1776 and 1860: (Counter-) Revolution and total war, that is what America must face if it is to survive. Vought is therefore not interested in “normal” democratic politics: He seeks to “traumatize” civil servants, use the military to suppress protests, and sees Trump as an agent of God’s will.</p><p>The Daily explicitly references Vought’s idea of a “radical constitutionalism,” so we must assume the reporter was aware of and read this particular piece. Ignorance is not a good explanation for why we are nevertheless getting “devout Christian, small-government conservative” Vought in the profile. Then what is?</p><p><strong>Sanitizing Russell Vought and the Trumpist Right</strong></p><p>It is obvious how committed The Daily is to sanitizing Russell Vought – and the movement from which he emerged. In a revealing moment, the <em>New York Times</em> reporter describes the Tea Party as a manifestation of “this wave of intense fiscal conservatism, anti-government, sweeping through Washington.” But the Tea Party was animated mostly by racial resentment; Tea Partiers weren’t actually concerned about the absolute size of government - but about government supposedly letting the “wrong” people cut in line. Another example for how committed The Daily is to presenting a soberly respectable picture of Russell Vought is how they describe his relationship to Trump. We are given to understand that Vought may not be entirely comfortable with the President (remember: the foul mouth…) – but sees him “as someone who can help him realize this vision of much smaller government.” But Vought is quite a bit more enthusiastic in his devotion to Trump than what we are led to believe here. He is singularly focused on bending the entire machine to Trump’s will because he believes Trump is the nation’s last chance at survival – he is the leader of a revolutionary counter-offensive against the evil forces of “unnatural” leftism. Literally, in Vought’s words, “a gift of God.”</p><p>The Daily failing to properly describe the combination of religious devotion and authoritarian leader cult that informs Vought’s relationship with Trump points to another really glaring omission: They are not even mentioning Vought’s overt Christian nationalism. This, again, is quite the choice, considering that Vought himself has explicitly <a href="https://www.politico.com/news/2024/02/20/donald-trump-allies-christian-nationalism-00142086">described himself as a Christian nationalist</a>. That is also why Vought not particularly liking Trump’s “foul mouth,” as The Daily emphasized, is entirely irrelevant for their relationship. Christian nationalism is best described as a form of political identity that fuses a reactionary version of Christianity with aggressive ethno-nationalist sentiment. It is, more than anything else, defined by a sense of grievance – by a perception that “our” country (“real America”) is being taken away from “us” (white Christians). Much of Trump’s appeal to the base as well as to elites like Vought stems from the fact that he is consumed by this sense of grievance himself – that is the “authenticity” his followers sense and admire. He is aggrieved as a <em>white man</em> who is convinced he has been wronged as he is being denied the constant reverence and subservience to which he believes he is entitled. And Trump is always eager to emphasize that he is being wronged as a <em>white Christian</em> as well.</p><p><em>The New York Times</em> is unable and/or unwilling to unpack any of that. I believe that is indicative of a larger issue that is shaping their coverage of the Right (and that comes on top of the more obvious points that the <em>Times</em> wants to make money and some higher-ups are evidently quite comfortable with accommodating the regime): They don’t want to engage with what they see as unsavory ideology at all (as opposed to the kind of free-market fundamentalism that the mainstream discourse has long treated as not ideological). Because doing so would make it very hard to uphold the “normal politics” framework that defines much of mainstream political journalism in the United States: Both sides are roughly the same, and the overriding goal of the journalist is to provide “balanced” coverage from a “neutral” position in equidistance to either side. That framework is much easier to justify if you pretend to be dealing with “normal” politicians and operatives – as opposed to committed ideologues pursuing an extreme project.</p><p>Vought is “driven by radical ideological fire,” we are told towards the end. But The Daily never takes that idea seriously at all. Here, that is only meant to say: He really wants to shrink government. Vought’s notion of “radical constitutionalism” is mentioned as well – but it is presented as some kind of originalism applied to the structure of the federal government, as if Vought was just attempting to turn the clock back to the vision of the Founders: A small executive, no independent agencies. They are completely missing and/or obscuring what matters here. Vought’s ideology of “radical constitutionalism” captures the defining sensibility on the Trumpist Right: The “Left” has command of America, all that is noble has been destroyed, there is nothing left to conserve, therefore nothing short of a radical “counter-revolution” can now save the nation. </p><p>Too many mainstream journalists simply refuse to accept that they need to approach people like Vought as the leaders of a radicalizing authoritarian movement – as opposed to “normal” political operatives who can be understood and described with the vocabulary of “normal” politics, and within the boundaries that define the comfort zone for <em>New York Times</em> reporters.</p><p>This leads to some really bizarre distortions. Instead of a proper explanation for Vought’s radicalization, we are told that during the Biden years, the poor guy, heartbroken that he hadn’t been able to achieve his “small government” dreams, was “in the wilderness,” lonely and sad, and that’s what led to him “getting angry.” But Vought was not some geek who didn’t handle loneliness very well. He was a powerful operative throughout, always remaining in Trump’s orbit while also serving as one of the architects behind Project 2025. The main reason why he is so angry is that he is not just after political power in a narrow sense but obsessed with status and cultural domination. Like so many of MAGA’s leaders, he perceived the mass mobilization in the wake of the murder of George Floyd in the summer of 2020 as a radicalizing event because it seemed to prove that the forces of “leftist” pluralism had advanced to the point where they were redefining who and what counted as “real America.” But to Russell Vought, it is the prerogative of people who look like him and share his sensibilities to define the boundaries of who gets to belong, to have their own image reflected back at them in the public square.</p><p>It is October 2025, the assault on what is left of American democracy is escalating, and one of the <em>New York Times</em>’ most influential formats is still presenting one of the Trumpist regime’s leaders as a devout “small government” conservative with a great work ethic and a real conviction that he can help the American people best by “clearing out all the inefficiencies and streamlining the government.” The Daily makes Russell Vought sound entirely reasonable, and they even add more than a tinge of admiration by calling him a “consummate disciplined executor.” On this basis, most Americans would probably register Vought as a noble, or certainly respectable guy.</p><p>But there is nothing noble about what Vought is doing. He is a fully competent, utterly committed radical ideologue. He lusts for counter-revolution and radical measures. There is no line he doesn’t feel justified to cross. He does not talk about the conflict with “the Left” in the idiom of democratic politics, <a href="https://apnews.com/article/project-2025-russell-vought-trump-federal-government-38fc446832062e40fc2ccad6f3348dfd">but that of war</a>. Vought is at war with large swaths of the population, with the very idea of a democratic society defined by egalitarian pluralism. If you have correctly identified that this guy is now in a really influential position, that people like him are now in control of the American government, how is that not the main story?</p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/08ca53da-bb0f-4eb4-aa08-c0648d2d9477/uploads/images/jdyria6vob/BD7A5C1A-0AA9-4808-9C8E-E1CFA34E1424_1_201_a.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/08ca53da-bb0f-4eb4-aa08-c0648d2d9477</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">08ca53da-bb0f-4eb4-aa08-c0648d2d9477</guid>
      <pubDate>Thu, 09 Oct 2025 10:55:25 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Where Is the Line?]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[On Ezra Klein, Ta-Nehisi Coates, and the struggle to define the boundaries of what is acceptable in America]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong>On Ezra Klein, Ta-Nehisi Coates, and the struggle to define the boundaries of what is acceptable in America. If we can’t even agree to hold the line against Trumpism, democracy must perish.</strong></h4><h5><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/about#js-publication_plans"><strong>Thomas Zimmer</strong></a><strong>, Oct. 05, 2025</strong></h5><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/c5d02496-98ac-4eac-a1dd-b8109b3e26c5">Listen on Steady</a></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/c5d02496-98ac-4eac-a1dd-b8109b3e26c5/uploads/images/5ty55gfius/iStock-2160545604.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>Credit: iStock / HJBC</figcaption></figure><p><em>Before you read on, can I bother you for a minute?</em></p><p><em>A little while ago, I became a full-time independent writer. If you want the long story of why I left academia, you’ll find it </em><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/ab02af47-9e87-4143-ba51-afa2d1804c1c"><em>here.</em></a><em> The gist is this: I now depend on your support. Unless I can convince enough of you to purchase a paid membership, I will not be able to continue this work.</em></p><p><em>Today, you are reading a free post that I am making available to everyone. I would love to continue to offer such long-form essays for a broader audience. However, I want to be frank with you: So far, the rise in free subscribers has not been accompanied by much of a rise in paid membership, which means this may not be a sustainable model going forward. As a result, I will switch to a mixed model, combining occasional free pieces with more regular posts that are reserved for members – hoping this might entice more of my subscribers to become members.</em></p><p><em>I am really not trying to coerce you into paying for my work if you are not yet convinced it is worth it. But if you do think what I do here is valuable, please consider becoming a member. Your support and generosity are what makes Democracy Americana possible.</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a Member</a></p><p><em>Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</em></p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p>The MAGA project isn’t any less extremist, dangerous, or anti-democratic just because Donald Trump won the 2024 election.</p><p>How should (small-d) democratic America respond to the radicalizing assault on democratic self-government and the foundations of the constitutional order? It has been over a decade since Donald Trump came down the golden escalator and quickly took over as the leader of the American Right. He was elected president in 2016; he orchestrated a multi-month, multi-level scheme to nullify the result of the 2020 election before inciting a violent insurrection; and then, four years later, he was elected president again. There is no easy answer to the problem of Trumpism, at least not one that translates to a political recipe that is easily put into practice. But there are wrong answers – dangerous answers even.</p><p>Last week, <em>New York Times</em> columnist Ezra Klein suggested it was time for liberal America to change course. In a conversation with Ta-Nehisi Coates published as an <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/09/28/opinion/ezra-klein-podcast-ta-nehisi-coates.html">episode of his podcast</a> “The Ezra Klein Show,” arguably the NYT’s flagship liberal program, Klein insinuated it was time for mainstream America to redraw the line that demarcates the respectable and acceptable from that which is not; to stop drawing a line that designates Donald Trump as beyond the pale. I believe Klein is dangerously wrong.</p><p>Where do we draw the line? And who gets to draw it? It is a fundamental question that any democratic society must continually answer: What is considered within the boundaries of mainstream politics and therefore deserving of respect – and what should get you ostracized from democratic discourse and “polite” society? What counts as <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/09/11/opinion/charlie-kirk-assassination-fear-politics.html">“practicing politics the right way”</a> – and what is to be treated as despicable behavior detrimental to the polity? What ideas are to be discussed as legitimate contributions – and what is to be fought as extremist ideology? What is political conduct deserving of all the privileges and respect of democratic politics – and what should trigger an immune reaction instead, a forceful mobilization of the system in defense of democracy?</p><p>The line between those who are inside those boundaries and those who exist outside is not always clear; it is historically contingent, it moves, it is contested. Must we redraw that line to include Donald Trump and the political project he spearheads? It would be exactly the wrong lesson to learn from a decade of Trumpism as the dominant force on the Right.</p><p>Yet Ezra Klein is not alone. He is a major voice on the center and among mainstream liberals – his position, platformed by the <em>New York Times</em>, will influence a lot of people. Klein’s musings about redrawing the line are, more importantly, a manifestation of a pervasive tendency in American elite circles to accommodate rather than fight back, to acquiesce rather than stand firm. The question since January has been whether or not the movement that took power would be able to consolidate authoritarian rule. If leading voices on the center and center-left are wavering, giving themselves permission to move the line instead of holding it, it’s a disaster.</p><p><strong>An uncomfortable conversation</strong></p><p>Ezra Klein has been on quite the journey lately. The day after the murder of Charlie Kirk, he came out with <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/09/11/opinion/charlie-kirk-assassination-fear-politics.html">a column</a> praising Kirk for “practicing politics the right way.” It was a rather bizarre piece: Klein invented a fully sanitized version of Kirk, suggesting that he either knew very little about the man and his role on the Right – or had decided that presenting a fictionalized character was worth it if it allowed him to make the point he wanted to make.</p><p>Klein has been <a href="https://data4democracy.substack.com/p/you-cant-expand-the-tent-by-shrinking?r=10322&amp;utm_campaign=post&amp;utm_medium=web">widely</a> and rightfully <a href="https://newrepublic.com/article/201104/ezra-klein-charlie-kirk-politics-compromise-strategy">criticized</a> for that piece, for <a href="https://www.arcdigital.media/p/ezra-klein-accidentally-shows-how">whitewashing Kirk</a> and for valorizing the work of a man who mobilized his audience via the activation of racial and male grievance, whose engagement in “debate” was only ever geared towards mocking his opponents and creating sound bites he could use to fearmonger and scandalize.</p><p>The most prominent critique came from <a href="https://www.vanityfair.com/news/story/charlie-kirk-ezra-klein-tanehisi-coates">Ta-Nehisi Coates</a> – which prompted Klein to invite him on the podcast. Their conversation is a little awkward at times, for two reasons: Klein and Coates are friends, and both are noticeably uncomfortable with having a public dispute. And there is also a significant disconnect between them. “Why do you think he was winning,” Klein asks Coates early on in the conversation, referring to Kirk’s success with a mass audience on the Right; “why are we losing?” He seems to expect answers about political strategy and tactics, actionable advice for Democratic consultants. But Coates insists that his role as a writer and public intellectual is not to help the Democratic Party prepare election campaigns – his obligation is to the truth, to understanding and exploring this moment in U.S. history, where it sits in the context of the struggle for freedom and democracy that has defined this country at all times, how being victimized by political violence has always shaped the Black experience. This seems to frustrate Klein, who has a much more immediate perspective on what is going in America: “We’ve written a lot of people off,” he argues, without ever making it entirely clear who the “We” is that he keeps bringing up. The liberal elite, the Democratic Party, the Left… something like that. For someone who is generally so policy-oriented, it’s quite remarkable how Klein doesn’t present any concrete evidence for his central assertion – beyond getting pretty worked up about Hillary Clinton infamously declaring that “you could put half of Trump’s supporters into what I call the basket of deplorables” in a <a href="https://time.com/4486502/hillary-clinton-basket-of-deplorables-transcript/">speech in September 2016</a>. For Klein, that is all the evidence needed. He doesn’t care about Clinton’s actual argument in that speech, however awkwardly presented, that was less about writing off the “deplorables” and much more about <em>not writing off</em> those supporters of Donald Trump who might be understandably frustrated by the system simply not working for them. Or about looking at the Democratic platform in 2016, or the governing record of the Biden era, to see whether or not his assertion is backed up by actual policy. Or about exploring what we do and do not know about the motivations of Trump voters in 2024 and whether that aligns with his blanket statement. All he gives us is soundbite punditry.</p><p><strong>Where are the lines?</strong></p><p>Klein is desperate to get Coates to agree with him that a reconciliation with the Right, restoring some form of political and civic unity, must take precedent now: <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/09/16/opinion/ezra-klein-podcast-ben-shapiro.html">“We are going to have to live here with one another,”</a> as Klein put it in another column in the wake of the Kirk murder. For Coates, however, the real issue is who will get to define the conditions under which Americans coexist: “For me, the bigger question is: Where are the lines?”</p><p>Klein is eager to pick up on that idea: Where is the line? “What does it mean to be on the other side of the line?” Coates answers: “If you think it is OK to dehumanize people, then conversation between you and me is probably not possible.”</p><p>This prompts Klein to ask: “And so what do you do with the fact that so many people think that is OK?”</p><p>It is worth quoting at length the next passage in the conversation where Klein outlines his own thinking around this question, and why he ultimately believes holding the line, or drawing the line in the first place, might be a mistake:</p><blockquote><p>“I think that one reality is that the president of the United States is a person who, in his comportment as a human being on the public stage, I would have said in 2008, 2012, in 2016, should be on the other side of the line. … I think he’s a person who does not act with any sense of public, or even personal, decency. … And then he won in ’16, lost sort of narrowly in ’20 and then won in 2024. And the thing that this has led to, for me, is recognizing that I don’t get to draw the line. Now it doesn’t mean I don’t have one in my own heart. But the thing that I am struggling with is that for most people, or a lot of people, the plurality of the voters in the last election: He is somehow not way over the line. That means there are a lot of people who are willing to accept things that I thought we would have found unacceptable. I would have thought that the way he acts in public is unacceptable. And it’s not. So, I think for me … there was a view that we could work with politics by drawing these lines. That there are people who are going to be inside them and outside them, and we could work that way. I am working with the question of: What happens if you don’t believe that? If you don’t control the line?”</p></blockquote><p>Ezra Klein never crosses into explicitly arguing that what Donald Trump is saying and doing is fine, acceptable, respectable. And purely on a diagnostic level, he is evidently correct: Many millions of Americans do not consider Trump beyond the pale, they do not agree he is outside the boundaries of the acceptable – or it certainly hasn’t stopped them from voting for the man and elevating him to the most powerful political position on earth.</p><p>But this isn’t just diagnostics. Klein’s position is entirely based on the assumption that liberal America must reconsider its relationship with Trump. “We” have (supposedly) tried to ostracize him, shun him, scandalize him. But it hasn’t worked. Drawing the line hasn’t worked. And with so many millions of fellow Americans supporting the man, it might not be justified anymore either.</p><p>Notice how Klein describes the results of the past two presidential elections: Trump “lost sort of narrowly in ‘20” – that was a 4.5-point win for Joe Biden; but Democrats “got our asses handed to us” in 2024 – which was just a 1.5-point loss. That’s a rather tendentious way of characterizing these numbers, isn’t it? The insinuation is clear: Forget the numbers, “the people” are with Trump. The people spoke, and Liberals have no right to declare the people’s choice unacceptable, to consider the people’s tribune to be beyond the pale. Klein’s decision to whitewash and valorize Charlie Kirk should be seen in this context: As Kirk was successful with millions on the Right, Ezra Klein redrew the line to include him within the realm of the respectable, the noble.</p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><strong>Apologist sleight of hand</strong></p><p>If this were just the personal opinion of one – albeit very famous – <em>New York Times</em> columnist, it would hardly be worth paying so much attention to it. But this isn’t about Ezra Klein, really. This tendency to obscure the radicalization of the Right, to normalize and legitimize rightwing extremism, to accommodate Trumpism, is a pervasive feature of the Trump era – it is one of its core pathologies. Since the mainstream discourse stipulates that extremism must be “fringe” in these United States, anything that has broad support is reflexively sanitized as <em>not</em> extremism. This apologist sleight of hand is often deployed to provide cover for extreme forces within the Republican Party: If extremism is not defined by its ideological and political substance, but as “something fringe,” then the minute it becomes GOP mainstream, it ceases to be regarded as extremism. And just like that, not only do extremist ideas and policies get automatically legitimized - by definition, the Republican Party, regardless of how substantively extreme, also gets treated as “normal” simply because it ain’t fringe, because it’s supported by almost half the country.</p><p>Remember when many a member of the polite society <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/03/opinion/joe-biden-democracy-crisis.html">commentariat</a> reacted with indignation to Joe Biden calling MAGA <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/aug/26/biden-trump-republicans-fascism-speech-maryland">“semi-fascism”</a> before the 2022 midterm elections? The mere suggestion that something extreme, something sort-of-fascist-ish, could have mass appeal in the United States was treated as <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/06/opinion/biden-speech-maga-republicans.html">a scandal</a>, an outrageous gaffe, peak liberal arrogance. Or think of how the discourse quickly changed when the election results came in last November. When Donald Trump staged an openly fascistic rally in Madison Square Garden shortly before the election, even mainstream outlets were willing to acknowledge that he was offering something that was aggressively hostile to democratic pluralism. But then he won, and the discourse quickly shifted to how he had mobilized a multi-racial coalition and how that supposedly made any talk about MAGA being defined by white male grievance and Christian nationalism obsolete.</p><p>If we take a step back for a second, the idea that if a political movement garners mass support, it can’t possibly be extremism, incompatible with democratic self-government, or beyond the pale in a broader cultural and societal sense is utterly implausible and historically illiterate. History is full of authoritarian movements that had mass appeal (the Nazis, to mention the obvious example, were supported by anywhere from 30 to 40 per cent of the German population when they rose to power in the early 1930s). And we don’t have to look to history at all: Orbán was supported by about half the voting public in the last Hungarian parliamentary election in 2022, and no one seriously argues that the AfD, which currently leads the national polls in Germany, is not the political home of German rightwing extremism.</p><p><strong>Pathologies of the American political discourse</strong></p><p>Because Donald Trump has the support of millions of Americans, he <a href="https://x.com/shadihamid/status/1562929399527362560">can’t possibly be a dangerous extremist</a>, his ascent was <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/10/31/politics-polarization-solution/">never a real threat</a> to the survival of the Republic, and liberals should finally stop indulging the <a href="https://x.com/shadihamid/status/1609245182024716290">“great moral panic,”</a> as a <em>Washington Post</em> columnist put it, that democracy is under assault… It’s an argument so facile, so implausible, so ahistoric that it’s worth unpacking why it has any credibility at all, to the point where smart, well-informed people like Ezra Klein are swayed by such notions.</p><p>First of all, the argument finds fertile ground in a deep-seated myth of American exceptionalism. In its purest form, it holds that Americans are essentially immune to authoritarianism of any kind – the “soul of the nation” won’t allow it, or the country’s DNA, or the freedom-loving national character… The political mainstream has generally – or at least rhetorically – moved to a slightly more nuanced understanding of the American story. But the collective imaginary is very much still grounded in exceptionalist ideas. Just think of how many times you have heard politicians utter the phrase “This is not who we are!” when referring to racism and white supremacy. On the basis of such exceptionalist mythology, examples of extremism garnering mass support elsewhere in the world don’t count: Sure, other societies might be susceptible to authoritarianism’s siren call… but this is America! Remarkably, such arguments must also ignore that America has had plenty of experience with broad popular support for state authoritarianism in its own history. Significant parts of the country existed first as a slavocracy and then, after a brief interlude during Reconstruction, as a one-party apartheid regime during the so-called Jim Crow era. During the same period, Native Americans were disenfranchised, dispossessed, and persecuted by the American state. However, this fundamental historical reality gets obscured by the fact that throughout its existence, the United States has conceived of itself as a democracy. And while that isn’t necessarily wrong, depending on the definition of “democracy,” it has installed in the nation’s collective imagination the idea of a glorious democratic past stretching back 250 years: The world’s oldest democracy, stable and consolidated – it is hard to reconcile mass support for Trumpian extremism with such notions.</p><p>Secondly, this tendency to latch onto any argument that helps to normalize Trump and his supporters is also indicative of how strong the incentives are within mainstream discourse to sanitize the political choices of white conservative Christians. We are constantly asked to presume benign motives and reach for non-incriminating explanations. They are just “regular folks,” and as such, they can do no wrong. Usually, this is achieved by exculpatory tales about why they <em>didn’t mean to</em> or <em>had to</em> support extremism. Maybe they were seduced by a brilliant demagogue; maybe they lack political agency entirely: Economic anxiety, anti-elite backlash, or just a reaction to Liberals being mean – someone or something <em>made them do it</em>. Whenever people rode waves of racial resentment to political prominence, their success has been described in such terms. Whether it was George Wallace’s surprisingly successful presidential run in 1968 or David Duke’s near-victory in the 1990 senate election in Louisiana.</p><p>This, here, is a slightly different variation of this sanitizing myth: White innocence is achieved not by justifying and apologizing widespread support for political extremism - but by decreeing that whatever a significant portion of “regular folks” are supporting categorically cannot be extremism in the first place.</p><p>Finally, underlying such arguments that “we must live here with one another” and therefore cannot afford to draw lines is a striking inability to separate between Republican voters and the political leaders of the American Right. I want to be careful not to exculpate Trump’s voters: As a default assumption, we should take them seriously and assume they knew who they were voting for – which means we can hold them accountable for the results of their political choices. At the very least, they did not consider Trump’s open promise of instituting a white nationalist purge and erecting a vindictive autocracy a deal-breaker. But that is still not the same as arguing that everyone who voted for Trump is an extremist who is fully on board with what Russell Vought and Stephen Miller want to do to America. There are certainly those who are, who believe a dose of Trumpian extremism is exactly what this country needs right now. Some are just fascists, or people who vehemently reject modern society and aggressively disdain multiracial, multi-religious pluralism. There is another big bucket of people who, while not considering themselves rightwing extremists, are giving themselves permission to make common cause with the extreme Right by either prioritizing a very narrowly defined self-interest (taxes!) – or by telling themselves radical measures are needed against what is supposedly the real, more acute threat: “the Left.” And then there is a third group that voted for Trump based on a vague combination of “vibes,” a generalized frustration with the system (and Democrats as the party in charge as well as the “system party”), and a hefty dose of ignorance and disbelief, either unaware of what the Trumpists were really planning or convinced that they wouldn’t be able to implement it anyway. My point is: It really is worth grappling with the reasons why Trump still garners mass support. But that’s a very different endeavor from simply using Trump’s mass appeal as a justification to normalize MAGA. That is not any more serious of an argument than claiming Trump can’t be racist because some Black people and Latinos voted for him.</p><p><strong>Why are liberal elites so eager to move the line?</strong></p><p>There is one more factor that helps explain the eagerness of influential people in the (small-d) democratic coalition to accommodate and acquiesce: The position of the liberal commentator in the discourse, and the role he assigns to himself. As America falls apart, Ezra Klein aspires to be the voice of reason and demonstrate that he can still operate across the divide and do politics where everyone else has given up on it. Some of this is intended to demonstrate how magnanimously above the partisan fray one is: a performances of faux-high-mindedness. There is, in Ezra Klein’s case, also a genuine desire to model good democratic behavior. But trying to find ways to do politics with the other side is not the same as creating a sanitized fiction of the other side as the basis of your politics. There is acknowledging the political realities and adapting to a new situation – and then there is denying that reality so that you can continue to do “normal politics” because that is what you are more comfortable with.</p><p>Too many prominent liberals and Democratic politicians are jumping at the chance to sacrifice a substantive commitment to democratic values and principles on the altar of “unity.” “I don’t get to draw the line,” Ezra Klein told Ta-Nehisi Coates. I don’t get to divide the county, he meant to say. And if alleviating “division” were the overriding concern, he would be right. But from a democratic standpoint, drawing a line and attempting to hold it means grounding your politics in substantive commitments that are non-negotiable. By not drawing a line, Klein isn’t fostering understanding. He runs the risk of helping to establish an aggressively anti-democratic movement and its leaders as legitimate. </p><p><strong>Hold the line</strong></p><p>There is a tone of despair in Ezra Klein’s voice – and that I share wholeheartedly. He is right to be dismayed at the state of the country, at what the continued mass support for Donald Trump says about America. “I have lines that I think should and should not be acceptable, but those lines clearly have no relationship to my country and its politics,” he told Coates.<strong> </strong>That is certainly true in the sense that there is indeed no consensus over where those lines are and who gets to draw them. There never was. It is true, therefore, that those who think Donald Trump should be beyond the pale cannot claim to be representing “the country” – but neither can the Trumpists. America is deeply divided over exactly that question. There has never been a consensus that the nation should exist as a pluralistic democracy. And right now, those who fundamentally reject that vision are in power. But the reaction to that reality should not be to abandon our democratic commitments in search for unity.</p><p>“I don’t get to draw the line,” Ezra Klein says. He is right, of course, in a narrow sense; but the larger implication – Who am I to draw the line? – is exactly wrong. Democracy depends on all of us, and especially those with a broader public platform, drawing the line. What that looks like in practice, in our professional lives and private interactions, depends on our individual personal situation. But it is an obligation that we must accept. Who are we to draw the line? We are citizens who demand to live in a democratic Republic.</p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/c5d02496-98ac-4eac-a1dd-b8109b3e26c5/uploads/images/5ty55gfius/iStock-2160545604.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/c5d02496-98ac-4eac-a1dd-b8109b3e26c5</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">c5d02496-98ac-4eac-a1dd-b8109b3e26c5</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 05 Oct 2025 13:22:28 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Is Trump Winning? Is He Losing?]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Kimmel uncanceled, a terrifying “domestic terrorism” directive, and troops to Portland: Where does America stand in the struggle against encroaching authoritarianism?]]></description>
      <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong>Kimmel uncanceled, Comey indicted, a terrifying “domestic terrorism” directive, and troops to Portland: Where does America stand in the struggle against encroaching authoritarianism?</strong></h4><p><a href="https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/8fd1d2c2-6733-424c-9547-8ebd132b6f54">Listen on Steady</a></p><figure><img src="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/8fd1d2c2-6733-424c-9547-8ebd132b6f54/uploads/images/f4tr7jbxwu/iStock-2192515406.jpeg?auto=compress&amp;w=800&amp;fit=max&amp;dpr=2&amp;fm=webp" alt=""/><figcaption>credit: iStock / Jorm Sangsorn</figcaption></figure><p><em>Hello! Before we get started, can I ask you for your help? </em></p><p><em>Just a few days ago, I re-launched the newsletter at a new platform. And most importantly, I officially launched my new life as a full-time independent writer. If you want the long story of why I left academia, you’ll find it </em><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/ab02af47-9e87-4143-ba51-afa2d1804c1c"><em>here.</em></a><em> The gist is this: From now on, I do not have any income other than what I can generate from my writing and public work. That is why I depend on your support – and on enough of you to purchase a paid membership.</em></p><p><em>So far, since the re-launch, Democracy Americana has experienced quite a big influx of new, free subscribers. That is wonderful, as it means I get to share my work with a larger audience. However, relatively few of you have become paid members. I want to be honest: Unless the ratio of free subscribers to paid members improves, I won’t be able to offer free posts like this essay and will have to put much more than what I had hoped behind a paywall (and let’s be frank: Unless I can convince more of you to become a member, I might not be able to continue doing this for very long at all). I am not trying to coerce you into paying for something if you are not convinced it is worth it. But if you do think this is valuable work: Can I ask for your support? Believe me, I am sincerely grateful.</em></p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p>Not ready yet for a paid membership? Then subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:</p><p><a href="https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/newsletter/sign_up">Subscribe to Newsletter</a></p><p>Let’s start with a timeline. Here are just a few of the events that unfolded over the past 18 days since the murder of Charlie Kirk – a snapshot to illustrate how precarious this moment is, and how uncertain the outcome:</p><p><strong>September 15</strong> - On Monday, September 15, the Trumpists used all channels to declare their intention to crack down on liberal America and anyone they consider to be a leftist enemy. Hosting Charlie Kirk’s talk radio show, for instance, <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/videos/ckge487nr6ro">Vice President JD Vance</a> vowed to “go after the NGO networks,” and Stephen Miller promised to use the power of the state to <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/videos/ckge487nr6ro">“uproot and dismantle these terrorist networks”</a> and bring down the <a href="https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/white-house/trump-administration-says-will-target-far-left-groups-kirks-assassinat-rcna231605">“vast domestic terror movement”</a> that was the American Left.</p><p>That same evening, late-night talk show host Jimmy Kimmel used his opening monologue to mock the MAGA attempts to portray the killer of Charlie Kirk as an agent of the Left in order to justify political repression.</p><p><strong>September 17 </strong>- This sparked a reaction from the Federal Communications Commissions (FCC) that demonstrated what this political repression might look like: On Wednesday, September 17, FCC chairman Brendan Carr, himself a devoted Trumpist, openly threatened to come after broadcaster ABC unless it canceled Jimmy Kimmel Live. In an interview on a rightwing podcast, <a href="https://edition.cnn.com/2025/09/17/media/jimmy-kimmel-charlie-kirk-trump-fcc-brendan-carr?cid=ios_app">Carr said</a>: “We can do this the easy way or the hard way. These companies can find ways to change conduct to take actions, frankly on Kimmel, or there’s going to be additional work for the FCC ahead.”</p><p>Two of ABC’s affiliates, Nexstar and Sinclair, reacted immediately and announced they were preempting Kimmel’s show. Both are currently seeking FCC approval in crucial matters, and they were evidently in no mood to defend first amendment rights at the risk of angering the regime. Not long thereafter, ABC also released <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/2025/sep/18/jimmy-kimmel-live-suspended-indefinitely-after-hosts-charlie-kirk-comments">a short statement</a> declaring it was taking Kimmel off the air.</p><p><strong>September 18-20</strong> - But the public backlash was swift. Already the next day, September 18, <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/jlray.bsky.social/post/3lz56xratss2q">polling</a> suggested that most people vehemently disagreed with the decision to cancel Kimmel and sharply rejected the threats ushered by the FCC chairman. By the weekend, it had become clear that Disney, which owns ABC, was paying a steep price for not standing with Kimmel, as a record-number of people decided to cancel their <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/gelliottmorris.com/post/3lzbrh2wm522q">Disney Plus subscriptions</a>. And even some Republican politicians in Congress deviated from their general “I will defend whatever the regime does” default: Texas senator <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/sahilkapur.bsky.social/post/3lz7fsf3y4k26">Ted Cruz</a>, for instance, called Carr a “mafioso” for issuing threats to the television network.</p><p><strong>September 22-23</strong> - As the new week started, the higher-ups at Disney and/or ABC had evidently decided it was time to backtrack: On Monday, September 22, they announced Kimmel would be back the next night. In his <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c1tjh_ZO_tY">opening monologue</a> on Tuesday, September 23, Kimmel certainly showed no signs of being overly intimidated by the regime: He was grateful for the public support he had received, called on Americans to come together – and went right back to mocking Donald Trump.</p><p><strong>September 25</strong> - The way the Kimmel saga had played out was widely perceived as a massive defeat for Trump. The American people, it seemed, had drawn a line and forced the MAGA regime to retreat. Was this not a clear sign that the Trumpists were failing at consolidating their authoritarian rule?</p><p>But then, just two days later, the Trumpists reacted with a flurry of authoritarian escalations. On Thursday, September 25, former FBI director James Comey was indicted in Virginia. Trump had been publicly clamoring for this for years: He considers Comey an enemy because the FBI, under Comey’s leadership, looked into illegal connections between the Trump campaign and Russia in 2016. What happened here was so transparent that even mainstream media coverage reflected how brazenly the regime was using the justice system to exact retribution.</p><p>The same day, Trump also released a presidential memo – an instrument quite similar to a presidential executive order – on “<a href="https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/09/countering-domestic-terrorism-and-organized-political-violence/">Countering Domestic Terrorism and Organized Political Violence</a>.” It was entirely geared towards laying the groundwork for the type of comprehensive crackdown on the “Left” the Trumpists had been demanding since the murder of Charlie Kirk: The memo instructed the entire machinery of the federal government to employ an incredibly expansive definition of “domestic terrorism” to go after any organization or individual associated with leftist “anti-fascism.”</p><p><strong>September 27</strong> - And that wasn’t even the end of the week yet. On Saturday, September 27, news broke that the ideological purge of the FBI was also accelerating: In what is clearly an illegal act, the FBI fired a bunch of agents who had been <a href="https://apnews.com/article/fbi-george-floyd-kash-patel-8d18a1e6a5a36636cc2415fc492b3f52?link_source=ta_bluesky_link&amp;taid=68d73106002abd000141bb12&amp;utm_campaign=trueanthem&amp;utm_medium=social&amp;utm_source=bluesky">photographed taking a knee</a> during the George Floyd protests in the summer of 2020.</p><p>Finally, the same day, Trump announced he was <a href="https://edition.cnn.com/2025/09/27/politics/trump-sending-troops-portland-ice">sending troops</a> into “war ravaged Portland” to protect the city “and any of our ICE Facilities under siege from attack by Antifa, and other domestic terrorists.” Trump said he was “authorizing full force, if necessary.” The militarization of the political conflict has reached another urban center; the Trumpists are determined to widen and escalate their war on blue communities.</p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p><p><strong>This is how authoritarianism works in the 21st century – but sometimes it doesn’t!</strong></p><p>What does this all amount to? After all this, where do we stand in the struggle over the fate of American democracy? Was the Jimmy Kimmel story just a blip? Or still a significant defeat for the regime?</p><p>It was fashionable in some corners of the political discourse to scoff at the Kimmel affair even before the Trumpists answered Kimmel’s reinstatement with another round of escalation: Who cares about some celebrity feuding with Trump, the argument seemed to be; this was basically all just a bit of pointless theater – catnip for the “resistance libs,” but meaningless overall.</p><p>Actually, the Kimmel story mattered quite a lot – both diagnostically (meaning: as a window into the state of American politics) and politically (in terms of how it is impacting the ongoing struggle). Regardless of its outcome, it pointed to what is one of the key differences between the first Trump administration and his second presidency. While the Trumpists were never defenders of free speech, there was no systematic attempt during Trump I to nullify the First Amendment or use the levers of state power to suppress protest and public dissent. They simply didn’t know how to use the government in that way, and they didn’t have the people in place who could have systematically used the state machinery as an instrument of repression. This led to a pervasive frustration within MAGA, and it is precisely what animated the big planning operations the Right launched during the Biden era – most infamously Project 2025. In fact, Brendan Carr literally wrote the chapter on the FCC in Project 2025’s policy agenda – in which he envisioned using the agency exactly the way he has since taking over as chairman in January: As an instrument to put pressure on business and media, threatening regulatory action or lawsuits against anyone not sufficiently deferential to Trump’s will.</p><p>The FCC’s attempt to coerce ABC into canceling Jimmy Kimmel was a reminder that the Trumpists intend to use the federal government as a machine that serves only two purposes: To impose Trump’s will and desire for retribution – and to impose a reactionary societal order against the will of the majority. It was also a demonstration of how an authoritarian transformation of a democratic society tends to work in the twenty-first century. Kimmel’s cancellation sits right at that intersection of open state repression – and pre-emptive self-censorship and complicity by businesses and civil society actors. No need to send the thugs in boots and brown uniforms to rough the place up, or to send the secret police to arrest everyone, if you can also “nudge” these institutions to comply by… less untidy means.</p><p>What to make of the reaction from the companies that first rushed to censor Kimmel – and then quickly brought him back, seemingly without any conditions? Let’s not kid ourselves: The people in charge at Disney or ABC did not rally in defense of democracy and free speech. Their immediate instinct, lest we forget, was to accommodate the regime. They reacted to consumer pressure and realized that their brand was taking a significant hit that would affect the bottom line. They made a business decision that just happened to align, in this instance, with the democratic defense. That may not be the case the next time. And yet, at the very least, their decision to backtrack does demonstrate that these companies have not yet fully bought into personalist rule. In a fully personalist regime, your position is entirely dependent on your relationship with the regime, on your standing with the regime leader. We have seen some very concerning signs in the past few weeks of how far we have already moved into this direction: Remember the <a href="https://www.wired.com/story/tech-ceos-donald-trump-white-house/">tech leaders all schmoozing</a> Trump in a ridiculous White House dinner propaganda enactment? In that sense, at least, this was a welcome sign that public pressure can still cause the type of market effect that keeps companies from fully rolling over. </p><p><strong>What caused the public backlash?</strong></p><p>One obvious reason Kimmel’s cancellation caused a significant public reaction is that he is famous. He is extremely well connected in Hollywood, causing a lot of celebrities and entertainment industry people to chime in. And since he is someone from outside the realm of politics, they also felt more comfortable taking a position, as it was less easily discarded as a purely partisan act. All of a sudden, sports podcasters who generally try to stay away as far as possible from being “political” were talking about <a href="https://www.theringer.com/podcasts/the-bill-simmons-podcast/2025/09/18/the-kimmel-situation-plus-can-the-chiefs-really-go-0-3-and-more-week-3-gambling-questions-with-joe-house">“the Kimmel situation,”</a> reaching a broad audience with lots of people who might otherwise be completely oblivious of whatever was going on in the struggle to stave off authoritarianism.</p><p>Another reason why the American public reacted so strongly to the Kimmel cancellation is that the Trumpists went about this in the most ham-fisted way. Since the very first day of the first Trump presidency, we have been wondering how much MAGA incompetence would hamper their malevolent attack on the democratic order? Here is a concrete example of how a more sophisticated, insidious approach might have gotten them a very different result. The FCC could have threatened ABC / Disney executives behind the scenes – yet Brendan Carr just had to play big, bad man on a rightwing podcast, likely because he thought it would endear him to the MAGA base. Trump could have used backdoor channels to make it known to Kimmel’s bosses what he wanted; yet he is Donald Trump, and so he went straight to talking into a microphone how the networks should have their <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/sep/18/jimmy-kimmel-show-trump">licenses revoked</a> if they were mean to him, and how he wanted to see two more late-night hosts, <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/yasharali.bsky.social/post/3lz32nywem22k">Jimmy Fallon and Seth Meyers</a>, fired too. It all added up to a spectacle that was so obvious, so easily recognizable as state repression; an assault that looked so much like “dictator stuff” to even casual observers that it sparked a rather basic response in people: That’s not ok.</p><p><strong>Will it last?</strong></p><p>Could the Kimmel affair have a lasting impact on how the struggle between the authoritarian aspirations of the Trump regime and the realities of American society plays out? One scenario is that the Trumpists just go back to a slightly less open approach to exerting pressure on media and business elites; that those elites understand that if they want to comply with the regime and seek to accommodate (and so many of them so desperate do!), they’ll also have to be a little less brazen about it. Don’t cancel Kimmel right away, maybe just announce a week or two later that his contract won’t be renewed… (that is basically what happened with fellow late-night host Stephen Colbert at CBS).</p><p>But there is also another takeaway that might potentially impact future behavior: The broadly hostile reaction from the American public certainly served as a crucial reminder that the Trumpists do not represent a broad societal consensus. No matter how many times they claim a “mandate” and angrily insist they represent “the people,” it remains true that Trump’s assault on free speech is extremely unpopular. The Trumpists are most dangerous when they combine their “will of the people” rhetoric with actions that are predicated on an understanding that what they need to do is to erect authoritarian minority rule. They got ahead of themselves with Kimmel, acting out in the open as if it was actually true that “the people” were on their side.</p><p>Could this reminder of Trump’s unpopularity strengthen whatever reluctance to go along with the regime might still exist somewhere within the Republican Party? Don’t hold your breath. However, I will say there is still a fault line within the GOP between those like Ted Cruz who apparently are still concerned that a public backlash like this will harm him and the party, that the rules of “normal” politics aren’t yet fully suspended, that you still have to be somewhat careful or risk losing the next election – and those like Stephen Miller who are so determined to establish a fully authoritarian order, and soon, that they cannot be bothered to care about public opinion.</p><p>Most importantly, perhaps: Let us hope that the Kimmel affair can convince at least a few more of mainstream America’s leading voices and most influential elites that there really is no reason to affirm and propagate the MAGA assertion that Trump represents “the people.” This has been Trump’s superpower for years, and especially since the election in November: So many, including in the country’s nominal opposition party, insist on treating him like he really is the tribune of the people, like the voice of “real America,” like a leader with a broad mandate to implement his agenda. It was never true.</p><p><strong>Beware the swinging pendulum</strong></p><p>I believe the developments of the past ten days or so offer some important lessons for all of us – they should inspire a reflection on the general dynamics of the political conflict and the way we are analyzing and interpreting it. In terms of the public perception of where things stand, the pendulum swung wildly over such a short span of time. The rightwing reactions to the murder of Charlie Kirk were so unhinged, the calls for violent escalation against “the Left” so furious, that it certainly felt like America had potentially reached a tipping point: Not from democracy to no longer democratic (we crossed that line a while ago), but from a hybrid regime to potentially something closer to the no-longer-competitive-authoritarianism end of the scale. The cancellation of Jimmy Kimmel, with its combination of brazenly open state repression and full-on surrender from media businesses, seemed to point in the same direction. Authoritarian rule consolidated, or at least getting there fast. Trump was winning!</p><p>But then Kimmel was reinstated. This immediately sparked a host of pieces arguing <a href="https://thinkbigpicture.substack.com/p/trump-authoritarianism-stalled-tide-turning">the tide was turning</a>, that America was <a href="https://paulkrugman.substack.com/p/is-the-jimmy-kimmel-saga-a-sign-that">not just another Hungary</a> after all. The regime had overplayed its hand and suffered a devastating defeat. Trump was losing!</p><p>But that was before the wave of authoritarian escalations to end the week. Comey indicted; troops to Portland; and a presidential declaration opening the door for virtually anyone in the United States – certainly anyone who is critical of Trump – to be harassed by the state as a domestic terrorist. If you believe that sounds hyperbolic, please <a href="https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/09/countering-domestic-terrorism-and-organized-political-violence/">read the memo</a> yourself. I will have to write more about it soon, but my first reaction is that it is a breathtakingly authoritarian document. The only purpose it serves is to create a flexible instrument that could be used against <em>anyone</em> the regime deems an enemy. It employs a definition of “domestic terrorism” that is entirely directed against the bizarre phantasma of “the Left” as it exists in the feverish mind of someone like Stephen Miller – even going so far as to explicitly declare all “activities under the umbrella of self-described ‘anti-fascism’” as likely to be terroristic. Meanwhile, the memo widens the definition so much – including “organized doxing campaigns, swatting, rioting, looting, trespass, assault, destruction of property, threats of violence, and civil disorder” – that it becomes difficult to identify what act of resistance or disobedience the state <em>couldn’t</em> persecute as “domestic terrorism.”</p><p>I think that’s terrifying. And it came just two days after Jimmy Kimmel returned with a defiant monologue that seemed to prove the regime had failed in its attempt to suppress public dissent. Now what: Is Trump winning? Is he losing?</p><p>The only productive way forward is to reject the question. Binary categories of “Winning/losing” – or “weak/strong” – are just not very helpful right now. They tend to reproduce mood swings more than they help generate plausible analysis. Every Trumpian embarrassment (remember the “Liberation Day” tariff debacle?) is destined to cause a new round of “Trump is weak, he is losing” pieces; every authoritarian escalation is accompanied by a chorus of “Democracy is dead, Trump won” post-mortems. My point is not merely to say that the truth lies “in the middle” (it might be far closer to one end of the spectrum than to the other) – but to remind us all that we must consider the bigger picture and how the many different actions and reactions are connected.</p><p>We long for certainty. That’s why we look for clear lines of demarcation and identifiable points of (no) return. But the lines will inevitably get pushed further and further out, and the next turning point is always right around the corner. Let’s think in directionality rather than fixed lines. And let’s not isolate specific actions or moments, but insist on a holistic understanding of what is happening around us. Things might move differently, at different speeds, in different sectors: The regime might have to make concessions to business leaders today, while aggressively moving forward on their plans to purge the nation tomorrow. A phase of escalation might be followed by a period of relative easement – and it would be as foolish to declare victory during the latter as it is defeatist to announce democracy’s inevitable downfall during the former.</p><p>Nothing is determined. But some things are certain. There should never have been any doubt about the Trumpists’ intentions. They are entirely sincere about their assertions of absolute power, unburdened by legal restraints and puny norms. They desire to transform America into some form of plebiscitary autocracy, constantly invoking the true “will of the people” and their “mandate” to restore former national glory while drastically narrowing the boundaries of who gets to belong, centralizing power to neutralize the opposition, curtailing the rights of those who dare to deviate, entrenching a tiered system of participation defined by hierarchies of race, gender, religion, and wealth, and restoring white male dominance in elite institutions as well as across all spheres of American life.</p><p>But that doesn’t mean they will ultimately succeed. Only that they are trying. And if it were all happening elsewhere, and our observations weren’t still distorted somehow by an exceptionalist mythology that wants us to believe “It cannot happen here” in this self-declared land of the free, we would have no trouble recognizing how disastrously far they have already come in just a few short months.</p><p>If you have been reading Democracy Americana for any length of time, you know this is not the place you come to for optimistic encouragement. We must recognize how dangerous, how precarious this moment is. But we must not perpetuate the Trumpists’ assertions of strength and dominance. It’s a constant balancing act, with enormously high stakes and a completely uncertain outcome. For now, the gap between their authoritarian aspirations and the reality of American society remains vast. That’s where politics still continues, that’s where the counter can yet happen.</p><p><a href="https://democracyamericana.com/about">Become a member</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/8fd1d2c2-6733-424c-9547-8ebd132b6f54/uploads/images/f4tr7jbxwu/iStock-2192515406.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/8fd1d2c2-6733-424c-9547-8ebd132b6f54</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">8fd1d2c2-6733-424c-9547-8ebd132b6f54</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 28 Sep 2025 22:53:55 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Onward. Forward. Steady.]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Things have really changed. Now I need your help.]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/ab02af47-9e87-4143-ba51-afa2d1804c1c/uploads/images/onkp3kfxsu/103739496_padded_logo.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/ab02af47-9e87-4143-ba51-afa2d1804c1c</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">ab02af47-9e87-4143-ba51-afa2d1804c1c</guid>
      <pubDate>Wed, 24 Sep 2025 10:12:49 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Right Wants a Reichstag Fire]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The military patrolling in the streets, an assassination, and a movement longing for escalation. America is teetering on the brink]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/e1939bd0-39f0-4bcc-8764-30742a3c7d02/uploads/images/fh25cpr5jx/Reichstagsbrand.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/e1939bd0-39f0-4bcc-8764-30742a3c7d02</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">e1939bd0-39f0-4bcc-8764-30742a3c7d02</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 22:01:04 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Why the Extremists Took over on the Right]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Fear of a pluralizing America is fueling a radicalization out of a sense of weakness and besiegement]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fc82b439b-4e27-48f4-b988-9c4af47a3033_1732x1732.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=88bac19532f2a3659dd7c3a4c0dd1df0" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/1fa94cc4-1d69-4c7b-820d-aab7dd5837d6</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">1fa94cc4-1d69-4c7b-820d-aab7dd5837d6</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 22:00:26 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[What is America, and for Whom?]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[A white Christian ethno-state or a pluralistic democracy with egalitarian aspirations? American society has always been divided over what this country should strive to be]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F6ed14e72-a2b2-4b8f-91eb-2f2dc25e02dc_2560x1681.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=7eb6d0a70f929260e761248bf0d414c4" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/ee2e090b-2857-4ff6-b296-073fd13a463c</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">ee2e090b-2857-4ff6-b296-073fd13a463c</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:59:47 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The American Government Sides with the Party of German Neo-Nazis]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The MAGA-AfD alliance of extremists is not surprising, but it remains outrageous. If democracy is to prevail, America needs to establish a robust anti-fascist consensus]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F44700eaf-65f0-498c-8429-3b5d9f81c259_1339x997.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=62c09f53c0fbaf8351414e4930de41d0" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/770fc317-db2c-4148-b9c4-a3b7e5747510</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">770fc317-db2c-4148-b9c4-a3b7e5747510</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:58:36 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[How the Republic Falls]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Constitutional protections suspended. The government purging “alien enemies” and the “enemy within.” Three months into Trumpist rule, despotism is rising in America]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F47b2864c-2b82-4c2f-aaaa-5b425c93fb26_2431x1233.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=ec148266fa837371c446e43d85024004" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/7d093680-c6ba-47eb-b5d6-fca9b16a6ff6</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">7d093680-c6ba-47eb-b5d6-fca9b16a6ff6</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:58:05 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[What Authoritarianism Means]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Even critical observers underestimated the speed and scope of the Trumpist assault, they overestimated democratic resilience. What is America now, and what comes next?]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F87294137-4178-437a-8925-b941289941fc_2451x1223.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=650cfcff747650d5a0a8a8b2575ea1fb" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/0c39122d-246d-4b3c-a3c3-e0bcb0731018</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">0c39122d-246d-4b3c-a3c3-e0bcb0731018</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:57:32 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[MAGA, the German Far Right, and the Transnational Assault on Democracy]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[A reflection on the German far right, Musk’s interference in the German election, and why the MAGA-AfD alliance isn’t nearly as irresistible as they want us to believe]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/0e7f7745-1136-42ad-837e-72f9c32d18d2/teaser_image/1756646769?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/0e7f7745-1136-42ad-837e-72f9c32d18d2</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">0e7f7745-1136-42ad-837e-72f9c32d18d2</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:56:58 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[MAGA Feeding Frenzy Has Caused a Constitutional Crisis]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The assault is coming from different angles: Project 2025. The feudal tech barons. The America First nativists. It’s not a single master plan – it’s comprehensive chaos]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff4f6bea9-a064-4d90-b2f6-1281d5791bf9_3336x2502.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=e19b4ea368df28e328284e7afef7acb7" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/ec5a38aa-486a-44fe-99d3-b3ed36e33dd0</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">ec5a38aa-486a-44fe-99d3-b3ed36e33dd0</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:55:40 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Navigating the Nonsense and Propaganda of Clownish Authoritarianism]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Ignoring what Trump says won’t work. Constant outrage is not a viable strategy either. We must find a more productive way to engage Trump’s dangerous outlandishness]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/b251cfc6-43fc-41a2-bb6d-81e5203bb0d9/teaser_image/1756646703?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/b251cfc6-43fc-41a2-bb6d-81e5203bb0d9</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">b251cfc6-43fc-41a2-bb6d-81e5203bb0d9</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:51:23 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Modern Conservative Tradition and the Origins of Trumpism]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Today’s Trumpist radicals are not (small-c) conservatives – but they stand in the continuity of Modern Conservatism’s defining political project]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/8836df02-0af8-4c6f-97d7-951793898934/teaser_image/1757252328?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/8836df02-0af8-4c6f-97d7-951793898934</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">8836df02-0af8-4c6f-97d7-951793898934</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:50:24 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Meet the Ideologue of the “Post-Constitutional” Right]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Russell Vought, one of the architects behind Project 2025, believes there is nothing left to conserve. He desires revolution – and to burn down the system]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fd280798b-3231-42bc-9549-e94df53cc29e_2048x1365.webp?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=3da24066de4ba47faaff2fcbe71ad1a8" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/754b715c-48b7-4419-9b63-dbc5691fdd56</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">754b715c-48b7-4419-9b63-dbc5691fdd56</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:49:48 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Elite Acquiescence and Treacherous “Normalcy” All Around Us]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[What are the reasons behind the pervasive tendency among ostensibly anti-MAGA elites to accommodate authoritarian power and preemptively signal compliance with Trumpism?]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fd4c3b188-4279-4188-8c03-325d2f3b78e9_1024x682.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=71ee0ebc0b96281f67a243f40dfead79" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/72cf11bd-5673-4018-940a-5b640f2a03dc</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">72cf11bd-5673-4018-940a-5b640f2a03dc</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:49:13 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Why the Second Trump Regime Will Be Far More Dangerous]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[This will be a much more radical regime – and it will operate under conditions that are vastly more favorable to its extremist cause]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff49bac69-da2b-41d3-9739-1b726359eb49_1538x2048.webp?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=2c9b7c34f00e07fc701641b652167975" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/57862474-a2af-4cd5-8e93-dc183725451c</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">57862474-a2af-4cd5-8e93-dc183725451c</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:47:50 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Why the Stakes in this Election Are So Enormously High]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Democracy itself is on the ballot. If Trump wins, the extreme Right will be in a much better position than ever before to abolish it]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F7fcb33d7-ec60-447f-860a-19b992b86adf_4128x2184.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=bef6a2dad06a68303131fb40236630d6" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/e734532a-5e61-4fe2-a50f-709e7ea0a2b9</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">e734532a-5e61-4fe2-a50f-709e7ea0a2b9</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:45:20 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[It Could Definitely Happen Here]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Many Americans struggle to accept that democracy is young, fragile, and could collapse – a lack of imagination that dangerously blunts the response to the Trumpist Right]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F25181116-1c51-4187-a875-2a5202183103_1739x2048.webp?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=a232ff10101a9217b1a3ed59a91f0897" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/26ac0ca8-f361-4878-838c-6bde6e5cd6e2</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">26ac0ca8-f361-4878-838c-6bde6e5cd6e2</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:44:40 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Donald Trump, American Fascist]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Trumpism is what a specifically American, twenty-first century version of fascism looks like. And in November, fascism is on the ballot]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/62f51e74-3cc7-4646-8fb3-4137b9006689/teaser_image/1757886228?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/62f51e74-3cc7-4646-8fb3-4137b9006689</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">62f51e74-3cc7-4646-8fb3-4137b9006689</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:43:48 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[How Project 2025 Became Toxic and Exposed the Right’s Toxicity]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The public history of Project 2025 reveals a lot about how Trump understands power - and how the mainstream discourse (mis-) understands the extreme Right]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F8421ab91-d44e-40a2-a108-377a2d0a89ed_3800x1086.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=de61d281e934cc6fbab184d91e54a1d8" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/c9eee98c-4ce5-42c6-8dcc-5e973934fb42</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">c9eee98c-4ce5-42c6-8dcc-5e973934fb42</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:42:47 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Blood and Soil]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The Right is committed to an idea of America as a white Christian homeland. They are determined to purge the nation and redraw the boundaries of the body politic]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/fd6042ca-dfa6-4693-85a1-b9552e6488f5/teaser_image/1757862642?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/fd6042ca-dfa6-4693-85a1-b9552e6488f5</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">fd6042ca-dfa6-4693-85a1-b9552e6488f5</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:42:11 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Liz Cheney and the Problem of the Anti-Trump Republican]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Republicans who hold the line against Trump deserve respect. But champions of egalitarian, pluralistic democracy they are not - and that also matters]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F861ff2fe-88e0-44bd-916f-f8c8276e6367_1001x674.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=4e44f85bae07923ccc34737b483e3352" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/6314b827-af11-40c9-abce-9388878635b1</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">6314b827-af11-40c9-abce-9388878635b1</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:41:36 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[What is “weird” and what is “normal” in America?]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Democrats are, finally, asserting a right to define the boundaries of normalcy – and their claim to be defending the nation’s true ideals against the reactionary assault]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0bd38e36-71cc-406f-ae70-735f72f3e4c8_1000x1000.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=97ba68ce841461b858f2fa176ad7284a" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/a66b1b57-4f3f-4384-9aa4-4531dc1ba29d</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">a66b1b57-4f3f-4384-9aa4-4531dc1ba29d</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:40:00 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[MAGA of the Beach Redux]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[On an encounter with enraged Trumpers - and the road ahead for a society in which conspiracies, extremist iconography, and political violence have become ubiquitous]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fdff23910-1b86-4e92-ae5f-cbfac0917377_1588x1588.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=8a74e457d609cb85a9d00ce4fc175824" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/d4c4d387-4138-477a-966f-3c8c937890d3</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">d4c4d387-4138-477a-966f-3c8c937890d3</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:39:20 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Kamala Harris May Force a Reckoning]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Harris emerged as VP in the summer of 2020 when it seemed the country might finally deal with its defining demons. She was sidelined thereafter - until now.]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fbeaba5e8-e430-47ec-85dd-998893564aea_1200x792.webp?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=70a7b76750be87188ade9009b283bcbb" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/1211329b-c452-421c-b04e-a255f6581fe1</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">1211329b-c452-421c-b04e-a255f6581fe1</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:38:48 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Allies Against Demoracy: Trump and Project 2025]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Trump is not the mastermind behind Project 2025. It’s worse: The rightwing establishment has radicalized so much that their plans are in line with his vengeful desires]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F117a374b-c431-4203-b2ba-17ee56719928_1034x769.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=4e8de89d43c39b5a9ba6e76d87088f60" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/8bb4b059-0a44-414b-a587-84b4032c9c1f</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">8bb4b059-0a44-414b-a587-84b4032c9c1f</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:37:21 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Origins of Trumpism and the Birth of the Present]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Reflections on the pre-history of Trump’s rise, the nature of Trumpism, and the radical politics of white despair – based on John Ganz’s masterful "When the Clock Broke"]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F6a33f2d1-34b8-4ef0-af15-bbbb619080df_900x1350.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=cd5396cc53a515449f175cb2f1e8bf52" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/5b95f96f-b63f-47b5-ae39-60bcc67c54bd</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">5b95f96f-b63f-47b5-ae39-60bcc67c54bd</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:36:49 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Right’s Politics of Revenge]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The responses to the Trump verdict offer a reminder of what defines the American Right today: They are out for bloody retaliation, all dressed up as patriotism]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/b5a166d2-72e1-4bf4-9bc2-7321b475b31d/teaser_image/1757862780?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/b5a166d2-72e1-4bf4-9bc2-7321b475b31d</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">b5a166d2-72e1-4bf4-9bc2-7321b475b31d</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:36:06 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The “Originalist” Supreme Court vs Democracy]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[As the Right is using “originalism” to re-impose a reactionary order on the country, I exchange letters with Madiba Dennie about the dangers of judicial supremacy]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F28a1ec31-fc60-4628-b4fa-a2d307fcd9e9_1685x2552.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=f6f3ca73e8c287a84979018cc84044ba" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/e7481e1a-5442-4d70-8ddd-bb30f071c599</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">e7481e1a-5442-4d70-8ddd-bb30f071c599</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:34:26 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Anti-Liberal Left Has a Fascism Problem]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Prominent leftwing intellectuals are allowing their singular, disdain-driven focus on (neo-) liberalism to completely distort their perspective on the Right]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F7b3086fb-9543-40d2-b11e-e5b4b3674c79_6829x4819.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=c565eaa65ecf706b26710d492527aa2f" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/b5cf6f1e-8418-47a5-b770-3bc595008ebc</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">b5cf6f1e-8418-47a5-b770-3bc595008ebc</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:33:50 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Fascism in America?]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The fascism debate: Why it matters, what the main contentions are, and why the arguments of the Skeptics are increasingly untethered from what is happening on the Right]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F9360c619-503c-4da5-a901-377e4c19db8c_2560x1577.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=4ac751384c866425562331df09fe5bcf" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/c9eadb82-003d-4aaf-a75d-a9e5259e5402</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">c9eadb82-003d-4aaf-a75d-a9e5259e5402</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:33:18 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Students Have Never Been the Enemy]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Student protest movements have historically functioned as an indispensable corrective for America and the West. That is the legacy of 1968 we should be talking about]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F5183bdc3-3aef-47b3-94ef-2faac2f070d9_1000x1497.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=f345eddf046b9bcc8fe9e6d1a4949ad3" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/2f892acd-b13e-4d53-83a8-67299b7d8693</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">2f892acd-b13e-4d53-83a8-67299b7d8693</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:32:13 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[America’s Elites Fear the Ghost of 1968]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Mainstream elites are adopting a reactionary tale about “leftist” indoctrination that verges on the conspiratorial and is destined to give the Right a major boost]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F06b57d50-533b-425a-80d0-ed32206ac2b1_2370x1574.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=1bfe64225848a62a202b3f54c0b3d348" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/608d88cf-b350-4b57-9e91-356fd1f14910</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">608d88cf-b350-4b57-9e91-356fd1f14910</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:31:28 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Student revolt and the Curtailing of Critical Speech]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The violent crackdown on campus protests reveals an alliance between the Right and mainstream elites who are driven by reactionary impulses and status anxieties]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F885e9653-aa7b-4dd0-8a47-cf4cc9887f64_1313x902.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=d3ef02c681cb4b4a217617b9e1a85f4d" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/d222de14-57cf-4687-9446-1039176ac85c</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">d222de14-57cf-4687-9446-1039176ac85c</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:30:47 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Anti-Anti-Trump Conservatives Are Paving the Way for Authoritanism]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Highbrow conservative commentators are giving themselves permission to support Trump by portraying “liberal hysteria” as the real threat: A case study of National Review]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F19660936-857d-40fc-b4aa-fbaa26487488_500x661.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=164b6c7e2a267cf1368329c442ad65e1" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/5e214505-ebcb-4767-ac2e-f6c48943da3d</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">5e214505-ebcb-4767-ac2e-f6c48943da3d</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:29:55 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[What Makes “Project 2025” So Dangerous]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Will the Right be able to implement its plans? Is Trump on board? What happened to traditional conservatism? Let’s tackle the key questions surrounding "Project 2025"]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe532de9b-f2fe-4231-885a-1e3b92b4707e_2048x1366.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=4a03ebecc253d9112c835b64e72d67bd" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/8e0c4a81-4dc6-4a69-8aeb-4a3649173bd3</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">8e0c4a81-4dc6-4a69-8aeb-4a3649173bd3</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:27:27 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[What Does “Defend Democracy” Actually Mean?]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Biden’s State of the Union hinted at a key shift in the liberal imagination: From a merely restorative to a potentially more transformative vision for America]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F05ecfcef-31cb-4c31-944b-13787c5fbeb4_1920x1280.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=09f1133d77f94651d6a0c3fba0276d2d" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/be9e14a5-9eff-4c47-bff7-93e237abe7f3</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">be9e14a5-9eff-4c47-bff7-93e237abe7f3</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:26:49 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Much Vaunted Guardrails Are Failing]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Unless America’s leading institutions start acting accordingly, how can we expect enough people to believe the danger to democracy is really all that severe?]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F5ad4ed83-a799-4cb5-ba91-5d7b83db0dc4_2516x1192.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=3238b46e96dc30d26c710c462c0e8abb" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/4121d9ed-3b23-438d-97c9-ed3bddc63447</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">4121d9ed-3b23-438d-97c9-ed3bddc63447</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:25:57 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[What “Project 2025” Would Do to America]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The Right has developed concrete plans to make America into a much nastier place for anyone who dares to deviate from the white Christian patriarchal order]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/2afb3c7a-3885-4cff-8607-90eadc17493c/teaser_image/1757251430?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/2afb3c7a-3885-4cff-8607-90eadc17493c</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">2afb3c7a-3885-4cff-8607-90eadc17493c</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:25:25 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[“Project 2025” Promises Revenge, Oppression, and Autocratic Rule]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The Right’s plans for a return to power are driven by a radicalizing siege mentality and a desperate desire to restore dominance]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F270d5e5a-16ff-486a-bddd-89be2936907e_2122x1413.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=89576400517d59282405e0f6badfb414" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/2c4b309c-9d68-4419-ac0b-39efe2f8adfc</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">2c4b309c-9d68-4419-ac0b-39efe2f8adfc</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:24:31 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[What the “Biden Too Old” Discourse Is Really About]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Let’s evaluate the arguments of those who describe Biden as manifestly unfit]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/7901b686-5b41-4f0f-af9f-ea066a241c7e/teaser_image/1757862882?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/7901b686-5b41-4f0f-af9f-ea066a241c7e</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">7901b686-5b41-4f0f-af9f-ea066a241c7e</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:23:50 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Domination or Dissolution, Rule or Ruin]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The Right is fantasizing about secession, “national divorce,” and civil war – because they will not, under any circumstance, accept pluralism]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe97a1e5f-6196-476c-9c26-40987548937f_2121x1414.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=96cd7f123501747250b152b320cc0905" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/8ed86f69-9b6e-4eac-a0f5-ce486a4117b9</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">8ed86f69-9b6e-4eac-a0f5-ce486a4117b9</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:22:57 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Texas Border Standoff Is an Acute Crisis with Terrifying…]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Is this how America ends? Echoes of nullification crises and Civil War, and the dissolution of the Union]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F515b9706-f055-432d-a95d-77c1ecc531c2_1827x1036.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=9ee8792c062d4a3c67e85ab9c05981a3" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/89386fa0-38b9-4580-9799-0e87348275c4</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">89386fa0-38b9-4580-9799-0e87348275c4</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:22:13 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[MLK’s Legacy and the Quest for a Racial Reckoning]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[A reflection on our distorted, sanitized version of the civil rights struggle, reactionary “backlash,” and the eternal objection of the white moderate]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F9b470064-3cc0-4c35-9ea2-517c0fbc7de7_4284x5712.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=b557cb75261c8973d45a939f44c37004" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/64b94dde-b8c6-4c34-b5e8-06c74c1d8079</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">64b94dde-b8c6-4c34-b5e8-06c74c1d8079</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:19:52 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[January 6 in History]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Was it a key moment in the republic’s eventual demise or a milestone on the road to democracy’s ultimate triumph? The meaning of January 6 is yet to be determined]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/653e87bc-1625-42e1-8f00-141ca9602b91/teaser_image/1767711147?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/653e87bc-1625-42e1-8f00-141ca9602b91</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">653e87bc-1625-42e1-8f00-141ca9602b91</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:19:16 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[On Substack’s Nazi Problem, and Ours]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The year is off to a depressing start with a reflection on how to navigate the moral quandaries of social media extremism – and a plea to my readers to stick with me]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/27925ac2-b1e2-4f58-9551-05abf24fcd3c/uploads/images/zbd6dwr6a3/iStock-121368241.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/27925ac2-b1e2-4f58-9551-05abf24fcd3c</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">27925ac2-b1e2-4f58-9551-05abf24fcd3c</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:18:35 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Things Seem Really Bad Right Now. But Let’s Put 2023 Into Perspective]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[It feels like an eternity since the year started with a palpable sense of optimism… A reflection on where democracy stands at the end of 2023 – and what lies ahead]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/fe1fc2da-cb5d-437f-b79f-1f3a55b4af4d/uploads/images/js6wqg3tna/iStock-157713818.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/fe1fc2da-cb5d-437f-b79f-1f3a55b4af4d</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">fe1fc2da-cb5d-437f-b79f-1f3a55b4af4d</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:18:02 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Militant Democracy vs Donald Trump]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Democracy is fated to fight those who assault it with one hand tied behind its back, lest it become that which it seeks to defeat. But fight it must – or it will perish]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/91c8b6cb-8b26-4b4c-8a9e-a7e11879acd9/uploads/images/jfc4zonhmn/Screenshot_2023-12-22_at_10.54.54.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/91c8b6cb-8b26-4b4c-8a9e-a7e11879acd9</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">91c8b6cb-8b26-4b4c-8a9e-a7e11879acd9</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:17:24 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[We Are Falling Apart]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The Right is exploiting fears over rising antisemitism for its reactionary crusade while the Israel-Hamas war is tearing the democratic popular front to pieces]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/9b005654-bd29-4eed-b23f-8fa8c839a94e/uploads/images/a32j6bdvgi/Screenshot_2023-12-14_at_02.32.52.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/9b005654-bd29-4eed-b23f-8fa8c839a94e</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">9b005654-bd29-4eed-b23f-8fa8c839a94e</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:16:29 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Donald Trump, American Dictator]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Every political analysis needs to start from the recognition that there is an eminently plausible - and fairly straightforward - path from here to autocratic rule]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/a14c259e-68bb-4388-a604-ee300e86688b/teaser_image/1757410323?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/a14c259e-68bb-4388-a604-ee300e86688b</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">a14c259e-68bb-4388-a604-ee300e86688b</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:15:39 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[How Can Democracy Possibly Work Under Such Conditions?]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Pervasive pessimism and nostalgia, waning support for a racial reckoning, anti-feminist retrenchment, and so many conspiracies…]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/66ee8f17-f604-41e3-8064-fe7bb6ed825b/teaser_image/1757622849?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/66ee8f17-f604-41e3-8064-fe7bb6ed825b</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">66ee8f17-f604-41e3-8064-fe7bb6ed825b</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:15:00 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[One Year of Democracy Americana]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[A personal reflection on the chances and pitfalls of publicly engaging with the political conflict from a precarious academic position – and what the future might bring]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/cd16e31b-920f-4f9e-bf77-d095030a36f0/uploads/images/kpoxi35gse/103739496_padded_logo.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/cd16e31b-920f-4f9e-bf77-d095030a36f0</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">cd16e31b-920f-4f9e-bf77-d095030a36f0</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:13:44 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Do Americans Value Democracy?]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Brace yourselves: A deep dive into the best survey data we have on the ideas and attitudes that shape the political conflict in the United States - Part I ]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/68792db3-d5e8-49a7-b7e5-1cdd28b674b1/teaser_image/1757623071?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/68792db3-d5e8-49a7-b7e5-1cdd28b674b1</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">68792db3-d5e8-49a7-b7e5-1cdd28b674b1</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 21:13:07 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[In Defense of My Students]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The idea of the campus as a stronghold of leftwing extremism and authoritarian censoriousness stands in stark contrast to what’s happening inside the classroom]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/c93e18e4-1552-4272-868e-277f9b29d814/uploads/images/o55qymlecw/Foto_L.jpg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/c93e18e4-1552-4272-868e-277f9b29d814</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">c93e18e4-1552-4272-868e-277f9b29d814</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 20:21:47 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[“Faith and Family” vs Democracy]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[On the normalization of Mike Johnson, the media’s inclination to accommodate power, and the perpetuation of “real American” extremism]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/a375d915-5cd4-4e37-bb77-389d5f164ec2/uploads/images/fh3seaze7u/Illustration_new.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/a375d915-5cd4-4e37-bb77-389d5f164ec2</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">a375d915-5cd4-4e37-bb77-389d5f164ec2</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 20:21:02 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Is This Democracy]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[An ongoing conversation with Lily Mason on the struggle over democracy in American politics and history]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/c898604f-8811-4858-9689-8615f25304d2/uploads/images/hiy3zbzmyh/100707328_padded_logo.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/c898604f-8811-4858-9689-8615f25304d2</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">c898604f-8811-4858-9689-8615f25304d2</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 20:20:22 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Why America’s Elites Love to Decry “Polarization”]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The fact that it obscures the actual political conflict is the feature, not the bug of the “polarization” narrative – A Manifesto, Part II]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/d2a819ac-0ee8-4038-8904-9a24c4676498/teaser_image/1757623627?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/d2a819ac-0ee8-4038-8904-9a24c4676498</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">d2a819ac-0ee8-4038-8904-9a24c4676498</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 20:19:45 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Treacherous Allure of the “Polarization” Dogma]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[On the limits and pitfalls of a narrative that obscures more than it illuminates – A Manifesto, Part I]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/a676dffd-d0c4-42e5-9a80-db45151ae6b0/uploads/images/cjakdifmh7/iStock-1488216172.jpg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/a676dffd-d0c4-42e5-9a80-db45151ae6b0</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">a676dffd-d0c4-42e5-9a80-db45151ae6b0</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 20:18:17 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Triumph of Weaponized Nostalgia]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Past eras of stable white Christian patriarchal dominance are widely sanitized and mythologized in our political discourse]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/e8c1c3f2-4144-4fdd-82a0-6a31ccf27639/teaser_image/1757864098?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/e8c1c3f2-4144-4fdd-82a0-6a31ccf27639</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">e8c1c3f2-4144-4fdd-82a0-6a31ccf27639</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 20:17:36 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Moralizing Nostalgia Leads to Bad History - and Helps the…]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[David Brooks’ “How America Got Mean” offers an ahistorical tale that obscures rather than illuminates – and provides fertile ground for a politics of reaction]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/8b61f7a1-cf3e-4494-9811-56989bb00056/teaser_image/1757624359?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/8b61f7a1-cf3e-4494-9811-56989bb00056</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">8b61f7a1-cf3e-4494-9811-56989bb00056</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 20:16:57 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Rightwing Dreams of American Reconquista]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[A counter-revolutionary zeal and desire for vengeance is what unites Donald Trump, Ron DeSantis, Christopher Rufo, Nate Hochman, and the rest of today’s Right]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/b833a247-9d73-425c-9c32-8cbaf3f21d8e/teaser_image/1757624535?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/b833a247-9d73-425c-9c32-8cbaf3f21d8e</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">b833a247-9d73-425c-9c32-8cbaf3f21d8e</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 20:15:58 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Ron DeSantis Dreams About America’s Founding - And How to Destroy His…]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[DeSantis’ forgotten 2011 book Dreams From Our Founding Fathers helps us trace the Right’s recent intellectual and political trajectory of radicalization]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F340433c7-7c5a-42fc-864f-45636166f2be_817x1189.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=ae77ea1e00be748c08f72363c5c94010" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/57107f0b-373c-4835-a5f8-c63867d5be0b</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">57107f0b-373c-4835-a5f8-c63867d5be0b</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 20:14:45 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Teasing DeSantis - and a Call for Questions]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[An upcoming exploration of the American Founding according to Ron DeSantis, a massive thank you, and a summer mailbag]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fb948b80a-fbde-4e8d-873a-0092714fab15_828x501.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=a34f1b45dbe2efb3b11700c04630a9f4" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/d45dd6c4-c773-4c62-982e-6c19dc8ee270</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">d45dd6c4-c773-4c62-982e-6c19dc8ee270</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 20:12:32 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Supreme Court vs. Modern Democracy, Part II]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Earlier this week, a major German-speaking newspaper asked me to write an opinion piece (“Kommentar” in German) on the Supreme Court’s decision to end affirmative action…]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/ec2fdd89-b9e5-491f-8b1a-a68e02315317/uploads/images/qkzgn4p5vl/Panorama_of_United_States_Supreme_Court_Building_at_Dusk.jpeg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/ec2fdd89-b9e5-491f-8b1a-a68e02315317</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">ec2fdd89-b9e5-491f-8b1a-a68e02315317</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 20:11:11 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Ambivalence of the Fourth of July]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The nation celebrates Independence Day as democracy is at a crossroads]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/04e36327-a7f6-41f6-afbd-9fc4f636c6b2/uploads/images/p7gifkzzkn/Acros-Potomac-River-Fireworks.jpg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/04e36327-a7f6-41f6-afbd-9fc4f636c6b2</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">04e36327-a7f6-41f6-afbd-9fc4f636c6b2</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 20:10:32 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Rogue Court vs Modern Democracy]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[America can accept this Supreme Court as legitimate and its rulings as the final word - or it can have true democracy and a functioning state. But not both.]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/8eebc27f-8903-4191-8b05-1680871a3fd5/uploads/images/bge3qnurje/Panorama_of_United_States_Supreme_Court_Building_at_Dusk.jpg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/8eebc27f-8903-4191-8b05-1680871a3fd5</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">8eebc27f-8903-4191-8b05-1680871a3fd5</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 20:09:49 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[One Year on From Dobbs: The Dangers of Radicalizing Minority Rule]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Reactionaries are pursuing an unpopular political project. They might still succeed – because they are committing to ever more authoritarian forms of minoritarianism]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/5647d728-5e4e-451f-a06b-781783603294/uploads/images/6t3b6tp6x4/Supreme_Court_of_the_United_States_-_Roberts_Court_2020.jpg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/5647d728-5e4e-451f-a06b-781783603294</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">5647d728-5e4e-451f-a06b-781783603294</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 20:08:32 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Why the Right Has a Problem with Juneteenth]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Reactionaries who oppose Juneteenth are the political, ideological, and spiritual descendants of those who were defeated in 1865. They dominate today’s Republican Party.]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/d0ccb3a5-7dec-4a2f-ab33-0604f5ef9431/uploads/images/sgpe2fnlvg/Flag.jpg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/d0ccb3a5-7dec-4a2f-ab33-0604f5ef9431</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">d0ccb3a5-7dec-4a2f-ab33-0604f5ef9431</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 20:07:57 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[How Republicans Give Themselves Permission to Embrace Trump]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Rightwing politics is driven by a logic of escalation, the loyalty to Trump additionally fueled by a sense of having burned all bridges]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/bbf926ee-4daa-4a73-b2e4-6a468fd5976c/uploads/images/sex3x6ov3v/IMG_8126_2.jpg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/bbf926ee-4daa-4a73-b2e4-6a468fd5976c</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">bbf926ee-4daa-4a73-b2e4-6a468fd5976c</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 20:06:50 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[What We Are Fighting Over]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[How much democracy – and for whom? That is the question defining the current political conflict across the “West.”]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/4bd53a51-6f26-4c37-962b-71434c869dde/uploads/images/4xwkkcfye4/o-angry-crowd-facebook.jpg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/4bd53a51-6f26-4c37-962b-71434c869dde</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">4bd53a51-6f26-4c37-962b-71434c869dde</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 20:05:41 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Status-Quo Fundamentalism of the “Moderate” Arbiters of Reason]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[CNN’s boss displays a deeply ideological belief in his own superior objectivity that is pervasive among America’s elites ]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/f50784f9-8415-4939-96d2-84087e96e5e4/uploads/images/xhsvxgdyfm/Screen_Shot_2023-06-04_at_06.03.22.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/f50784f9-8415-4939-96d2-84087e96e5e4</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">f50784f9-8415-4939-96d2-84087e96e5e4</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 20:03:26 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Fascistic Myth of Trump’s Special Connection to “Real America”]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The mainstream political discourse needs to stop perpetuating ideas that form the bedrock of the extremist ethno-religious movement that has galvanized behind Trump]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/70fcfed5-953c-4055-8894-d7b9507dfa42/uploads/images/yvykp6gy3u/IMG_8031.jpg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/70fcfed5-953c-4055-8894-d7b9507dfa42</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">70fcfed5-953c-4055-8894-d7b9507dfa42</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 20:02:44 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[All the Wrong Lessons from Trump’s Rise]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The justifications for CNN’s Trump town hall reveal the deeper pathologies and fallacies that have characterized the Trump discourse since 2016]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/e7cbdf8b-8b33-4924-bc10-bfd7cf8f24dd/uploads/images/vtskcawqqv/Screen_Shot_2023-05-22_at_00.29.10.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/e7cbdf8b-8b33-4924-bc10-bfd7cf8f24dd</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">e7cbdf8b-8b33-4924-bc10-bfd7cf8f24dd</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 20:02:09 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Vigilante Violence Is Part of the Right’s Plan]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The open embrace of violence plays a key role in the broader reactionary mobilization against democracy]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/4927be10-5b67-46a7-92d6-5bf8ef07a541/teaser_image/1757714396?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/4927be10-5b67-46a7-92d6-5bf8ef07a541</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">4927be10-5b67-46a7-92d6-5bf8ef07a541</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 20:01:16 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[How White Men Have Always Fought - and Thought of Themselves]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The fallacies of Tucker Carlson discourse, what the Right really believes, and old-school white elite racism]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/dddffd76-f95f-46e2-9dff-3697f5542daf/uploads/images/n5qf4ksuqh/Screen_Shot_2023-05-08_at_02.17.23.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/dddffd76-f95f-46e2-9dff-3697f5542daf</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">dddffd76-f95f-46e2-9dff-3697f5542daf</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 20:00:32 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Sabotage of Twitter Is a Disaster for Democracy]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Thoughts on Musk’s destruction of the virtual public square – and what democracy is losing]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/84aaf3ab-989e-4f75-abc0-e945b0e2e5d4/uploads/images/6nzxfmtlrd/IMG_7708_2.jpg?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/84aaf3ab-989e-4f75-abc0-e945b0e2e5d4</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">84aaf3ab-989e-4f75-abc0-e945b0e2e5d4</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 19:59:53 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[There Are No Decisive Victories for Democracy to Be Had Yet]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Processing an extreme week in U.S. politics]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/329cfc8a-024b-411e-9571-3827448f826b/teaser_image/1757863342?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/329cfc8a-024b-411e-9571-3827448f826b</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">329cfc8a-024b-411e-9571-3827448f826b</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 19:59:12 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[America Is Sacrificing Its Children at the Altar of the Gun]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Mass shootings are a political problem. A democracy problem. A uniquely American problem]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/7721b2f6-9963-4466-825d-e97a317a3d24/teaser_image/1757879896?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/7721b2f6-9963-4466-825d-e97a317a3d24</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">7721b2f6-9963-4466-825d-e97a317a3d24</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 19:58:17 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[If It’s Really That Bad, People Need To Know]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Unless America’s leading institutions act accordingly, why would anyone believe Trump is a serious threat - or that the danger to democracy is really all that severe?]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/c7ed6ea8-7718-49a9-90af-92953a51ea01/teaser_image/1757715058?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/c7ed6ea8-7718-49a9-90af-92953a51ea01</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">c7ed6ea8-7718-49a9-90af-92953a51ea01</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 19:56:55 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The “Free Speech Crisis” Is Not a Crisis. It Is Progress.]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[America is in the midst of a profound renegotiation of speech norms. That process can be messy. But it’s not “cancel culture.” It is necessary and overdue.]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/5787fac1-a368-47d7-bd1a-71a069e32842/teaser_image/1757879759?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/5787fac1-a368-47d7-bd1a-71a069e32842</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">5787fac1-a368-47d7-bd1a-71a069e32842</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 19:56:00 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[On “Cancel Culture”]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[A deep dive into the narrative that America is experiencing an acute “free speech crisis” – and why it is so misleading]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/6c0e9a90-1812-4b85-8e74-0cb8282acb1d/teaser_image/1757879623?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/6c0e9a90-1812-4b85-8e74-0cb8282acb1d</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">6c0e9a90-1812-4b85-8e74-0cb8282acb1d</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 19:53:43 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The State of the Union and the Problem of Unity]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[On Bidenism – and the limits and pitfalls of a unity politics that runs the risk of stifling the response to the authoritarian assault on democracy]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/89554430-3b01-4044-88f4-fb91a8b9beec/uploads/images/3l37dbwy42/Screen_Shot_2023-02-13_at_22.06.28.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/89554430-3b01-4044-88f4-fb91a8b9beec</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">89554430-3b01-4044-88f4-fb91a8b9beec</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 19:16:38 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[On the Murder of Tyre Nichols]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Reflections on systemic racism and the question of who gets to be violent in America – and whose responsibility it is to stop the violence]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/b7f03568-97f7-4ff9-8146-461c1ef41d29/uploads/images/mkvevxov4z/Screen_Shot_2023-01-29_at_08.40.14.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/b7f03568-97f7-4ff9-8146-461c1ef41d29</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">b7f03568-97f7-4ff9-8146-461c1ef41d29</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 19:15:26 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The IRS, Fake Populism, and the Conspiratorial Right on the Beach]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[From a personal encounter with MAGA America on the beach straight to the legislative priorities of the Republican Party]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/68e7d701-6829-42b7-9345-38e87c926587/uploads/images/rxaqweytyg/Screen_Shot_2023-01-19_at_12.47.43.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/68e7d701-6829-42b7-9345-38e87c926587</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">68e7d701-6829-42b7-9345-38e87c926587</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 19:14:13 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Insurrectionists Finally Took the House]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[McCarthy is speaker. The extremists won. The Republican Party is getting worse.]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/6a8e129c-0a91-4c52-b623-c70f81598e8b/uploads/images/7tx4tnj44m/Screen_Shot_2023-01-10_at_01.48.33.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/6a8e129c-0a91-4c52-b623-c70f81598e8b</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">6a8e129c-0a91-4c52-b623-c70f81598e8b</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 19:13:28 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Why the American Right Admires Putin’s Russia]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Reactionaries largely agree with Putin’s critique of the weak, “woke” West. To the Right, the fight against multiracial pluralism overrides everything else.]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/0cf8e1e2-fb49-4bdd-82e9-7d0ecb427dad/teaser_image/1757715891?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/0cf8e1e2-fb49-4bdd-82e9-7d0ecb427dad</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">0cf8e1e2-fb49-4bdd-82e9-7d0ecb427dad</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 19:12:41 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[The Reactionary Right Mobilizes]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Conservatism no more! A reflection on what we are up against – Part III]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/2fed1fb9-9a38-4461-b0ab-fcfc2a9681f8/teaser_image/1757716007?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/2fed1fb9-9a38-4461-b0ab-fcfc2a9681f8</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">2fed1fb9-9a38-4461-b0ab-fcfc2a9681f8</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 19:11:58 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Conservatism No More?]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[The Radicalization of the Right and the Reactionary Assault on Democracy. A reflection on what we are up against – Part II]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets-proxy.steadyhq.com/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstackcdn.com%2Fimage%2Ffetch%2F%24s_%21dKob%21%2Cf_auto%2Cq_auto%3Agood%2Cfl_progressive%3Asteep%2Fhttps%253A%252F%252Fbucketeer-e05bbc84-baa3-437e-9518-adb32be77984.s3.amazonaws.com%252Fpublic%252Fimages%252F29baf911-9118-41f1-a978-92fca01827ea_2111x1513.png?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg&amp;s=bbbc1b06ce6b71f8500a34c3b2d67e49" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/f1477ba4-315d-4d14-95e0-4a65dea6c3d2</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">f1477ba4-315d-4d14-95e0-4a65dea6c3d2</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 19:09:48 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[A Republican “Soul-Searching”? Highly Unlikely.]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Don’t trust people who keep promising a GOP pivot that never comes]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/703ffc90-b66b-40ca-a399-71a1b93a9f6e/teaser_image/1757716193?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/703ffc90-b66b-40ca-a399-71a1b93a9f6e</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">703ffc90-b66b-40ca-a399-71a1b93a9f6e</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 19:08:10 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Far-Right Extremists Assemble]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[Some thoughts on Trump, Fuentes, and the Republican Party’s white nationalist core]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/106b5d06-daf1-4f78-bed1-db2f7dfcbcfd/teaser_image/1757716252?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/106b5d06-daf1-4f78-bed1-db2f7dfcbcfd</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">106b5d06-daf1-4f78-bed1-db2f7dfcbcfd</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 19:06:50 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Democracy Faces a Reactionary Counter-Mobilization]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[A Reflection on What We Are Up Against – Part I]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/cf7f7c01-529c-4cfe-9f00-ab4685a4ecb4/teaser_image/1757716317?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/cf7f7c01-529c-4cfe-9f00-ab4685a4ecb4</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">cf7f7c01-529c-4cfe-9f00-ab4685a4ecb4</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 15:46:18 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
    <item>
      <title><![CDATA[Reflections on Democracy Americana]]></title>
      <description><![CDATA[How much democracy, and for whom? In many ways, the conflict over this question – between those who wanted to restrict and confine democracy, make sure it would never…]]></description>
      <media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://assets.steadyhq.com/production/post/dfa65457-d7a0-4f2c-a8b4-6079324a5614/teaser_image/1757716393?auto=format&amp;h=787&amp;w=1400&amp;fit=fill&amp;crop=faces&amp;fm=jpg" medium="image"/>
      <link>https://steady.page/592d8a22-bf28-437e-8fcc-2ae8772d4bb9/posts/dfa65457-d7a0-4f2c-a8b4-6079324a5614</link>
      <guid isPermaLink="false">dfa65457-d7a0-4f2c-a8b4-6079324a5614</guid>
      <pubDate>Sun, 14 Sep 2025 15:41:56 +0000</pubDate>
    </item>
  </channel>
</rss>